Archives: Episode

  • 012: Alternate History and Science Fiction

    012: Alternate History and Science Fiction

    Games talked about in this episode:

    • 1:38 Bioshock
    • 7:41 Rocket Ranger
    • 15:57 Metal Gear
    • 16:33 Metal Gear Solid
    • 19:50 Wolfenstein 3D
    • 21:39 Savage Frontier

    Tim Broadwater

    Alternate history, historic fiction, kind of the what-if scenario, a branch off of history; I know this has become a very popular genre in gaming. And I know that we’ve talked about things like mortal engines or savage frontier, Man in the high castle or hunters. And so want to kind of pick your brain about what are your thoughts about that genre. And I don’t even know if the name is correct. I think it’s also referred to as alt-history, like alternate history, alternative history, Alt hist. Ah, but it’s also sometimes called speculative fiction. I think steam like not steam works. But um, steampunk is generally kind of this in general. So anything that steampunk is, it’s kind of in this genre, or sub-genre, per se. But taking it back to games, the ones that stand out to me the most, the ones that are the most memorable to me, are Bioshock. This is the 1920s. And people are dancing, the Charleston, and then there are flappers, and there’s bathtub gin. You’ve got the Moxie. What I love about Bioshock is that it’s like okay, in that time period, when you think of like, the money in the United States, so to speak, if you think of like the Fords and the Carnegie’s in the people, like you, are kind of, like molding it or like Atlas Shrugged to even some degree is this right? That there’s this person who kind of separates himself from contemporary society and builds an underwater city in Bioshock. And you’re exploring it as someone who’s like, whose plane has crashed or boat has crashed or whatever, and you happened upon it in the ocean. And you see that there’s, oh, wow, this is literally like, you know, the roaring 20s but in an underwater city, and then the offshoot there is how it impacts history. And then how science fiction kind of plays into where it offshoots in different ways to where they figured out ways to make people into these kinds of big daddies, which are the mind slave robots. They take killers to turn them into the Little Sisters. They collect, I think it’s called, “atom.” And that gives people powers. And then people have powers where they can levitate objects and shoot fire from their hands and whatever. And then, of course, it leads to crazy destruction incarnate, and the city kind of collapses. But what I like about, and that’s not a spoiler for anyone, but I like about the Bioshock games, and one, two, and three, three being kind of the same thing, but it happens. It’s a floating city, you know, that’s kind of but at the same time-period. To me, I think those are phenomenal games that capture that period or piece of time, you know, kind of historically, but then propose this different outcome than what you would think historically, you know?

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, so Bioshock is a really good example because it’s not only like set in this time, right, but it is specifically Randian. Right, in terms of mine, Ayn Randian, that’s to your point. And it gives you an opportunity to put yourself in the shoes of an Ayn Rand-like character. The chief antagonist of Bioshock is Andrew Ryan, I believe, and the notion is that the world is full of moochers. I don’t know that they would say the world is full of socialists, but those who are listening now certainly can appreciate that line of thinking whether or not they agree with it, or hear it in everyday discourse anyway, so it’s something that we are still debating to this day. But at this point, Andrew Ryan’s idea is like, hey, the way that society in the United States at this time or is trending is at odds with personal freedom. And so he with his great wealth, and with the combined efforts of like, a select class of people go and create Rapture, that is, you know, like in international waters under the ocean, etc. And so it’s both, you know, it takes the place of this kind of like, I think it’s supposed to be like the 40s era. And you can kind of really enjoy the pop culture and novelty of that timeframe. But it also really grounds you in this mode of thinking, this philosophy, which you know, is part and parcel of Ayn Rand’s Objectivism, you know, Ayn Rand who wrote like Atlas Shrugged. And it lets you explore a kind of philosophy that is put to practice. And that’s, I think, kind of like the appeal. There are two sides.

    You get to question that what-if scenario. When I’m thinking about novels, I think of the Man in the High Castle. What happens if the Nazis won World War Two, this kind of situation is interesting to explore because it reveals something about yourself or your society. In this case, you know, Bioshock, you know, for good or ill, is telling a story of unchecked capitalism and selfishness.

    Tim Broadwater  

    100% I agree. And I think most people, yeah, I think most alt hist is like — I’m just saying “alt hist” because it seems a lot shorter than like, “spec fic,” or like speculative fiction or whatever — it does seem to be very much around the Industrial Revolution. It seems to be like, when you think of other things, like, apart from Bioshock, you think of like, let’s say the Rocketeer, Rocket Ranger being, you know, the kind of the game, but the Rocketeer. Still, it’s kind of the same thing to where that time period where it’s like if one Man had a jetpack, and he’s a superhero, but it is, you know, kind of, you know, how would it change things, you know, when you are talking about? I’m not sure of the time period if it was the 20s, 30s, or 40s.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, I think it was post World War One, right?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Well, it may be pre, but to that point, it’s the industrial revolution, like a lot of these, all his games seem to center around either the Industrial Revolution, or they seem, in my opinion, or from what I’ve seen, they seem to center around wars, like WW2. WW1, you know, things of that nature. And so when you look at things like Freedom Fighters or Bioshock, you know, I don’t know if you find that to be true, but a lot of it seems to be around wars, but I say so. 

    Michael Schofield  

    I have a theory like a possible explanation for So, so no, cut all this out if you want. But no,

    Tim Broadwater  

    No, what do you think? I’m curious because I do not gravitate to that genre because I don’t like warfighting. I’ll shoot a gun and run around to some degree, but I am not a call of duty person. I’m not an assassin’s creed kind of person. Yeah, I’m, you know, and I know that those are phenomenal games that people play.

    Michael Schofield  

    Well, look at looking at something like I’m like, whoa, hold on. Let me rewind for a minute. The there. There’s an alternate timeline where I end up as an English professor right at some University; this was my track originally. Before I went into grad school to pursue Information Studies, I was looking hard at getting a master’s in literature or pursuing a Ph.D. So, as part of the honors program that I was in, in my undergrad as an English major, I focused on the commonalities between Victorian literature and far-future science fiction. And I have a point here, so one of the reasons is that.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Those two intersect or like ….

    Michael Schofield  

    right, so, so so one of the thinking here is that, if we take sort of like the Victorian period, let’s call it 1860s, through like, maybe up to like the modernist part, so which would be like 1912 1913, something like that, from, you know, Queen Victoria, up until World War One and World War One plays a role in here. But like, if we take that period, just out of context, there are a few things that we can say are true. One is that we have a really good grasp of the history of that time. It was a period of high literacy, right. And while there was a high degree of complexity and the growth and fall of empire wars, etc., much of it was written down in a way that we have never had prior. So we can look back at this time with a good degree of clarity, appreciate and even identify moments that are catalysts, right, like the assassination of Franz Duke Ferdinand, right, that arguably started World War One? Would the war have started without that assassination, probably? But it started a little earlier because of that. So we can identify these kinds of moments. Because of the industrial revolution, this was a time where your relationship to God or the cosmos was really in question. No longer Did you need to have, you know, a whole bunch of Tim’s on a factory line when you had a machine that can do what many people could, like had to before, right? You know we have this idea of like Man’s place in the world, and machines place in the world and Man’s relationship to the machine. These are all things Man’s relationship to God, there’s a huge like, like, there’s a strong like, atheist movement in the Victorian period. But again, it’s just unparalleled before that you have this world where some degree of supernatural was just a given, never questioned. So the Victorian period is this huge time of well-chronicled complex events, exacerbated by all-new technologies that just totally changed the world left and right all the time and the struggles individuals had, especially individual, like, the individuals who happen to write like that the artists and, and the novelists and the poets and stuff like that are struggling with their sense of self. When we look at something like science fiction, we are addressing a lot of the same issues. So like, now, when we’re talking about artificial intelligence, we’re still having these questions about like, like our place and our machine world, whether we become like, artificial intelligence, something that augments us, where does humanity end? You know, like things of this sort, right? We were in the far future, you know, content that we create, exploring the same kinds of things, as you know, this sort of Victorian period. There’s a reason that Jules Verne appears at this time. Let’s say you’re going back to World War One or something like that pre or just after; it’s a situation that you really can understand because it’s so chronicled, you can put a character or put a player in a pivotal moment because you can identify those pivotal moments. And then if you sprinkle in little changes like that, you know, there’s a world where steam power does dominate and change the course of history, and then we can explore what those kinds of things are. Something like Bioshock or shit, even like Assassin’s Creed or the Rocketeer, they’re questioning the role of humanity in this super-changing thing.

    Tim Broadwater  

     No, I agree. I think what you see in Rocketeer is like, okay, does science ever go too far? Does capitalism ever go too far because robotics ever go too far in one point?

    The one that occurs to me here, even though it’s soft, I would say, all pissed or, you know, kind of speculative fiction is, in the end, this is probably as military as I go, or like war game as I go, is, I love Metal Gear and Metal Gear Solid. And metal. Yeah, and Metal Gear is completely based on an alternate history where the Cold War doesn’t end, you know, after the 1970s 1980s but continues right into the 90s. And so the first one, which is the Nintendo one where it’s all kind of above, you know, kind of view your Solid Snake or this rookie member of this group called Fox Hound, and then you are sent into where they find this weapon of mass destruction, you know, kind of in this place in South Africa, you know. Then with Metal Gear Solid, I think it becomes a little bit more pronounced because it’s the same premise to where it’s alternate history, Cold War, it keeps going, like it’s never ended, like Nazis or not, I don’t know, I can’t think of a name for it. But it’s like, there’s one piece of like, there’s a movie where like Nazis live on the moon or nazi zombies in Switzerland still, and, or whatever. But I mean, along that line, you’re sent into these kinds of scenarios, or these kinds of remote locations to do as a special-forces or SpecOps kind of person.

    You discover something like, Oh, you know, I’m finding a boss, like Psycho Mantis, which I’m not sure if you’ve played Metal Gear Solid. Have you? (Oh, yeah. Yeah,) so Psycho Mantis is from this German or Russian kind of experimentation. I’ve learned how to weaponize psychic powers. And now I’m working with, you know, the armed forces with that. And even though it’s not alternate history, per se, I would say it kind of lends a little bit enough from it. It’s kind of like, what I would say is like what Michael Crighton does, like a lot of it is writing. You’re like, Michael Crichton is a doctor who quit being an ER doctor, and he wrote the show. But all of his fiction is grounded in a little bit of science in history. Right? And so that’s why there’s so much of that seems plausible what they do in Jurassic Park, because it’s like, well, if we could get the DNA and we can clone, you know, what I mean? So it’s like science fiction versus, I guess, what you would call speculative fiction.

    Michael Schofield  

    Well, yeah, I think the idea of speculative fiction is, you know, “what if.” To your point about war before, it didn’t occur to me, but like, yeah. Nazi zombie is a great example. Because in World War Two, the Nazis were exploring all sorts of things. One of the reasons that we have Indiana Jones is because the Nazis were interested in the occult. So in that kind of scenario, the question that Indiana Jones poses is, “what if the Nazis found the Ark of the Covenant?” Right, you know, I mean, it’s ridiculous but —

    Tim Broadwater  

    Dead Snow is that show.

    Michael Schofield

    Dead Snow, which is like, it’s nazi zombies.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, it’s a Norwegian horror film from, like, the mid-2000s. And, and it’s, you know, Nazis went to Norway, I think what it is, and then like, they were looking for this occult relic, right, which reanimates them after death, you know, so, that kind of, definitely, like, science fiction and speculative fiction.

    Michael Schofield  

    Well, in this that whole thing where, you know, I feel like we should say, the big Nazi What if you know, being Wolfenstein 3d, like back in the day when you know, one of the first first-person shooters, where you have to go like fight like Mecha Hitler.

    Tim Broadwater  

    You’re escaping from a prison or concentration camp.

    Michael Schofield  

    Castle Wolfenstein. Yeah. You’re BJ Blaskowitz.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, Iron Sky is the movie I’m thinking of. Sorry, that is the one to where the Nazis have left Earth in the future because they’ve explored space travel and rocket technology. And they’ve built like the Nazis are on the moon, and they control the moon.

    Michael Schofield  

    The reason that this is like lowercase a lowercase p plausible is that in World War Two, the Germans built the v2 rocket, like had they won hadn’t had the world changed a little bit, maybe they would have been the ones to ultimately like land on the moon, right there. They’re really good fodder for speculative fiction, not only because we can look back at it, but because it’s so well detailed, it’s so well documented, in both picture and film, not let alone writing that we can, you know, speculate. Yeah, it would have happened if they would have won.

    Tim Broadwater

    There’s this interplay between like, and maybe this is speaking to the larger like, stepping back, like, what people want in games. Or what are players wanting? What is my balance between like, how real do I want this, or how much fiction do I want? Or do I want them to mingle together, right? And so I know that we started with mentioning Savage Frontier. I’ve never played the role-playing game or the tabletop role-playing game. Still, I played the old-school computer game Savage Frontier. And to me, like it was so amazing that you know, like, these people from I would say, the latter 1800s Britain or the UK, like go into a place to where dynasty? It’s a jungle and dinosaurs still exist, but they can understand firearms, and, you know, they understand how medicine works and how to make gunpowder and things like that. So it’s like when those two things kind of meet land of the Lost, Savage frontier, like how does it play out? And that’s exciting.

    Michael Schofield  

    I guess the question is, what do you as a player get out of like, exploring a scenario, right? Like, like, what is your takeaway, like, so maybe you sit down to play like a game of Battlefield, and you just run in the gun because it is ultimately like a stress reliever, right. But there’s something about dipping your toes into Bioshock, which probably spawned as many like objectivists as it did otherwise because it lets you explore philosophies in the safe environment of your bedroom, or your couch or chair, like with some headphones. Safer even then maybe just like reading, like reading a book, right? Because it’s in the context of a game as opposed to, you know, the danger of actually picking up a manifesto and reading propaganda that’s truly trying to change your mind. It’s fiction in the same way as reading, reading Jurassic Park, or watching Jurassic Park or playing Jurassic Park, Lego, or whatever, you get to safely explore how you might act if you came face to face with one of those acid-spitting dinosaurs that take Newman from Seinfeld out.

    Tim Broadwater

    — or maybe you want to kill Mecha Hitler.

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the Design Thinking Games podcast. To connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim, please go to designthinkinggames.com where you can request topics, ask questions, or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on.

  • 011: The Olympic Experience

    011: The Olympic Experience

    Games discussed on this episode:

    • Olympic Games Tokyo 2020 – The Official Video
    • Mario & Sonic at the Olympic Games Tokyo 2020

    Tim Broadwater  

    I’m always fascinated by the Olympics; I’m always fascinated about where they choose to like, where it’s going. And you know, it spits it out, like 10 years in advance, like, eight Olympics forward. And I think in 2028, it comes back to the US; it’ll be in LA. And then I’m always, you know, as a designer, part of me is always excited by the, you know, what fonts are they using. They change the logo here, and they have, like, a character that they make and a logo for both the Olympics and the Paralympics. So, personally, the Olympic branding, their website, their web app, and experiences are always the cream of the crop when it comes to the future of web design – or what’s happening right now. Right?

    Michael Schofield  

    What? Wait, yeah, really, I’m gonna have to load it up.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Their websites are phenomenal, you know, and I think NBC’s, you know, they always kind of throw up one, I feel like there’s is always going to be like, just like the most responsive, the coolest, you know, just great with content, but then that’s nbcolympics.com, but then there’s also, you know, the core Olympics.com which is actually by the Olympics committee. And so I’m just always kind of impressed about how you can search it and, and then also how it’s implemented. Like as it trickles down, right. So if you have a Roku TV, right, you can go into a Roku TV. It has iconography for all the sports, so you can actually go to an Olympic section, and then you can just go to gymnastics or sailing or, or whatever. And you can then get those highlight videos and content. So it’s like, it’s a lot. It’s like, I think they say it’s like 17,000 hours of content that’s recorded that’s baked into those 17 days, that is the Olympics. And then it’s just how it’s routed out to YouTube. And now streaming services are a huge part because of what NBC is doing with Peacock, and there’s now a Peacock +, which is their premium subscription. So you can watch the replays and the recaps, which are very, very constructed. And they’re very, like, here’s Lester Holt or Hoda Khatam, or like someone just like framing it and telling you to view and, but if you don’t want to watch them, you can go to the live streaming. Still, of course, it’s in Tokyo, so you’d have to watch it at four in the morning, you know, to get the live streaming. But then to get the live streaming access, you have to have like a cable network, and you have to have like all of the ESPN channels or the NBC Sports channels, and it’s just like this big to do. And it’s a lot of media, a lot of backstories, and it’s just like planned years in advance. And so I’m always impressed, you know, with how it’s reached and how, you know, kind of what all it touches media web-wise, and game-wise too. But I know that there’s a lot of Reddit and Twitter anger out there because once again, what people are reminded of is that NBC has paid $1.7 billion for all the US rights for airing, right. So they have total control of what we see in the States. And there are literally very few options to see if you don’t go through NBC.

    Michael Schofield  

    Planning out and putting together the Olympic design is one of the biggest design projects historically, every four years, how hundreds of design professionals, not to mention a Bible of design patterns that have to … – well, I don’t know if they have to be like honored by or trickled down through all the different streaming services through all the different websites because the other thing that like is true about the Olympics.com is that it like parts of it has modules that can be pulled into other news sites and the same way that I think of NPR where they’re You know, an NPR grandparent website. But all these other individual local public radio stations are NPR affiliates or pull in NPR programming. And that all comes down through, you know, these, you know, this kind of like modular design, both in terms of like look and feel, and in terms of the technology about how they pull it into their websites. And the Olympics looks like it’s doing the exact same thing. And I just did a cursory search. And I found, like the whole pattern libraries of the previous Olympics, which is fascinating. And also, of course, Reddit is going nuts about the bad UX of the Olympics. At least on the UX design subreddit, I guess, because I guess they’re doing some really cool things, or are arguably cool, quote, unquote, scare, quote, cool core cool. Things about projecting speeds and scores and stuff like that onto the event itself, as they’re happening in the same way that, like, Monday Night Football does.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Exactly. And then if you’re watching it, and you’re like, Hey, I just want to check out, I just want to watch that opening ceremony. Like every couple of minutes, you’re slammed with all of these plugins for NBC’s fall lineup or shows that are only available on Peacock. But I feel like, like, the UI is amazing, right? The UI as it extends to YouTube, and Peacock and an NBC or olympics.com is great; it works. The patterns are there. However, it’s the service that I think is a total disconnect for people. Because what people want, right the user experience here, they expect what the expectation is, is me as an average joe, whoever in the world, I’m, let’s say, I’m super interested in skateboarding, which is new this year and the Olympics. And I just want to go somewhere on my web, on my PlayStation, on my computer, on my phone, whatever. And watch. I just want to see the finals, you know, or I just want to see the qualifiers, or I want to see that. And so what the expectation is on that part of the user is always the same every, it’s not every four years, it’s every two years because the Winter Olympics are exactly the same way. I just want to go and watch what I want to watch. And if it happens to be live right now, I’ll watch it live. But if it’s already happened, I just want to be able to watch that feed, you know, and fast forward and rewind in it. It’s the same mechanics that we get with a DVR on Comcast, or if you have Hulu or YouTube or Netflix, the user wants to be able to go to the part they want to see or go to the content they want to see. But there are so many obfuscations and layers, where it’s like, NBC is like, we’re gonna create all this content and backstories of athletes, and then we’re gonna do the solo side stories. And then we’re gonna do these individual wrap-up stories. So we’re gonna do all this. And it’s just not what people want. And it’s the same every two years, every four years if you’re a summer or winter Olympics person. And it’s always the same. And the only way to get that experience you want is to pay for it and pay a lot. 

    Michael Schofield  

    I only learned there were even Olympics pay-per-view options this year because, frankly, as you know, as long as it takes to hit my radar with this kind of stuff. A lot of the people I follow were griping about the cost of the pay per view. And I legit had no idea. You had to pay-per-view Olympics if that sounds weird because, like growing up, it’s always been, you know, public access television or something. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    It’s definitely changed over time. Right. And then the other piece of it, depending on where it is in the world, when it was Sochi for the last winter Olympics, like it all happened in the morning. You had to get up at 6am, or you had to have the only option really was with you know, NBC is a company owned by Comcast. So you have to go to Comcast. That is literally the cream of the crop. You have to have Comcast cable, you have to have a DVR, and you have to have all of ESPN sports. That is legitimately The only way that you can watch anything and everything whenever you want. And fast forward and rewind and go to it. They have that lockdown. That is the only way to experience it in the way everyone expects and how it should be sure. There’s just you have to pay, and you have to go through that forced content. And it’s just so off-putting right it’s so off-putting.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, I totally understand that. And I just happened to find a discussion about the jobs to be done of providing an Olympic, I guess, an Olympic level Olympics experience. And I kind of want to run these by you to see if this sounds right. If you were to imagine, you know, if this were your job, if you were, you know, King Olympic design. And it was your job to provide the service. These would be the jobs, presumably, that your users have. I wanted to run through this just to get your thoughts and because I think it illustrates the difficulty in terms of the design challenge here. Particularly because these jobs will be very subjective, as I describe them, so here they go first, the big one. Watching the big events live in crisp and clear coverage, without buffering. There’s a little sub-thread here about how interesting it is that the idea of buffering or any kind of lag within the last 10 years was pretty reasonable. But we are now at a point where even given the popularity of the streaming services. How robust that infrastructure is now, that lag is now 20 in the 21st century, deemed unacceptable. For an event of this magnitude, Does that ring true?

    Tim Broadwater  

    I agree. That’s an infrastructure thing.

    Michael Schofield  

    It’s the convention, you know, like, if you can, if you can stream, you know, the latest Black Widow like through Disney plus or whatever. So maybe it’s not the same thing because it’s not being filmed in real-time. But the idea is that many people have a number of streaming services in their house. And for the Olympics, you know, the Olympic design and delivery service have to adhere to that convention, right? So it can’t look like, you know, PBS or something like that.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, webcasting has existed forever. Right. And so it’s basically you’re just delaying a couple of minutes. Yeah, we’re seconds or, you know, five minutes or whatever. And then it’s just, you know, once it’s cached, you’re streaming it. So the problem is not so much the webcasting, the two problems are further down the stream from that are the infrastructure of our cable networks in the world. If you’ve talked to anyone who’s actually gone to South Korea, before much faster, and they have national fiber, you know, so that’s, it’s paid for under their taxes, you know. So they have, it’s a utility, and it’s considered that way. And so there’s no, you know, you have the best access all the time. But then the other piece is this, this rights purchase, kind of purchasing. Right? And so when you have the partners of the Olympics and Paralympics that are Samsung, Toyota, Visa, Intel, Panasonic, Coca Cola, they’re paying for the content, right? And so, you know, their filters, their conference, their content, their lenses, their product is what is the place, and people. You know, so I think what’s happening is that what we’ve seen with the opening ceremony was the lowest it’s ever been in 33 years. 

    Yeah, the viewership is the lowest that it’s been in 33 years, which is, you know, over the last 15 or 16 Olympics, it’s the worst, especially in a time when everyone’s at home. They’re trying to stream, right? And they can’t, and so that speaks to a problem. That really speaks to the situation that’s there if the disconnect between it’s not always is. I understand what the stakeholders want is a bill, but is it really what customers are going to put up with? And so what you’re gonna see now is, it’s all going to below, we’re gonna have two weeks of low attendance, essentially, 14 days, and it’s over. And then people are just gonna watch it in reverse, right? They’re going to go on YouTube and watch it, or they’re going to go watch clips because it’s, it’s, it’s kind of inaccessible and unwatchable as it’s going on. And I think that it’s different from last year’s COVID-19. And we’re seeing HBO NOW, or Disney plus, like vying for like, oh, we’re gonna get certain movies, and we’re gonna get features and add it. But if you play premium, you can watch Milan early or, or HBO is like, no if you just pay us, we’re not going to screw you, you. You can watch our theater releases as they get released in the theater, you know.

    There’s always been this competition for attention. It’s an attention economy. But now I just think it’s like, you’ve kind of buried yourself. Some part of I think everyone is wondering, Is this what NBC is trying to do to leverage Peacock or get more people on Peacock subscription, so they get all the people to pay five bucks for just this month to watch it live. But this is the funny thing, it is not live coverage. If you just have internet and you don’t have cable, you can’t watch it through Hulu, you have to pay for the Live TV option for Hulu, or you have to pay it through Peacock or something like that. And so you’re not getting live TV. And then also when you’re watching it, it’s not like ESPN, where it’s just like, Hey, we just set up the cameras and it goes and what, you know, what event announcers we have there? Or who the people are that are really there physically? No, you’re getting a remixed kind of cut show. So you’re paying for, like, okay, Lester Holt’s coverage of it, that has been cut up and pieced together for you over a two-hour block on NBC every night at seven. And no one wants that, you know, no one, everyone just wants to watch the sport. They don’t want the commentary, you know, or if they do want the commentary. They don’t want broadcast news, people doing it.

    Michael Schofield  

    A huge part of like games and the design of games is the –

    Tim Broadwater  

    in which it’s given, you know, —

    Michael Schofield  

    the productization of it, right? I mean, the fact is that none of us can play games till that’s marketed toward us and that there’s some sort of like monetary value surrounding it. Right. So like, there’s this, like, one of the things, you know, it’s kind of like at this kind of marketing or monetary or, you know, what, I think what you can imagine is that you know, here, the Olympic Games, it’s a world good, right? It’s supposed to be this great uniter, maybe not uniter, but you know, a kind of a peaceful exercise, internationally, where countries can put their best faces on and do something other than politic for a little bit. Right. But in this case, I think what we have is a super example of, you know, the creation of like a hardcore anti-pattern specifically to you know, pump up the subscriber numbers to Peacock plus where they are funneling access or making access difficult specifically to you know, create these points of friction that’s going to make them a little bit of money. You see this in games, like all the time, these are microtransactions, these are whatever, right? And it’s just interesting where, you know, I think it’s valid to talk about the games and you know, that’s what the Olympics are there, you know.

    Tim Broadwater  

    No, I agree with you and, and how and I how I equate it is not microtransactions how I equate it is as a user, or viewer, and I love the Olympics. I’m actually in the Summer Olympics. I love that their karate is this year. It has never been before. This will be the first year for karate and the only year for karate. Um, Sumo was supposed to be in, but it is not. That is kept a lot of people upset internationally. Because Judo has been in for like 40 years, it’s like come on with the can. I thought the goal here of the IOC, the International Olympic Committee, is building a better world through sports. And that’s excellence, respect, and friendship. And then, you know, the inclusion and, you know, kind of everything. But what it feels like, as the user experience, feels like if I did not buy early onboard access, or like I didn’t buy the dynamic, or what is it called the director’s cut edition, or like when a game comes out. You buy it, you’re like, Oh, you can buy the game, or you can pre-order the deluxe. Yeah, you can pre-order the beta. Or you can pay $200 to get the deluxe Steelcase with a map and a poster in a T-shirt. And it’s like, if I didn’t do that, then I don’t get the experience that I kind of expect. That’s what it feels. To me. It’s just like how this happens every four years. And it’s like, people just want to watch their sports or watch their athletes compete from their hometown, there are real people involved in this. And that’s what people like about it. You don’t need to sell us the story of the real people. Yeah, we know that real people, you know, so it’s, so what, why, why is it so difficult? You know, why? It just kind of feels that way? To me? Yeah, I don’t know if it feels that way, too. You know,

    Michael Schofield  

    I mean, like, what it feels like is that you know, there’s like a product team who were like, hey, how can we milk the shit out of this? Particularly, because we, you know, have such a, we control all of the bottlenecks, right? So they can hook them all together into like, one long funnel from product A to product B to product C, all of which they own. And in par, I bet the confusion alone is accidentally having people subscribe to services, which boosts the money. You know, it’s like, you know, what it is, is like I like, you know, probably a case study in how, you know, maybe like, what people hate about product teams. And I think that’s really important because it’s the kind of shit that gets in the way of everything. There are all these articles about the Olympic design system, the amount of work that goes into creating and facilitating these services, the jobs to be done of the users are pretty clear, crisp coverage, being able to find out when the big-name athlete is competing, according to the country you care about, right? Keep you up to date about the country’s sports that you care about, you know, stuff like that seems pretty clear. And from all intents and purposes, that looks like these provisions totally exist. Except, you know, the top of the funnel part just getting to it. Yeah, is, is a minefield.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So it’s like, they kind of know that people want to watch it, you know, but it’s like. It feels, as, from a user perspective, it just feels disingenuous. It feels like I can’t play the game because I have all of these filters or things I need to pay for. And I just want to get to the game and watch the game, you know,

    Michael Schofield  

    We can all put on our Business Administration hat and then see what the big sponsors want out of the Olympics and how they are, how they’ve decided to get it. So what can fans of the Olympics do? Can they do nothing? Right? Because, you know, there is a pretty strong iron grip monopoly over how footage, like how the footage is controlled.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I think it speaks for itself. If the opening ceremony was the lowest viewership, it’s been in 33 years. People are just gonna wait until it’s done. And they’re gonna watch it after the fact. So maybe just keep the counter to see where the medals are like, Oh, are we good? Are we had I wait?

    Michael Schofield  

    I have a question for you. So I think we can see like maybe like how the Olympics got here if we kind of imagine. The IOC, or at least like NBC and Comcast, have been designing around the key performance indicator of viewership, right? And so what brings in most viewers while Judo, and not Sumo, like all of these decisions about what sports get footage what sports get brought in how people get, how things are aired, how things are cut up, or how things have ended up in a series of single setting digestible clips, which they may discover is exactly not what people want. But we can all imagine that, you know, that sort of viewership. So KPI is sort of at the middle of this, do you think that? Is that indicator tanking? Is it going to mean an improvement in two years? When the? Or do you think it’s going to have an effect?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, I don’t. So there are two issues here, right? I, like somatically, there’s the issue of the IOC and the sports. And there’s also the issue of, like, how it’s being delivered and consumed. Right. So the sports that don’t get into the Olympics create their own global kind of things anyway. Right? And they have world games that go around, and so there just seems to be so there’s like, so that’s one issue, right? That I think a lot of people aren’t happy with, to work with, to cycle in new sports and, and get rid of older sports and, and, and some things stay forever, in some things. Doubt. But then the other piece is like when you’re talking about your viewership is the KPI. If it’s the metric that people are looking at, well, yeah, I’m sure the way that BBC does it is completely different than NBC. And so I feel like, you know, at some point, I don’t know if those are going to change. If you’re doing something that’s not happy, and you’re losing viewers on the show gets canceled. I mean, that’s Yeah, that’s what it is. You know, it’s like, you may think this show is the greatest, but I mean, when viewership drops, it’s time to change, like, what are we doing wrong. And I feel like we know more than ever live in a period where people don’t want commercials. We know that from DVRs. People will pay not to see commercials. They will pay to not have to watch them. And they will, and they just want to get to that content that they’re looking for. And the advertising part is just kind of like a fly that’s in the way that’s bugging you, you know. So I think we’ll have to see how this works out.

    Michael Schofield  

    I turned from the Olympics. Who knows how many years ago when we started chatting before we recorded? You know, we were talking about the Olympics. And I was like, man, I have not. I haven’t cared about the Olympics and such in a certain amount of time. And, boy, it’s fascinating to like, look at from the outside in as like, you know, I was just talking about like, oh, how product, people ruin everything. I’m a Product person. You know, I’m, like, I’m thinking about, it’s interesting to watch. And I’m very excited to see something like, you know, hashtag design Twitter. And the product folks on the internet in the blogosphere have to say, you have to see how it shakes out. Like it occurred to me, because now that you mentioned that, hey, skateboarding is now an Olympic sport, you know, years ago, years ago. And still, I guess they have the X Games. And those are crazy to watch. Right.

    I wonder if there’s going to be a time in our lifetime where eSports ends up in the Olympics, somehow?

    Tim Broadwater  

    I don’t know. That’s a pretty good question. Because and then also with that, like, a lot of people don’t understand. It’s the duplicativeness, right. So it’s like volleyball beach and volleyball. Why would we need two volleyballs, you know, Oh, you know what I mean? And then I think it’s kind of like I think there’s like equestrian dressage eventing and jumping? Yeah, it’s like okay, so three-horse events. And then freestyle wrestling versus Greco Roman wrestling? And you’re talking about stuff that’s been in there since 1920.

    Yeah, sure. It’s like, can you rotate that out and like, give something else a space. But then also with that is, you know, every time Olympics comes up, it also is a game. And it’s there. So there’s an official Olympic Games, Tokyo 2020 2020 video game, and it’s out on, you know, PlayStation and Xbox and switch and steam and stadia. And so, it is very much this experience that is, you know, people want what people want about it. And then also, what comes out with that are other spin-offs, like Sonic, Mario Olympics, or you know, other stuff like that. But, um, what people want is like, I just want to make up my character. I wanted to compete and do well and see how well I do, you know, and just qualify, and do well and keep playing and get a better time. So I think the gaming piece here from the player experience is that people like competition. They want to compete and be healthy with other people. They want to get better. They want to improve. And when you kind of apply that to watching, or just the Olympic Games, like real sports, like it’s tough, but I mean, we’re rooting for people, we want them to get better. We want to play, and we want them to succeed. Yeah, it doesn’t matter if it’s like a figure skater from France, or a gymnast from Romania, or like, you know, a track person from Nigeria, or, you know, kind of a Jamaican bobsled team or whatever. You know, we all cheer when they do well, yeah, when someone falls or gets injured, we’re like, we all cringe because we don’t wish that on anyone. And so we are all here for it because it is the sports that do kind of unify, you know, that brings us all together. And you know, and I feel like at its core level, which is building a better world through sports and like sports brings people together. That will always be the same, whether the coverage or the sponsorship or the product team screws it up. Right, so I feel like the desire will always be there, the sportsmanship part of it right. And that’s what I think is kind of maybe getting a little lost.

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the Design Thinking Games podcast. To connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim, please go to designthinkinggames.com where you can request topics, ask questions, or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on.

  • 010: Class Mechanics

    010: Class Mechanics

    In this episode we talked about:

    • 6:29 AD&D 2nd Edition
    • 12:25 Starfinder
    • 16:17 Pathfinder 2nd Edition
    • 18:30 Battlefied
    • 20:25 Mork Borg
    • 21:30 Marvel Superhero RPG
    • 27:28 Vampire: the Masquerade
    • 31:30 New World

    Introductory Guy  

    Hello. Welcome to design thinking games,s a fantasy and user experience podcast. Each episode, your podcast hosts, Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield, will examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper role-playing games, live-action games, mobile games, and video games. You can find every episode, including this one on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at designthinkinggames.com.

    Michael Schofield  

    So last night is Thursday evening, which for many a  Dungeons and Dragons player is their game night as a holy day of the week. We had a couple of our players who had guests in town, and so I was able to randomly generate a class for them. Here’s an example of kind of like, what was counterintuitive for a new d&d fifth edition player who [Schofield gibberish] about the class system. They come into play a game. In this scenario that they’re dropping into, the Quarriors have found their way into Temple of Deneir out in the Living Dunes, deep in the sands. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    This is your homebrew, right? 

    Michael Schofield  

    Think of Brendan Fraser’s The Mummy. Right?

    Tim Broadwater  

    I love that movie. It’s a good movie.

    Michael Schofield  

    So here they are, trying to get into the heart of this mysterious sand-covered temple. The new players, our party guests, are picking up the roles of a couple of the retainers that the party had hired to help them, you know, do some of the labor around traveling, but here we are. Okay, so these players who are guests of the party are picking up the roles of some of the retainers that helped the party do some laborious travel. They’re the ones who carry all the heavy packs, things like that. I happen to know because of the mechanics of the game and some of the homebrew that we’re playing that one of these is a lower class or lower level Ranger and the other as a lower level barbarian. So I randomly generate these characters at that level and dole them out. The issue is that this first scenario for two people in the session is one full of puzzles. They are deep in this temple, and they’re not fighting bad guys or zombies or sand creatures. They are trying to get from chamber to chamber by solving riddles. It’s one of those things. So what do players do around the table? They start solving the riddles, and riddle time is one of those parts of a game where… 

    Riddle time is the part of the game where I think the line between the player and the character really blurs right. You can sometimes have a character who’s smarter than you. And they may roll to get some added insight that you as a player might not actually know. But generally, you, the player, are the one who is trying to solve the puzzle. It’s no longer your character tit’s you. So what we had was this person who’s playing Hither the Barbarian was making really good guesses at some of these puzzles as they go all the while when periodically she had to roll ln arcana check or a history check, she had a negative one. Right? So her character is by class and just especially by the random assortment, or the random allotment of skills for this barbarian class, is dumb as rocks, but the player is quite smart. And when she failed every single intelligence check that was made, she was really confused because she’s like, Damn, I  the player solved the riddle or could solve this riddle, but my character is stupid. And it’s one of those things where she found that the constraint of the class was was really confusing. So all this to say, this is the anecdote that I want to lead into when we start talking about the mechanics and the design of particularly like RPGs, where powers and skills and capacities are organized in classes, engineers or soldiers or adepts or barbarians as opposed to the alternative, which is some sort of like classless game design where you level up a certain ability through use.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, there are a couple things there. I know you told me in the past that you’ve never played Dungeons and Dragons before the fifth edition. That’s a grasping the pearls moment for me. Because that’s, I’m just like, how is that even possible? Because I know you, you know,

    Michael Schofield  

    I brought that up because there’s a lot of discussion about the constraints of classes and d&d fifth edition and going classless, and I thought this was new. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    no, no, it’s always baked into d&d. I’d never played the original OG Gygax Dungeons and Dragons. I played Advanced and then Advanced second edition, and so on. So I played the first, second, and third edition Dungeons and Dragons. In the first edition, I can’t speak to it because I literally don’t remember. But I spent many years playing the second edition, Dungeons and Dragons, advanced dungeons and dragons. In the second edition, it was the kick in the gut to dual-class or multi-class. And the reason why is if you went along, and you were a barbarian. You got to the third or fourth level, and you’re like, hey, I want to pick up, you know, a thief kind of thing like to pull off maybe a barbarian thief, kind of like Conan is in the movie. It made no sense. Because to start over just to learn to pickpocket and use thieves tools and sneak, you didn’t retain anything in your brain about being a barbarian until you’ve got up to that third or fourth level again. And once you were third or fourth level, and you got to the same point we were with, like rogue or thief with a barbarian, then you could pursue both, like you would split your experience. Right?

    Michael Schofield  

    Wow. Wow, that’s hardcore. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    And it was just like, dude, there’s very, there’s a huge difference between a first and a fourth level character, you know, just like there’s a seventh and a 10th level character difference, right? And so when you are rolling with your buddies, and you’re playing, and you’re just like, oh, crap, now I go back to level one. They’re gonna have to carry me for like a while. And so it was really clumsily done, just for the reason that you specifically said, because it didn’t seem real. It didn’t seem that you could have a smart barbarian that you could have a magic-user who could fight, you know, like martial arts, not martial arts, but like melee, right? Could fight in melee. And but we all were raised with Gandalf and read Lord of the Rings. So we’re like, well, this doesn’t make sense. Gandalf had a sword, you know what I mean? And so I think it was, to me, and this is kind of stepping back and looking at it. It’s like, I think classes can be great. And they’ve worked for years. But I think what we see now is this push towards more sophisticated or realistic or advanced ways that we can put skills and proficiencies and abilities together than having it divided in these silos? Like if you want to heal someone, versus if you want to steal from someone versus if you want to be able to fight on a horse. I mean, those are like those three classes never shall the twain meet, you know. And I think that’s a lot of people’s experience with tabletop RPGs until maybe recently.

    Michael Schofield  

    It occurred to me while you’re talking, and I decided to Google just to see if there’s some evidence here. Still, to me, the idea of like classes plays really well when you think of the party as a single unit, right? The reality when you, as a group of players in a collaborative game, are playing against the big bad, you’re going after the white dragon, or you’re facing down Cthulhu, is that it’s not five individuals versus the hulking beast. It is a party unit, your coterie, your group that, together, composes a well-defined opponent to the bad guy cuz you have the tank. You have the healer, and you have the spell slinger, and so on. Right, but increasingly, you know, especially with the popularity of d&d, in the last couple of years, thanks in part to that pandemic And Critical Role before that, is that Dungeons and Dragons and these kinds of RPGs and maybe dovetails with the popularity and scale of single-player RPGs that have come out like Skyrim, and The Elder Scrolls games. But it seems to me that now when I’m playing with my group of players, where I’m playing by myself, or I’m listening to people talk about the kind of like the meta-conversation around d&d, it’s, the RPG is an exploration of the individual, as opposed to like the group dynamic. So it’s really highlighting those individual features.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so if you think of traditional role-playing games, to where it’s like, who’s our healer? We can’t even go if we don’t have a healer. So there’s some truth About that, you know, where it’s like we have to have a paladin who will not cut it. We need a cleric or, you know, something our Life Oracle or something like that, right. And I think that’s something that, over time, kind of evolves, not that it was bad. It’s just not realistic, right? And I think if you look at modern systems that I’m aware of, well, let me just say Starfinder, which is the sci-fi, tabletop role-playing game from Piso. Oh, are you aware of it?

    Michael Schofield  

    I’m aware of it because you talk about it all the time. But I’ve never once played it.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So it actually won in its first year, best RPG of the year, like the tabletop role-playing game of the year, because I just think it was a time when people …  like it was a good time. People were sick of high fantasy, and they wanted something different. And it’s kind of like Mass Effect, but the role-playing game, you know what I mean? So there’s like all these, like, an insane amount of player races that alien races you can play and whatever. But what Starfinder does that I really like is that, since it’s the future. It’s space, everyone if you think of these things that are like, okay, magical items, tech, cybernetics robots, those are things that anyone can have. That’s all kind of offloaded into the, like, a lot of skills are offloaded into that, like, you don’t need to play a winged race because dude, everyone can buy a jetpack, you know. And it’s kind of like everyone can buy anti-gravity boots, everyone can have a drone with a camera on it, you know, everyone can have, you know, these kinds of things. So it kind of levels a lot of the playing field. And then really what it is that I like, what I think a lot of people like about Star finder and find it refreshing is that it would be a combination of the unique eccentricities – I don’t know what word I’m looking for. But the unique characteristics of I guess what I’m trying to say is classes don’t matter so much anymore. Your alien race matters. And if you can all get magical items, and tech and cybernetics, and whatever, and a vehicle in a spaceship. You know, it adds enough play to it. So it really comes down to more of the character flavor that you want. It’s not limiting, right? There are many different ways you can heal yourself. You can do it with serums, you could do it with medkits, you can do it with magic, you know, and you can have access to all those things. So it’s a combination. So if you think of offloading all your skills that way, like hey, I don’t need to put a lot into computers or hacking, but I could have a robot with me that hacks computers for me, you know, or something like that. It kind of lets you kind of do whatever you want. And the classes themselves in Starfinder don’t have a lot of crazy abilities. I mean, there’s some cool stuff, but they can’t really only really do one thing and so like you’re either Everyone can fire laser weapons so everyone can range attack, right? Everyone can fire. Everyone can use a melee weapon. So the classes are like, well, this one’s maybe better at melee or this one’s better. This one inherently gets magic, but that doesn’t mean you can’t use magic, so it opens it up enough to where you don’t have to worry about, you know, kind of being pigeonholed into being one thing like in older RPGs and Piso which does Pathfinder and StarFinder. And there’s Pathfinder first and second edition, first edition second edition, and Starfinder – well I will say this the first edition and second and Starfinder lets you add every level so at every level you can say like I’m going to be a Vanguard and the next level the class I’m going to take is an envoy. Then I’m going to take two Soldiers and then think so each level you can just add a new class. As long as you can meet the requirements for that class, like at least you have to have the basic strength or wisdom score whenever you can just custom build it as you level up, there is no kind of penalty; however, when they released Pathfinder second edition two years ago, they nerfed that because I think they found out like although people loved it because you could be a barbarian wizard Bard you know what I mean? If you want to and may have something cool. What they found is that characters got really OP quickly and became overpowered, so in second edition Pathfinder, when you level, if you start out as a, let’s say, a rogue or thief, you are always a rogue or a thief. However, they’ve tons of feats, and in the second edition, there are racial feats. There are class feats, you know, there are combat feats, and everyone gets everything right. You can sack some of your class feats as a rogue. So you’re like, I can pick pockets, But okay, I’m not gonna hide in the shadows. But I will sack my hide in shadows to get access to cleric abilities. Oh, so they’ve made it to where you can kind of like you can like learn and do things from other classes,  but it’s not you’re not going to advance as much as you do as a rogue if you are also going to heal people, but it doesn’t penalize you you know,

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, that’s interesting. I kind of want to rewind a minute to your mention that they discovered that players kind of doing a building however they wanted, ended up creating really overpowered characters. I think that’s probably what the argument for class is like in terms of the design of the system of the game. I imagine classes make it easier to balance right you see this kind of expressed and really counterintuitive ways in some shooters. I like my first-person shooters, and the war game I really like is I prefer the Battlefield series to just about everything else. Recently they have really excellent rifles class locked to a medic class that you would think would be available to a sniper class or class or any class really. But they do that precisely because the specific intricacies of Class A added to the buffs and abilities of Weapon B create something indomitable. It’s weird, and it’s hard as a player not to run into that cognitive leap. It’s almost like an uncanny valley where you’re like, wow, this is really not real this is not how it would be in an act like if you actually like setting foot in the game, which is probably exacerbated as games become increasingly realistic. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    There’s the opposite to that as well, like even more of rejection or run away from reality like I want fantasy isn’t ridiculous. I want overpowered. 

    Michael Schofield  

    One of the things that we’ve been talking about for you know, the many episodes now have been about like player like the role of Player customization and that like overall experience, and it’s one of those things where classes really get in the way. These are real barriers.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I also am, I don’t know, what other kind of class versus classes, classless mechanics you’re a fan of or you like, but I kind of like one of the things we talked about here recently, I think, was Mork Borg. Yeah, so Mork Borg is an old-school revival. It is a brutal, post-apocalyptic game. And it is, essentially, but you have limited stats. The cool thing about Mork Borg is, is you have limited stats, you have limited health damage attributes, or whatever, whenever you level up. It is basically like White Wolf or World of Darkness to where it’s like you get dots. Now, you can put those dots on whatever you want. It could be your vampire power of celerity. Or it could be your claws, as a werewolf, or it could be just your health. But it’s just like you actually choose what you want to be good at because you just get dots.

    Michael Schofield  

    It’s just a finite amount of dots.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, and so maybe you do a campaign, and at the end of the campaign, you level up, and it’s like, you get free dots. And so it’s really how you could then make yourself super fast or make yourself more healthy, or, you know, or whatever, or good at firearms. I mean, it’s really, you know, it’s kind of that open system. And Mirk Borg is like that as well, as well as the old school Marvel Superheroes role-playing game, like when you level up, you essentially can increase. Marvel Superheroes, the role-playing game, is an old tabletop role-playing game that I want to actually start running a campaign for here in the next couple of months, just because I hadn’t played it since I was in Middle School. And it’s fun. If you ever want to play a superhero-based tabletop role-playing game, I highly suggest Marvel superheroes role-playing game, but it is essentially the same, you have powers. However you get them, it doesn’t matter if they’re tech, alien magic, whatever, you have the knowledge, and you have resources. And so essentially, if you want to make yourself better at driving cars or make your laser eyes, like more powerful, or you want to have more money, I mean, it’s like the dots for like White Wolf, it’s where you put them. So it doesn’t really matter.

    Michael Schofield  

    When it comes to balance, where does having like a finite amount of points to expend how do you prevent that OP nature? What prevents you from putting, you know, five points into Firearms which maxes it out? 

    Tim Broadwater  

    know, it’s kind of how it’s what I like about White Wolf. And you may be able to speak to this too, like the White Wolf tabletop role-playing game, or Marvel Superheroes or Mork Borg or others that are classless systems have this, you know, kind of not a skill tree, but it’s like you get what you get, like experience, and you can put it however you want to your character in whatever way, it’s kind of just a note like, through role-playing, or through what you do in your downtime, quote, unquote, is that and so if you want your character to be like really good at ranged attacks, or firearms or weapons, you kind of that’s what you focused on when you’re working with your character, like, Hey, I started going to the gun range with my human friend, he doesn’t know I’m a vampire, but you know, and then I started getting really good at shooting and then that’s something that you can take over. Because you can also say that you worked on your speed or your celerity, right, so you could move super quick.  So it’s kind of like that, if it’s for richness or resources, then it’s basically like, Oh, you spent a month or two weeks or whatever your downtime is doing PR spinning up a website, doing some podcasts interviews there, you know, and then but then people know you and recognize you. So you know, it’s kind of so it lets you play whatever character you want to play and grow it however you want to grow it. And it doesn’t always have to be, “I will never get these powers or abilities. Because I’m limited by a class.” 

    Michael Schofield  

    And that’s the key. Let’s say you’re a ranger in fifth edition dungeons and dragons, and you are hanging out with wizards in your travails. You have lifted the spell books of many, many another wizard antagonist, right. So you have, like in your downtime, ample opportunity. Let’s say you have five spellbooks in your party, you know, one belonging to your own wizard, and then just four others that you’ve looted, you have ample opportunity in like a long rest, like over the course of a campaign to maybe study, but the system will not let you earn certain or use certain spells because you know, those spells are locked to the wizard class or something like that. And that’s, and that’s the main, that’s a particular gripe, right? Because the uncanny valley comes in when you are told for system reasons that under no circumstances could your forest-born wood elf ever learn this spell, Even if it’s taught to you by the creator of that spell or something like that.

    Tim Broadwater  

     100% Yeah, it’s like, you’re never going to learn. In Pathfinder Second Edition, they actually have, like, occult magic, nature magic, arcane magic, and divine magic, right? They have four magic systems. They used to have psychic magic too, which was, basically, mind magic. I mean, it’s what they called it, you know what I mean? But it’s basically everything you think of a scientist or, you know, you know, telepathic or whatever. But, but no, I agree with you. And I think the reason why, and I’m not gonna say it’s lazy, is because I think it has to work, like content-wise and map to a game, and you’re not super powerful, super early. But the reason why the White Wolf, Mork Borg, Marvel Superhero systems like the dots, like you get dots and points, whatever you want to call them. It maps to video games really easily. You know, whenever you complete a class, or you kill X amount of people, and you get to experience, you level up, boom, you get a dot.

    And so if you want to be faster, or you want a lot of people in games, go to the strategy, like, dude, I’m gonna max out my health first. So I have just huge health. Or I’m gonna max out my defense, so I don’t wear my attack. So you know, everyone plays differently. And it’s not lazy. I think it’s a little lazy. But, but it’s like, that’s an easy go-to experience system. But the thing it affords you, we call it lazy you’re not, is also you can kind of work to what you want. You’re not locked into trees or in a class.

    Michael Schofield  

    In Vampire there, there is a kind of class, however, right, and it’s your vampire clan, where I think classes play a role, which I think is interesting because I play, I like to play low fantasy gritty games that deal with real things hashtag. And that’s one of the reasons that I liked the World of Darkness when we talked about in that episode is because it’s this world is just a little more supernatural. One of the things where I think classes work, and vampires have, you know, veiled the vampire class system is their clan, which does restrict I mean, for the most part, like with different disciplines, the vampire powers that you have access to, like only the Brujah have, maybe potency and celerity. And you know, that kind of like, the powers that you think of in terms of vampires being super strong and super fast. And the clan that you choose as a player tailors your experience, not to the skills that you can develop, but like the potential for your vampiric power.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I think what you’re saying and this is it’s been a while it’s been a minute since I’ve played, you know, Vampire, that or werewolf is that the whole point of the clan or werewolf tribe, or whatever it is, is that there are actually certain powers that only that that clan gets access to that are passed down through turning. But then there’s a general vampire pool, right? Like werewolf to where you can just kind of get general powers that all vampires could get. Yeah. Is that correct? No.

    Michael Schofield  

    No. Like, at least not in the Old World of Darkness. Right? Like it really is that the idea of the clan, like what, like when I think of a class that works a class system, the idea of the clan is really on the nose because the clan is effectively about the in this case, vampiric but the social strata into which you are born, you can’t escape the nature of your clan. Now all vampires have things in common. They’re pretty hungry, they have things, and they have something within them called the beast that wants to come out whenever there’s a hint of blood in the air. Or

    Tim Broadwater  

    Claws? Not all know like vampires have claws?

    Michael Schofield  

    Not in the original. Well, so in “OWOD.” So we know there’s World of Darkness one, and now we’re in World of Darkness Three (?). I made a huge caveat when we talked on this episode that I played in the late 90s through the early 2000s. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    First, like Gangrels can get claws.

    Michael Schofield  

    Only Gangrels can get class. Now, how do you let’s say, one of the Toradora? Who are who’s considered sort of like the bougie clan?  How do you get Gangrel powers? Well, you kill one, you kill a Gangrel, and you suck their soul out of them.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Right? Like you drink, you kill one and drink their blood, and you can get it that way.

    Michael Schofield  

    You may do more than drink their blood. You literally consume their very essence and, and there’s a game mechanic. It’s called Diablerie. And there’s a mechanic where that can go awful for you. But if it works,

    Tim Broadwater  

    You get powers from other bloodlines.

    Michael Schofield  

    Exactly what I like about certain, I’ve seen some homebrews and Dungeons and Dragons that I’ve, I’ve considered because I feel constrained by classes now. But one of the things I like is like class or a kind of certain features or skills that are unlocked by your background, like, I think there’s something kind of interesting about the ideas like, Oh, my family is a noble, my family are nobles, and we have all these resources. And thus, I am an excellent researcher. Right. But like, Oh, it was like I was a peasant child born like, next to a wood – like a lumber mill. You’re probably illiterate. I think that’s compelling. And I love the idea. Whereas like, you know, I when there’s a game that Amazon is developing called New World that you put me on to that I’ve been watching interested because I’m pretty sure. Although I’m pretty sure that it is a classless MMO

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, and I think that was one of the reasons, even in a general topic about it, because it looks amazing. And that’s the big selling point that they keep pushing. It’s like no classes, be whatever you want to be, build who you want to build. Everyone’s on the same playing field. You know,

    Michael Schofield  

    it’s amazing.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah. So for like New World, I know that there are a lot of people that I where I work who are interested in getting on board, and they’re doing a beta now or an alpha. Now, unfortunately, what you do in the alpha or beta doesn’t get copied over to

    Michael Schofield  

    I hate that. Yeah,

    Tim Broadwater  

    yeah, it doesn’t get copied over to the actual game. So to me, and every player is different. But for me, that is like, well, I’m just gonna wait till it starts. Right and, and I know, you’d pay more to get on the alpha or the beta just to get like a new custom item set, or like a cool armor piece or a cool mount. But that doesn’t appeal. That’s not enough spin for me to be like, you can play and waste it all. And it doesn’t go anywhere. But like what I like about the new world is exactly this thing to where it’s like we are totally embracing this classless system. It’s a point build, and my understanding of the limited stuff I’ve watched is if you think about Pirates of Caribbean time period, which I’m not exactly sure what that is, but it’s basically like, we have technology to some degree. We have simple Steam Machines, and there’s gunpowder, and there are muskets and guns, right. And there’s giant like armadas and sailing across the sea that basically it’s an alternate version of history where they find an island. I guess it’s named a Turnham or a Turnham. Like

    Michael Schofield  

    Aeternum. Yeah.

    Tim Broadwater  

    As you know, and I will be an Amazon fanboy and say, everything that Amazon touches is gold. Yeah, they know, desirability. They know the difference between usability and desirability, and they give people desirability, and so a lot of people are very excited for, you know, what Amazon can do to try to experience it, and I will definitely be checking it out.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, as much as I like to even treat in my normal life, like, you know, like, we, we utter the word Amazon and spit over our shoulder and sprinkle salt on our ancestors some shit, but like, they are winning, because they’re good. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    They know what people want and what will people pay for and they, and that’s what they give them. 

    Michael Schofield  

    When we get a chance to play this, I really want to break down some of the design choices they make. Is this style of classlessness, and do as you will like the future? I would love to really pick the mind of someone who’s working on the engines underneath something like this, about how they think about it because when I think about gosh, if I were to design a game, even at like a small level, like a game that just exists within the four corners of a table. To your point, I think classes are easier to balance. Right. The difficulty The development probably increases exponentially to give the player this kind of experience, but if they nail it, then you know this is going to be sticky. Because you know, and then and maybe this is a good dovetail into like a subsequent episode, something that we’ve never even put on our board, but I’m thinking about it. Because, you know, if this game gets legs and there’s a player base, and Amazon really leans into it, they’re going to embellish this experience with cross-platform opportunities. Imagine Alexa tells you, oh my gosh, there’s someone waiting for you at your fish market to make a transaction.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Oh, yeah. Microtransactions definitely baked into it. There’s also I think when you think about the quest for the most usable game, and we talked about yet another metric or slider, right, realism, some of the things that you said versus realism versus fantasy, where some people would say, well, that’s not realistic in the real world do you have to devote for years to just learn how to become a sword Master? So you should be if you’re a samurai class, you should only get this and people outside the class. Should it? Yeah, and I see that I get it. I’m like that. I do get it. That’s realism. Some people don’t want that in games. Like the realism piece of like, studying your class being locked down versus like being a phenomenal sniper, like, what’s my shooting time? And what’s the kickback of a gun? You know, that’s, that’s a type of realism. But there’s also this the fantasy side, right, which is, you know, why can’t I transform into a cat swing a giant magic sword and, and cast lightning fireballs, you know, you know, and be able to pickpockets, you know? So it’s like, oh, well, so it kind of also depends on what people want out of the game.

    Michael Schofield  

    Tim, if you put your mind to it, you can accomplish anything.

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the design thinking games podcast. To connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim, please go to designthinkinggames.com, where you can request topics, ask questions, or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on.

  • 009: Grinding the Rewards

    009: Grinding the Rewards

    Games talked about in this episode:

    • 2:02 World of Warcraft
    • 2:59 Dark Souls
    • 5:16 Mass Effect
    • 7:12 Bloodborne
    • 8:27 Cuphead
    • 15:26 Hellblade
    • 19:59 Monster Hunter
    • 26:51 Spider-Man
    • 34:16 Sea of Thieves

    Introductory Guy  

    Hello. Welcome to design thinking games, a fantasy and user experience podcast. Each episode, your podcast host, Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield, will examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper role-playing games, live-action games, mobile games, and video games. You can find every episode, including this one, on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at designthinkinggames.com.

    Tim Broadwater  

    We were talking about experience models, and grinding different games, depending on if they’re tabletop role-playing games, video games, what have you, even LARPing they have different kinds of experience models. And, you know, some have visualizations of that, like trees that you unlock for skill sets. Others just seem to be like, unlocking abilities as you advance in levels, you know, for your character class. But, still, then others are just like the heinous grind that is essentially unrelenting and unforgiving. So, like, are you like that type of player who loves that kind of experience? Or that kind of high difficulty, right?

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, experience model is an interesting way to phrase it. It’s, you know, it’s a reward model. Right. So you grind, you kill all the pigs in Warcraft, to either mine experience points, actual coins, look for that loot drop, but the reward is a gift from the game. You get a thing by performing an action. And I think difficulty makes that reward from having like a middling impact to being orgasmic. Right. And I think the folks who love the difficulty, the high difficulty type of gameplay, regardless of whether it’s a specific grind model, or something else, is because the reward the payoff for is so good when you get through it. So when you finally get through your first or second Dark Souls boss, you feel like a boss yourself, which is a different kind of gameplay model than, you know, churning XP, which you’ve gained by killing rabbits to get to level two.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, I mean, I’ve attempted Dark Souls once in my life, and I think after 45 minutes, I was like, fuck this game and quit.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, we’ve talked about this before. And I think we were talking about, you know, for the umpteenth time, we’ll bring up the Mass Effect legendary edition, but we were talking about our different playstyles. And, you know, I’m trying to roll through this game on the insanity level because I want that sweet, sweet achievement at the end, but you’re here. So like trying to like, you know, enjoy yourself, which seems bananas.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Auto leveling, auto-leveling auto skill assignment, I don’t care, I just kind of want, I’m the exact opposite. I just like low maintenance, ease of joy. That’s why I’m here. And in. And I think honestly, beyond insanity, I have a friend who has a great YouTube channel where he does walkthroughs; he does professional walkthroughs and doesn’t for GameFAQs and stuff like that. And he’s a completionist. He will get every item in Final Fantasy 6, he will level up every character to 999, you know, will do 100% map exploration like and that’s what he likes, and you don’t get a reward for that at all. There’s no, you know, some games have it baked in, but some don’t. Right. But that’s just personally what he likes about it. And to me, that just seems it just seems painful, right? I have very limited time to play games, and when Do I want him to be enjoyable? And? And I feel like I don’t know. I’m not a completionist. And I’m not a person who wants to do something like …. What did you call it for Mass Effect, like in legendary mode.

    Michael Schofield  

    Insanity achievements? Yeah. And it’s pretty difficult and like, here’s here’s the thing. You, you kind of like tailor your tailor the reward for the kind of gameplay you like. For me, it’s different. So Mass Effect. I love Mass Effect. I talk about it all the time when I’m not talking to you. I play a Mass Effect Dungeons and Dragons campaign on Sundays. I’m all in. I went up to the insanity level for this time because I’ve played the original trilogy many times already. And I’m looking for a new experience. What Mass Effect offers in terms of its like player model is or as experience model is one where, you know, maybe the second time you play through a game, it is pretty darn different depending on your choices, the characters you choose to sidle up to. But for me, I’ve exhausted all of that, you know, I’ve completed 100% exploring the galaxy and that kind of thing. But I did that not because I am a completionist – I’m not; nor am I an achievement hooker – I’m not. But because I ended up knocking these things out as I was looking for these new kinds of narrative hooks that show up on different planets. I went for insanity level on Mass Effect because I was worried about being bored with something that I already love. So I kind of did it as a hedge against being bored with a game that I’ve been in a bunch of times. With something like Dark Souls, or Bloodborne, which I like a little bit better, the difficulty …. Let me backtrack the Mass Effects difficulty is hard because your AI is stupid. And then the damage done to you is dialed up. But it’s not hard because it requires great skill. Dark Souls, Bloodborne, that kind of experience, to an online experience – something like maybe like Chivalry which I’ve been looking at, or For Honor – the difficulty It is hard because the gameplay itself is hard because there are a lot of factors that you have to time that block perfectly you have to roll, so you don’t take bludgeoning damage. There is a game to not getting crushed. And it’s not simply, you know, dragging like a developer dragging all the way right on the damage level. And so the difficulty in Dark Souls or like maybe like Cuphead —

    Tim Broadwater  

    I was going to say Cuphead because to me, what you’re describing is like Cuphead. It’s baked into the game. The game is that difficult because it requires that level of execution.

    Michael Schofield  

    and getting to the next platform in Cuphead is a sign of your expertise. Maybe to a degree, it’s like Yo, I suffered like some dumb as AI, or I’ve I figured out how to get around this bananas boss. You know, where, where its difficulty layer is because it’s got like an annoying component. But for the most part, it is hard because I don’t know. Getting past it is a show of skill and expertise. And that’s when I love difficulty. I hate grinding. I hate the grind. I hate churning for XP, but I love a good hard game that requires badassery to get through. I love that feeling. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    So, yeah, we talked about that. I love grinding. I’ve played Cuphead for those who are not familiar with it, next to maybe Super Meatboy, which is notorious for being the most difficult side scroller game, right. And Cuphead has like maybe six to eight run-and-gun loops, meaning that you are just going right or left, and you’re shooting and jumping. But 98% of Cuphead is boss battles like it is one boss battle after another after another, and it’ll let you play it on easy mode. When you do that, you get credit for it, like you can get gold or something to spend, but you have to beat the boss on difficult mode to get that contract. Because you work for the devil, and you’re collecting his contracts. And the only way to collect a soul, like a contractor or someone is to beat them on this insane, difficult level, that is like Cuphead’s akin to like one, two, maybe three hits, kill your dad, you know, I couldn’t even, and I’ve played technical games before like Bushido Blade is one I played in the past where it was like you can block on the left and the right, you can do an overhead block and a lower block and a sweeping block. And if you do not pull off, if you’re not reading your opponent correctly, you’re not, you know, kind of definitely, you know, blocking, and hence you get killed, right. But to your point, as I think, you know, that’s part of those games, like I, I’ve played Cuphead for like two years, I still haven’t beat it. I’m sitting at the last boss, the devil at the casino, and I cannot get past the casino dice, man. Like I cannot do it. I’ve tried many, many times. And essentially what happens is, which is like what Cuphead is, is that you get tired of trying and you put it away, and then maybe after a while you’re like I’m right at the end. I’ll go back, and I’ll play it again. But, but it’s like I’ve done that and slowly got through the game. One day soon. When I beat Cuphead, I’ll post something that took me two years to beat that game. 

    I played Cuphead, and it’s beautiful. It’s wonderful. It’s as silly as joyous. I understand that it won the game of the year rightfully. I quit it so fast. Right? I made it through like three levels. And it got hard. It got hard. So you’ve never stopped?

    What about Dark Souls, where I quit Dark Souls. How much have you played there?

    Michael Schofield  

    I think I’m about 50% through Dark Souls, but the same thing I gave up. I appreciate the game. I felt amazing. Like I felt amazing getting through my first handful of bosses. But my tolerance for that difficulty appears to be lower than yours. So maybe, like when it comes to Cuphead, what is the hook for you? Why haven’t you quit yet?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Cuphead is memorization, so it appeals to that old school like Mega Man, and I hate to say it, but it’s like Mega Man or Super Mario Brothers exactly like a Mega Man. If you memorize like the if you know like oh, when you see the boss flash this they’re going to shoot this weapon, and you can be or have to dodge accordingly or when the bosses on halfway health he transforms into a second state and like can start shooting at the floor and then you have to like jump in the air. Do you know? And so I like there’s a part of me that loves that challenge of like, oh man, you gotta hit it perfect. You gotta hit it perfect every time, or it’s not gonna you’re not gonna do it. But to your point like you can’t do that all the time. Like it took me two years to get to the boss, and I haven’t been like the final boss, and I still haven’t beat the game, right? And I think, but I know in my head I’m going to one day I’m going to do that.

    Michael Schofield  

    it’s like maybe that’s it is the promise of eventual success.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so I definitely can make chip away at it right definitely will chip away, but I couldn’t even chip away from it for me, like Dark Souls-like. The learning curve from the beginning was so high for me that, as I think in Cuphead, like the first boss you fight is like a flower in the garden, or an ear of corn, or something.

    Michael Schofield  

    I wonder if you just stumbled on the design mechanic there. Regardless if it’s intentional or not, there’s something like from the developer perspective where you provide hints or encouragement to the player that they’re going to make it through. With Cuphead that encouragement, There’s a couple of parts, but one of that, well, you know, some of that encouragement comes from the fact that you did last longer than you did last time that you’ve, you know, jumped over this thing multiple times. You can feel and see and demonstrate your success, and you know, because Cuphead is a platformer – left to right. The further right you go, the more done you are. You are making it spiritually further right the longer you last. In Dark Souls, or Bloodborne, or back to my favorite Hellblade” Senua’s Sacrifice – I was gonna say sex-rifice. Jesus Christ.

    Tim Broadwater  

    That’s the DLC, and it’s coming out here. 

    Michael Schofield  

    “In the original game, you experienced what it’s like to hear voices. But now, one of those voices was coming on to you.”

    Tim Broadwater  

    Is Hellblade difficult?

    Michael Schofield  

    Hellblade is like Dark Souls light; it’s in the spirit of there’s not much HUD, partly because the design of the game is that your HUD is aural. It’s audible. So you have a voice in your head that says Like, watch out when someone’s coming at you from behind that you might not be able to see otherwise from another indicator. But a very much as you know, block, hit right, hit left. The bosses have the gimmick where they have a few moves, but they’re all the same moves right, and you figure it out as you go. You have to time the jump. It’s not as hard as Dark Souls. It’s, it’s a different game, but it’s in that spirit. I forgot what the point I was gonna make. Oh, well, so the idea with like, like in Dark Souls, the difference between the Dark Souls and the Cuphead, or a Hellblade and Cuphead or whatever is the encouragement element that you’re getting further, is minimal. Right? So like, Oh, my God, you just made it past this weird lich, who has this huge claymore, because you rolled enough and you blocked at the right time, and you slew him. There’s no indication that you’re anywhere near the end of the level. Because just around the corner, there’s some like, like, Dragon Wolf, who is going to like leap out at you and kill you. There’s something about that lack of encouragement.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Cuphead at least has like when you die, or at least a little horizontal bar shows how Yes, a status, like how far you got through the boss battle or the level. And so you can see like, oh, I am getting a little bit better over time, as opposed to like,

    Michael Schofield  

    I wonder how important that aspect of the design is. So yeah, it’s a progress bar. And there are other indications that you’re going to make it instead of the total lack of progress bar.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, I think it’s very important in Cuphead because it’s kind of just like the smack in the face, where it’s like, oh, my God, I can’t even get past the first third, what am I doing wrong? And it’s like, oh, I just need to camp all this shit, I or dodge it all. I can’t shoot it, you know, or so. It is, you know, that mechanic that if you keep doing it over and over and over and over and over again, if you’re getting a little bit further, you know, you’re making progress, right. And I think this is very interesting about the kind of UX versus UX for Games, right? I mean, you know, when we want, when we think of design thinking, we’re using centered design or user-driven development, whatever you want to call it. In services, products, or software applications, we want things to be usable, right, and people to understand. Still, we also want things to be desirable, like people want to use it. There is a reason I would quit my, you know, Google Drive or jump to this service. You know that, right? The difference for UX is that UX for Games is there has to be friction. That friction is the bread and butter of gaming. It has to have friction like it’s not just simple, usable, understandable, and discoverable, and all the things that we think for UX, but with UX for gaming there, there’s there is that friction that has to be there. It has to be difficult, but it can’t be too difficult. But it has to be difficult enough to be challenging to keep user engagement, but then if you don’t, but if it’s not challenging enough, people drop it, but if it’s too challenging, people drop it. So it’s like, what’s the reward mechanic versus what’s, you know, what are you getting out of it and why grind? Like, the reason why I love like, I don’t mind grindy games like JRPGs are notorious for this like, Final Fantasy or like Dragons Quest or Monster Hunter like Monster Hunter. is a grindy game that is also really has a high difficulty level like you can get one hit killed by a monster, no problem. And you have to know how to dodge and get out of the way. And then you have to know how to like, okay, these are the items I need to wear and the armor I need to put on that enables me not to get hit or disabled by the monster. And so it’s a lot of learning curve at the beginning. But then, once you, the people who love it, are the people who love that complexity. They want to like, max out their armor and their weapons, and they know how to move, and they know how to fight, and they can use strategy, and then they kind of can master it. But it’s always kind of grindy because, to make the next weapon and the next armor, you need specific parts of monsters. And those parts don’t drop all the time. It’s like some of those parts are like only a 15% drop rate or when you kill a monster or only 25% carve rate, like if you kill a monster and you’re carving it for pieces. So I don’t mind grind where other people hate it because I see the, I guess. Like, this is the mindless enjoyment. But I know there’s a benefit, you know, down the road.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, let’s think about the design of grind because that’s interesting. I’m not a fan, but I think I could probably pinpoint why. So let’s take a simple grinds mechanic, imagine that maybe it’s in Warcraft, maybe it’s in Star Wars Online way back in the day, or something like that, where you have a pickaxe, and you’re mining against a hunk of rock that is sitting next to a tree. The elements of this piece of the gameplay. The object-oriented UX part of this, the object of this experience, right? Is like contains a tangible reward, right? Perhaps you’re getting iron ore from this block.

    As you go, the aspect of encouragement may be present when you hit this thing like plus one plus one plus two or something like that. There’s some like UI, like nudger, or tickler that shows you that you indeed did do a little bit of mining damage or whatever to this rock. There’s an element that the developer can’t control, but there’s an element of your tolerance for time expenditure, how much time you are willing to spend, maybe in the game overall, to get to a certain reward. And because that may determine that you have to whack this thing 50 times, or you whack this thing ten times, or that there is a microtransaction to let you just buy the fucking ore, right. And there are other things around here. And then, of course, you know, there’s the ultimate multi-step part of this journey, the ultimate experience from completing the fact that you have to mine 20 of these ores from 20 of these different rocks or something like that. For me, the big thing isn’t the lack of UI or the sense of lack of progress, or, or I think, the encouragement is always there. It’s like, man. I can make some awesome Draconic armor. But it’s the amount of time it takes to get the awesome Draconic armor, which, even larger experience require, you know, I need the awesome Draconic armor to wander into this part of the realm. And at that point, I like the time aspect, something the developer can’t control, but I’m not willing to invest that amount of time. I will grind like I will mine the shit out of planets and Mass Effect 2 because I’m willing to devote all my time to Mass Effect. But if I’m not willing to do that for a game, or the game had taught me that the story, the narrative hit on the other end of that journey, like a Warcraft like I do, like when I was a World of Warcraft player, like getting to like the end of like, a new expansion or whatever, was always a letdown because it wasn’t the end of the game. After all, there’s always another expansion, or something like that is the time part of that object or that experience-object that kills it for me. For that reason, I don’t care. For the grind, that’s probably the same case of why I abandoned Cuphead. I’m like, this is gonna take forever, right?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so Cuphead like, I think is if you think of the payoff in the currency in which you get I mean, getting a perfect and a level, like gives you some coins to where you can buy some abilities Now granted, those abilities are like, oh, here’s a shield or like my all my, all of my gun bullets, like automatically hit they’re like homing bullets, you know, so I mean, they can be significant game-changers, right? And then, But to your point, the game itself, you can’t beat it unless you beat every boss on difficult you know, you don’t need like the side item. So you can you have to beat every boss on difficult. And I think that type of flipping of the dynamic is what made Cuphead like Game of the Year, it’s just like no difficulty is what you need here. And that skill and memorization and, and just grinding practice. Trying over and over and over again. And I know we’ve talked about this before, but I don’t mind the grind when it’s like that nuanced, right? I mind the grind when it is difficult for no reason but not enjoyable. Cuphead is super difficult, but I still find it enjoyable. To me, I’m just not into that kind of grind. Even if I got all the items, I have all the treasures; I have all the armors, I have all the swords, you know, it’s like well, Game of the Year Spider-Man, which was a couple of years ago, it was like this. It’s if you’ve never played Spider-Man for PlayStation. It is phenomenal. It is a great game. It is the reason there’s reason why it won Game of the Year. Right? And there’s a reason why they made the PS 5 Miles Morales version there. And I think it’s also on PS4. Because the game is just solid. It’s really good. And it has that kind of I don’t know what you call it. It’s like that sloped learning curve right to where it’s like yeah, not playing Super easy. But then you start to realize like crap, I’m not leveraging my equipment and gadgets, like the best way that I could. Yeah. And when you start to figure that out, you’re like, man, I can really like go in and take out as a whole crime syndicate because I now know how to recharge leverage my items block but then parry and you know, and then start to use super combo moves and whatever. But that doesn’t. There’s not that. You don’t do that from out of the gate, right? It’s like learning that expertise and nuance as you go that makes you more effective a player. I like that. I don’t know what it’s called. But it’s, but it’s kind of like learning the nuances that help you master the gameplay. And yeah, I’ve experienced even have to grind. Yeah, so in Spider-Man, the point I was getting to there, sorry, is that at some point in the game, you have all the equipment, you have all the abilities. But then it turns over to like, oh, to get the Platinum on PlayStation to get the trophy, right, you have to unlock every outfit. To unlock every outfit, you have to do all of these crazy time trials and sneak trials and things. And that to me, I started it I got to that point. And then it just became too much. It’s like trying to swing through a city and hit all these goal points and shoot between these rings. Under two minutes, it just like I could try it 20 freakin times, but I’m never gonna get it. And then I’m just like, what am I doing here? It’s not do I need every outfit? You know what I mean? What level? What level of crazy is this that I don’t need, you know,

    Michael Schofield  

    I wonder if that’s something about the collector drive. And some people have it, and some don’t. I have zero interest in collecting all the gear unless it serves an ulterior purpose. It impacts the narrative in some way that interests me, or I’m doing it because I otherwise love the game so much. I’m just trying to milk as much out of it but as an end to itself, collect all the bone plates or whatever it is a game that I don’t want to play. I feel like over the episodes we have. We’ve gradually been sussing out what I think is a model of gamer experience or player experience. And there’s another element to this that is somewhere like some kind of spectrum between collect like the collector drive collection mechanics and, and other and other things, and I think for some folks, the game is the completionist aspect is the game.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, I think when we’re talking by the end of season one, we will probably have one. And by one, I mean some type of metric or guide that we can use. We talked about like, like a lack of a better word like, not like what is it called with a 2d grid? Like not a compound board? 

    Michael Schofield

    It’s a matrix: a quadrant matrix or something like that.

    Tim Broadwater  

    We talked in the past before, it’s like, well, do I want to be the game? Or do I want an avatar to represent me? Or do I want to be a third party? Right? There’s a spectrum, like one spectrum of it. But or one axes of it? Right? And if another axis is like, How much creativity Do you want to bring to the game? Do I want to craft things around it? Or do I want it to let me be creative? Or do I? Do I even care about that, but it feels like this other one we’re talking about is like, What’s your goal here? Is it leveling up, unlocking all your abilities, getting all the trophies, or collecting all the objects? Or you know what I mean? So it’s kind of like, we should, by the end of season one, at least have like a model that we put up on the website? Yeah, that is literally like on our quest to find the most usable game? How do we, you know, now we know how to look for it in a three-dimensional space. You know,

    Michael Schofield  

    yeah, I think that’s interesting. Because there is I, you know, like, part of this experience model is one that, I guess or your goal, like, what is the, you know, ultimately, what is the game you’re playing? Then, you know, are you in it for? Is this is a spectrum between, like collection and narrative is? Or is it not a spectrum? Is it to your point, you know, like, like a multifaceted chart or grid? I don’t know. There’s something there because I, I certainly consider myself, you know, if we have if we had little sliders on our game or profiles where I’m, I’m heavy into the narrative. I’m heavy into the skill-based difficulty because I like refining my technique. That’s why I like first-person shooters so much, especially those that require you to be

    Tim Broadwater,  

    we talked about that Kinsey, a Kinsey scale. Oh, my God,

    Michael Schofield  

    it’s a Kinsey scale. Yeah, yeah,

    Tim Broadwater  

    we talked about it before, but for me, it would be kind of like, I will set that grind to meter all the way out and make it brutal. If what that gets me is creative control and power. You know what I mean? In the game, I will grind. I will put in the work to build a unique thing I want to build. Yeah, if I have to go on an MMO RPG, it’s like you have to get 14 eggs by defeating these 14 dragons in 14 different zones and whatever. And I was like, Okay, well, what does it get me? And it’s like, nothing you can get like a castle or keep. I’m like, No, I don’t care. But if it lets me build a new class with new powers or something cool, I could customize it. Then I would definitely like Well, let’s get those for today. 

    Michael Schofield  

    Are you a reward-based grinder? Or how willing are you to grind for the joy of grinding? Would you mine or craft? Maybe you can craft something with it, but it’s nothing game-changing? Would you mine?

    Tim Broadwater  

    No way. It’s like when they put fishing in games. It’s like, Oh, do you just want to fish the fish? Or do you want to catch the best fish, or like you know what I mean? It’s like, Well, no, if these fish can, I can turn into a potion. That makes me powerful.

    Michael Schofield  

    Boy, you just like touched a button again. I feel like I need therapy. So let’s take Sea of Thieves, but this applies to any game with a fishing mechanic. I will solo co thieves go out to some like random rock, and I will fish. You can collect different kinds of fish, and you can trade them in, and then you can increase your standing with one of the various guilds. Do I do that? No, I don’t. I fish. Why? Like I’m not a collector.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Do you enjoy the that the experience of just like it calming you and the challenge and then it’s like the

    Michael Schofield  

    game is the grind there the game is the fishing, right. But I feel like grind implies the collection of some like you grind to mine. You grind to accumulate. And I feel like I

    Tim Broadwater  

    guess I think there is some type of reason for some reward.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah. Because otherwise, it just becomes the gameplay

    Tim Broadwater  

    or Cuphead.

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the design thinking games podcast to connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim, please go to design thinking games.com where you can request topics, ask questions, or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on.

  • 008: Gaymer Pride

    008: Gaymer Pride

    Games talked about in this episode:

    Introductory Guy  

    Hello. Welcome to design thinking games, a fantasy and user experience podcast. Each episode, your podcast hosts, Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield, will examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper role-playing games, live-action games, mobile games, and video games. You can find every episode, including this one, on your podcatcher of choice. And on the web at design thinking games.com.

    Tim Broadwater  

    One of the things I’d like to talk about is relevant as to when we’re recording and releasing this episode, specifically about Pride Month, which is coming up in June 2021. Most people know this. But, you know, it was actually President Bill Clinton in the United States of America. That declared June as Gay and Lesbian Pride Month, and that was back in 1999, which at this point is — oh, my God, 22 years ago?

    Michael Schofield  

    I didn’t know that, um, that Wild Bill instituted that.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah. He declared it in 99-2000, and then there was, of course, a lull, I think, in George W. Bush’s presidency. But since Bill Clinton already said it, it was kind of like, you know, “we’re grandfathered in.” So it just kind of became that. Right. But then also, like, in 2009. I think Barack Obama, the President, brought that back up and officially declared it from 2009 to 2016. And then here recently, our President Donald Trump also acknowledged LGBT Pride Month in 2019. So it’s kind of stuck. But so in regards to that, I think businesses and technologies, of course, jumped on to it. I have a limited amount of experience with LGBT characters and stories, and games. And I’m gonna just say this first and foremost: The Last of Us 2 is probably one of the most famous characters.

    Michael Schofield  

    That was a highly politicized one too. That announcement was controversially received. Right?

    Tim Broadwater  

    There were a lot of strong feelings, I think, in the gamer community, in regards to canon. What’s canon? What’s not? So I know, like gaming, as you’re mentioning, like, with Last of Us 2 and the lead character, Ellie being kind of gay, or lesbian, actually not gay. I keep going back to female Ghostbusters and black stormtroopers and just changing or progressing a narrative or fandom and kind of growing it into a new type of area. So the last was to was definitely really controversial. 

    Michael Schofield  

    Anything that displaces the norm and the status quo can be interpreted as an attack on a group’s power and hegemony. All of these changes over the last couple of decades as gaming has become increasingly mainstream reflect that. Adding gay relationships to Mass Effect 1, which highlighted the ability to have relationships with your party members, was a big deal. It was on Fox News. It was one of these things.

    Tim Broadwater  

    2009 right?

    Michael Schofield  

    2007 is when Mass Effect 1 came out.

    Tim Broadwater  

    For Last of Us and then Last of Us 2, we see Ellie living with a female companion on a farm. They have a child, and it’s accepted in their community, which is this kind of world kind of mountain, farming community where everyone knows. No one has a problem with it. There’s kind of both bisexuality and lesbianism, and the community’s okay with it. And the way that it’s treated to where it’s just normal, it’s not anything different. It’s just kind of how this couple is, you know, that, I think, is what is refreshing to LGBT players and gamers. When they kind of experienced that game, you know.

    Michael Schofield  

    I imagine there’s a spectrum, right? A spectrum between pandering and representation. You can tell when you’re being pandered to, and maybe, historically, pandering-to was the best-case scenario at the moment in time. On the other end of the spectrum, it’s just represented as normal, where it’s not even brought up as part of the character story. I’m replaying Mass Effect 1, and you can be in lesbian relationships if you play as FemShep. There’s an argument that it’s not really such because the Asari partner’s entire species is female-presenting, so there is no gender distinction there.

    But in 2007, it was a highly sexualized thing. So like FemShep (in Mass Effect, you can play as male Shepherd or female Shepherd), all of the female characters throughout the Mass Effect series look like they were designed by dude, comic book artists, and the gay relationship can be read as a male-gazey exploitative perk, especially when you consider that as MaleShep you can’t have a male gay relationship. So this falls to the pandering or exploitative end of the spectrum, where it’s “LGBT as feature.” But then you go all the way to the other side with DONTNOD’s Tell Me Why. This game is in the vein of the Life Is Strange series or even Telltales’ Walking Dead. In Tell Me Why, the main character is a trans man. And it is a part of the narrative in the sense that presents social obstacles for this character, but it’s not the point of the story at all. It was additive to the game is super interesting to put yourself in those shoes. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    That’s interesting because you know I can’t say much either. I am a white cisgender male homosexual, right, but I will say this like I think people respond to when it’s just a story and normal. You can’t always lead though with like, “Hey, this is this new side-scrolling action-adventure, and it’s a gay plumber who’s Italian, and he’s saving ….” If you lead that way, you know, this is one part of this character it’s not the whole thing you know?

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, I think that’s the design challenge, right? Regardless of its legitimacy, an argument you hear is that “these people are trying to hit a diversity quota.” Or, because productized narratives and games or movies or series are a numbers game, they want to include more diversity to increase viewership or readership. (Frankly, that seems like a great reason to diversify the narrative.) But the unspoken slight is that this is insincere.

    Tim Broadwater  

    One of the things to kind of note about what you said is that there are franchises that, oh, this character happens to be gay in the film or comic book, or what have you. And then when we make the game version of it, you know, do we include that? Or do we not include that? But then we just see a movement more towards not just main characters, but side characters and other characters in games that are bisexual or lesbian, or gay, or trans. And I think we start to see characters that show up like in Grand Theft Auto, a construction worker or a police officer, or a side quest to find their ex-boyfriend. I remember back to the first experience that I ever had of a gay character in a game, and I don’t even know which one it was, but it was one of the Sims versions. Back when the Sims were on everything, they just kept releasing Sims all the time, like Sims: Pool house Party, or Sims: Auto Show, and they would just like keep giving you stuff that you buy and like add on. But I can remember there was a time where you could actually make two people live together. After enough time, you could get them to buy gifts for each other and build affection. And it was like, Oh, I can build a gayborhood, I could actually build all these different types of relationships. I think it’s great to see characters of different diversities, just different stories, and comic books, in movies, in series in games. It’s like, just kind of what I think Pride has become in general. Maybe what people associate with it, or whether I think over 50 years, has become a call for diversity and inclusion, you know, and celebrate that in June.

    Michael Schofield  

    Did you ever play the game Gone Home?

    Tim Broadwater  

    This sounds familiar to me.

    Michael Schofield  

    Gone Home was, for lack of a better term, a walking simulator. There’s not even like a plot, arguably. And you are a college student, I think, who returns home and the house is empty, Mom and Dad are gone, you have a little sibling who’s also gone. It’s stormy outside. There’s kind of a haunted house type of feel. The lights flicker every so often. And you are wandering around this lived-in house, not perfectly clean, lots of papers everywhere. I think it’s hard for me to figure out what the game is about. But one of the things that you find as you as you go, through the outside in, you are basically looking through people’s drawers, your own drawers, the drawers of your sibling, etc. And you are, for all intents and purposes, this college student returned home. And you don’t really discover until three hours in when you’re digging through your own room or whatever – that either you or your sibling, I think you, I think you’re gay. The game lets you immerse in the first person totally from another perspective. It’s one thing to play like as FemShep, right? In the third person over the shoulder view, where you are piloting the character. And it’s different when it’s first-person, and you are. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, I mean, it makes me think everyone’s experience is kind of different. And so some people made fun of Facebook for a while, but the fact that they could do all of these different types of relationship statuses. These different sexualities and different gender identifications? I don’t think you played Cyberpunk 2077? You can be nonbinary, you can be transgender.,

    Michael Schofield  

    Is this like the first time? Can you think of other games that have given you that option at this Triple A level?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Vampire: the Masquerade, I thought that they let you choose your pronouns. I mean, essentially, like social media now allows you to kind of if you fill out your profile as much as you want, but we want to give everyone different options. And so, you know, I think what I like about seeing this in Cyberpunk 2077 and Vampire: the Masquerade, it acknowledges and then lets you celebrate, or live or experience, your diversity, right? And so the fact that there are people who are in the world who all don’t have the same experience. There are people who were attracted to people of the same sex, or they do not feel like a man, they feel like a woman inside, or maybe they’re in a relationship with two different people, maybe they’re in a poly relationship, or maybe people are nonbinary, that they feel gender fluid, and I think we’re starting to see a lot more of that in character creations and profiles, you know, and the way that players can express themselves. A lot of gamers now know themselves through Twitch streams and Discord and through their online kind of profile. So it’s very much like, Ready Player One or Ready Player Two that you can kind of be your avatar. It’s whoever you can be. And why can’t it be completely crazy or completely accurate? And why is it offensive to you? 

    Michael Schofield  

    That’s funny. Remember the late 90s, early 2000s. Maybe that persisting fear to never, never trust that the person you’re talking to in the chat room. It really isn’t a 16-year-old girl because it’s a 40-year-old man.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Exactly.

    Michael Schofield  

    This was a threat in early internet life, that, hey, there are people out there posing as something that they aren’t, and this is perverted and creepy and scary and literally threatening in a way.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Now, on the flip side of that, it is probably to some degree the opposite. I feel like a furry, I feel like a blue wolf, and I’m gender fluid, and I should be able to do these things. And then if we look at games like Fortnight, where I want to be John Wick, or I want to be Wolverine, or I want to have blue hair, I want to be a wolf. I think we’re only going to see that kind of level of …, with games that don’t have a specific narrative that writes you as the player into the main character role that doesn’t have enough wiggle room to be whatever sex, gender, race and by race, I mean, you know, if you’re a robot or a dog, or human or Cyborg, I think you’re gonna have you know, some limited wiggle room. This is the game that your avatar can be whatever. It kind of separates the hardware from the software.

    Michael Schofield  

    There’s a really interesting dovetail here to like an earlier conversation we had that was all about the growing basic expectation of customizing the user interface. Your example was the ability to customize a table throughout a web app where you can say like, I want this column and this column, but not this column. We ended up with a term for it. Like, like, operator agnosticism, or something like that. But you know, it’s the same principle that is just going to scale to avatar and to presentation. And there are going to be instances where the linear story matters in this specific way. And you’re going to tell the story of like some soldier in, you know, the mid-2000s, Fallujah, you’re going to be shoehorned into at least probably a gender, right? If not a specific race, depending on who they’re showing. But there’s the other side, where are these kind of like, sandboxes where the expectation that you can just be whomever…

    Tim Broadwater  

    Definitely with Mass Effect or Pathfinder or just like future science fiction? 

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, like, I’m a fucking slug human. I’m a Salarian. It’s the normalization of being someone different, not even permanently after, other than the person that you were born with. Maybe in the future, you switch genders several times throughout your life. Something like that seems really healing.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I think that happens now. Two examples come to mind. So this is the thing that I think that as UXers — it doesn’t matter if you’re making software services, or you’re a user experience person that’s working on games — you have to realize you’re working with people, and people want to express themselves in different ways. And people are gonna want different things out of games. So we’re walking along, and Korra, the Avatar, becomes a lesbian. People flip out. Iceman is now gay. And I love how they explained that in the comic books to where they went back in time and brought the first X-Men team forward in time, and they’re like in today’s society, and there’s more acceptance or more inclusivity, and Iceman was like, “I’m gay.” And he goes to the older Iceman who’s like in his 40s now, and he’s like, “are you not if I’m you from the past?” And he’s like, “I guess I am. I’ve just always kind of pushed it down. I never even thought about it.” And people may not realize it, but everyone doesn’t have the guidebook or the tutorial to life. So I think people will realize along the way if they have an attraction they didn’t have before, or if they may feel a different way to where they’re not their same gender or sex. And I think, as UXers, the thing that that kind of encapsulates this, which is realizing. I always think I always kind of like the user. When they talk about the users, it sounds like they’re a dirty drug addict, right? But it’s like their people. Your job is to advocate for people, and people want to express themselves in different ways. And I was completely blown away, like when I see advances in user interfaces, and I think like the very first time I ever played Secret of Mana, and I saw like the ring navigation system, I’m not sure if you’ve ever played Secret of Mana, but it has this ring navigation system. I’m like, this is the future. Like, this is literally amazing because it’s just different than what everything else. It’s not Bootstrap, right. It’s something that feels different and works different, and you have to learn it, but then it kind of really is fluid and works, and you can fly through it. It’s just like the different design keyboards, I feel. So I guess my point being is that Pride Month is celebrating inclusivity celebrating diversity. We need to just empower people to express themselves in the way that they want to, and we’re just gonna see more and more of that in social media. We’re gonna see more of it in games, and we’re gonna see more of it in any type of product or service that people use.

    Michael Schofield  

    Well said.

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the design thinking games podcast. To connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim, please go to design thinking games.com where you can request topics, ask questions, or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on.

  • 007: Collaborative Board Games

    007: Collaborative Board Games

    Games talked about in this episode:

    • 3:57 Forbidden Desert
    • 5:02 Pandemic
    • 7:01 Castle Panic
    • 12:02 Pokemon Go
    • 13:13 Phasmaphobia
    • 15:26 Ghost Hunters
    • 15:51 Ghost Adventures
    • 19:01 Angry Pug
    • 19:58 Flash Point
    • 21:43 Magic Maze
    • 22:53 Sentinels of the Multiverse
    • 25:48 Last Night on Earth
    • 30:56 Betrayal at House on the Hill

    Introductory Guy  

    Hello. Welcome to design thinking games, a fantasy and user experience podcast. Each episode, your podcast host, Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield, will examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper role-playing games, live-action games, mobile games, and video games. You can find every episode, including this one, on your podcatcher of choice, and on the web at designthinkinggames.com.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I’m excited to talk about my favorite board game genre. And for me, that is collaborative board games. As we’ve talked before, I  specifically look for board games with a very low or quick turnaround to learn the game, they don’t take too long to play — so like 15 minutes to an hour tops — and the games are collaborative, meaning that the players are working together for some type of goal. We all win, or we all die, so to speak. Do you have a preference for collaborative games versus competitive games?

    Michael Schofield  

    I like team-based games. I really like this idea of a group of people who have to collaborate, or you fail. The failure is poignant because you are playing another group of people. But I guess the other group of actual humans is not really the point. It’s team versus a world. The competitive aspect, I think, is maybe the point where the other human is introduced. But I love it when, frankly, the lack of teamwork, a breakdown in cohesion means failure. And so I think the common theme here is “collaborate or die.” And it’s really that simple. If t breaks down, you fail.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I’m definitely a fan of collaboration games. I think one of the things that I like about tabletop board games, with this kind of dynamic of collaboration versus competition, is that you’re all face to face, right? You’re not a computer away, and you’re not saying something bad about someone’s mom, and you can’t do anything about it, right? But it makes me think of the different mechanics of collaboration. There’s definitely, like you said, this collaboration or you all die or something bad happens. But there’s also collaboration for the achievement of a goal or treasure, monetary incentive. There’s also collaboration to help others. And I like them all, to be honest. I’ve actually slowly moved away from competitive board games, just because there’s only a couple that I really like. And it’s just because they’re hilarious, and so the competition kind of takes a backseat to it. 

    I think a very popular one is the Forbidden Desert or the Forbidden Island games. Are you familiar with those?

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah. In fact, I almost got a copy of Forbidden Island for my kid recently, when we ventured from our pandemic lockdown to the comic book store for the first time. It was right there on the shelf. And I know you’re a fan, and so I almost bought it.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so it’s like Forbidden Island, which is probably, I think, the first one. But essentially, the Island is sinking every round. And you are a collection of people with different skill sets trying to help each other. Someone can swim. Another person is a pilot, another person’s a medic who can help people. And there are only certain things that you can do together. It’s very similar to Pandemic if you’ve ever played Pandemic before.

    Michael Schofield  

    I think we’ll talk about Pandemic soon. Yeah.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yes. It is very much like Pandemic, except instead of the world you’re flying around, where you’re trying to get samples of diseases, and cure them, and stop outbreaks. [In Forbidden Island] you’re all trying to collaborate to get together to get off the Island in one piece. Like Pandemic, and we can just talk about it. I mean, it’s where your characters don’t die, per se. And I think it’s the same thing. Like when the Island sinks, it sinks.

    Michael Schofield  

    I think they imply death [in Pandemic]. Yeah, with like, when the outbreaks grow large enough, right?

    So the conceit of Pandemic is that you are all an assortment of mostly medical experts. But there are different kinds of experts in there. Especially logistical ones or military experts. But you are among the best of the best there. There are a variety of roles that one to four of you can pick. And there is a massive global pandemic that is spreading, and it goes from city to city. 

    There are a number of cities linked to Chicago, and if the pandemic gets to a certain density in Chicago, it spreads to the other cities. But I think there’s this I think, implicitly, if you lose, you failed, right? You know. And it’s just one of those things where, you know, what is the end result of a pandemic you’ve failed to stop? And that’s, that’s, that’s kind of how I read it. I look at it bleakly. This is a pre-apocalypse game,

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, I believe that Forbidden Desert and Forbidden Island is like you all escape, or the island sinks. You know, it’s so it’s a timer-based. And then as the tide rises, you know, more Island sinks. I love this genre of game.

    So there’s also another one called Castle Panic. Which is the game where you all are defending a tower. In the middle of this, this, you’re kind of at war, I guess. And so you all have different abilities if you’re like a fighter versus someone who’s a ranged elf or a spellcaster, or whatever. But you have different things that are going to help with the oncoming orc / goblin hordes that are like every round, there’s more, there’s more, there’s more, and they keep appearing. You can set up barricades, and you can do certain things, but it is very much that if the tower is completely destroyed and breached everyone loses.

    So I think those games have this great kind of, you know, kind of lasso, right, which is like, hey, let’s all play, we all can win together, or we can lose.  But it’s so it kind of emboldens everyone to want to beat the circumstance, instead trying to fight each other, they’re trying to survive this kind of very difficult situation.

    Michael Schofield  

    There is a challenging aspect too, you know, the sort of teamwork in which, you know, one role is better for a specific job than the others. And I think the conflict comes in, not just from, you know, players, plural, against the world, but also probably internally. Who gets to move forward? Who gets to take this action? Whose strategy is the best?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Some people don’t like the collaborative games, I think, because there is a lot Table Talk and working together. And I maybe want to do this action, which I think is super cool. And, you know, or it’s something that I think is gonna be effective. But the other person on my team who’s also collaborating with me to avoid drowning may have a suggestion, which is, “Hey, no, why don’t you wait this turn and do this next turn? And that will help us better.” Everyone hates the word “team building,” right? It’s very much that working with other people dynamically, and not having so much ego about it, but just kind of keeping an eye on the prize. There is no me in this, per se, but the importance of us surviving is more important than my particular actions or choices.

    Michael Schofield  

    I can understand why people hate that kind of stuff, right? It requires a kind of humility, right? Or you get humbled when the rest of the party outvotes you. So there’s a problem there. Collaborative games in which the humans themselves, the players themselves, aren’t prone to collaboration or interested in collaboration, or one is definitely used to leading until someone else has a better character or plan.

    But that’s the kind of stuff that I love, this collaborate or die style of game really requires you to face that strategic problem. It’s a people-problem game. The challenge is hard, the game is hard, the math and the mechanics make the game the game, but you really have to participate amd people-manage and be a team for it to work. And that’s why I like, you know, you mentioned that there’s another kind where, like, Hey, you all work together to, like, the better you work together, the better the prize? Those games don’t catch me the same, because I like to win or lose, collaborate or die because it really forces the issue. If you are a bad team, you will lose. And I like that the game forces you to confront that.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I agree with you. I think what you’re describing is, to me, like Pokemon GO Raids. We’re not technically losing. But like, if we’re not successful, we don’t get a chance at capturing the rare Pokemon. You know that I’m kind of cracked out on Monster Hunter, I love it. Like you go into this timed match, which is like 15 minutes long, your goal was to capture a killer monster to harvest its part to make more weapons and armor to fight even more monsters. But technically speaking, if you lose the match, you maybe lose a little money but you could totally be an asshole and just do what you want to do if you want it to. Unlike a game that I just started playing last year, and I don’t know if you’ve seen, but it’s kind of popular: Phasmaphobia. Have you heard of that?

    Michael Schofield  

    Oh my gosh, I have. It’s actually been suggested as, like, funny that you mentioned team building earlier as a, like, it’s a leadership exercise was like, let’s go play. I can’t. I can’t say I always want to say like phantasmagoria or something, which I think is like a horror magazine. But I love this idea of Ghost Hunters. I love it. I’ve been dying to play it. I’m an XBot with not a very good PC. I have just been reluctant to fire up these PC games because I’m just assuming that they’re gonna suck for me. Anyway, I want to hear about your experience here because it looks amazing. I know I would love it.

    Tim Broadwater  

    We’re talking about the game Phasmaphobia, which is the fear of ghosts. Unlike Pokemon GO or Monster Hunter, you don’t get a big payoff. You’re in it for the research. You get a little bit of cash from completing collaborative matches, but there is no incentive to work together apart from seeing if you can uncover the ghost.

    Michael Schofield

    You just said the word “match.” Is there an end? Do you win?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Essentially like you log in, and you are in your garage, it’s what’s you’ve turned into your garage into like your this is our ghost hunting, you know kind of garage or T.A.P.S. 

    Michael Schofield  

    We should reference The Atlanta Paranormal Society:  T.A.P.S. from Ghost Hunters, the show on Syfy, I think, with Jason and Grant, and recently rebooted with just Grant. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    I’m assuming you’re a fan then.

    Michael Schofield  

    Oh, my God, I love it. And of course, I love Ghost Adventures with Zak Bagans and his crew because they are so …. Zak Bagans is a goth bro, right? He wears all black. In early episodes, he was wearing those Hot Topic pants that were really baggy with straps between each leg. He’s also jacked. He goes around challenging the demons. Like it’s like, “if you have to enter somebody, enter me!”

    Tim Broadwater  

    Phantasmagoria is actually the game, and then Phantasm is the movie I’m thinking of. Yeah, that’s a lot of crazy convoluted stuff. But essentially, yes, you start the game, you’re in your T.A.P.S. makeshift garage, and you got like 20 bucks in your pocket. That’s it. And so you’re like, “I can get like an audio recording device, and maybe a flashlight,” you know, and so you can team up with other ghost hunters. You go to these rumored places, like this old farmhouse, this abandoned public school, or this old mental asylum.

    You’ve got reports that have come in, and you get, like, literally a manila folder. So you are going in with a team, and you only can bring the equipment you can afford. And so the incentive is really to kind of build a little bit of cash so you can get better equipment to keep grinding and doing the same thing. And if you lose cash or lose money, then it’s just like, you’re kind of, you’re kind of depending on your other ghost hunters to like, “Hey, man, will you let me use your flashlight,” because you’re lame, you know?

    And so essentially, you go in, and you have like, these audio recording devices. You have smudge sticks, and you have Ouija boards, and you have UV lights, and temperature raters, like these thermometers, things in your hands and whatever. And you’re trying to pin down where the ghost activity is. Then you’re trying to engage or piss off the ghost, to get it to show itself or move something or turn on the water or whatever. Yeah, and then capture that on film or document it. You’re trying to get evidence. So you’re not doing it for cash, you’re not doing it for parts, you’re not doing it to get evidence to kind of see if you could prove the existence.

    Now it is possible to get killed in the game. You can piss off a ghost so much that it literally will attack you. But essentially, all it is in the game means that you’re kind of out of the match.

    I don’t know if you follow Angry Pug? Angry Pug is probably one of the more popular Twitch streamers. But if you actually search for, I think “Phasmaphobia Scream,” he comes up. He’s this bearded guy who literally just screams like a girl when it happens, and I think that’s probably one of the most famous video clips out there.

    Michael Schofield  

    I found it. Amazing.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so I like, you know, those incentives, there’s like monetary or item incentives, like kind of in that part, the research, but I kind of also like, just to do good.

    But if you’ve ever heard of Flashpoint or Sentinels of the Multiverse, yeah, those are games that are where you’re essentially trying to do good. In Flashpoint, you’re a team of EMTs or firefighters, and there’s a building that’s on fire. And you or your team is working together to rescue as many people as before it burns down.

    Yeah, you don’t lose. But it’s like, but you maybe didn’t get to save everyone. 

    Michael Schofield

    It’s really interesting to think about. We have this umbrella category of cooperative or collaborative games. But for me, a lot of it is really driven by that incentive of why you want to collaborate. And one of the things we like about Phasmaphobia is that I want to play this because I love this genre and I want the scares, but I don’t know that it like I have any interest in like working with people there, especially if they’re strangers. I’m sure I would, but the draw wouldn’t be the collaboration part of it.

    Something like Flashpoint, which I’ve played, is really cool. But it’s the same thing. It’s like the second tier of severity where you failed to collaborate and so people burned to death.

    For me, because my incentive to collaborate, the thrill of collaboration is the inter-party conflict, but it’s the fact that like,we have to make the right bet, and it’s that aspect that really, really, like really appeals to me.

    Tim Broadwater

    There is. I don’t know if you’ve heard of Magic Maze, either. Magic maze is probably the most frustrating collaborative game. And the reason why is because you can’t talk to each other.

    Michael Schofield

    Oh, interesting.

    Tim Broadwater  

    And your nonverbals are limited as well. But Magic Maze is like, you basically pull a heist, someone’s a dwarf, if someone’s an elf, someone’s an orc, or whatever, and you’re trying to get out. But you can’t, you have to work together, but you can’t talk to each other.

    So you can point to things. And you know, but you may notice something that someone else doesn’t, and there’s no way to actively tell them. But you have to kind of like, infer that they do something, and then they have to kind of be tuned in enough to do it. And it frustrates people. It really does. 

    Michael Schofield

    That sounds awful. To be honest. 

    Tim Broadwater

    I’m not a fan of it. I tried it, and I probably will never play the game again. But if you want to like thinking like ghost hunters and thinking of Phasmaphobia, you know, comic books are huge right now. And if you wanted to be a superhero and play on a superhero team and do that, that’s what Sentinels of the Multiverse does.

    I mean, essentially, you have all these decks, and you choose a deck for whatever hero you want. It could be a Batman-like hero, or an alien, or like an Iron Man, hero or something, whatever. But essentially, you have an entire deck for you, and all the other players at the table have a deck for their hero. 

    And the difficulty is based on how many players there are. So it’s all scalable. You can have, you know, I think they recommend not having more than six people. But like, essentially, if you have five people to sit down, they choose five heroes that have five corresponding decks, and your difficulties to the power of five.

    But then also, there’s a deck for the supervillain that you’re fighting, and then a deck for the environment. And so you kind of keep going around in a circle. And let’s say you’re fighting in the jungle, one of the villains is Omnitron. He’s an artificial intelligence who can create robots and duplicate has, you know, cyborgs or robots that attack you. And so each round, you all can do something, and you can work together as a team or set each other up for these cool moves or help or heal each other. But then the environment could spawn like a rock slide or like a mud pit or like a T Rex. And then the supervillain also has a move.

    And it’s very difficult. Like a lot of people don’t win. It’s kind of one of those games to where it’s like it’s kind of like Betrayal at House on the Hill. There’s only like only a 10% chance of winning ever because it’s the villain. Is that difficult?

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, I wasn’t gonna ask like so with like with Sentinels. Can anyone play the villain?

    Tim Broadwater  

    The villain plays itself. Then the environment, you just pull the top card, and it does what it does.

    Michael Schofield  

    So, but there is this kind of collaborative type of game which is, you know, given let’s say given five players at the table, for versus one where there is, you know, a betrayer among the party. But I think the idea is there’s this collaboration that is like almost-all versus one because you can have everyone at the party go against, you know, a game villain —  the virus,the burning building, the sinking desert — or you all can have a bad guy sitting at the table.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Traitor, a traitor? Yeah. Oh, a werewolf or vampire.

    Michael Schofield  

    I like these games, too, right. And I bust out every Halloween is, there’s this game called like, Last Night on Earth, where you’re a bunch of high school jocks and maybe a cheerleader. I mean, of course, it could be the nerd, or you can be the teacher or the town sheriff who was at the high school for some reason. And there’s a zombie outbreak. And a player plays the zombie. Usually, what happens at least, like on Halloween, we throw like a little party or whatever, and have our adult friends come over and force their kids and our kids like upstairs.

    Tim Broadwater  

    “Go watch Monster Squad while we play!”

    Michael Schofield  

    What happens is like, we actually have a bunch of people at the table, we’ll have like five or six. And then like two people can play the zombies. And then the rest can play the heroes. They’re really bad characters who should die in horror games. They’re the dimwit who runs up a half complete ladder, and just gets like stuck up there, you know, so shit like tha, some of them are meant to die. But that’s the idea. 

    You have to cooperate. Because the notion is that, oh my god, zombie apocalypse, at the highest school, there’s a truck, there’s only one truck in the parking lot. And for whatever reason, the keys are in the library, and it’s out of gas, and the extra gas is in the storage shed. And some other important part is like over here, like the wrench, for whatever reason, these things are spread apart. And you all have to collaborate and work together to get each piece. And without coming together. You die.

    There are tough times of zombies like the duck is really stacked against you.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, that’s, that’s, there are those games, which are basically collaborative because it’s in your best interest. But if you need to cut and run, or like, save yourself, you can do that. And that’s very much what happens with Betrayal at House on the Hill. 

    Michael Schofield  

    What does a well-designed collaboration game look like? A lot of these have timers, right. So whether or not it’s like a literal timer. In Pandemic, there’s not a timer per se, except that, you know, you draw the wrong card, and the severity of the Pandemic increases until it reads reasons like there are absolute deadly levels. I think the Forbidden games that literally have a timer. And so like, there’s one thing where just like the pressure, the external pressure of time, forces the issue, like for instance, oh my gosh, you have to make a decision. Or you’re all going to take a step back.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, I think communicating that not only the time is counting down, but in Pandemic or in Dead of Winter, it’s getting worse. The Island is sinking each round. So it’s more prompting you to be efficient with your time work together, and make the best choices you can. The other mechanic that I like is that everyone has value and that everyone is important, has a role, and can do multiple things that everyone can do, but then there’s also your unique identifiers or abilities.

    Michael Schofield  

    I think that’s important. Each person can do four of the same actions, but only this person can do that, and so to pull off the strategy, you have to get that person there. In Last Night on Earth, only the sheriff can really aim the pistol. 

    The other thing is like, but many of these games, you also carry some sort of flaw. You have your unique power-up. And you also have a flaw. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    It creates strength and dependency, not dependency in a negative way. 

    Michael Schofield  

    It’s a mechanic for like, humility, it’s like, it’s right there in like a number or a stat block.

    Tim Broadwater  

    You know, Betrayal at House on the Hill. There are four stats in that game. And some people have a great like physical strength body stat to where they can attack and defend, that is not the person that you want to withstand psychic penetration. Because their mind power is not that great, you know. And then, exact to your point, some of that is sometimes balanced with like everyone can do these four actions. However, where is everyone can do it. And it takes two turns, or three turns, or two tokens, or whatever, this person can do it free each round.

    So the successful games that have collaboration in them are ones that make that pretty well known. I know, a common thing for a lot of the tabletop board games is like, you will have your own card and it literally just highlights you know what it is the abilities that you can do. And that mechanic is through a lot, not just board games, but then I think video games. There’s a reason why people go like a ranger build, because it’s like range damage, right? It’s your Archer. It is not the tank or the meat shield, that is literally in the battle, you can take the hits. And there’s also kind of the medic or the healer, the cleric, or whatever, who can actually help repair.

    So lets all kind of get the role that we want to play. And then let’s figure out how to do this together. The challenge being we can survive or defeat the big bad or save as many people.

    Michael Schofield  

    I can’t think of an example of where this actually happens, but just, you know, name the elephant, to say the obvious thing here, it’s important that these roles are finite, for instance, you all can’t be the medic. Because you would probably lose. In Dungeons and Dragons, of course, you know, you could have an all cleric party, which is great. But in most of these games, like in Pandemic, it all wouldn’t work if you all were the helicopter pilot, you guys are fucked.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Here’s a challenge to you, if you’ve never played like Dungeons and Dragons, or a role-playing game, to where you’ve done that before, I’ve done it before, where we were all wizards, or we were all clerics. It changes things. You can’t tank per se. You have to summon something to tank so you can get some spells off, you know, I mean, it’s possible to do it. And I like games that have that amount of bend, right? 

    Michael Schofield

    It increases the difficulty level in a way.

    Tim Broadwater

    We have all of our core needs, range damage, crowd control, healing, buffing, but then also melee damage and tanking kind of like all like handled, we have to change it up to where it can work another way, but it’s just going to be different.

    Michael Schofield  

    Tim, I have a collaborative plea for our listeners to help bolster this team. It would be awesome if we could get folks to leave reviews on their podcatcher-place of choice, specifically like iTunes or Google Play stores, and like, heart, star, favorite this episode (and all of the other episodes). 

    What literally every other podcast says that “hey, this really helps us reach new people.” Yo, it totally does; it plays into the algorithm.

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the design thinking games podcast. To connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim, please go to design thinking games.com where you can request topics, ask questions, or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on

  • 006: The 3 Clue Rule

    006: The 3 Clue Rule

    Games talked about in this episode:

    Introductory Guy

    Welcome to design thinking games, a fantasy and user experience podcast. Each episode, your podcast hosts, Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield, will examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper role-playing games, live-action games, mobile games, and video games. You can find every episode, including this one, on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at designthinkinggames.com.

    Michael Schofield  

    On my journey to level up as a Game Master, I enjoy taking Dungeons and Dragons way more seriously than you should. So over the last year, year and a half, the pandemic has really given me an excellent opportunity to find some writers that I like and read them. There’s one who I like quite a bit. His name is Justin Alexander. He writes a simple WordPress blog called the Alexandrian. He wrote about this method of designing or developing a story called The Three Clue Rule that I’m totally in love with, and I just wanted to throw it in your direction and get your thoughts.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so what is the elevator pitch, the two-sentence version of what’s the three clue rule? 

    Michael Schofield  

    Of course, that’s exactly the hardest part here. Assuming this is an elevator in a large building, here’s what I got: the three clue rule is a technique for solving the narrative problem of how characters get from one mystery to another without railroading them. By railroad, I mean, that as a player, regardless of your intentions, you are guided directly, beat by beat by beat through a story.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So a linear progression, like a linear story, a linear narrative for something.

    Michael Schofield  

    Exactly. Well, the three clue rule is trying to provide just a little bit of framework for folks who want to tell a story that isn’t linear. Suddenly being able to tell like a cohesive story, in a world or scenario where people can go in any direction they want, suddenly becomes an exponentially difficult problem to write for. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, I actually don’t know of anyone, and I’m kind of wondering about the percentage of players, right. But does anyone actually like a linear story that is literally that you walk through, and you’re not really changing your direction? No matter what you’re doing, you’re still going to the same pieces. To me, that makes me think very much of The Last of Us or The Last of Us 2 because essentially, in that system, and what I call it is like “map locking.” But essentially, it’s like, Hey, you go through this building. And now, once you go to this building, you are now in this area with a convenience store or whatever. And there’s only one way out of the building. So you’re locked in these 3d zone maps. And even though it seems like a world, here’s this 3d container, funny walls that you can’t climb over or buildings that you can’t climb. So it’s enforced, right? And you there’s only one way out. Now you can sneak your way through it. You can kill all the people you can run through and slaughter them, or you can snipe them or whatever. But I mean, essentially, you’re locked in a map, and you have to go to the next, and I think that’s how the story works the same way. No decisions I make in the story change anything, right? And the biggest thing that people hate about Last Of Us is how it forces you or railroads you, quote-unquote, into these difficult decisions. I don’t know how many people actually like linear. Apparently, there’s some do, I guess.

    Michael Schofield  

    With a linear game, I think you can design really specific experiences that are mind-blowing. Perhaps this gives you more opportunity to focus on excellent dialogue or really polished gameplay. You have a really cool scenario that you can plan the shit out of because, you know, people are going to get there eventually. Right? So I think there’s definitely benefit to it. And of course, they can have a spectrum of good to bad. I imagine Last of Us is way closer to the good end of the spectrum.

    Tim Broadwater  

    That’s like the number one thing that people complain about but also love about the Last Of Us is because, and I’m sorry, if you have not played the game, this is a spoiler alert. But essentially, at the end of the first game, I won’t use the second one because it’s rather new. But what people love but hate about it is that Joel, the main character, has no other option in the end – you can wait it out, and the timer goes down, and there’s a ticker but and nothing ever bad happens – but you kind of have to, you’re forced to kill the doctors and save Ellie. And people hate that. And 2’s the same way in the end, but I’m not going to ruin it. So half the audience loves being railroaded and forcing the player to make a difficult decision and that, you know, kind of example, whereas other people hated it, because they’re like, No, I wouldn’t have done that. I wouldn’t have done that, even in the context of the story. I wouldn’t have done that, you know.

    Anyway, so we know what linear is, what about the 3 Clues?

    Michael Schofield  

    To design something that’s nonlinear, you have a pretty difficult path ahead of you. It becomes really difficult to like craft something meaningful around there. If you want to sandbox, a sandbox with a really good story is way more difficult to do. So the three clue rule is proposing a system that is really kind of principle more than anything to help guide players from situation to situation without railroading without pulling them along artificially, right?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Like they cannot make any progress whatsoever. Unless they go do x and specifically x. So is it like clues that are in the world then?

    Michael Schofield  

    Imagine a Sherlock Holmes story, where you have some sort of mystery, a conspiracy that requires a lot of deductions to fall into place before you can even come to that aha moment. Now, what Sherlock himself does, is wander into a room and sees everything there, plucks the correct deduction out of the ether, and is able to move on. But the reality is, from Dungeon Master to Dungeon Master, if you create, like a similar kind of story, where pieces of the puzzle become clear over time. The reality is your players, or you, as a player, are gonna miss all of the clues. For any conclusion you want your player characters to make, include at least three clues. And Justin Alexander actually explains why three: “because the player characters will probably miss the first ignore the second and the misinterpret the third, before making some incredible leap of logic that gets them where you wanted them to go all along.” If you have a story where to get to point C, they have to get to point B, which requires they get to point A, that’s fine if you want to guide them hardcore into that direction. But if you want to make it feel like a world where they have agency, what if they go to C first?

    Tim Broadwater  

    I feel like this is like the bank, like literally the thing that every good GM, DM, or storyteller plans for, and then it’s always getting thrown off track by the players because they’re real people. It goes to something that it says it’s like it needs to create the parameters in which they can understand, which I think is what I understand from the three clue rule as opposed to railroading ABC. When you gave the example of the d&d module, it makes me think of the Pathfinder and Starfinder modules. There’s a star finder, one that I’m thinking of right now that I ran recently as a GM. And you kind of crash on a planet, and you’re trying to figure out why you crashed, where to go and what to do. You’re in a swamp when you crash. If you even just physically walk around, you’re going to think there’s an A, B, and C, right? One: you see these elementals attacking this weather station. The other: you see these weird electrical portal things that you can kind of investigate. Then another: you hear at some point, a yell and you respond to it, and you save a person, and the person ends up leading you to a village of their place. But then, by understanding that there was a weird temporal electric storm going on, that’s what kind of got your ship crashed. And this is how it’s affecting the local wildlife, right? And so you kind of get the story, but it doesn’t matter if you go ABC or CBA. 

    Michael Schofield  

    That’s probably an example of how a well-designed narrative takes place. And, you know, someone probably followed whether they called it or not this three clue rule. Instead of imagining a scenario like, “oh, I need these players to deduct from the crime scene,” you flip it around a little bit, and you say to yourself, “well, I need the players to conclude that the criminal was a large furry rabbit.” You just define what they need to know. And from there, the three clue rule is like … 

    Tim Broadwater  

    They found for on the crime scene, or they talked to a bystander, yes, all of a sudden, a big rabbit in the street or something. Yeah, so you drop it in three places. 

    Michael Schofield  

    Exactly. The way your narrative design looks like in the game, if you were to map this out on a piece of paper, instead of an outline, or like “first step one, then step two,” you have a whole bunch of dots, little nav points on your, on your paper, HUD or nodes, these little chunks. And the idea is that, like, wherever you place clues for one conclusion, there is evidence for other conclusions from that node. But it just shows your story can become really complex in this way. You’re still guiding the story. You’re still guiding the players. But it gives the illusion of agency.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Free choice or interaction. It’s interesting you said “nodes,” it’s because I think, you know, what we’re really talking about is like this node or this package, right, where you’re putting things together, and packages can exist on their own. And no matter what time or order they happen in, they find one when they go to a museum, or they get access to another one the next day, by a kid, they talked to him a street or whatever it is, you know, it’s this kind of modular thing that can move around. And it specifically makes me think of how we have that kind of in design, and software modular design objects, reusable components. There’s also much I don’t know if you’ve heard of it before, but have you ever heard of OOUX or object-oriented UX?

    Michael Schofield  

    Yes. And super popular?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, I think it’s Sophia Prater. And, Sophia, if you ever listen to us, I hope you do. But if I mispronounce your name, I’m sorry. But I actually will say I get your weekly email that comes to me that is literally kind of all the cool applications of object-oriented UX. I actually used it about a year ago. I was working with a client. And the client was a school counselor. And he wanted to apply for this grant that kind of gave this demonstration of how an app could work to help ease the job, and then you know, get backing so they could put it and make it offer free to school systems and whatever. Long story short, how object-oriented UX works is that you have these content components that are main objects, core content, metadata, nested objects. And it’s really those kinds of pieces. And then you kind of identify the best example that she uses is, if you think of like you’re using an app that is a recipe app, or a cooking app, right? You have a recipe. That recipe has ingredients. Tere’s a chef that made this recipe and submitted it. And then there are reviews, which is like users Yelping or giving it four stars. How can we design an experience in such a way that is so organic that a user can fly from recipe to ingredient back to the recipe to cook two ratings? You see what the cook rated? I want to see what other things the cook wrote or like, see if users like this particular recipe, or if they gave it their own twist? So I kind of did the same thing with kids in school. Who was their teacher? Who were their parents, what grade they’re in, so you could kind of fluidly navigate around to get what you need.

    Michael Schofield  

    It sounds like it’s like a three clue rule plus more clues, some of which are ultra obvious. Justin Alexander’s making the point that look, your players aren’t Sherlock Holmes. He calls it proactive clues. AKA, “bash them on the head with it.”

    Tim Broadwater  

    What it makes me think of is honestly like Detroit: Become Human, or Heavy Rain, which we talked about before, or Wolf Among Us. You can look at everything and interact with everything. And there are probably 40 clues in there. But you really only need to build up that percentage, like three, right? Oh, you don’t have to look at it really anything else. I mean, you can if you want, but you got to just,

    Michael Schofield  

    That’s the other part of the spectrum of this narrative design. So it’s not just when you come to a conclusion go straight to it. In some cases, the next beat of the story is like a lot, either behind some kind of like meter as like, Oh, you have to complete this, you know, 30% before you can continue on, which I think is supposed to simulate, get it like figuring it out, getting all the clues that you actually need. In-app design, you have things like, “oh, you can’t do this until you do this.” It’s guided. It’s sort of like this bread crumbs style of design.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So you mentioned something before, maybe in a previous episode, or when we were talking about this – “Gumshoe.” What is that?

    Michael Schofield  

    Specifically, I think it was named after all of these Sherlock Holmes style of games, specifically mysteries as well. Did you ever play any of those like, first-person, almost like point and click adventure Sherlock Holmes games like Sherlock Holmes, and I don’t know if this is the real title, but there’s like, there’s one where it’s like Sherlock Holmes versus like fucking Dracula. Oh, they get weird. There’s like Sherlock Holmes verse jack the Ripper. But I mean, there’s you can play like regular mysteries as well.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, I think Sierra games, where Ken and Roberta Williams – 

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah! That’s where it comes from.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So I’ve done the Laura Bow mysteries. But they’re a mystery game where you can click on the mouse to move around. But then you have to type in, “look open closet,” and then hit enter. 

    Michael Schofield  

    Let me read this briefly. It’s just a couple paragraphs. For the Gumshoe System used in games, “Robin D Laws decided to get rid of the concept of needing to find clues. And in each scene of an investigation, there is a clue. It is automatically assumed that the investigators will find it.”

    Tim Broadwater  

    So all you have to do is just go there.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, it’s like in the case of the gumshoe system. They need to find the clues and make it a correct deduction is handled mechanically, with the players committing points from their character skills to receive increasingly accurate hints. I love the Sherlock Holmes games, they are fun, but there’s no mystery to it because all it is is about finding the part of the room that you’re in that is clickable. The deduction, or the clue, at least literally becomes a line in a dashboard, right? Or in your notebook or something like that. And, and the game is to take, you know, three clues and draw the correct lines between them. And then you get a deduction. I think it’s specifically this idea that there are that first, you are going to be in the right place at the right time to get the clues. But then you can use a mechanical solution to make it more likely that the player will figure it out.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Did you ever play the King’s Quest, or Space Quest, or Police Quest? Sorry?

    Michael Schofield  

    I played King’s Quest. Yeah, man. Classic.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So the one that is the Colonel’s Bequest, which is the Laura Bow series. Laura Bow is a student that goes to college somewhere in Louisiana or something. And then she goes with her friend home for the weekend, to visit for a family reunion. And they’re like, “Okay,” and so they get in the swamp boat, and they go out there. And they have it, and at dinner, the colonel, who’s the head of the family, and it’s everyone meets there. And it’s like Southern Gentry, but then that French Creole, kind of, you know, Louisiana Bayou mystery, whatever you want to call it. So essentially, he announces that he’s writing everyone out of the room. Well, that you’re all ungrateful brats, and you’re all horrible people, and he’s not giving anyone his money. And that’s what happens at the family reunion. You know, good times, Thanksgiving, I guess. And then that night, he gets murdered?

    Michael Schofield  

    Who did it?

    Tim Broadwater  

    So it’s this game where you’re clicking around with a mouse, and you’re investigating clues, and you’re trying to search for fingerprints. You’re eavesdropping and hallways behind walls to see secret conversations. And then there’s all this stuff that happens. The only thing that keeps the momentum going is the clock keeps turning. You’re just trying to get to the morning because the police will come in the morning. You can’t leave because the swamp has risen. And so there are events that you can miss. And so it’s really hard to get all sides of the stories. And at the end, it gives you this percentage, which I thought was amazing that when I beat the game, finally, which was so hard to do, it was just like, “Oh, you got to 45% correct.”

    Michael Schofield  

    So you potentially came to the wrong conclusion?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so kind of what happens to your point is that you can finger the wrong person. That’s horrible. I said that. You can blame the wrong person. You can then the cops will arrest someone who’s incorrect. And it’ll just say this plucky thing that’s like, “Oh, it’s a shame. You didn’t find the right person.” It would just give you these sentences at the end of the game that said, “oh, shame, you didn’t spend more time in the parlor.” And then you would read it in the replay value was crazy. But um, in that regard, there’s like hundreds of clues. Sure. So what do you think? I mean, I think that’s a great example of a game that is kind of this nonlinear, kind of three clues or gumshoe kind of thing to where you’re trying to piece together. Do you have a game that specifically speaks to you in that kind of genre?

    Michael Schofield  

    You got me thinking about all these Sherlock Holmes games. I played them all. They’re all like this. There’s an old game. I kept the CD ROM even though I can’t play it on anything because it’s one of my favorite games of all time. It was a Titanic game, which was a whodunnit on board the Titanic, the night that it sank. I love this style of game which lets you complete it even if you’re wrong. Recently, relatively recently, in the last 10 years. LA Noir did something similar, which was a game where you’re a detective, and you have to read the person’s face as you question them and come to a conclusion. And boy, I got a lot of them wrong and sent a lot of the wrong people to jail.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I have played Gabriel Knight before. I’m not sure if you’ve played those.

    Michael Schofield  

    We should talk an entire episode about Gabriel Knight, specifically, the second one, which is it Gabriel Knight the Beast within or Gabriel Knight …

    Tim Broadwater  

    “The Beast Within,” and I think he goes to visit his family in Scotland, and he inherits a castle or something.

    Michael Schofield  

    Gabriel Knight 2t: the Beast Within specifically my favorite one because Gabriel Knights 1 and 3, one for technical reasons and 3 for stylistic reasons, they were both graphic games, but in Gabriel Knight 2, they had this kind of weird blend of video game and real human actors that was a thing in the late 90s.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Wouldn’t they like video them and record their audio, and then they would turn the video into like a –

    Michael Schofield  

    like GIF, almost. So you would see actors act out the scene, and then there would be these static cutouts of actual photographs that had slight walking mechanics. It was pretty bananas. But at the time, it was great. All that to say, Gabriel Knight goes to Germany because he’s either inherited or occupying a castle from his family. The Ritters.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I said Scotland. Yeah, it’s Germany.

    Michael Schofield  

    I remember because a main through point there is the story of an old “Barovian” count.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Basically, Gabriel Knight, the first one was that “Sins of the Father?” He’s a bookstore and an occultist. That’s what this is what I always thought was cool because he was a bookstore owner and an occultist who was also a private detective. So it’s kind of weird, but it’s kind of cool. You know what I mean? So you’re thinking like Friday the 13th, the TV series, — 

    Michael Schofield  

    It’s very Lovecraftian, right? Because often like like Lovecraft characters, or like Call of Cthulhu, it’s like, oh, this is a librarian who has a deep knowledge of the occult.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, and I mean, he has interactions with New Orleans, and he goes to Lafayette cemetery and Pontchartrain Park, I think, and then there are murders, and he’s being hired individually, but then he has to of course he shows up, and there are cops there, and he has an interaction with the cops, and there’s its course there’s voodoo, and it’s Mardi Gras, it’s really cool series, but it has a lot of that —

    Michael Schofield  

    it has a deep mystery, too —

    Tim Broadwater  

    You have to research. You get fingerprints at points.

    Michael Schofield  

    I can’t remember if it Gabriel Knight gate-kept you, though. In your earlier example with like the Colonel’s Bequest, or in the Sherlock Holmes games, you can finish them wrong. But you can still finish them.

    Tim Broadwater  

    You can’t proceed and Gabriel Knight. So Colonel’s Bequest was like the night marches on. So if it’s three in the morning, or four in the morning, or two in the morning, whatever. I mean, it’s gonna happen, and you either get information, or you don’t. And then, at dawn, the cops come, and they kind of ask you who did it, and you can choose anyone. But in Gabriel Knight, every day keeps going by, and I think there’s an overall time ticker that something bad can happen. But then every day you can drive around, you can go to the Pontchartrain Park, you can go to Lafayette cemetery, you can go to the library, you can go to your store, you can kind of do anything and it’s just like, as the time picker goes by, I think you just can’t do things unless you ask the right questions and get the right clues that prompt those questions. 

    Michael Schofield  

    Those Dark Pictures Anthology games do something similar where you miss an opportunity to have this conversation or progress in this specific way because you dilly-dallied or you went the other way. I love these things.

    Tim Broadwater  

    This makes me think of a board game clue. It’s a super good game, and there are many versions of it, and I love the movie is even hilarious. But uh, it’s hilarious.

    Michael Schofield  

    “MURDA.” I can’t do a Tim Curry.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I just remember Madeline Kahn and the line where she’s like, “flames, flames on the side of my face, burning flames.” Anyways, but include you’re just trying to find the weapon, the location, you know, and who did it, and all you’re doing is literally asking everyone like a detective would. 

    This conversation is just about detective games in this genre. And then the different ways that you can get through the story. It’s interesting mechanics. And then having these things set up to where they’re like, separate or like modular like we’re saying whether they’re just self-contained things that you can move around, find out and experience and be wrong. If you’re trying to figure out something or maybe go to the wrong place and miss something.

    Michael Schofield  

    What a hard type of game to design. I think that’s the point. To do them well, it’s super difficult. To do a mystery well, hard; to do a sandbox well that guides you through a story, pretty hard.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah. So like in UX, I mean, we think of findability and discoverability. Right? So especially on a website or web application, or enterprise software application, or whatever. But can the user get to where they need to? Or find where it is, but then can they, by just interacting with the system, organically discover things that help them and they didn’t see before? Because you just got the user, the player just needs to get in there and start moving? Right? That’s what they want to do. But when you apply that concept to the narrative in the game or discovered or what you’re trying to find out in the game…

    Michael Schofield  

    That is a discoverability thing, right? It’s because what you’re trying to guide is a conclusion. You want the players to discover the next beat of the story. There’s probably a really good rule there too. In designing information architecture, you definitely need people to be able to find X.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Information architecture is all its own thing. We think maybe just navigation and card sorting, right? And card sorting, making dendrograms to this is how you should group information because this is how our user would do it. And then or, but yeah, it’s a lot of nuanced kind of thing. 

    Michael Schofield  

    There’s probably something there where an application or like the three clue rule to say…

    Tim Broadwater  

    Everyone always says like three clicks, right?

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, exactly. It’s like, you should be able to get to every part of a website within three clicks from anywhere within that web service. Clearly easier said than done, but that kind of you can imagine if you were to map this all out on a two dimensional plane with crime scene like strings drawn between thumbtacks that suddenly a service of any significant size that adheres to that principle, has a lot of potential throughputs, which is probably a greatly designed system.

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the design thinking games podcast. To connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim, please go to design thinking games.com where you can request topics, ask questions, or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on

  • 005: Enter the LARPZone

    005: Enter the LARPZone

    Games discussed on this episode:

    • Vampire: the Masquerade
    • Kindred the Embraced
    • Society of Creative Anachronism
    • True Dungeon
    • HEMA
    • City of Heroes
    • Dungeons & Dragons

    Introductory Guy  

    Welcome to design thinking games, a fantasy and user experience podcast. Each episode, your podcast host, Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield, will examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper roleplaying games, live-action games, mobile games, and video games. You can find every episode, including this one on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at design thinking games.com.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so one of the things that I really don’t understand, and I’ve met a couple people in my life, and you’re the third one actually, is LARPing. So let me give you a little bit of my perspective on this. As far as I know, it, like Dungeons and Dragons, or Pathfinder, or any other roleplaying game. There’s kind of a game that I came in contact with in college, and I was in college, probably from like, 95 to 2000. And it was in the World of Darkness kind by White Wolf.

    So Vampire: the Masquerade, Werewolf: the Apocalypse, Mage: the Ascension, Wraith: the Oblivion, and it keeps going, right? The system is what I really loved about those games, because in college, we can have a werewolf play with a vampire play with whatever. But what I didn’t realize is that there’s a whole community, and forums, and people who play this game live, and that’s kind of live-action roleplaying. I went to Gen Con a couple years ago, and a friend of mine, Kevin, wanted me to go and attend a Vampire: the Masquerade LARP. And I was like, Hell no, I’m not doing it. That’s way too geeky. You know, I’m okay with roleplaying in tabletop roleplaying games, like Dungeons and Dragons, or Pathfinder or whatever. But at some point, like, I do, like the math and the dice rolling, and I’m a hack-and-slasher. So essentially, the question is, can you speak to it?

    Michael Schofield

    I want to clarify a couple of things. There’s the thing that I sometimes say when people who aren’t among us discover that I played Dungeons and Dragons or some of these other things. And it’s always like, No, no, it’s okay. I’m not a larper. I’m way cooler. And so it’s been some time. I’m turning 36 this year. So it’s been well over 17 years since I did any of this. 

    Dungeons and Dragons players know that there are several versions: the original, there’s the second edition, third edition, fourth edition, 4.5, fifth edition, which we’re in now, I’m not exactly sure, but at some point, it was a big deal. When White Wolf announced the World of Darkness 2, Vampire: the Masquerade was sunset. It became Vampire: The Requiem, which had an entirely new rule system. All that to say, I’m merely bringing this up to say that Yo, I was a world of darkness one player. Vampire the Masquerade is what I know best.

    Tim Broadwater

    I don’t know if you know it or not, but there is a World of Darkness documentary on amazon prime. 

    Michael Schofield  

    Oh, fascinating. No, I didn’t. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    I’ve watched it here recently. It encompassed the tabletop game and the LARPing, also the video games that kind of spun-off. And what I love about it is, here’s this genre, right? Like Star Wars or Marvel, that literally has got video games, it’s got live-action roleplaying games, a TV show…

    Michael Schofield  

    It was on Fox, back in the late 90s.

    Tim Broadwater  

    That’s right.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, called Kindred the Embraced. And I think it only ran for one season. Unfortunately, the actor who played the prince of San Francisco died in a motorcycle accident, but this is well within my teenage goth years, so I remember it pretty well. But yeah, to your point, it’s a culture. As a budding goth kid, my first CDs as gifts included, I think, one of The Cure albums, and I ended up getting all of them, right? So it set me on this  snowball into eyeliner and dyed black hair and stuff like that.

    Tim Broadwater

    So we can blame it all on The Cure.

    Michael Schofield  

    It began with The Cure, but it started probably because I played this kind of spin-off like Yahoo chat room online text-based RPG. And vampires are super cool. Anyway. So like, of course, Vampire: the Masquerade was really big back then, I guess it still is, but at least in this area, it was super big. And it just so happened that all the kids I was playing with were totally preferring to be vampires instead of knights slaying dragons, right? So all the rules that we stole off the internet all came from this game.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, I feel like sometimes people get sick of high fantasy, like elves and castles and wizards and magic. And you know, and that’s so these other genres are like superhero roleplaying games or World of Darkness. Or I’m playing one now, which I think I told you about, which is like a wrestling one where you actually are wrestlers. And you make personas, and you’re either a face or a heel.

    Michael Schofield  

    You didn’t say anything about your wrestling RPG!

    Tim Broadwater

    Yeah, actually, I just started a couple weeks ago. But yeah, that’s a whole other episode. Did you start it as a tabletop game, and then it just turns to like a LARP. And it’s the math and the system? Because I’m familiar with the mechanics and the mechanics. Is that really easy to translate to like LARPing? Or …

    Michael Schofield  

    The mechanics of Vampire the Masquerade, specifically, lean themselves more RP heavy than a straight out-of-the-box D&D module. Because I don’t know if they do it now. But like the original byline was: “Vampire the Masquerade is a storytelling game of personal horror.” And it’s set in our world when the sun sets, etc. And it’s specifically a political game. You operate within one of a couple political entities: the Camarilla or the Sabbat. Within them, you have princedoms that have a variety of vassals, and so on. And so much of the game and its mechanics are about controlling social circumstances and behavior.

    Tim Broadwater  

    What makes people who haven’t played it before, the appealing or the like, the neatest thing I guess I found out about it is not just the systems work with one another, right? All the characters have their own “personal horror” that’s actually been baked into the game because werewolves have rage, and they become totally feral. And I think vampires have a bloodlust or something. 

    Michael Schofield

    No, it’s literally called “humanity.” It can go down like if you do bad things, but it goes down permanently. 

    Tim Broadwater

    Yeah, so vampires lose humanity, werewolves increase their rage. Yeah. And I think changelings lose glamour. Mages have the paradox. It’s basically like when you use magic as in Mage: the Ascension, you’re kind of breaking reality to some degree, like little fissure cracks in reality, or like breaking like physics, right? And you could only do that so much. Before you go insane. I guess we’re missing words. Yeah. And I know that changelings, like they become banality, is their thing, right? Because they’re connected to the fay world, but they’re kind of forced to live here on earth. And so their connection to the fay world like with fairies and Seders and, and Red Hats and goblins and whatever, diminishes over time and so the more battles they get, and the more they don’t get, they lose that whimsical fantasy fade nature connection. Banality is what happens, and they just become human, and they lose it right. So there’s, it’s interesting because the White Wolf games, either gaining or decreasing like your characters can be self-defeating, right? Yeah, so chat room I get. Did you ever play a tabletop version of it? And did you ever play any LARPing of it? Or video games?

    Michael Schofield  

    Yes, to all three. The tabletop is more obvious, like so yeah. 100% played tabletop vampire. And I ran a couple of sessions, or a couple of them not called campaigns, you know what I mean? Maybe they are called campaigns. The video games 100% have a lot to say there. The LARPing is a little different. There was like a network almost like the Society of Something Anachronism.

    Tim Broadwater  

    The Society of Creative Anachronism.

    Michael Schofield  

    Thank you. So there was like, there was a network, similarly governed, where there was an official print of this, that and there are different chapters, and they all participate in like a larger, nationwide system, where at the very top you had, you know, your, your elders, your Camarilla leaders and your Sabbat leaders? 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah. So the other person that I’ve met, my friend, John, who’s played this, who did it in public, they would use those type of things. And I’m not sure if those are chat rooms, or forums or whatever, to where people would organize. They were forums. Yeah, yeah. And so you would have groups coming in from outside the state or outside the area, and they would do this. And he’s described it to me before, and I’ve never, I don’t have the details on it. But that when they would identify or like they would just like 100 of them to be like in a town. Yeah. You know, and then essentially, they could do like Rock Paper, scissors or something to make decisions or Rock paper scissors. Yeah. Yeah. And then, and, and so what my understanding is from this documentary is like, people love that like, so. You mentioned the SCA, the Society of creative anachronisms. And so I’ve had experience with them. I’ve attended a couple of their events, because I was really interested in combat, like physical combat with armor, you know, and, and then I found out it was like, it was pretty much a third of combat, or like, maybe a fourth of combat and then like three-fourths roleplaying, right. Yeah. And so to me, as we’ve talked before, I will get down in roleplay. But it’s like, I don’t want to do it all the time. And I’m not a reenactor at all. And I know some people like that, you know. But so I’ve attended that. And it’s been cool. And I’ve attended some of their combat kind of events. And I’ve seen large-scale army battles, right? With SCA. And I think very similar to that is this world of darkness, right where you’re like, but it’s not a werewolf, and it’s not. It’s like specifically Vampire that speaks to people that have created these, like SCA, there are kingdoms, and there’s Lord over the kingdom. And then you have your subclass of a kingdom, and you have a location and, and fealty, and kind of all that. And so that’s what was in the kind of the documentary that showed, Hey, that was this kind of that was the thing that people wanted out of LARPing. That’s what they wanted, like connection and person. And then I guess some of the people who played, I mean, they would do like to put on prosthetic ears. Oh, definitely banks and all that stuff, the contacts,

    Michael Schofield  

    Right, because around the early 2000s, especially as when you started, colored contacts were really easy to order. Even if they had no prescription on them. I remember folks in school, walking around with them. So it was easy. It was easy to look like a vampire. And it was easy to look like a vampire in public. Remember, the big conceit, generally is that in the world of darkness, and that vampires exist, and they are in your world, now you’re not in some city called Haven, or Waterdeep, you’re in. You’re in Richmond, or you are in Chicago, and there are vampires here, and you may be one of them. And the idea of a lot of the stuff that we kind of enjoyed was the fact that like, yo, we are vampires and we’re gonna walk around with like, you know, maybe it’s like some small things in or whatever without anyone noticing, and we’re gonna go about our day. But you’re always a vampire. Right? And so and so it’s, it’s the hiding in plain sight, kind of appeal. That’s really neat. And then, of course, like in the LARPing environments. These are things I’ve never participated in. But nearby, I was like I was three and a half hours north of Chicago. So in Chicago, they would rent out, like hotel lobbies or whatever. And the prince the quote, Prince of Chicago, would be there no fancy-ass chair, and you would pay your fealty there. There’s a performative aspect to it. That transcended the game. In fact, there might not even be a story. It’s just like, Hey, I’m in Chicago. I have to see the prince, I have to announce myself. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Have you ever heard of True Dungeon at all?

    Michael Schofield  

    I haven’t; I’m gonna check it out.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So I came in contact with it a year ago. True Dungeon is, it’s kind of, it’s a little expensive. You pay like 40 bucks a game to do it, maybe more. And essentially, True Dungeon is kind of this thing where they set it up at big gaming cons, it’s at Dragon Con, it’s at certain taxes. It’s a Gen Con. It’s at Origins. So the big ones. But basically, it’s virtual. I mean, it’s like, they take a giant space, they put up walls, they do lighting, they do sound effects, there are animatronic monsters in it, you all meet up. And so I’ll just say this, I’m a level two barbarian intruder. I’ve played it. I love it. You essentially get with a group of people, you have a character and cards, every time you play, you get treasure and items, and you keep them all, and the next time you play, you can kind of build your character with what you want to bring potions and items and armor, right? And you go up and level. But essentially, like you’re going through, you’re solving puzzles as a group would, which can be chaotic, because there’s like six of you and you’re in a time limit and the rooms about to close off, or you’ll die, and you’re trying to figure out, you know, the puzzle, but then there’s also the combat, and the combat is dealt with in a kind of an I don’t know like a Bochy, ball or skeet thing, or air hockey table where you kind of throw your weapons or spells across and you’re trying to get them to land in a certain zone to do the most damage. Yeah, yeah. So it’s, it’s very cool. And they have a lot of people doing it, like Wil Wheaton has done it and like, famous people, because it’s, it’s just kind of a cool experience that you want to do with your group of friends. And that’s kind of like as LARPing as I go. For me, I still like puzzle solving and grouping and like getting the treasure, and I like combat. But I know that True Dungeon has a huge community that does that kind of thing. And I think that’s, you know, that’s probably the coolest like LARPing thing that I’ve I’ve really kind of enjoyed,

    Michael Schofield  

    You know, it’s funny, this makes me think of things like the increasing popularity of escape rooms. And that those are, those are horror, LARPing. And that’s, um, and it’s really fascinating that like, now, this kind of experiments, and just the ability with like 3d printing, probably, to create immersive props and immersive settings. Make this way, way more interesting than I was, and you know, the late 90s.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, there’s a guy that I played with who actually brought a shield like it was like, not cardboard, and it wasn’t wood, but he actually made a shield, and he was like, he came in and was like, Don’t worry, guys. And he says this to the group, I was playing True Dungeon. He’s like, I’m a level a cleric, I, none of you will die. And he has his giant life side shield that he’s on. But all the items or spells that he can cast are like velcroed to his shield, and then combat like I went down, like fighting a monster in a bog. And then he basically pulled a thing off of a shield is like it’s an immediate reaction. I bring him back to life at four hit points. And like, it’s like it was like nuts. But like people build their props and they build their costumes and wigs and items, and they have to work with it. And I would encourage people that if you’ve never had any type of experience with LARPing, geocaching games, true dungeon vampire, maybe your SCA person. There’s also even, I think, out of Australia, there’s a thing called armored combat league. I don’t know, like, even if you just want to do the whole, like, medieval times, and you just want to see people fight in armor. Or you want to do it yourself. That’s something that you can do. There are also Hema schools.

    Michael Schofield  

    HEMA is something I’ve been personally looking into. I’ve gotten pretty deep into HEMAtok the hema section of TikTok, right. And have looked for human groups locally. There’s another one I forget the name, but it’s literally combat-like a maybe it is armored combat league. There’s one in the US. Where it’s real armor, and it’s real, I’ll be adult weapons, and you can do you beat the shit out of your opponent. Right?

    Tim Broadwater

    When I went to SCA last time, like the Society of grenade mechanisms, they did have a physical like a combat section. And this person that was healing is amazing, didn’t compete, but she was like, a phenomenal with a spear. And then it’s like a point system just like karate. It’s like, oh, did you avoid and block? And did you land a hit? And was it clear and apparent and efficient? You know, the same thing, except it’s weapons and shields. And you know, and apparently, she is like, the most amazing person with spear-like no one can beat her no matter what, because of the reach of it and yes, her proficiency. And yeah, and when I attended, they had different things they had like a shield and, like, a sword and shield tournament. But then they also had a free weapons tournament, like whatever you wanted to bring, but then they had like a rapier tournament. And, and it was just, it was really cool to watch.

    Michael Schofield  

    It’s fascinating to watch that kind of thing to Hema as a, as a, as a sport, or as an as a proper martial art that you practice regularly is fascinating. But I wonder if this all just comes down to the characters and narratives that we identify with? Because when we’re talking about, you know, what, what was LARP? You know, pre 3d printing, right? And then, and then what it’s become, I mean, like 3d printing just opened up like a, I guess, spectrum of opportunity to inhabit these roles, whether that’s actually part of a system or it’s almost like cosplaying, right, maybe all you care about is the gear. And a lot of people play games just for the amazing gear, too.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, I have a friend Chris, who lives in Chicago who makes prosthetic teeth for cosplayers. And he does work teeth and Vampire’s teeth and, and he does it from his 3d printer. And he’s like, in demand, like he has to. He’s like, hey, everything’s kind of on backorder. But I think you’re right, like, when you were describing, like the vampire game that you can play with trends and you can kind of as a storyteller, construct a story and build your characters and kind of like set it up. So you can play online. I mean, City of heroes had the exact same thing. It had a builder to where you could create your own villains who had powers and your own villain teams, and you could create a story where it’s a rescue or your or whatever, but it’s kind of giving the parameters of, of a system that everyone can kind of maybe agree upon, right? But then you can bring as much flourish to it as you want. So if you want to cause play, or LARP, or build out armor shields, you can do that. It’s just like having super control over your avatar in a game like people want that apparent from, you know, yeah, cyberpunk, to where you’re like, Oh, I like the mantis arm bill, like, no, I really like the gorilla and build and you can make, change everything about yourself, you can make yourself a complete persona and chat. VR chat lets you do this like you can kind of build whatever character you want and go and start interacting and roleplaying with people. And so VR chat in itself is very much like what we’re talking about here to where you can go talk to people, you can look, you can roll out roleplay and do kind of whatever you want. And I think it’s that level of just providing your players or users, you know, kind of at least alike in sculpture, where they call it like an armature or like a base, like kind of mechanics, and then let people go with it, right. They can do whatever they want with it, they can expand it, they can grow, it may get a community, like whatever.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, and I think the other thing that this raises is just awareness of how the job to be done for these games differs. The reason you play Dungeons and Dragons is dramatically different than the reason that you play old-school Vampire the Masquerade.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I think that it’s what do people want out of games from the player or user perspective? I definitely have played with a lot of hacking slashers at the table, and I’m sure we all have the people who were just like, I have the best build, I can cleave, I can super cleave. I can step up when you try to get For me, and just like they’ve, they love being able to pour into like building this kind of combat build. But just on the flip side of the coin is literally the role player who wants to have that roleplaying experience. He wants to develop the history and narrative of their character, which informs how they’re acting in the game. And I think there’s this kind of balance between role play and hack and slash. And the people who, I guess in my mind, the one side of the coin is the role player. And the other side is like the miniatures person like your Battletech 40k, or Warhammer 40, attacker, whatever because those are people like I just pure combat strategy. And then there’s this kind of nice, easy balance in the middle to where which is what I like. And I think a lot of players what they like about Dungeons and Dragons, or Pathfinder, or even White Wolf games to where it’s like, well, I want to roleplay, but I also want abilities, and I want to roll it, you know, and

    Michael Schofield  

    We even have miniatures, yeah, optionally, cool, cool 3d printed maps and to, you know, to fight the big bad evil guy in.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so there’s a spectrum right of what each player is looking for. And it doesn’t really matter if it’s tabletop LARPing or MMO RPG. It’s really the bubble is like the combat build versus the roleplaying and interaction. And I think you’re always gonna have people who follow on that, that Kinsey scale and lack of a better metaphor, what is your roleplayers Kinsey score?

    Tim Broadwater  

    I am, I would say that I am in the I’m a solid right in the middle to where I like a balance between roleplaying and hack or mechanics and hack and slash, and I enjoy both. What about you?

    Michael Schofield  

    I am a narrative hooker, right? So I prefer narrative and storytelling, you know, my background begins in Vampire the Masquerade before Dungeons and Dragons. So that’s what I prefer. I want the mechanics to be able to express the things that I want to do through the narrative.

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the design thinking games podcast. To connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim, please go to design thinking games.com where you can request topics, ask questions, or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on

  • 004: Narrative, the World and Everything

    004: Narrative, the World and Everything

    Games discussed in this episode:

    • Life is Strange series
    • Red Dead Redemption
    • Mass Effect
    • Man of Medan
    • Cyberpunk
    • Guild Wars
    • Wolf Among Us
    • Medium
    • Fury of Dracula

    Introductory Guy  

    Welcome to design thinking games, a fantasy and user experience podcast. In each episode, your podcast host, Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield will examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper role-playing games, live-action games, mobile games, and video games. You can find every episode, including this one on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at design thinking games.com.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So last time, you asked me a lot about the games that I gravitate to and like. Specifically, the question was identity and games and how I see myself in games. I kind of want to ask you the same question. And so what is the type of game that you like? And how do you see yourself in games, and what are the commonalities between those games?

    Michael Schofield  

    I’m very drawn to Choose Your Own Adventures. The games I’m thinking of literally off the top of my head at the moment are DONTNOD’s Life is Strange series, TellTale’s series before TellTale went under. Even before that, these old Adventures of Sherlock Holmes series, where the game is mainly in choosing the questions you ask or how you answer, how you react to situations, more than navigating through dark hallways and popping the first thing on site.

    I enjoy those games, too, but when I think about something that I’m in the mood for, it’s one of these experiences more often than not. Where, yeah, so you were talking last time about RPGs. And the ability to and the idea of the sandbox world. 

    I don’t very much appreciate a sandbox, even when it’s good. Red Dead Redemption comes to mind here, where it’s arguably one of the best sandboxes for an individual for a single player to have ever been made. And even though you’re constrained to the narrative of Arthur Morgan, you know, you can wander off and live in the woods for the entirety of the game and never engage with a plot point. And I find that it can be as fun as it is to be a rum runner and shoot bears and grow a beard, I find that continuity error where the town is going to burn, and then you wander off for 40 days. I find that so disruptive that I kind of get repulsed by it. So I have my fun on those games. And then I walk away. 

    What I like is a Mass Effect, right? You have several choices that you can make.

    Tim Broadwater  

    100% transparency I’ve never played Mass Effect, so I don’t know anything about it. 

    Michael Schofield  

    It’s one that I’ve totally encouraged you in the past off-mic to try. The idea is that Mass Effect is a science-fiction game. It’s a little bit of space opera in the 80s, and you are the one person in the universe who can assemble the ragtag team, fight the big bad, maybe save the galaxy, etc. You aren’t Tim, in the year 2142. You’re Commander Shepard. You have a name, and not only do you have a name, you have a voice, and you can pick male or female, but they have different voice actors. So you are piloting Commander Shepard. You are not Commander Shepard. And there’s a lot of wiggle room about how your Shepard responds to the situation. And they do something really cool where the decisions you make in game 1, which roll over to the decisions on game two, which roll over into game three, and even vaguely impact the spin-off Mass Effect Andromeda. And when Mass Effect 4comes out, I assume it’s going to take your saved files there. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    So is it first person?

    Michael Schofield  

    No, you are a third-person Shepard. Looking over the shoulders of your hero. So they’re either the equivalent of a magic-user or a fighter, just space versions. Those are the things I gravitate toward. I don’t want to be me. I want to be Commander Shepard. And specifically, I have a particular Commander Shepard who is defined by my decisions. 

    So Life is Strange has Max Caulfield. You are Max Caulfield. You’re piloting Max Caulfield, those kinds of things.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So is it safe to kind of, I guess to describe it, you would say that this is its narrative, and then your actions in that character? When you’re not playing yourself, you know, you’re playing these, you know, the specific characters you’re talking about. Changes the outcome of the story. Is that accurate?

    Michael Schofield  

    Oh, 100% it’s like the hand of God guiding some humans or human-like things who don’t know better than they are being guided?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so there’s a decent amount of what I would call in lack of a better word. It’s like you’re it’s a movie, like yeah, pretty much just watching a movie and you and you make decisions at certain points. And that changes the story, right.

    Michael Schofield  

    So last night, I played. I think it’s called. I think the actual series is called The Dark Pictures Anthology.

    Tim Broadwater

    Man of Medan

    Michael Schofield  

    I haven’t played little hope yet. No spoilers, but I beat Man of Medan yesterday, and I started over again because I only made it through with three survivors instead of all five. That’s the kind of thing that is — chef’s kiss — that’s my type of game.

    Tim Broadwater  

    You really liked it then.

    Michael Schofield  

    I loved it. Yeah, that’s the kind of thing I like. I want I’m in it for the story. And I want the characters to behave the way I imagined they would. I don’t desire to see myself represented there.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So it to you doesn’t matter if it’s sci-fi or Cyberpunk, or if it’s a Western or even, like, dystopian. Like, it’s the story that attracts you.

    Michael Schofield  

    It has to be a tight story as well. So once you can wander off the rails. I get bored. In Fallout 4, there’s this mechanic that some people didn’t like (I did) where you could build settlements. So it’s kind of Minecraft in the loosest sense where you can, you know, you can construct walls and put up turrets and stuff like that. And I admit that I ended up just becoming a settlement maker, like, and I stopped with the story altogether, but because, but because, like I don’t give a shit about the story. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    It’s funny because when you talk about Red Dead Redemption, there are definitely places that you are mentioning that are, oh, you have this pressing story or thing to do, but you don’t have to do it at all. And if in this story, and I think there’s one in Cyberpunk that I’ve heard from a friend, specifically you have to do this by tomorrow night. Well, you can just go off and do whatever you want for a year and then come back, and it’s still tomorrow or something like that. 

    To your point, like, you can just go off and to the woods. And by the way, my life goal is to be a rum runner and to shoot bears and grow a beard, scamp in the woods. 

    But I mean, yeah, it’s just like, I don’t even have to do the main story, you know? So that’s kind of, I think, a template, right? To where like, you have this open? It’s like, when they say open-world game, it seems so vague, right? But it’s just like, Oh, well, there’s some story quests that you can do. But you don’t even have to do any of them ever. Maybe if you want a piece of armor or a certain weapon, or just to complete the story. You can search and unlock points, or you can just kind of explore, so the story is kind of de-emphasized in those games.

    Michael Schofield  

    On the flip side, what it means is that you’re like, with Red Dead Redemption, could I just wander off and let it become the early 1900s and grow old and gradually the West diminishes, as the railroads are built? That would be dope. That’s the story. I mean, that’s what an open world is because the world is alive. But the discontinuity between the world is either living or isn’t based on your actions. That bugs me, and so I think with these kinds of heavily narrated games, your actions in the world are interwoven.

    Tim Broadwater  

    When you think about this living system, right, or living game, and that if you are the chosen one, the Neo to The Matrix, or Aragon of Lord of the Rings, or whatever you want to say, one of the things you don’t see in a lot of games is like what happens when you don’t do anything? I see it in like, you know, kind of very specific, and these railroad narrative games, like Detroit: Become Human, or, you know, like you said, Until Dawn, or Man of Medan, to where there are very specific things that happen if you don’t do things within a certain time, or don’t make the right narrative choices or screw up, right, so there’s cuz it changes the story. Y

    So let’s say you’re playing Guild Wars, and in Guild Wars 2, there is the main story that is your character, but then there’s also an open world. And you can come back to the main story at any point, just like Cyberpunk, just like Mad Max. But nothing negatively happens if you lose or fail the quest, and you just go to one specific place to load up or join up with people to do that thing, right. But there is no Oh, no, now we’re in the dark timeline because you failed to do X or save the princess or whatever. And so there’s no kind of, you know, it’s, it’s something that’s very unique to this railroad narrative kind of game that you’re describing. And that the living system goes on with or without you, you know, things change.

    Michael Schofield  

    The difficulty in designing that must be pretty, pretty substantial. But yeah, I think it’s the I maybe it has the illusion, what I need out of the game is an illusion of impact on the world. And maybe through those narrative-type adventures. That the gulf between my actions and what happens in the world are is pretty, pretty small.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so I’m wondering, you try to make the choices, or run the character play the character and the context of the story as they would act? Do you ever just be evil to see what’s happens or, you know, be or, you know, whatever he wanted, just to see how the story changes in the play, cuz I’m assuming there’s a replay value of all of these games because of the way the story changes? 

    Michael Schofield  

    Not really, like I’m always all of my characters like, okay, yeah, all of these characters. Express a kind of an assertive, neutral, or a sort of good version of themselves. I feel real pain when I make them do something evil. But it depends on how it’s cast, right? If the game teaches you that the evil choice isn’t like blatantly cartoonishly evil, but it’s actually, again, like influence from prior actions taken. It’s within the realm of the character, then yeah, maybe. So in Mass Effect. Again, not a spoiler, really. But there’s this. I forget if it’s in the first or second game, but your Shephard becomes a bit of a celebrity for a variety of reasons. And the like a reporter comes to ask you a question. And Mass Effects introduces these quick-time actions during conversations during the cinematics where, depending on how good or evil you are, they use the term Paragon or Renegade. They appear to you, and if you’re just badass enough to be like on the renegade spectrum. There’s this thing where the reporter is asking a probing question, and you get a renegade QuickTime action. That’s just like, I’m done with this conversation. It’s clearly the evil action. But that’s what the phrase says is like I’m done with this conversation. At this point, Mass Effect is taught to you that what you see in the subtitle and the preview of your choice is not what the character will say. And it’s not cartoonishly evil or cartoonishly bad. It’s in character. So anyway, what happens is like when you click this, like, I’m done with this conversation, I’m opting out of this interview, we’re done here. Your Shephard, just just like sucker punches, the reporter bam, just knocks him out and then walks away. And those are the things like is under those circumstances where, okay, I’ll be a little bit more badass than not because it feels real. But obviously, there are circumstances where you choose the evil action, and they’re like laughing underneath a flashlight. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yes, there’s in some of the games that you’re describing. And I definitely, Man of Medan as well as I think the Call of Cthulhu game. There’s also Wolf Among Us. I don’t know if you’ve ever played that?

    Michael Schofield  

    I have. Excellent. Yeah.

    Tim Broadwater 

    It’s all fairy tales living in the city, and you are the big bad wolf and called BB. And but if you were diligent about talking to people or pursuing leads, or finding out what’s going on, options become available that in conversation and unlock that you can sometimes see, like, crossed out or grayed out, like you don’t know what that option was. And that cues you that you could have missed something. 

    Michael Schofield  

    Those cues and game games are traumatic, and the Telltale Games, especially like The Walking Dead. You say something either hurtful or whatever. And it’s like, Lee will remember this. And you’re like, Oh, shit. I didn’t intend for that at all. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so there’s a sequel to The Wolf Among Us that comes out this year. They did a trailer last year that says it’s coming out in 2021. You know, really, so I played it for the very first time last year when that trailer dropped for two. And then I was just like, a, my nephew kept telling me is like, you’re gonna play it. It’s its own thing. 

    I don’t want to ruin the ending of the story or anything like that. But I was a total asshole badass. I’m bringing you to justice. And yeah, the story really changed based on Okay, you’re an asshole, and this is what the asshole’s story is, you know?

    Michael Schofield  

    That’s funny. Oh my gosh, I hey, I did not know that happened because Wolf Among Us is one of those cult classics that I don’t think played very well. At least in the market. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    When it’s definitely a cult classic. They revealed the trailer for Wolf Among Us 2. So yeah, you should watch it. I don’t want to ruin anything. 

    Michael Schofield  

    You should play Life is Strange, man, if you haven’t.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I think I have, actually. What is it about?

    Michael Schofield  

    You are Max Caulfield, you’re an artsy high school girl in the Pacific Northwest, and lo and behold, you discover that you can wind back time a little bit. Stuff happens, and you navigate through your overly dramatic, like, like school experience in the frame in the framing of like a larger main net, And that has a point. And you can play through, you know, it’s basically the same thing where you pick your actions and do whatever. But if you don’t like it, you can rewind and change and change your actions. And what you see sometimes Is that you get to a point where you die. You took the wrong action. But instead of reloading your checkpoint, it’s through this framework framing of rewinding time to the right point. So it always feels like it doesn’t feel like you died. And now you have to restart over it feels like you died. And now you have to navigate this situation again, but that dying is part of your timeline. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Have you seen Medium? It’s a new game that just came out. It’s called Medium. It’s something that you may like because it is using a kind of psychometry, which is the fact that psychic ability to read objects’ histories or the history of objects that you’re holding, right, as psychic power. Yeah. And then a medium can kind of is kind of not only unfolding their story and discovering some stuff but then also exploring this place and piecing together a mystery. So it’s very story-driven. I think you might like it. And I’ve seen what’s up my alley. Yeah. Yeah, but I imagine a young Michael is very much loved to pick a path book or choose your own adventure. Is that correct? 

    Michael Schofield

    100%.

    Tim Broadwater

    Yeah, so it sounds like it’s kind of up your alley? If so, if you took this narrative, what you’re describing video games, in many ways, is just like choose your own adventure books. Does this also extend to like tabletop games and board games? Are there board games that are story-driven that you really like? Was it something of Dracula or Vlad or something like that? 

    Michael Schofield  

    Fury of Dracula. Yep. This is specifically a game where you’re kind of in like the late Victorian period, and you are playing the roles of Van Helsing and other vampire hunters who must trip chase Dracula around Western Europe. And like you, what’s Dracula doing? Like? Yeah, you know, he’s going from city to city making vampires, you know, doing Dracula shit. But your goal is to find him, and you don’t. It’s not clear where he is. So you have to, it’s very much a mystery detective type of game, where you have a ticking clock. You can fail and become infected yourself. You can just run out of time. And Dracula wins. It’s hard to find, though. If I’m looking at it on like, oh, gosh, I mean, like, you can buy it from Amazon for like, 150 bucks. I didn’t. I couldn’t say it’s worth it. But it’s one of those games that I have that I don’t really have anyone to play with. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Is it story-driven?

    Michael Schofield  

    You are constrained by the narrative that you are chasing Dracula for #reason, and you have like a player card that explains some of your narrative backstories. But it’s about chasing the bloodsucker down and putting driving a stick through his heart. If if you’re good enough, and it’s designed, in a way, I think, to suggest that you’re not.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So the stories that the games no matter what format they’re in, it sounds like largely railroad narratives or for video games, and then, you know, you jamming and a tabletop role-playing games are very aspect you like is the character, the story and that the world exists you know, regardless of the characters in action and then hopefully their actions do intercede or change, but if not, it still goes on.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, the world must be conducive to the narrative, and your narrative must impact the world, and I think those two things together create a Michael drug.

    There we go. I think we can end there.

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the design thinking games podcast to connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim, please go to design thinking games.com where you can request topics, ask questions, or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on.

  • 003: Customization vs. Personalization

    003: Customization vs. Personalization

    Games discussed in episode:

    • Hero Quest
    • Dungeons & Dragons
    • Magic the Gathering
    • Pokemon
    • City of Heroes
    • Monster Hunter

    Introductory Guy  

    Welcome to design thinking games, a fantasy and user experience podcast. Each episode, your podcast hosts, Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield will examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper roleplaying games, live-action games, mobile games, and video games, you can find every episode including this one on your podcatcher of choice. And on the web at design thinking games.com.

    Michael Schofield

    In our first episode, you mentioned something that really piqued my interest. You’d mentioned a game that early in your life gave you the options for the first time for you to identify with a specific character. You had a lilt in your voice about it. I wanted to explore this idea with you about gaming and identity. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    I guess when I kind of think about it, the type of games that I love, or gravitate towards, are games I can bring something creative to it. It’s important for me to just have an enjoyable game that’s fun to play, but what I love about games that I seem to really gravitate towards is when it allows me to create and bring strategy into the game and make my own thing. 

    I think the game that you’re specifically talking about was HeroQuest. That was the first board game that I ever played that is like the training wheels version of Dungeons and Dragons. D&D is super difficult. It has a high learning curve. But it was the first way that I kind of got a taste or exposure to what being a Game Master is like. And it gives you the kind of guidelines that you can follow. And then different scenarios that are triggered by different antecedents, and then the game can go kind of multiple ways. 

    Michael Schofield  

    What about the aspect of creating a character that you inhabit, whether it’s like HeroQuest, D&D, Dragon Age …, how important is that to you?

    Tim Broadwater  

    I guess what’s very important to me is total creativity and control within parameters. So like, I guess what it makes me think of is that HeroQuest gave you parameters. Here are all the minis, here are the maps, here are the stories and the techniques and the spells and stuff. And you can create your own stories, right. And that’s cool. With Dungeons and Dragons, I can choose my race and my classes and my feats and then build out something unique that is for me, so I have a character let’s say who was literally a gnome who is a summoner 

    and she rides her summon into battle and she has a lance, and that’s something that I can customize and specifically build. 

    I guess that’s what I like about Pokemon and Magic the Gathering, right? In Pokemon, I can build a bear team or I can build a poison team. I’ve been playing Pokemon, since Gen 1, and the video game, not the card game not any of the spin-off crap games, but legit Pokemon, and I’ve been transferring my Pokemon from Gameboy to GameBoy Advanced to DS to 3DS to Switch and I have the Pokemon bank, which is I think called Pokemon home now, and I pay a yearly fee to house all my Pokemon because I have a free evolution bird team that’s named after Decepticons. It’s named after Jet Decepticons from Gen one. So like, Skywarp and Thundercracker. I built this team five years ago, and I can still battle today.

    It’s the same with Magic the Gathering. Yes, in tournament play, you’re limited to Type 2 or Type 1, which is like just the last two expansions, right. But essentially the appeal is that you’re a wizard, you’re building your spellbook – which is however you want the deck. The strategy is you’re bringing a spellbook into battle. I still have decks that are my favorite decks that I fight and play against people. And they’re not legal for the type to play, you know, in tournaments. But for friends who play like, hey, all Magic generations work. I have a flying city spellbook that lets me summon walls, make them fly, and make them attack. I can name tons of games that I gravitate to or enjoy, but it’s that it lets me quickly understand the mechanics, understand the fair battlefield or the playground, and the fair physics and balance. And then I can work within that system, within those parameters to make my own thing and try it out. So I don’t know what that is. When you look at Pokemon, I mean, it’s just like, team building and battling. But it’s kind of having that in lack of a better word, constrained sandbox or parameter game to where I can build and create stuff. And I hate Minecraft like, I mean, people say like, Minecraft is like, Oh, it’s great. You can build stuff. And I’m like, it’s work.

    Michael Schofield

    Yeah, man. That was gonna be my next question. I was like, oh, man, you must love Minecraft.

    Tim Broadwater

    No, I totally hate Minecraft.

    Michael Schofield

    Clearly, there is an obvious difference between Magic the Gathering and Minecraft but in the spirit of a loosely defined sandbox where you can do anything, what about Minecraft doesn’t appeal to you?

    Tim Broadwater  

    I get that you can create your own server and you can have friends come on, and you can build and you can battle or you can play the game and fight to fend off death and you can make your own hideout and cool stuff. And it’s like this creative space you log on to that’s kind of like a clubhouse or what a lot of people now use with the Oculus and PlayStation VR – like a VR chat. It’s like a social hangout thing and I’m not about that, I guess. 

    I’m here to kick ass or have a purpose. I want to destroy the other player. I Love Street Fighter and Eternal Champions and Mortal Kombat and we talked about that in previous episodes. So it’s also the layer of competitiveness added to it.

    So having that with Magic the Gathering, you’re fighting another wizard or multiple wizards. With Pokemon, you’re fighting another Pokemon trainer. Even if you applied it to an MMO RPG, like one of my favorite MMO RPGs is —  and I will say is the best superhero MMO RPG that was ever created —  City of Heroes. What was phenomenal about the City of Heroes, is that you had more than any game I’ve ever known in the history of gaming 100% control over your costume. Then you had customizable powers you basically could get like a power set, but you can make it look like whatever you want.

    Essentially, with the combination of your costume, writing your bio and your backstory, which people can see when they click on you in the game, and being able to customize your powers, you literally could make Wolverine you can make, you could make Avatar: The Last Airbender, or you can make your own thing. And so what I loved about that is that the story connects to the costume, which connects to the power, which is completely customizable. And so when you’re in the game, and you see someone who’s created something really cool and unique, and it’s awesome. There’s a kind of respect there.

    The same thing with, characters in tabletop roleplaying games, or Pokemon teams, or even like when we talked about games to where you can control your costumes and build out custom parts and make your characters have combos to where a character can heal, but they can also hide or, you know. I like that kind of that customization. Because that lets me bring not just my creativity but strategy, if that makes sense.

    Michael Schofield

    What is the role of performance as applied to this customization? The way you’re describing to me is that you have complete control in which to demonstrate to other players, whether that’s like whoop their ass, or showing off that character that you built. In the case of something that’s not player versus player or player with player, but like player versus world, something like a Red Dead Redemption, where you have a huge sandbox except you’re not building your own character and there’s nothing performative about it.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I see what you’re saying. I don’t care if it’s collaborative or competitive. In that regard, I do like playing with other people. The board games that I gravitate to the most are quick setup tabletop board games that are collaborative, to where we’re all working together to get a goal, or we all die. There’s a bunch of games out there sure, like Castle Panic, or there’s also Forbidden Desert or Forbidden Island – we aren’t going to get off the island before it sinks. 

    What I would like is, hey, if we’re competing against each other, or we’re collaborating together, that’s fine. I think you need the other people, of course, and that’s something I’m not much into solo games. You can sink hours into it and just explore and have fun, which is like Zelda: Breath of the Wild, Ghost of Tsushima, or Mad Max. It’s just you’re logging into a completely open world and, and doing that, and I like those games. I love the games that allow me to creatively build and, and strategize my character or monster or team or whatever, and then compete against other players or collaborate with other players to accomplish with large goals.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, it’s fundamentally social. And you also know that these other players can also have the exact same powers of customization, the same choices for the most part. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Monster Hunter is very much like this, because Monster Hunter allows you to have so many weapons and so many sets of armor, and then you can give yourself abilities. And you can also build decorations and charms that you put on your armor that gives you special effects. And so you can really make yourself like, I’m gonna make my armor, my weapons and my effects, or charms or decorations all make me max damage, so I can just do more damage to anyone else. Or you can make them to where Oh, well, status effects don’t affect me or don’t stick to me. So I never get knocked unconscious or I never get dizzy, and that’s that open system that operates in the same parameters in which we all kind of the laws that we obey.

    That what I enjoy. And I don’t actually know if there’s a gaming term for it. This is me, my naivety or ignorance here? I know what deck building is. So I can apply there. And then, but I don’t know, like custom battle arenas or MOBAs, or whatever.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, that’s interesting. Yesterday afternoon at work one of our early users expressed interest in being able to customize something they couldn’t. That doesn’t have to be the case: how might we design for a wide variety of customization? Why are the constraints that we designed into like the first build of a thing, even present? Are they necessary? Are they technical constraints? And we admitted that they weren’t. I don’t know what the term for that says, either. It’s some sort of degree of like, wiggle room, right, within the use of a service, whether that services a game that you’re experiencing or some sort of some sort of tool.

    Can we have features that allow us to diverge from the original design? More, I don’t know, it’s kind of like it’s sort of like a user experience version of that Muhammad Ali, quote that, you know, your best plans. All plans are out the window when you get punched in the face or something like that. Yeah. And there’s something about the deliberate design of, if I imagine a game but you know, kind of in our world and app or some other digital service, where you either assume in the build that people are going to use it exactly as you intend. But they don’t. 

    I’ve always been in awe of these games that are fundamentally creative and co-creative. Because yeah, it’s funny, the lack of vocabulary to describe that kind of openness is huge. But I imagine there has to be some industry terms for that, because, you know, they’re not going to do anything for the most part that allows you to break the games, there are real, deliberate design decisions behind letting you customize the powers in City of Heroes, or something like that in a way that keeps it fair and equitable, and technologically feasible. And that is a design, that is a style of design that is suddenly really interesting to me. And to your point, I don’t know how to talk about it.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, you do. I’ve worked for years now in enterprise software applications. And one of the things that we dealt with years ago, and we still, to some degree deal with when we are designing for these giant enterprise software applications, I mean, essentially, all giant enterprise software applications are dashboards and tables, that’s literally, now you’re creating, like off the tables and searching the tables and stuff, you know what I mean? But it’s essentially dashboards, and tables. That’s every single enterprise software application. And the thing that we encountered a lot of the times is that when we would bring here some marketing person, here’s a business analyst, here’s a subject matter expert, here’s an end user, a dev, whoever, and or CEO of the company, we brought them into meetings. They would all argue about, like, what columns of these tables are relevant to them, and what they need. And it’s like, an operator will use this. And it’s like, oh, yeah, but a mechanic will never use it. It’s like, Okay, well, the accountant needs this. And it’s just like, Yeah, but no operator would ever use that.

    So I guess, something that we implemented. And I now we kind of do it all the time, for any kind of software enterprise applications we work on, is that for? Because I think we think it’s, it’s also kind of expected from any user exactly like what you’re saying that there is this level of wiggle room or customization that, you know, in every user kind of expects there to be in the UI, that every table has a pattern that has a gear on it in the top right, essentially. And that when you click on that gear, you just get a flyout of a bunch of things that have checkboxes on them. And those checkboxes literally are the columns, yeah, you know, so you can turn on and turn off whatever columns you want, or you can drag and the columns to reorder them. It sounds so small, and easy, and not a big thing. But I can tell you, I can’t tell you how many meetings I’ve been in, to where we’re just like, we have to be able to fit all 14 columns on the screen. And it’s just like, well, I don’t know what devices your users have. But unless they have a monitor that is 3000 pixels wide, they’re not going to get it and it’s like, well, we need to make the font smaller than or we need to shrink it. And it’s just like, you know, that’s in, and what we’re basically what the user expect, you know, expectation is now is that there is baked into every application, web app, you know, enterprise software application, that you have these, like customization, the basic lowest level of customization and wiggle room that you can afford to your end user, right. So turning on or turning off column rows or reorganizing colored rows. And the only say this is because this is something that kind of always at least once or twice a year comes up. And then we always just now say like, Oh, we have a gear, we’ve just put it on here that we use this pattern from like bootstrapper, or, you know, or material or whatever. So you the user can turn on and turn off the columns. I say one, is that good? Okay, then we can proceed. And that diffuses that conversation.

    Michael Schofield  

    Eventually that degree of customization becomes some sort of like convention if it’s applied everywhere else, right. So your idea, like what you guys do with the tables is frankly would fast I’m going to steal it because we don’t do that with ours. But it’s such a great idea. But it’s probably just because it hasn’t become conventional to this point in the way that being able to skin your character in a video game is, right. It’s almost weird that if you have any kind of avatar in a game that you can’t dress them a certain way. We’re not talking about personalization and in, in the biz, that is something different. It’s usually the personalization of data.

    Tim Broadwater  

    You put your finger right on it, actually, there’s the word is customization versus personalization. Yeah, that’s what it is. I can make it in any video game. Most video games or like take at the beginning, you’re making your character before you give them a name, you can customize what the avatar looks like, right? skin color, hairstyle, clothes, whatever, how wide their nose is how, you know, all that kind of stuff. And I will say out there for bald bearded men like myself, there’s not a lot of outfits. And mostly because I want to make bald bearded men and they don’t ever let you do that in Pokemon. It’s that you always have to be young. And have anyways,

    Michael Schofield

    That totally set your spiky hair.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Exactly. It’s like now I would rather have bald and a nice beard instead of face tattoos or blue hair, you know? So I want to see myself you know, but that is personalization, right? That is not customization. And I think if we kind of look at customization as applied to games, we’ve now reached a time where I think everyone, it doesn’t matter what the app is, with a web app, enterprise software, application, native app, whatever. Everyone expects a light and dark mode now, just because everyone has different preferences and time at times a day, depending on light, you know, you want to see, oh, this would be better with a black background and lighter text or this is better with a light background. And I’ve noticed that that you know, kind of customization is something that people want. And all the time now it’s just, I think it’s because browsers are doing it your phone does it. Google Maps does it now automatically, but you can toggle back and forth because it actually does it, you know, based on the sunset, you know. And your phone does it based on the light and availability. Another customization that I think from the game side is and I mentioned Monster Hunter, because I know that does this but because once they’re going to rise, this came out, and I’m kind of cracked up and playing on it all the time right now. But in general, and all the monster hunters. And this is something that you may be familiar with, I can customize my HUD, I can move around where my health bar is, I can move around where my map is, I can turn things on my head on and off, or it can move them. And that’s something that I think a lot of games are starting to move to because they realize that, hey, I don’t need the map or I don’t want I don’t want it or I want a minimal minimal experience or they’re in gaming. I think more so than the software side. they’ve embraced customization. And now it’s kind of an expectation that I think it’s kind of bleeding over into apps, web apps, enterprise software applications,

    Michael Schofield  

    are we perhaps talking about something that we might call context customization, being the ability to tailor an interface for context. And that context is sometimes external, the time of day, or occupational, I am an operator, not an accountant, or I have many windows on my screen, many tabs open, many, whatever. And we’re not talking about like, because it’s the difference from personalization, which is, I want to see myself in experience . I want your newsletter to greet me with Hi, Michael. Or I want this character to be bald and bearded, like both of us. But what we’re customizing and allowing for and designing for is context. What do you think? Yeah, I think

    Tim Broadwater  

    I guess that makes me think of a couple things. It’s already out there because frameworks habit. And so bootstrap already has built into it a light and dark theme, right? That lets you whenever you’re building your web app or your website or whatever, you can just kind of talk I got them back and forth, they have that built into the framework, a lot of work that we build in my nine to five is they have to work in command center mode, command center mode being like this needs to work on multiple screens, multiple monitors. And so one of the frameworks that we use a lot or adapt or or kind of, there’s many frameworks that do this, don’t get me wrong. 

    But golden layout is one, I’m not sure if you’ve ever, if anyone has, like, checked out the golden layout framework, but the golden layout framework, lets you completely customize your UI, drag and drop stack, it treats everything like tabs, I can pop out those tabs into new windows on two different monitors, I can pop out a group of tabs onto a new monitor. Wow. And I can pop them back in.

    Yeah, it’s pretty slick. It’s a pretty slick, you know, kind of framework. And so I think, I can say that the need is already there. And we’re working with it. And the sign is, if the framework supports it already, then that means that the demand is there, if that makes sense. And I definitely think that it is context because someone who is running a hospital command center where they need, like, they have 20 monitors, right? And they have the I need video feed on the parking lot. So when the ambulances arrive, and on the life flight chopper, I said fly someone in, but I also need a screen that shows breadboards that shows how many people are currently in our er, and how many people are waiting for or and then we can move them around that when Okay, now we have a bed on the floor that’s freed up so we can move someone from er to, you know, normal. That’s a command center, you know, and that requires multiple screens. And so yeah, I think it is kind of context. It’s like people need screens, people need controls, people need that wiggle room to configure what they need. And where I know, we talked in a previous episode about being pissed off with games that don’t let you invert your access. I think that’s just you’re shooting yourself in the foot, you know, kind of at this point if you’re not, because everyone’s kind of expecting that contextual customization.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah. To your point. This sort of context customization is also probably fundamentally interwoven with designing for inclusivity. So the context perhaps being personal, something to do with your abilities at the time. It is as much as occupational. And I think you’re right, I think the expectations either for gamers or users of the internet is one where your ability to customize your context is what I was saying? Yeah, that expectation is growing. This is a snowball, essentially, from almost 10 years ago, if not more – the advent of responsive design, right, where you are designing responsively for the context of the person screen size. And now that has just dovetailed into all sorts of other contexts.

    It’s this unspoken awareness that the user experience does not happen inside a bubble and is impressed upon from all sorts of different aspects of an ecosystem, whether that ecosystem is in like something that you were born with, or a job that you are employed in doing or whatever.

    It requires that ability to adapt the tool that you’ve decided to use to shifting context, and those contexts may actually even change throughout the period of a day or an hour. Maybe you’re in command center mode for x reason for a little bit. And then you have to walk away and use it again on your phone. Right? There are things like this that are fundamentally very interesting.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, I agree. I remember like the response, our CSS, responsive server side, or just a responsive web design, our web, kind of came around. It was like, “Oh, no, all of this is totally affecting the web, and everything will change based on this.” And now when I look at like, oh, it works on different squares. Okay, so now what about if it’s lighter, too? What if it needs to be on 14 squares? You know what if it needs to be, the user needs to adjust this widget or adjust this view because that seemed to be such a big deal back in like 2008 to 2010. Right. And now it’s just like the expectation. It’s more that it needs to work with people and work for them.

    Michael Schofield  

    Command Center mode. I never heard about that before. That is fascinating. I’m going to use this term.

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the design thinking games podcast. To connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim, please go to design thinking games.com where you can request topics, ask questions, or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on