Archives: Episode

  • 030: Is Stray GOTY?

    030: Is Stray GOTY?

    Games Discussed in this episode:

    • 0:53 Stray
    • 5:44 Death Stranding
    • 17:53 Elden Ring
    • 24:24 Horizon Forbidden West
    • 25:41 Splatoons 3
    • 27:09 Tunic
    • 27:36 Evil Dead
    • 27:47 Ghostwire Tokyo
    • 28:06 Bioshock
    • 29:02 Moonlighter
    • 29:15 Cult of the Lamb

    Introductory Guy
    Welcome to design thinking games, a gaming and User Experience podcast. Card-carrying UXers Tim Broadwater and Michael Scofield examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper role-playing games, live-action games, and video games. Play through the backlog on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at DesignThinkingGames.com.

    Michael Schofield
    “Design thinking” is a process that is used to understand users, challenge assumptions, redefine problems, and create innovative solutions. In this podcast, we apply design thinking to gaming.

    Tim Broadwater
    we’re going to talk about Stray. We both beat the game, just out. But then we’ve had some buzz about, like, what are some thoughts here soon are the predictions for Game of the Year awards. And I know we have some feelings about Stray’s gonna get nominated for some awards, or all awards or whatever. But the criticism that the Game of the Year awards gets is because the video gamers only their votes are only 25% or 10%. Of the deciding factor. And so no, you’re like, shut the fuck up, stakeholders, get into your lane. It’s essentially like, you know, this is our award ceremony. We’re awarding it. We do this shit every year. I mean, we definitely want to hear from you. But you know, you’re not the deciding factor. You know, there are many deciding factors. So I know that’s criticism that it gets.

    Michael Schofield
    No, it’s totally right. Like, generally, I’m on the side of the gamers here. But I think, like, here’s my prediction: Stray is going to get a game of the year nominee. I think it has a good chance of winning because its press is Great. There are a lot of great things about it. But I don’t think it’s that high caliber, which I know is against the grain. And so in this case, I’m like, on the side of the academy, you know, like the people who actually know a little thing or two, like fuck the gamers. Right! But no, I mean, it’s, it’s a great game. And it’s like, really, it’s really good.

    Tim Broadwater
    So there are a couple of criteria worth mentioning for Game of the Year. And Stray that pertains, and as relevant, Candidate, there has to be decided before November like the game has to come out before November essentially. That’s one thing. But then, you know, the gameawards.com? Like, if you ask them about you know, why don’t the flat? Why don’t the fans choose 100% Choose, right? I mean, they say there are problems there. And they’re pretty, you know, forthright and opaque about it. That, you know, some games are exclusive to platforms, that’s really not. So well. How can people vote on it if it’s not even available for them, right? So if you’re exclusive to a platform, that’s potentially disadvantageous. And they understand what happened in the election with Reddit, they understand what Facebook does, and so they definitely don’t want socially engineered social media feedback or social socially engineered kind of swayed voting, like manipulation, right? That’s, and they say that, so that’s why we do a plan to vote. You know, that’s why we do it has input from it, but it’s not solely from it. And so, stray, however, is out on every platform.

    Michael Schofield
    Let’s see what we can say. Like, the game has been out for a month. What are you doing? Right now, this is definitely a game that I think you should play. You play as a cat, some three / 400 years into, into some future I don’t know. Earth’s future. And you effectively stumble into this kind of slum world of robots and neon signs and techno and 80s CRT monitors. That is like devoid of. I don’t know if a spoiler out is devoid of human life. We are a cat. And you know what, for whatever reason, like you’re the cat that’s gonna save the day.

    Tim Broadwater
    you’re the Savior.

    Michael Schofield
    Yeah, we talked about the game mechanics we love, and we’re talking about simulations. And this is an excellent cat simulation, you want to scratch on some curtains, you want to lay down and take a nap. You want to knock shit over.

    Tim Broadwater
    — and a bunch of weird spaces. You can take naps where only a cat can?

    Michael Schofield
    Yeah, totally. So um, so it’s a cat simulation. And a really, here’s how I was like, trying to describe it. So, to me, this has strong like walking simulator vibes. Are you familiar with like Gone Home?

    Tim Broadwater
    Oh, yeah. So a lot of people say that. Death Stranding? I played a beat that game. It is definitely a walking simulator. Yeah, it’s the idea.

    Michael Schofield
    You walk around, like, it’s your it’s a cat simulator, walking around and exploring this really cool world. And the story presented to you isn’t. So in your face, there’s a there’s a degree of discovery, you know, if you go and read everything, or discover or run or, you know, remember everything, or walk around enough begins to puzzle together. things that just aren’t, you know, given to you through like exposition, and there is an ending and there’s a and there is there is a climax, but in a way, it’s also just like a cat. That day, like a few days in the life of a cat and like some like really cool setting that you walk around and whether or not it affects the cat’s life deeply at the very end. Like who knows, you’re just you know, like an all all of the all of the day of life of a cat.

    Tim Broadwater
    It’s not just, it is a futuristic sci-fi walking simulator. Where you’re playing a cat, cat-sim, I don’t know if you’ve played Death Stranding. There’s a lot of notes that are very similar. This futuristic synthwave music that is like, holy shit, am I in Blade Runner? Or am I because that’s the music feel. But then also kind of what you hear in Dune, like the soundscapes you know, to where a lot of the sound and just exploring is the story and understanding what happened, right? And it has this I will say, what sticks out to me, it’s like when you watch like a life-affirming movie, something that just like it makes you feel something that it’s maybe sad, but it’s also it’s teaching you something or it’s making you feel something right. I feel that’s kind of where this is. And I guess not to spoil too much about it. But there is this if you ever watched the old sci-fi movie Logan’s Run. And I know I’m talking sci-fi movies here which are like Logan’s Run or like, Blade Runner, but it’s that kind of feel of the game. But you’re a freaking cat dude. And you don’t you can’t like combat per se, but it is this combination of like soundscapes and exploring and discovering and puzzles that pieces together. What I think is actually a very beautiful story that you kind of find out the more you find out the more clues the more information right, the trailer does show that you’re a cat walking around and there are robots.

    Michael Schofield
    Yeah, exactly. Like one of the things that got like, perfect. I realized I might have just punned there – purrfect.

    Tim Broadwater
    You have to do it like Earth Kit

    Michael Schofield
    Purrrrfect. The highlight of my entire experience in this game is really early on whereas a cat, you you bumble around and you find your way you start getting pointed in various directions by these monitors who are are trying to communicate something to you you are being watched through cameras, there’s something in the network that is paying attention to you. And you discover that oh my gosh, it’s this kind of little cute AI that transfers its consciousness to this little drone that’s called B12. Which I’m sure they’re gonna be plushies of and I can’t wait to have one. But you have like this little cute little like drone that gives like hovers around and they give you the 12 gives you this harness and you’re a cat and he puts the harness on you and the cat-like walking like for like the first like 10 seconds is like walking around like dragging its stomach on the ground. Because oh my god, it has a harness on it and it’s just so like uncomfortable. I have an orange tabby. And anytime I tried to put like a harness on him he just like, like lays down immediately or the only way he can can only like belly crawl his way like around they have the cat so perfect. And this was like my favorite moment I like laughed out loud because I just see this in my own orange cat like all this time. But this thing was amazing. I played on PC, and so like you had to, you had different buttons to to right paw, left paw, right paw, to smash things and stuff. And I gotta tell you, it’s a real, it’s real fun being a cat. Like I loved it. I was like, this is everything.

    Tim Broadwater
    I played it on PS five. And you actually did this with a controller left and right. And I actually just sent you an image of all of the cat cosplay that’s already out there and the existence of street racing, and I don’t want to spoil anything. But I would say that not spoiling us saying its future. It’s sci-fi humans, aren’t there robots are and you’re a cat. I don’t feel like that’s spoiling I think that’s kind of almost what the trailer says. You actually in the game? I will say this no spoiler. You don’t know what’s happened to the humans? I mean, you don’t know if they’ve laughed? Or if they’re dead, or if they’ve moved on or left the planet because, like the technology so advanced, but then the technology has been left for hundreds of years, that it’s like, here’s advanced technology that’s been left around for hundreds of years. And so you have no idea you don’t know. You kind of start the game with what is a group of cats called? A litter? Yeah, you get separated from your litter, like very first thing in the game, right? And so you’re kind of trying to get back to your litter, right? And so you don’t know. And so you’re experiencing kind of all this, but you cannot communicate with robots. And so you to your point, you get it kind of like an assistant or companion like a NaVi to your Link or your Cortana to your Master Chief. That is this kind of robot, but this flying little droid. And so you get all the story through your guide the whole time and that, yeah, and I’m dude, I can’t even like it is so I can speak to a PS five, I’m sure it’s just the same on everything. But it’s so beautiful. Like the game is really had like great art direction. And it’s and then the soundscapes and the music. Really good, too. And so I definitely think I’m not sure what awards I would say that it’s up for. But I definitely think it’s in the fact that it’s on every platform. And it’s a cat sim and it’s all the things we described, I think it’s going to be up for something.

    Michael Schofield
    I think the world, every scene was so like, meticulously crafted. So that, again, like this really isn’t like the Stray’s story, right? As you are experiencing the world that these people put together? Well, I bet like they’re just, there’s so many talking points there. Its soundscapes are amazing. The structure of the world makes sense. From you know, from like Midtown to the slums, it being a physical like hierarchy. The fact that they did build these, like giant walled cities, the cities aren’t named, they’re just numbered. They had all this technology clearly at some point, this technology could have been used to leave the planet. That’s something I didn’t even like to think about. It is some 100 years or so or several 100 years since the last human at least. That any of the characters you encounter know of or has been encountered. There’s like some weird kind of like alien creature like down in the especially down in the sewers, whereas I think it was a sewer as well like underground that is like really like grown out like this kind of like biomass. And then of course you got Yeah, I think I think I got all the story there.

    Michael Schofield
    How many clues and memories that you unlock? Because I got 21 out of 27. And I wondered the same thing. I’m like, is this what happened to the humans?

    Michael Schofield
    I think I got about like, 22. And so like, yeah, my like, so I’m kind of interested to, like, hit up youtube or whatever. And look at like, some think pieces.

    Tim Broadwater
    There’s so much I don’t know.

    Michael Schofield
    I’m just left with questions. But these are fun questions. These are fun hypotheticals. Which again, we’ve talked so many times about, like, like, so much of the success of like a great game. We always talk about, you know, the Supermassive Games is kind of like the hallway conversation that happens around them. Elden Ring, too, it becomes like a community event, like talking about all this different kind of stuff, all this different kinds of lore, all these different ones. And Stray really like pushes that button.

    Tim Broadwater
    Elden Ring I almost forgot about it. I could look at Stray, knowing that it came out on all the platforms, and it’s a new game. And Game of the Year has won the gameawards.com has 30 awards. That’s it. 30. Each year, that’s what games are nominated for. So Game of the Year, maybe Stray? I don’t know. But there’s also most anticipated game. I mean, a lot of people I’ve been looking at straight since last year. Well, yeah, it was announced last year, and it was just like, hyped up. There’s also like, best art direction, which I could see Best Indie debut indie game, right? music score, I mean, so these are just some ideas about what it could be. But when I think of this year, and I think of Elden Rings, and I think of Horizon Forbidden West I, to me, those three games like standout the most for like, I don’t know what you think I know one it’s a PlayStation exclusive, which is the Horizon Forbidden West, but it will probably go out like to other platforms that just takes a long time. Stray is on everything. And then I can’t remember what Elden Ring was on was out and ranges PC.

    Michael Schofield
    It’s multi-platform, I think. Yeah. Like so. So. So what does Stray do that’s like truly unique? I think, I think the world who building the art direction, a triple-A, the sound design, triple-A the narrative, triple-A, the hype and the marketing and like being a cat-like amazing, amazing. I think the thing that like fell a little flat for me. And like my only critique of the game, but I think it’s an important piece of the critique is that I got I found myself getting I found it getting repetitive, right, like, like, I found it getting a little I was starting to get a little bored. Like being the cat. I was motivated to see what the end of the story was. But many of the puzzles had the same elements to them, walk around, knock something over, find a little plug, or like a power supply / block thing. The moment to moment of playing the game ran on a little too long. And I feel like I’m probably in the minority there. But like, you know, many of the things I felt like, like I just started seeing the pattern, you know? And then I couldn’t I couldn’t look away from the Matrix. You know, I was like, ah, like, so it just started distracting me, the more I saw it.

    Tim Broadwater
    I actually didn’t experience that I was really pissed off for no map. There were places to where, right? Yeah, so you’re in like, over the course of the game. There are places that you can only go one way for whatever reason being chased or map or whatever story. But essentially, you’re in like three different complex maps three cities zones or three places, right? And then the game actually requires you as a cat to remember where things are. And so my most troubling, the thing that I did that was the most irritating to me is tuck this corner did I go down this hallway, she was already here. And so I spent so much time I I feel like I could probably beat the game in eight hours, instead of 10 or 11. Because some of the maps weren’t that big, but you’re a cat, you’re small. And so and you can climb up on every roof. You can go down every hallway, you can, you can sneak in and stuff. And so I just felt myself like, Dude, give me a map. You know, just, I don’t need you to point me to waypoints of like where things are, but do at least give me a map so I can see where I’m at. But then I realized, like, Dude, you’re a cat, a cat sim wouldn’t have a map. So I don’t know if that was it. I would think it’s intentional. But that was the only thing that I would say, you know.

    Michael Schofield
    If it were intentional. It probably was, I’m sure it was, it forces you to explore, right? And it forces you to see like, the murals on the wall. And it forces you to see like little signs and stuff. But yeah, like, there was a literal plenty of times where I’m like, boop, boop, boop, boop, I go over here because I couldn’t figure it figure out what to do. Like, because like, where I had to go was like, like up a roof and over or something like that. And I just like, I just kept walking around. You’re right, I didn’t even think about some of the things like it really did have the kind of like a reduced HUD and didn’t even have a HUD at all. Right? Sometimes you got to prompt like, you know, like, oh, right mouse left mouse to to CLI .

    Tim Broadwater
    why I enjoyed it and saw it more as like this really fun cat Sam noticed more and listened more because there is no hide, and there is no map

    Tim Broadwater
    don’t know, I had not played Elden Ring. I know, it was so hot. And I don’t know. If it’s, you know how it stacks, so I don’t want to speak to it and say it’s crap or not, you know, I played Horizon Forbidden West, you should start Horizon. By the time you get to the third game. Even if it’s translated over to Xbox was the first one is ideal. It’s worth playing it because it is an ancient futuristic Mass Effect. It’s huge. It’s got this it’s a trilogy, dude, it’s just got this epic quality to it. And halfway through the second one, you’re like, this isn’t gonna be over this game. It’s this big of a trilogy, it’s this big West story. So people are gonna love it. That’s an action sci-fi game. However, I’m not going to, I’m going to also make a prediction, which is here in a couple of weeks. Splatoon 3 drops for for switch. And that is going to be probably the game online game of the year. Just because it is gangster hella fun. It is so enjoyable. And I don’t know how it will not explode. Like just because I’ve played hours and hours and hours of too.

    Michael Schofield
    Yeah, it’s really getting hyped up to like, just like everybody who has a Switch, which is I’m not gonna say everybody that’s but like, lots of Switches out there, man. Like, everyone has good memories of Splatoon like, I never played Splatoon too, but I played a lot of Splatoon one. And that was fine. Like so like, it’s just one of those things where like

    Tim Broadwater
    It’s one of those things where Nintendo doesn’t have a lot of great online games, whereas most other platforms have all on all the games are online, right? However, and I’m not I can say my fanboy. I’m not a fanboy. I’m kind of on the fence with Nintendo to be honest. But when in tendo does come out with online games when it is like Mario Party and it is like Mario Kart 8 Deluxe, or it’s like, Super Smash Brothers or Splatoon 3 like they they get online. Right? And people love it. So I don’t know, what are your thoughts about how Are there any other games that you played this year or no that are coming out at least in the next couple of months to make the deadline that you think

    Michael Schofield
    here’s the hard part. And ever since I joined the PC master race, like I’ve been playing like most of my backlog has been old games. And so like I don’t actually feel more detached from this specific year than I have in a while. So I’ve been playing like I’ve been playing like older games.

    Tim Broadwater
    I will say a shout out to we’ve talked a little bit on the podcast about Tunic. I think tunic is a phenomenal indie game that I recommended to you that it they’d be up for some awards as well. I played it this year. It’s out this year. A lot of people played it. It’s on multiple platforms.

    Michael Schofield
    You said November.

    Tim Broadwater
    And then of course, we’ve played like, we both played vampire blood hunt. But I also know the other things that come to my brain that’s like big releases this year, that Evil Dead game dropped this year, that people like synchronous horror, like a lot. And I’m currently literally one hour and 10 minutes into Ghost Wire Tokyo.

    Michael Schofield
    Oh, how’s that that was on my list

    Tim Broadwater
    It is like this crazy future. But retro Japanese mythology kind of action-adventure game that feels like Bioshock kind of, but it’s got like, Japanese mythology and the undead. And so I don’t know, I’m intrigued though. In one hour, what I’ve played is pretty cool. So I’m just going to keep going. I think it’s the story that’s interesting to me more than anything else. Because I’m not a person who likes first-person shooters. I mean, I actually liked BioShock because it was simple. And I loved the story.

    Michael Schofield
    You thought BioShock simple?

    Tim Broadwater
    Well, I mean, it’s, I guess I think first person shooters are simple. Oh, yeah. But I also know like, there’s another indie game that you shared with me last week Cult of the Lamb.

    Michael Schofield
    Do have you been seeing the press for that recently? Like people are like, hooked on that shit?

    Tim Broadwater
    Yeah, so I love as you know, for like, Moonlighter it was my suggestion for the game for you to play this year. And, and yeah, and lastly, at the end of the season, we’ll talk about it like your experience and playing it. But halfway through you sent me Cult of the Lamb and I’ve been looking at him like, oh, it’s very similar to Moonlighter. Except instead of managing your own shop, you’re managing a cult. And you’re the cult leader. So yeah, so it sounds like what we’ve identified is Stray, Elden Rings, Horizon Forbidden West, and then Cult of the Lamb. Those are the four that were saying. Those are our predictions for like Game of the Year. Is that correct? Maybe tunic. I don’t know. Maybe tunic. But that’s, but that’s more from my side, I guess. Because I liked it.

    Michael Schofield
    Same thing with like, cultivar the lamb-like, like, I don’t know if that’s gonna be one of those things that that make it or if it’s caught our attention, because that’s the kind of shit we pay attention to. But let me tell you, let me tell you, I’m driving. I’m picking up my daughter from like school today; I’ve got NPR on because I’m the kind of parent who, whose windows are down broadcasting my allegiance. And, and they start talking about Cult of the Lamb. And they’re like, there’s like, like, I had, like, it was like, it was like, it was like. Like, there’s like the like, the holy debacle around the new cult, or whatever was like the headline, and turned out to be just like call to the land, the fact that it’s getting like NPR coverage, because you have to go and sacrifice your little cute sheep, you know, like, and I guess like, there’s something where like, oh my gosh, you really want them to like like you so of course you have to like build them outhouses, and you can do all the things, but sometimes serving is just a little too much. So what you could do is give them all magic mushrooms and then sacrifice one of them. And that’s going to make them really worship you.

    Tim Broadwater
    As one does.

    Michael Schofield
    feel like this is like but they said like all of your land or all of your little lambs are individual. So like if one person isn’t high enough, like they might be unsettled by you sacrificing one of their compatriots, and they’ll start like, creating some sort of dissent.

    Michael Schofield
    Thank you so much for listening to design thinking games, the podcast where we apply design thinking to games. I’m not 100% sure how this episode turned out. We went on a ton of different tangents, but I hope you enjoyed it. There are a lot of really cool things coming up in our future the future of the community here like this fall, maybe we some things that we can really talk about super excited about it. We would love for you to give us money through a number of different ways. Perhaps you heard one of our excellent ads, we put a lot of work into making sure that they work and that they convert. We record them ourselves, and they’re really affordable. You can find those at designthinkinggames.com/advertise Or if you wanted to join our many Patreons on Patreon, you could go to Patreon.com/DesignThinkinggames, where you have a backlog of every episode without ads. And I don’t know maybe if we actually get people over there like you’ll have access to some of this really cool stuff we’re talking about in the future. You can find us on all the social media, especially Twitter design DTG games podcast, they’re just look for Design Thinking games, they’re Tiktok, Twitch. We’re trying to have like a relatively reasonable presence. I am not sure why I’m explaining to you to your listener who’s made it this far. We only have like a few more episodes this season. We hope you stick around to the end, they’re going to get crazy good. And then we appreciate you being here.

    Tim Broadwater
    That was good.

    Michael Schofield
    Design Thinking games.

    Introductory Guy
    Thank you for listening to the Design Thinking games podcast. You only have so much time and it means a lot you shared it with us to connect with your hosts Michael or Tim. Visit Design Thinking Games on tick tock twitch and Twitter. DMs are open. You can also check out design thinking games.com where you can request topics, ask questions or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on.

  • 029: Game Mechanics We Love

    029: Game Mechanics We Love

    Games discussed in this episode:

    • 1:33 Stray
    • 2:21 Goat Simulator
    • 2:35 Maneater
    • 4:20 Fly Simulator
    • 7:34 Hell Let Lose
    • 9:40 Battlefield 4
    • 10:39 Friday the 13th
    • 13:14 Dead By Daylight
    • 15:48 Spy Vs. Spy
    • 16:28 Oregon Trail Card Game
    • 16:47 Munchkin
    • 17:33 ROBOT RISE!
    • 19:34 Vampire the Masquerade
    • 24:35 Ticket To Ride
    • 25:57 Settlers of Catan
    • 27:32 Lords of Waterdeep
    • 28:05 Call of Cthulu
    • 30:21 Marvel Superheroes RPG

    Introductory Guy  

    Welcome to Design Thinking Games, a gaming and user experience podcast. Card-carrying UXers, Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield, examine the player experience of board games, pen-and-paper roleplaying games, live-action games, and video games. Play through the backlog on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at DesignThinkingGames.com.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Design thinking is a process used to understand users, challenge assumptions, redefine problems, and create innovative solutions. In this podcast, we apply design thinking to games.

    Michael Schofield  

    Very well. I’m going to be coughing, dude. I think I got it. I think I got I think so. I got like this nasty, dry cough.

    Tim Broadwater  

    My husband has it right now. He tested positive for it Saturday. And I have not had a temperature or tested positive at all. And so I’m literally just here in a blanket because I’m lazy as fuck. 

    Michael Schofield  

    We spend so much time kind of fanboying about just different little snippets from different games. How characters move in various video games, how how much fun it is to like jump from rooftop to rooftop in Blood Hunt, etc. (Or Stray). No spoilers. I’m only a little bit into Stray.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I think a lot of it is like a cat parkour game. You’re running into like jumping up pipes and across roofs.

    Michael Schofield  

    That’s totally up my alley. We should talk about Stray in another episode, but you already kind of like clocked it as a potential Game of the Year nominee. It is getting some fabulous press.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I think it’s the sim mechanic that people love. Now don’t get me wrong. I’m not into like virtual farmer or like anything where I want to run a plow or anything but games that are like the Goat Simulator or Stray where you play a cat or what is the shark one that is really popular?

    Michael Schofield  

    I know what you’re talking about. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Maneater. 

    Michael Schofield  

    I don’t think you start as anything other than as a baby shark. And you gradually grow up, and you become this monstrosity that is really wreaking havoc on the beach. That’s different than Stray. Because like I have to say, I think you clocked it that the appeal of Stray, at least in the trailers, was like, oh, like I get to be a cat. Looks like a real cat. It’s not like a super cartoony cat. Right? And that was 100% draw for me. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    You can nuzzle other cats, and you get to nuzzle against the legs of people. And then you can kind of like purr and then when you purr your, your remote control purse, and the sound comes out of it and then you just basically like being lazy, and you drink water. And it’s just like, oh, this is what playing a cat’s like, you know,

    Michael Schofield

    You’re right. There’s something like super attractive for that.

    Tim Broadwater  

    And the mechanic that I like is just like putting me as a player into forcing me into something I have no experience with. So it Maneater you’re playing a shark, Stray a cat Goat Simulator, you’re literally just running around eating and head butting stuff. So it’s I like the mechanic to where it’s, you know, I’m not, I have no basis of comparison for this. And so you’re putting me into the role of that. And I just get to experience being a cat or a shark or goat, you know,

    Michael Schofield  

    there are kind of like extremes of that there are games. I can’t think of the name of it, where you play a fly, and you have to like survive in the house. That’s a game. Yeah, yeah, it’s a game. So you, you kind of start as a maggot and you like, wiggle around. You flop around as a maggot as you hatch out of your little fly egg, and you’re just kind of wiggling and writhing, and then you sprout wings and oh my gosh, now you’re a little fruit fly, and you’re irritating the shit of the gigantic humans who are just kind of like wandering around this little house. I think your goal is to, you know, land on their food and consume stuff like that and avoid getting obliterated.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I think it’s just called Fly simulator if it’s the one I’m finding on Steam.

    Michael Schofield  

    Inhabiting these sort of like extreme perspective shifts, like, Oh, I’m going to be a cat, and I’m really going to roleplay being a cat. Or I’m going to do this with like a fly. I’ve never seen anyone actually take Goat Simulator seriously, like, all right, I’m like, there’s like, I’m gonna be a goat with a rocket pack. And I’m gonna, like a slide into, like, into different cars and stuff. But I love the idea that someone would play Goat Simulator to like really experience goat them, right? It’s like, Oh, I’m just gonna walk around at a normal pace and eat cans.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Both your and I’s definition of game mechanics. We like maybe wildly different. So like, being put into like a simulation or like that. I like and even like the farming simulator once where you are growing crops and driving tractors. I mean, there’s a simulator. I have a fondness for simulator mechanics and where it’s forcing me into something to do that. I don’t like chores, but like simulating experience, you know, but uh, for you like, what game mechanics? What are you thinking of? That you’re a fan of?

    Michael Schofield  

    I have a list. There are a few different things. But I think I think the idea of like the sim is that it’s role play, right? It’s like, I’m roleplaying as a farmer. I’m gonna play. I’m really, and it’s really good. Roleplay, you know, if you really feel like Commander Shepard and you really feel like, like, Jim Bob Crawdad, who has like plowing his cornfield. So I do like mechanics, I like really kind of like reinforced that, that sim that that, that roleplaying.

    Michael Schofield  

    The video game, I keep getting sucked back into this. Distracting me from all the other stuff that I want to play as Hell Let Loose. It’s a tactical kind of war shooter. Because you can’t win or do well unless you are playing together with a squad that is organized strategically by a commander. And one of the mechanics that I really liked that reinforced that I actually kind of love is how they handle voice chat in there. So this is like a really specific, like mechanics. But the idea, I’ve mentioned it before, is that when you are a member of a squad, you’re just a rifleman. You can chat among your squad. You can be anywhere across the battlefield. It’s not proximity-based, but it’s restricted to your squad. You can talk to your squad leader, but you can’t talk to other squads. Unless you’re like right next to them using proximity chat, you can’t communicate if you’re in the silo.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So it’s the like walkie-talkie mechanic that you’re kind of referring to

    Michael Schofield  

    a mechanic, but the squad leader can talk to their squad, they’re the people that they are leading around, and to the other squad leaders, not to the other squad leader squads, but to the other squad leaders and to the commander. So they’re the commander can only talk to squad leaders and can never talk to any like locals. And what this does is create like a, again, it just sort of like reinforces the roleplay aspect of the hierarchy of it. Like no, like they’re, you know, it’s not democracy you have officers in your game, and the only way to win is to kind of follow them, and the only way they can win is to coordinate with other officers. It’s just like a mechanic that I really like

    Tim Broadwater  

    so what are some games that have that walkie-talkie mechanic? Sounds like there’s more than one.

    Michael Schofield  

    I mean, I think there are a few, so like So let’s compare it with, like, the most popular first-person shooter ever on the planet, like Call of Duty, where I actually don’t know there. There are a lot who do that right even in like, like if we rewind the clock and go all the way back to Battlefield 4. This was a game on the Xbox is an Xbox 360 generation. So PS3, nope, ps4, Xbox 360. Battlefield 4 is like several years ago, and that had a commander mechanic. There was a commander, and then there was like everyone else.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So like, you have like a lot of people logged in. I guess that is what you’re saying. And then, like once a commander, then there’s like several squad leaders and then their squad members.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, so that’s how Hell Let Loose does it, so like you can only talk to people like basically at your scope. And it just requires it just reinforces that thing. So it reinforces the hierarchy, which reinforces the kind of simulation of this kind of like war shooter, the fact that it’s World War Two and it’s using like real battle maps and stuff like that. It’s just kind of, I don’t know, it just makes it feel really good. Again, real it’s this kind of like roleplay aspect. Yeah, so

    Tim Broadwater  

    my only experience with a walkie-talkie mechanic is like the old school Friday the 13th online game, which was a phenomenal game. Everyone loved it. And then, because of the intellectual property lawsuit, they got tangled. It got frozen in court for a while because Friday the 13th, A guy came out basically saying that, hey, I had the idea for Friday the 13th that was stolen, and now there’s a whole franchise and bla bla bla, and they’re like, well prove it in court. And he did prove it in court. And so now Yeah, so now there’s like, that just resolved here recently. And so the people loved the game, but it couldn’t do anymore because everything was frozen up in the court system. But essentially, like a synchronous for eight people go into a game, one is Jason Vorhees. The other seven are camp counselors. The camp counselors can only communicate with one another if they find a walkie-talkie in the game, like find one in a drawer. Oh, that’s hardcore. Yeah, they may have a perk installed that says I want to start with a walkie talkie you know, we’re or like an item attached. But then once you have it, then you can start talking like Hey, I found the park to this generator or like, I’m at the boat, and I’m fixing them, and so that’s really the only familiarity I have with a walkie-talkie kind of mechanic.

    Michael Schofield  

    Restricted communication is really interesting, right? Because I think like most like cars, like most multiplayer like allows you to chat however you want, either through literally like a chat like if you’re playing on the PC or through a literal chat like text chat, or voice over chat or something like that. But I kind of idea like restricted communication really requires you to be more deliberate than the question. So if Vorhees was an earshot, and someone talked to you over the walkie-talkie, can you hear it?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yes. So that’s the thing there is a risk to use where you want it so you can communicate with people to say like, Hey, I found the propeller, I got the gas. Let’s meet at the boat, and then I’ll fix the propeller and put the gas, and we’ll get out of camp. Like you know, we’ll get out of Camp Blood or Crystal Lake or whatever it’s called. Yes, you are right. Once you’re within like so many feet as the killer, you can totally hear someone talking and the replies through the walkie-talkie. And so it’s kind of like you can definitely spoof it and definitely like hey, let’s get on Discord and like a cheat, you know what I mean? And I think that’s cheating. I still think to this day that’s cheating because especially if – in Dead by Daylight, you see that all the time where all the heroes get on like all the survivors get on like Discord, and they’re like, why am I not finding any and how are they getting the generators done so quickly as an as a killer, and then you realize like, oh, man, there’s a discord team together, and that’s

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah

    Tim Broadwater  

    I have a mechanic that I thought of. This is totally unrelated. But this is more for tabletop games, but it’s

    Michael Schofield  

    — those are the only other commit mechanics I even have so great. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    I don’t know what you would call the mechanic. But it’s like using cards like puzzle pieces to where you lay them down and grids and formations. So if you’ve ever played Spy Versus Spy, where you’re building out tunnels, you’re actually putting the cards out. If you play Betrayal at House on the Hill, every time you draw a new room, you’re kind of building out like the map, right? Unknown is like that as well. Tapeworm – Tapeworm’s a great game that also is you’re building out kind of what it looks like on the table even to the point of like Robots Rise or even Bears Versus Babies to where this cards my head this card is my body this case my arms this you know, I love to where you’re building something like with cards.

    Michael Schofield  

    That’s like Munchkin, right? Oregon Trail, the card game which exists, does that where you’re building the trail from, like, one end of the table to the other end of the table as you go?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Oh my God, I didn’t know this game existed. I’ll have to check it out. 

    Michael Schofield  

    Pick it up. Yeah, I’ve never been. I played it many a time. The entire wagon dies. (Oh, wow.) It’s, it’s pretty delightful.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so Munchkin has like cards where you augment cards with other cards like here’s my card, and it’s kind of like Magic the Gathering where you’re just like, Oh, I’m gonna put a weapon on, or there’s an encampment on this land or my player, like, now is a dwarven cleric who wills and acts, you know. And so those are augmented cards. But I mean more so, like where you’re actually just building out the cards under the table. And then that is your map or you this your creature or that is the area that you’re exploring, or the tunnels you’re building or the tapeworms, you’re building or whatever, yeah, and so that’s just I love that mechanic. Robots Rise is a good one. It’s actually really rated decently well, and I played tested at origins a couple years ago. And that’s the one where you’re building robots that have heads, bodies, arms, weapons, legs, but then you can mix and match robot parts to like, kids, but I have a drill, but I also have an arm laser, but you know, just kind of, but that’s how you kind of combat.

    Michael Schofield  

    That’s really cool. It seems like it makes it just much more tactical or tactile. And it’s different than what I think, you know, the conventional like a board game is where it’s static, maybe you move pieces around on top of it. Oregon Trail does a thing that I just say because that’s top of mind because I feel like we play it quite a bit. 

    Michael Schofield  

    it really helps reinforce how daunting the trail is. Because like as you kind of like draw the cards and you discover shit. There’s like a river I have to afford and, and whatever. And gradually, you end up in these kinds of like troughs of civilization where the last outpost you ended up on 10 draws ago, like 10 rounds and go here like, oh, man, we’re running out of everything. And there’s like snakes biting me and stuff, like a die out here. I mean, you could do this with like, dice or whatever. But I love the idea of like, having to visualize the map. Because it’s just, you know, it’s just part of navigating across the wild frontier.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, it’s fun. I see it in a lot of games. A lot of games use it. What other mechanics are you thinking of?

    Michael Schofield  

    I’ve got a bunch. So So I’ve recently like kind of like been. So we’ve talked about how I’ve been kind of a stan for like the old Vampire the Masquerade like way back in the day. And so I’ve been kind of revisiting the new stuff since, you know, since like, all this stuff has come out at like, 20 years since I last like meaningfully played. I bought the new core book. I bought all of these things. And there are things in Vampire the Masquerade that like I really like that I feel like Dungeons and Dragons lacks. And so, as mechanics, they stand out to me because they help reinforce roleplay. And what those are, is that I mean, I’m sure you have experienced being a member of a party, in which you all happen to be at a tavern, all happenstance and the only reason y’all are together is that there’s some cool bounty that you have complementary, complementary skills. But you’re an arbitrary party that happened to be at the right place at the right time. And now you’re expected to —

    Tim Broadwater  

    Organized play basically starts this way every single time.

    Michael Schofield  

    I really liked the roleplay of like d&d, and that’s always bugged me. So like Vampire, the masquerade starts out with different convictions that must be shared among your party, which it calls your coterie, so like we’re going to keep the Bronx safe, is something where like we’re all into that’s like a deep conviction we all have, and then we all have our own individual convictions. But as a mechanic, what these are is that like, as you take actions that violate those convictions, you’re penalized for it. Either you like lose your humanity or something bad happens, or there’s like a cost, but it’s the kind of mechanic that forces a group to work toward the problem together. And this way, the problem is, you know, staying like a cohesive roleplaying party, one person can’t go off and be a murder hobo or something like that.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Oh, no, that’s my favorite.

    Michael Schofield  

    This kind of mechanic I just like it just really like, and I’m like, wow, that seems like it’s very much lacking in like the d&d that I play. And it just stood out to me. It’s new to me. I don’t remember this being a thing. And OWoD, the Old World of Darkness, so the fact that they make that part of character creation is pretty cool.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So is it like So there are things that Dungeons and Dragons, which are you can get more points if you take vices or like an affliction or something like that. But I mean, it sounds like what you’re describing is there’s something that forces party cohesion, or else we all lose our goal, right?

    Michael Schofield  

    Yes. Yeah, exactly.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Kind of like that makes me think of a little bit of like Forbidden Desert or Forbidden Island where it’s like, dude, we are or pandemic, I mean, you kind of have to work together, or we’re all screwed, we’re gonna lose. But it’s not really the negative that you’re taking on. Do you know what I mean? It’s, it’s, as opposed to the agreed upon thing that you’re kind of talking or referencing,

    Michael Schofield  

    You know, we talked about this on our collaborative Games episode, but there are different ways to kind of like reinforce collaboration. And it’s just one of those things that felt like it was missing from like, the, you know, the handful of like, tabletop RPGs. I play like dungeon dragons and Call of Cthulhu that Vampire the Masquerade does, like, pretty, pretty well, man. And so it’s just something that I’m like, Oh, I like this, I’m going to incorporate it. My next thing. I just want everyone. I don’t like arbitrary storylines, and I want people to like, stay on task, you know. And in a big old sandbox RPG, that’s a big ask unless it’s part of the mechanic.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I was actually looking through my board games as well, kind of identifying like, let me just objectively see the things that I got, like gravitate to. And something that I found that I like that I know, we’ve talked about putting it making an episode about it at some point, but that I don’t think we have is totaling games. Like, I really love games that are like Ticket to Ride, where you’re building railroads. But everyone has secret goals and initiatives and things they’re trying to do. Or Lords of Waterdeep, right to where you are vying for control of the city, and you’re sending adventures out. But then, like each, you have your own secret. Every time you complete a quest, you have this thing, and then bam, at the end of the game, you may think you know who’s won. But then when everyone starts to total up, like, oh, no, I completed at least five quests. And that puts you over 100 points. But then someone else is like, Oh, I built the railway from New York all the way to San Francisco. So that gives me 20 points. And so then it’s just like, it’s interesting because you there’s that big reveal, aha math moment, I guess, at the end of the game, and I have a bunch of games that actually are like that. Because I think there’s a fun way of like, okay, this is a quick, fun game that we’re all playing. But then we don’t really know until the end. I mean, we’re all playing the game. And yes, we know we’re competing against one another, but it’s not important until the very end, where it’s like, oh, yeah, okay, you, you were awesome. You completed this three-part quest or this railway to Florida, like Oregon, and then bam, that puts you in the lead to some degree, like, I think Settlers of Catan has that to a little degree, because you’re at the end, like, Oh, this is how many roads This is how many cities I get the longest road. And then the math adds up it’s a little different, like in Catan, of course, but that kind of totaling or secret, like totaling at the end from secret objectives or quests, that’s I kind of I like to have a kid.

    Michael Schofield  

    I find that I find it interesting because I waver on that kind of thing. So my core example of like, of this where I hate it is like in the game of life, right? Where where you see who is going to win by the most money way in advance? Right? Like it depends. They take or whatever,

    Tim Broadwater  

    you know, by who owns all the property, and he’s got the cashback.

    Michael Schofield  

    And so I wonder what it is about “good totaling.” Like, what are the components there? Maybe that’s that there truly are secret objectives, or? 

    Tim Broadwater  

    think you’re right. 

    Michael Schofield  

    But if it’s like all Yeah, if you can forecast it, as soon as you can forecast it, like the joy of that moment, like takes,

    Tim Broadwater  

    you’re right. I mean, there’s some strategy that’s secret that you are just sharing with yourself, which is essential that you know, you are unveiling cards yourself each round that it’s like a train route to build or you are or what quest to go on and Lords of Waterdeep, let’s say, for example, but essentially what you’re trying to do is like, I will get lots of points if I complete this railway, like across the country, but if I don’t complete it, I’ve just spent like a huge part of the game wasting that you know what I mean, working towards that goal. And you’re right, like, there’s some strategy with kicking yourself. But there’s also something that no one else sees except you. You see it.

    Michael Schofield  

    I think that’s, I think that’s the secret component there where it’s good. There’s a mechanic of luck in Call of Cthulhu that I don’t think comes up a lot. In that, every character has a luck stat. It’s like zero out of 100, just like maybe 60/67 or something like this. And the chief reason for this existing is actually kind of boring. It’s like if you fail a role, and you will fail most of your roles and Call of Cthulhu, you can spend luck to achieve success. That’s kind of that’s that sort of math mechanic is fine. But that’s not what I love about it. What I love about luck, of course, like roleplay nature is how to like, like a tabletop RPG, you’ll have somebody say like, they’ll realize, as they descend to the stairwell that oh, man, they should have said that cool thing or Oh, man, they should have picked up the wallet. In a recent, recent episode of like New York by night, one of the characters says, oh, shoot, like I, I drink this dude’s blood in the alley, and I walked away. And then a few scenes later, he’s like, Oh, I wanted to remember or say an event like, gosh, when I did that, I took his wallet, stuff like that. Call of Cthulhu lets you roll luck for that. And it’s just like, Oh if you failed to prepare, luck lets you maybe stumble across like the right thing luck allows you to remember. Oh, in hindsight, yes, I did bring my pistol right or something like that. And each time you roll and rely on luck, it diminishes. Anyway, it’s just like a little mechanic that doesn’t have like a huge impact on the game, but it creates a tiny system around not thinking ahead. And taking advantage of those moments when you realize he should have done something. So again, I just don’t see that it’s kind of like anywhere else. There are all sorts of different groups where you can push, like, push the stats a little bit like, Oh, I’m going to invest superpower into this stat, and you know, spend it, but yeah, so

    Tim Broadwater  

    the Marvel superhero game, like the old school game, has something that’s like this, except it’s called karma. It’s not called luck. And so it’s the Marvel superhero playing game. It lets you create your own characters. Your characters can be mutants or aliens, or altered humans or robots are magical, or, or just tech, like people, you know, no powers. But it has stats, that’s phaser rip, that’s what I always remember from it, because it’s fighting agility, strength, endurance, reason, intuition and psyche, right. And so, you have the first one phase F A S II, kind of equals out whatever you have, those abilities, that kind of dictates your health. But then what you have and reason, intuition and psyche dictate your karma. And so what karma means is that anytime you try to do anything in the game, you have a Karma Pool per character. Now, if you make a supergroup, let’s say you, and I are a dynamic duo, and we’re playing, we share our, our Karma Pool, we pull our pool essentially. And so, if you’re the Fantastic Four, you have an even bigger pool because you’re for people who have a Karma Pool. And then when you’re trying to do like a badass event, like I’m gonna throw this trashcan lid through a window and hit this like robber, and you miss it by like five points, then you can take a little bit from your Karma Pool to make sure it happens. Or if you want to make a critical success, and you’re like, dude, to make this a critical success, I need 15 More points to meet the mountain but then 10 more to put in the next one. You can take 15 points from that Karma Pool and then make it a critical success is like not only do you do that, but then he falls out the window and then lands in a dumpster and or you know, whatever. However, you want to play that. So you can shift you can use your individual Karma Pool or your combined Karma Pool for superheroes or villains to pull off call actions, but it is a limited resource that you only get what’s a pool, and That’s it goes down the pool regenerates like every day or like next adventure like so you don’t have an unlimited pool, you know?

    Michael Schofield  

    That awkward death of the conversation is brought to you by our advertiser. Thank you so much for listening to Design Thinking Games, a podcast about design, thinking and games. If you don’t know what design thinking is, rewind back to the beginning of the episode where we describe it. If you can, help us support help support the podcast by liking starting favoriting on your podcatcher of choice that tells the algorithm in the sky that we are deserving of its good graces. You can always visit our many Patreons on patreon.com/designthinkinggames, where we post things for ad-free, and that’s pretty dope. Or you can just follow us on any of the social media Twitter Twitch Tik Tok. The three T’s t cubed the cool kids call them were Design Thinking Games on all of them. Stay tuned for cool shit that we’re doing in the coming year, as well as additional podcasts and like sooner. This – uh, we both have COVID.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Unconfirmed! You highly suspect, right?

    Michael Schofield  

    This is what we can do. Stay safe. Get jabbed.

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the Design Thinking games podcast. You only have so much time, and it means a lot you shared it with us to connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim. Visit Design Thinking Games on TikTok, twitch and Twitter. DMs are open. You can also check out designthinkinggames.com, where you can request topics, ask questions or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on.

  • 028: Designing Games with Breeze Grigas

    028: Designing Games with Breeze Grigas

    Games discussed in this episode:

    • 1:53 AEGIS Combining Robots
    • 12:15 Magic the Gathering
    • 12:42 Warhammer 40K
    • 20:02 Gloomhaven
    • 23:15 Protospiel

    Introductory Guy
    Welcome to design thinking games, a gaming and User Experience podcast card carrying UXers Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper role-playing games, live-action games and video games. Play through the backlog on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at designthinkinggames.com.

    Tim Broadwater
    Design thinking is a process used to understand users, challenge assumptions, redefine problems and create innovative solutions. In this podcast, we apply design thinking to gaming. Today, we’re joined on design thinking games by Breeze Grigas from Zephyr Workshops. Thank you so much for joining us.

    Breeze Grigas
    Hey, yo, thank you for having me on.

    Tim Broadwater
    We went to P.A.X. East, and we had an intercept where we talked to you candidly about your game studio and A.E.G.I.S. But for those who didn’t listen to that episode, maybe you can speak to really quickly, you know, who you are, the name of your design studio, and then probably the games you’re most proud of.

    Breeze Grigas
    Oh, yeah, absolutely. So my name is Breeze, like the wind, it’s my real name. I am the director at Zephyr workshop. We are a board game development studio based in Washington, although we’re all from Massachusetts. And our flagship sort of game is A.E.G.I.S. Combining Robots. It is a tactics game about having a team of five robots, fighting against your opponent’s team of five robots, and combining smaller robots into bigger robots. And there’s a lot of content in the box that was basically made to be a, you know, a faster, more accessible, more affordable, like, version of like the more popular WarGames in the, in the genre. So we did. We’ve been doing that game for a while. We Kickstarted in 2018. And then we published it. We Kickstarted in 2017 and published it in 2018/2019. We sold through all of it right on time for the pandemic. And then, during that we have been working on a whole bunch of new stuff.

    Tim Broadwater
    Oh, nice. So, um, when I talk to you, or like when we talk to you at P.A.X. East, you are working on the second edition.

    Breeze Grigas
    Yep. So yeah, we are making the first box of A.E.G.I.S. had like 100 playable robots in it. And then we’re doing a second box called Second Ignition, which is its standalone game but is cross-compatible with the first box. So it’s basically like an L.C.G. type model that we’re going for, like a third box or fourth box, and then will you all be able to play all of them on their own? But also, they’ll all be cross-compatible with one another. And that’s what we spent most of the pandemic doing and finishing up. And then we’re going to throw it up on Kickstarter soon, along with reprinting the first game.

    Tim Broadwater
    And so can they work together or separately? Correct.

    Breeze Grigas
    Yeah, they work together. And separately, you can own one without the other. But together, they make each other better.

    Tim Broadwater
    Yeah, I know that I’ve been talking to you. And I’ve been trying to get a hold of this original one. And it’s hard to get a hold of because, you know, you’d have to get it on eBay or Facebook marketplace or something. But I’m glad to hear that you’re also reprinting it. Are you is that going to be rolled up in the Kickstarter as well? Or just kind of will happen?

    Breeze Grigas
    Yeah, that will be rolled up as it’ll all be rolled up in the same Kickstarter. And yeah, no, that’s that was actually news to me. When you said, you couldn’t find a copy. I’m like, no way. There’s always like,

    Michael Schofield
    It’s a good problem to have, though. Yeah.

    Breeze Grigas
    Yeah. The other BoardGameGeek marketplace is empty; eBay’s empty; I couldn’t find any on Amazon, so I guess our game was just like now we’re very hard to find. Collectible status. Yeah.

    Tim Broadwater
    Exclusivity! There you go.

    Breeze Grigas
    Right. It’s still available up on TableTop Sim, though, which is honestly where most of our regular players play it anyway. So that’s always an option.

    Michael Schofield
    Like is the experience dramatically different without, like, the box that says jack full of all those pieces? I imagine that the map is really similar to Tabletop Sim?

    Breeze Grigas
    It’s like it’s better and worse. Like in some areas, it’s never a perfect one. For one thing, the game looks different in tabletop SIM like real life. It has standees button tabletops. And we use tiles because you look at it from the top down. And the tabletop sim helps with setup. We have a bunch of automated things where you can just hit a button, and it’ll poop out a robot team for you. And like it’ll set up the board and take out all appropriate things with like, really quickly. Not that our get a real-life game doesn’t really have that bad of a setup either. But you still have to like hunt and peck for some like your appropriate cards and pieces sometimes. So tabletop sim makes that easier. And then tabletop but then also tabletop sim’s, like playing a board game with oven mitts on, so it makes a little bit longer, more cumbersome so you give and you take

    Tim Broadwater
    I’m a kid of the 80s, and I love Voltron. And, you know, Transformers and combining robots is amazing. I’m kind of wondering about the inspiration for this game. Can you speak to how it came into existence?

    Breeze Grigas
    I used to go to Blockbuster as a kid and rent the same Voltron, Transformers, and like Starvengers VHSes say over and over. And because of that, I do this instead of being a doctor. So yeah, I watched a lot of cartoons, and then that ended up shaping its way into, I guess, my career.

    Tim Broadwater
    Were you going to be a doctor then? (No, not at all, lol).

    Michael Schofield
    I love the idea that there’s a trajectory of how you spent your early days in Blockbuster is what you ended up in your real life.

    Breeze Grigas
    Oh, yeah, no, absolutely. I think that’s how it works. I could have worked on real robots at Boston Dynamics. But then I watched too many cartoons one day, which obviously flung me into the starving artist orbit.

    Tim Broadwater
    Different timeline. That’s how it happens.

    Michael Schofield
    We feel like over the pandemic like there’s been a whole influx of solo people getting into creating their own T.T.R.P.G. this creator space is really getting a flush. My bias was like, oh, yeah, we’re talking to another person. But you kept on saying, Oh, “we we” and “I’m the director,” so, at some point, you formed a team? What’s that Like?

    Breeze Grigas
    Oh, yeah, so it’s my friends and me out of college from this company. If you actually look at, you ever see like the credits for the first A.E.G.I.S. box there’s like 70 people in the credits because there’s the first day just box was in development for like six years because we didn’t know what we’re doing. And so I went through this whole saga, just like on a flight. We self-published it. Then we went through another publisher, and then self-published again, for realsies the second time, and then but yeah, so currently, like, you know, the team’s like, you know, four people, five people. And also not only that, we have like a bunch of new artists I’ve been working with the last couple of years on the new box, too. So, you know, there’s still I do I still do a good vast majority of like, the actual game production stuff. The first box actually did most of the art too. But now I don’t have to do that anymore. So I got to hire artists, and I can just be the art director. But yeah, no, it’s cool. I wish I had more people, and I divvied out my workload better, but it’s also still better than being completely solo. Because that would be utterly impossible to make a game of our scale as one person

    Tim Broadwater
    How long were you kind of interested in gaming, not specifically tabletop board gaming or you know in general, and then can you speak to how does one even How did you even get interested or think about like you couldn’t make a game and started to do it and how did that happen?

    Breeze Grigas
    Well, I went to school. I guess it started like I was in high school. And then I went to I decided I had to go to a game design college because there was a little thing tacked on to the guidance counselor’s wall. And then I applied, and I got in because my college had no standards whatsoever. And then I end up doing really, I end up doing pretty well there. So A.E.G.I.S. actually started as a senior capstone project in my final year of school, or actually the final semester of my final year of school, A.E.G.I.S. was our, like, senior project. And yeah, I wanted to. I guess I’ve always wanted to like make games. I didn’t know, really, I originally went into college to do character art for games, but I always just kind of knew I wanted to make things. So yeah, I went to school, M.I.T. did a screwed around for three and a half years and then made this in the last semester through, like, the product, pretty chaotic process. And then, when I started this game, I actually had very little experience in tabletop gaming. I played magic. And like, you know, I had the No, I knew all the rudimentary is off, you know, mainstream board games. But I did not know anything. Actually, my friend described it to me. He was a big Warhammer enthusiast. So one day, I’m just like, tell me everything. They told me everything about Warhammer. I just need to know how it works. Because we were on this project together. And I was like, Okay, I just need to know what, okay, how does Warhammer work? And he explains that he gets out the way he gets in front of the whiteboard and the audience. Yeah.

    Michael Schofield
    For our audience, how does Warhammer work? And go.

    Breeze Grigas
    not enough time in the day! So yeah, so I came from a background I played. I played lots of handheld strategy games like fire emblem in advance, whereas which are very, very streamlined, single-digit numbers. Everything’s very intuitive. And then I got explained Warhammer, which every there’s like a million different units. You can there’s a bunch of different factions that contain those units. Every unit has its own textbook size, the book that explains how the faction works. And those books change over time. And the actual process of setting up the game and playing the game is like a four-hour process. And I just couldn’t, I couldn’t actually, you know, you measure it all with a ruler. And I actually just couldn’t at that point. I had no familiarity. So I couldn’t even believe what I was hearing. It’s just like, what if I just want to put dudes on a map and move them? And we take turns, and we shoot each other? What is this? What is this? Some arcane process?

    Tim Broadwater
    Warhammer for dummies? Yeah, that’s literally working on life. So you got paired with a person who loved Warhammer. And when you were coming up with a game together, that’s where this conversation kind of came from.

    Breeze Grigas
    I was he was telling me about this. I’m like, Oh, how do I like the entire time like, Hey, how can we streamline this, I can make this simpler and actually be able to, like, you know, make it as an idiot student who didn’t know what they were doing. So that’s where A.E.G.I.S. came from. It just like it all hit me in like, an like a day. It’s just like, thinking about like, what if there are five different types of robot and they could put the different colors of room these five different types of robot together into different combinations? What if you basically just played pretty similarly, from a bird’s eye view to like Fire Emblem or advanced words, you know, simple, small teams, you move back and forth? And so that, it kind of like it kind of came, it kind of came together. The core concepts all came together pretty quickly.

    Tim Broadwater
    I’m assuming it was received. Well, like, did people tell you to like, this is legit, you should publish this or like, for your senior project, or?

    Breeze Grigas
    No, it was not. There’s not a lot of supportiveness. Oh, my God, when you go to a game design school, it’s not that great of a one.

    Michael Schofield
    We’re professional UXers, man. Everyone tells us everything we do sucks.

    Breeze Grigas
    Oh, yeah, no, exactly. So yeah. A lot of people were very disillusioned by the time we were about to graduate. And you know, I was like, hell-bent on actually making a game with this degree that I paid for. So I like I went the very full month into it. And we, we first show, he just decided to throw it together and show it at like some local conventions, and my hand make some copies, like physically and make them like we got dice from here and pieces from here and stuff. And we’d like threw them together and put them in a handmade box, and we brought like 10 copies to like sell it like some really like local Podunk convention and And that was the encouraging part is when we first sold our first couple of copies, like these handmade copies, and then from there, we ramped up, and we made like the next time we went, it was our first time at P.A.X. East. So we made like 100 copies, and we sold them there. And then, from there, we got the attention of a publisher, and we signed on with them. And we kind of like spun our wheels with them for a while. But through working with them, we learned everything about the board game industry, we went to like Gen Con for the first time, and like all these other major conventions we shipped around to, and like the whole process of using InDesign, like Adobe InDesign to like, make our cards instead of manually making everything in Photoshop.

    Tim Broadwater
    mail-merging them. Oh, and templates and all that kind of stuff. Yeah.

    Breeze Grigas
    Oh, yeah. So we went through like a crash. When we were working with our publisher, we went through like a crash course on how to actually functionally make a board game, ship it and market it and stuff like that. So even though like we didn’t end up going through that publisher, ultimately, and publishing the game through them, we learned a lot.

    Tim Broadwater
    So when you sold your first version, like where you kind of build it yourself and add a local con. Like before that? I guess I’m wondering, one thing that we’d like to know, as it relates kind of to the theme of our podcast, is like, how did you handle playtesting? Like, how did you refine the game? Was that all done in school? Or is it a kind of post? You know, have you even after the first version you sold or up to it? I mean, are you always tweaking and testing the game? Can you speak to that?

    Breeze Grigas
    Oh, my. Yeah, no. So when you’re starting, we’re starting out. I guess I didn’t know what we were doing. So you know, ignorance is bliss because you are uninhibited by knowledge. So we, when we first made the game, we put it out, like we made the first little initial copies, you know, that wasn’t played tested. We play, we playtested it, so nothing was theoretically broken. But was it balanced? No, not really. And then we refined it a bunch more by the time we made like the next, like, 100 copies that we would sell at P.A.X., but even those were like, you know, we weren’t, this was not Gloomhaven. So this is not because, like, we were just thinking like, well, if we look at the cards, and we think about how they work, that’s obviously a form of balancing the game. It’s not, don’t do that. So yeah, there was, so we just without worrying about it too much. We just, you know, we made we threw the cards together, we made the rulebook as decent as it could be, and actually very proud of our original rulebook, I made that in Photoshop 40 pages, and we, the game was playable, and decent, and some things were degenerate, and like, our card designs could have looked better, and you know, whatever. But through selling those, we learned stuff. And like a lot of playtesting actually came while we were demoing at events because there’s no better type of testing for your product than showing it to total randos and just having them trying to try it out and play it with you. And you’ll figure out which things are which things work and don’t work very rapidly. And that’s actually where a lot of our agents play testing in general. Got done in subsequent years as we just went to a lot of conventions and, you know, all the way up until three published the actual final version of the game and like 2018. You know, we were adjusting and changing things and refining things based on feedback and questions people had and things like that.

    Tim Broadwater
    Yeah, I think that’s yeah, I guess I’m wondering like, when we are I was at P.A.X., some people were admitted like, Hey, we’re still alpha testing we’re we’re still playtesting that’s why we’re here where other people are like no, we got the game. We’re ready. We want to let people know about it where other people were building hype for like Kickstarters or like back, you know, and so I was kind of curious because it seems to be also like like you said, a great place to where you can you know, actually interact with your players and two birds one stone promote it, but also play test it simultaneously.

    Breeze Grigas
    Yep, and that’s exactly what we were doing a Pax East this year. Like A.E.G.I.S., two is in like a pretty good state because we were playing testing it online all throughout the pandemic, but nothing beats just you go to a convention, and you play the game 100 times, like across four days. So yeah, there’s so we were, you know, we were whipping out the Sharpie and changing numbers and stuff and just really catching things that we hadn’t caught before. Luckily all the core things were still looking pretty good. But ya know that when you when, it comes to just like, really seeing the big picture of like, how will what? What’re your average numbers look like? Is the game length too long or too short? That’s where you really that’s when you can start to really see it when you go to a convention. Yeah,

    Tim Broadwater
    I kind of want to ask because some people, you know, that we kind of talked to you Do it all through Tabletop Simulator. And they’re just like, hey, we had to do over playtesting that way. And then other people go to things like protospiel, which is like a conference for playtesting specifically, and just wondering if you’ve was that part of your strategy?

    Breeze Grigas
    you get different information from different types of playtests. Online play tests are still good for like, measuring. Do my rules work? Are things intuitive, but you don’t really know if your board game works or not until you’re playing it a lot in real life? Because things that are easy and digital might just get lost on you in real life, or vice versa?

    Tim Broadwater
    Setting up a board like you were talking about.

    Breeze Grigas
    Setting up the board. Is it easy to parse something when it’s all displayed in front of you, like on a real physical table? How often are you reaching your arm over people to touch and grab things, you know, things that just don’t matter digitally? Because you can like zoom in and out and things like that. So knowing how usable, like physically usable your game, is, and how long the actual game time is or something, those are things that you can only find out in real life. We try to, you know, you still try to do like both we do a lot of our like intensive balance testing with like our diehard fans on our Discord online, because that’s where we’re gonna get like, the walls of text feedback about why this mechanic should do this instead of that. Pax feedback is actually a lot more like, why are our average games 10 minutes longer than we think they should be? What mechanics are slowing the game down? Is something too complicated? Our Tech’s not doing enough damage is, you know, things like that stuff that you that we really didn’t actually notice until we started throwing it into conventions again at unplugged and East.

    Michael Schofield
    To your point, you know, a better product comes out of observing people use it. And but I’m, I’m kind of curious, I don’t know if I don’t know how many people talk about this. What kind of like emotional gut punch? Is it to receive some sort of like critique or feedback? Or is that not really a? Is that less of a thing? And like the gaming play tests or community that it is? And you know,

    Tim Broadwater
    Yeah, cuz I think in UX, you definitely can something you’re like, Oh my God, I didn’t even consider that. Or like, really, something happens to where you’re like, Oh, and

    Michael Schofield
    one of the things we do with with with my team is like, train them to, like, not get emotionally attached to the critique, right? Because like, it’s, there’s a lot at stake. But we have to train people to like, not get destroyed. Like, like, what’s that? What’s that? Like? What’s that like receiving kind of like negative feedback? Or does it was that negative feedback always couched in a good way? Because the community is good.

    Breeze Grigas
    So it’s so getting negative feedback is actually awesome because the worst kind of feedback is just utter indifference. Oh, yeah, no, if people really feel strongly about something, and I mean, at least gives you something to hone in on to figure out what’s like, you know, what’s going on here. That’s why we don’t get a lot of it, mainly because so we make a niche game. And so people who hate it usually would never sit down to play it, to begin with. Yeah, so it’s like it’s with our game. Our Saturday morning cartoon Robot Game has a filter. So I like to literally filter people out. Where if they don’t want to play this tactical dice rolly Cartoon game, that immediately kind of cuts out a lot of people who would normally not play the game, to begin with. And then from there, we’ll get So it sounds, so it’s interesting, like feedback bias. So yeah, most of the feedback that we’ll get is from people who would like the game and would play the game anyway. But we spoke we do miss out on feedback, more general audience feedback. Like we don’t know why somebody looks at our poster. And like, just doesn’t it just doesn’t register in their brain, and they walked by it, or maybe they don’t like it or something.

    Tim Broadwater
    What’s wrong with you? You don’t like giant robots?

    Michael Schofield
    What? The problem is clearly with you, player!

    Breeze Grigas
    I was gonna say like, we have this big poster that we made for P.A.X. unplugged that has like a million characters all over. It’s very loud and very dense. And it’s almost like it’s like a Kryptonite that chases away people that don’t want to talk to you anyway. So, but yeah, like, if you like, as we try to make the game as, as we try to fulfill the promise that the game shows you with its art, right? So like, if you look at this game, our game is a dense, colorful thing. And so, if you liked the poster, you’ll probably be inclined to enjoy the game. And if you don’t like the poster, you probably won’t like the game.

    Tim Broadwater
    That’s cool to like Mike’s point. So we both do UX in digital products or software, you know, and kind of the podcast is the UX of gaming, or the player experience or P.X. or whatever people want to call it. Right. And it’s interesting to hear you say that, like, the worst feedback you can get is meh. You know, yeah. Oh, yeah. Well, you definitely want to get more than that. But then also, if there are people that are game designers, and we’re putting games out there, but they’re really not getting feedback from players at all. Do you have any thoughts or any thoughts about just the playtesting experience as it relates to that

    Breeze Grigas
    you have to move past being defensive or arguing against people who have feedback on your game because you like the idea that you put in. And it’s also then you also have to like. It also matters what kind of playtesters and feedback you’re getting. I mean, it’s very easy to brush off certain kinds of feedback, even though like, you shouldn’t, like I say, like, if see if I if we, if somebody like sat down, and they’re like, I hate this kind of game, I’m gonna play anyway. Because like, that my friend wants to play it. I’m like, okay, cool. Well, I would still like your feedback at the end regardless. So I can actually get a slight get insight into the mind of somebody who, because when you release a board game, there will be people who don’t like your game, people end up being forced to play it because somebody else wants to play it because that’s just the reality of board games. But I think you should, you should always listen to all feedback. But you should also consider, you have to consider where it’s coming from. Not all feedback is equal. It comes from different perspectives and from different types of players. And you have to still, while taking that into account, you have to also try to remember what your game is. You don’t have to like remodel your whole product to appeal to somebody who probably will never like it. But it’s still really useful to understand how your game is perceived by people.

    Tim Broadwater
    What advice would you give to aspiring game designers? There just seems to be a lot of like sayings or aphorisms or general truths or guidance that people have. And I’m just wondering, what is yours? Like, what would you say to aspiring game designers?

    Breeze Grigas
    If you’re gonna make a board game, there’s really no reason not to just do it. If it’s like the easiest thing to do because you can just take out a bunch of note cards and a pen, bam, five minutes later, you can have a board game that probably sucks, but you can play it. It’s so much easier to do than making apps from an entry point perspective. Or like making video games where you have to like, you know, it could be months or weeks before your stupid thing even turns on. But in board games, you can just jump kind of right into it. And if you have an idea, you can try to get that thing to paper, or you get that you can get that like you can go from brain to paper without too many barriers, and you don’t even need to have. It’s cool if the game has a beginning, middle and end. But if you even just like make one part of it like the core like a mechanic or whatever, just to see if it works. You can just like bust that out and run it back really quickly. So I would just not hesitate. If you want to make a card game or a board game, it’s just you should jump into it. There are lots of resources available to you. There are lots of good Facebook groups. Board Game Design Lab community is where I post in a lot of very active. You should go to conventions to test other people’s games in like various testing areas like Gen Con and origins. There’s always like, the first exposure room or the play of whatever play tests or the unplugged room or whatever playtesting room, you can, that’s a really easy way to get into making more games is play testing other people’s board games, and you can kind of start getting an idea of how what is a prototype look like? How can you ask these other designers questions? The whole board game industry has probably like 1000 people big. So once you start learning things and people, it’s pretty exponential how fast you’ll grow and learn things.

    Tim Broadwater
    Are you able to speak to like, you know, when people when you think that Kickstarter is gonna launch or like, roughly upon time of the year or something

    Breeze Grigas
    as soon as possible. We’re literally at the mode where like, I just need to finish like Kickstarter page. We have the preview page up right now; you can find it. You can find the agencies it’s called A.E.G.I.S. 2 or A.E.G.I.S. Season 2 or A.E.G.I.S. Second Ignition, that’s all the same thing. But you can find it up. If you search for it, we have a couple 100 subscribers on it on the Kickstarter page already. So just go there and hit the remind me button. And then you will get a ding when we click start.

    Tim Broadwater
    I’m already a subscriber because I love games that are six-player games. They’re kind of hard to find. And so it checks off a lot of cool boxes for me and probably for our listeners too. So if people want to learn more about you or get in touch with you, or learn more about the game sort of coming, how would you tell people to get in touch,

    Breeze Grigas
    you can go to our website at Zephyr workshop.com. And the easiest and best way to really follow up with whatever we’re doing is probably just to go into our Discord or follow us on Twitter at Zephyr underscore workshop.

    Michael Schofield
    Well, listener, I hope you enjoyed that episode of design thinking games that we just had with Breeze. If you like the show, like our heart and favorite us and your podcatcher of choice. Specifically, if you’d like more interviews like this, please let us know. Any kind of feedback is appreciated, especially the kind that comes in five-star ratings on Apple podcasts. If you are interested in getting in front of our audience, we have extremely affordable advertisements that we handcraft from the clay of the earth for merely the cost of a fancy coffee. Consider you probably heard one of those advertisements today. Consider that you yourself could have something as epic as one of those advertisers. If you just want to try to give us money and support us for keeping the lights on, we put a lot of work into Design Thinking games patreon.com/design Thinking games is your place to go. We have delightful tiers that are named after the original Wolfenstein classic, Wolfenstein, Wolfenstein. And if you can’t afford it or you don’t want to afford it every other week thereabouts every three weeks, we have a show for you on all the podcatchers of choice. That’s it. Voltron assemble.

    Introductory Guy
    Thank you for listening to the Design Thinking games podcast. You only have so much time, and it means a lot you shared it with us to connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim, and visit Design Thinking games on Tiktok, Twitch, and Twitter. D.M.s. are open. You can also check out design thinking games.com where you can request topics, ask questions or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on.

  • 027: The Quarry

    027: The Quarry

    Games discussed in this episode about Supermassive’s The Quarry: 

    • 1:33 The Quarry
    • 9:23 House of Ashes
    • 10:32 Until Dawn
    • 27:34 The Devil in Me
    • 31:23 Detroit: Become Human
    • 32:22 Little Hope
    • 33:56 Pick-a-Path Book Series

    Introductory Guy  

    Welcome to design thinking games, a gaming and User Experience podcast. Card-carrying UXers Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper role-playing games, live-action games and video games. Play through the backlog on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at designthinkinggames.com.

    We played The Quarry

    Tim Broadwater  

    In the beginning, there were rocks, and then when those rocks were broken up, they became The Quarry.

    Michael Schofield  

    Specifically broken up by Septimus Hackett. That might have been his name. I forget he is something stodgy.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, totally Septimus Hackett

    Michael Schofield  

    We should just preface this entire thing. So those of you who have joined us for this journey on the long haul know that Tim and I really love these as like Superma — I was going to say Supermassive style, but literally made by Supermassive — a choose-your-own-adventure style games. We’ve talked thoroughly about the Dark Pictures Anthology; I think all of them that have come out so far. And a whole bunch of others. The Quarry just released, I think, in the last seven days, like recently in the last —

    Tim Broadwater  

    — a week or two, June 10 is when it dropped.

    Michael Schofield  

    Tim and I have beaten it. We’re probably just going to spoil it real soon.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, I don’t care. We can spoiler cast. I cared before, but I don’t care anymore.

    Michael Schofield  

    We don’t care anymore. Like, it’s like when you lose everything at the end. Like the things you hold dear, I just cast aside. The Quarry is the latest Supermassive game. They made Until Dawn, again, all the Dark Picture Anthologies —

    Tim Broadwater  

    Man and Medan, Little Hope, and House of Ashes.

    What is “The Quarry”?

    Michael Schofield  

    It is a choose-your-own-adventure style of game. The specific mechanics tend to be choosing dialogue and quick-time events. But it is kind of like a master class in branching scripts and Decision trees, what-if scenarios, and the idea is that you know, you are telling helping tell the story or helping narrate the story of often five-plus different characters, and all the choices you make Have, like truly like thoroughly different endings.

    It’s interesting to me that Supermassive – they don’t have a market for this game. Other games are similar; some parts are like interviewee conversation stuff that, you know, I would say that Mass Effect or Horizon Forbidden Dawn have. Similar games like Detroit: Become Human or Wolf Among Us are similar.

    It’s The Wolf Among Us. That’s what it is.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Okay. So then, so that’s, they don’t have the supermarket on its or the market on it or have a stock market on it, or whatever market you want to say. But I will say, when it comes to the feeling that you are in an interactive horror movie, Supermassive has it down, man. 

    And how it works, to some degree, is that you control a cast of players or characters, you can make decision tree conversation choices, which kind of reflect like, is your character an asshole, is he nice, is their love interests, you know, things like that. In addition, as you search the world, you can uncover clues that unlock story paths. If you don’t search and power through the game, many paths are locked and blocked off to you.

    But then, in addition to that, when you’re in the moments of a scary horror film, there are skill checks or quick action checks. And it’s like the combination of you piloting a cast of characters in a horror movie. You choose how you want them to interact and be portrayed and what their personalities are like, and then how much you want to explore it and how you respond to stressful quick actions all sculpt this very specific web that is subjective to you, the player playing at that time, there are multiple different types of evenings, everyone can die. It is possible to come out the end that it ends prematurely. 

    But all of these games have a six to 10-hour cap on them, right? Because it’s like an actual movie that plays out.

    Fixed Camera as a Gameplay Mechanic

    Michael Schofield  

    A miniseries may be right like the ones I forgot about, like when I was going over the mechanics. So what are the game’s mechanics,  make some choices to some dialogue, play some quicktime events? I forgot about wandering around slowly at walking speed. And searching every kind of like nook and cranny. I was thinking about that kind of like a lot as a gameplay mechanic. Because there are like on the surface, there are a couple of reasons. I think that this kind of gameplay can be a little bit obnoxious.

    I think it has a stilted control like old-school Resident Evil, where the camera is like sticking; sometimes, it’s behind the character. But sometimes it’s fixed in place, like in the room, right, and you have to navigate around and like wandering around. But what I’ve decided is that what this makes you do, even if there’s not a whole lot to do, you know, you can wander a little bit off the path and find something like a tarot card, what it makes you do is like really pay close attention to the screen. Because you can’t just walk to the next. You’re not just walking to the next cutscene; you are meticulously walking to the next cutscene, which makes the jumpscare or the horror or the cutscene just that much more impactful. 

    So it’s scripted very much like, like a series, it makes me think of that. Like, you could map this and probably watch this movie mode over like six to 10 hours, and you would be maybe a similar experience to like how some like, like, what is it like The Haunting of Bly Manor on Netflix or Hill House or even like a Stranger Things…

    A Very “Directed” Game

    Tim Broadwater  

    Do you know what the camera angle also makes me think of? It makes me think it’s a director’s choice. Like it is. You know, there are some places where you want the camera behind the character for that suspense, but there are other places where like a horror movie, which is, you know, kind of very much we put the camera in the bushes, and you’re watching the people from afar to create, like, am I being watched, am I but then there are places to where you’re going through a haunting, or creepy kind of stairway or maybe like a cellar and the cameras fixed in a corner so you can kind of get an understanding of space.

    So it’s that director cinematography shot kind of thing.

    Michael Schofield  

    It’s not very artful, isn’t like, you know, the art director had their hand on this entire game. It’s very directed gameplay, which is great. Like, I mean, like, you know, there’s a reason that you and I love these games, right? You know, like, the story is good.

    It feels your own.

    The Narrator puts you at fault

    You feel, you know, we were talking about this with like, the House of Ashes where like the core narrator throughout each of them is this antiquarian or librarian style character that you pointed out is potentially literally the character of death. But he this kind of like —

    Tim Broadwater  

    it’s different, though, from the other two.

    Michael Schofield  

    Well, and then you are backed out with this narrator. You know —

    Tim Broadwater  

    I think narrators are good because it’s used differently in different ones. But yes, like the narrator is a good word.

    Michael Schofield  

    Well, that whole mechanic kind of makes you feel at fault. Like there’s, on the one hand, it’s like, oh, shit, you missed a quicktime event, you broke your leg or something like that. But when you kind of abstract out to the narrator, and you are no longer these other characters, you’re responsible for their fate, which makes your poor choices even more impactful, like, oh, I didn’t break my leg. I broke her leg. Like I’m so sorry.

    Tim Broadwater  

    One thing I’ll say that it’s interesting that Supermassive is doing here is that they have Until Dawn, which came out in 2014 or 2015. And then you have since then, the Dark Anthologies are Dark Picture Anthologies, which is, you know, kind of Man of Medan on a haunted boat, you have Little Hope (haunted town), and then you have House of Ashes (haunted crypt in the Middle East, right? ), and then there’s a fourth one that’s coming out. And we know from talking about it that that is an encapsulated season. They’re calling that season one. And there are already clues in those first three games and how the games are related.

    And so there is a kind of American Horror Story kind of feel where, hey, all of our stories are related. And we all have the same actors portraying the roles. We just have to kind of change it up. However, in those, you’re right, there is the narrator who is kind of like death, and he is the person who is the same as all of Man of Medan.

    However, the difference here is between Until Dawn and with the Quarry. This narrator is a part of the story. They’re not outside.

    The Therapist

    Until Dawn, the entire time between sessions are talking to Dr. Hill. And I know you haven’t played Until Dawn, my but Dr. Hill. This is sorry, spoiler alerts from eight years ago. Essentially, you discover if he is a therapist, and you know that because you’re meeting with him in his office, and he’s talking to you like a therapist does. But you find out, well, maybe not a spoiler, that oh, he is indeed a therapist of one of the people who’s a member of the cast that you’re controlling, and it has not revealed until the very end which he’s talking to and how he’s dealing with all of that right.

    The Fortune Teller

    And so, like in The Quarry, and I will say this, spoiler alerts cut out whatever I on my first playthrough had uncovered the whole story. I know everything that’s going on, I got all of the clues, I got all of the evidence, so there’s nothing to where like it prematurely ended, and I didn’t figure out what was going on. I got the whole story. So I understand — now I had seven counselors die; one of them and then one of them, you know not SPOILER ALERT as something bad happened to one, and only one survived — but the narrator person in The Quarry Who is this fortune teller woman that you are working with I know how she relates to this story. And I know kind of what her ending is, and I know who kind of I am who was talking to her, and I don’t know if how much of the story you uncovered you might have got the whole story to I don’t know.

    What doesn’t kill you ….

    Michael Schofield  

    Well, we should talk about it, like so the Quarry the whole idea of the Quarry right is summer it’s we opened kind of just at summertime the day before? Like, I think like a whole 24 hours before camp starts. The conceit is that —

    Tim Broadwater  

    Camp Hackett’s Quarry, right?

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, Hackett’s Quarry. And what is the motto, Tim?

    Tim Broadwater  

    What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger.

    Michael Schofield  

    Some terrifying like real life like —

    Tim Broadwater  

    Summer camp, bitch. That is summer camp.

    Michael Schofield  

    Exactly you know, of course, like the idea is that like either camp counselors who are going to have like you know, a great summer there’ll be like summer flings you know, they’re the counselors like Oh of course, and so there’s like other kids there.

    Tim Broadwater  

    You control nine camp counselors essentially.

    The Counselors

    Michael Schofield  

    All the kids are absolute dicks, right, because like without like, just like saying okay to authority, like they’ve put everyone in danger including themselves.

    Tim Broadwater  

    But this is I totally understand Jason Voorhees now and why he just fucking goes sees blood and seeds red and kills camp counselors because they’re all shitty. People make the worst decisions. They’re awkward, and then they’re self-serving, and they’re just like teens who are asshole dicks. So the fact that I came out in the end with seven dead counselors and one surviving, I was just like, ah.

    Michael Schofield  

    Which counselor did you make? Did you make it?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Oh, the geeky artist girl is the one who survived.

    Michael Schofield  

    Abigail? Yeah, the geeky artist girl.

    Tim Broadwater  

    And then and everyone else died, so what about you? What was the ending like for you?

    Michael Schofield  

    I came out a little. I want to talk about my journey here so that I can come out with more survivors than you. I found that the way —

    Tim Broadwater  

    You said Abigail in such a way that made it like why she’s dead.

    Michael Schofield  

    Why she like she’s the only one like what happened to like Emma the girl as they survived together in my story.

    Romance

    Tim Broadwater  

    Then I must ask you before you get to your death in the ending, did you have any love?

    Michael Schofield  

    No, not really. (Did you get the gay kiss?). No. I didn’t get the gay kiss.

    Tim Broadwater  

    It’s possible for two gay kisses as well as there’s possibility for a lesbian kiss and a gay kiss. And I think there’s a possibility for like a hetero kiss too. So you had hetero kisses.

    Michael Schofield  

    So let’s talk about romance. Because there are definitely like in my game, there were a few romances they were trying to put up. I was shipping, so one was like Abigail and Nick. I didn’t have a that didn’t have a lot of time to mature. But then there’s also Emma, and I think her name was Emma, Emma and Jacob. Jacob is the jock. They had a summer fling, and Jacob was not ready to let it go. And was like, Hey, man, we had a good time. But she doesn’t seem like a bad person, especially as you go. But it’s a summer fling that she has decided is over. Jacob doesn’t like it.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So you didn’t have the Ryan / Dylan kind of thing I had

    Michael Schofield  

    I had Ryan / Dylan. I was shipping Ryan and Dylan. I never got a kiss, though. But they were always like. I was playing them like that together. But I never got any romance option. I got Abigail and Nick to kiss.

    Tim Broadwater  

    What about Abigail and Emma?

    Michael Schofield  

    No, that wasn’t even an inkling.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I don’t know. Like when you first come on, Abigail, she has pictures in her book that I believe she’s drawing that are literally of Emma. Yeah. Because Emma, and then there’s like, these places where he was trying to push him to like you should get with Thank you chicken with Nick. And it’s kind of like, No, I want to be with you. You know, so I didn’t know.

    Michael Schofield  

    No, I didn’t, as I mean, I should have picked up on that bait. But no, I totally like missed that entire thing. So there was no Abigail / Emma. And I was I really wanted like Caitlin who was like this. Like, I think clearly the most competent person —

    Tim Broadwater  

    She pissed me off so much.

    Michael Schofield  

    But yeah, I was saying she died for me too. And but she doesn’t have any romantic interests you seem to be into like Ryan, but because I was shipping Ryan and Dylan. That was the thing that was going on.

    The Crows

    Tim Broadwater  

    When I first interacted with the crow, and you know, you’re walking around, and you’re like the crow, and you hear it, and then you start looking for it, and then you see them. But because I could interact with the crow. Every time later in the game, when I heard a crow, I’m like, oh shit, this wanted me to look at something or want me to investigate something. And I did because they were they helped me find the reason that I found all of the clues and all the evidence and all the tarot cards is because I was conscious of the sound of the crow because I found out early in the game that I can interact it and it’s funny because I had to shoo it away.

    Michael Schofield  

    The crows were helping. Yeah, because the conceit is like, you know, this lady, this narrator you’re talking to? She has crows everywhere, right? And so like all around her. So I wonder if I will pay attention to my next playthrough because I bet those crows.

    Mother of Crows

    Tim Broadwater  

    Here’s the other thing: when you are talking to her, and you pause the game, it shows her face, and she’s just looking weird. Yeah, when you were not, when you were in the menu system. And you are looking; it’s the crow. You see a crow and not someone’s face. You know how it shows on the pause. You awkwardly look at someone’s face. And it just shows them going like this. And they’re looking back and forth. And then you can go with the pause menu and see read clues and do stuff when you are on her or in menus. You see a crow. So she’s like, I was like, oh, she’s the mother of crows, and she sees through the crow’s eyes, or she’s like they’re doing her bidding or she’s She also helping me because every time a crow, I felt like he was helping me. It’s like, wow, she has been with the crows because she has been leaving me all these clues, cards, evidence, and stuff.

    Michael Schofield  

    That’s fascinating. Yeah, like, my relationship with her was super suspicious. I missed the crows. And so when she’s like, look how much I’ve helped you, I’m like, bitch —

    Tim Broadwater  

    That’s interesting, then yeah, so we had two very different experiences.

    Layers of story

    One of the things that I like about Until Dawn and The Quarry versus the Dark Pictures Anthology is the Dark Pictures Anthology as you go, the story keeps morphing. And it’s like layers of an onion that you’re peeling back, and you’re like, Oh, this isn’t? This isn’t booty pirates. You know, this isn’t just a haunted ship. This isn’t just chemical warfare, you know what I mean? or something, or whatever layers you want for any of the other ones. This one, the story’s the same, the story doesn’t ever really change, you’re just getting like, can you get pieces of the story to know what’s going on. And then, depending on — I don’t think there’s any way to get every single card, piece of evidence, and save everyone on a perfect playthrough. 

    However, I don’t know if that’s even possible without having to like replay and then explore and check. And I’m telling you, man. I look at everything. And of all the available paths, only three paths were not available to me based on the decisions I made. And, and then when I look at the numbers of how many clues I got, and how many pieces of evidence is how many tarot cards, I’m like, Dude, I have to choose those other three paths to be able to get those other cards. So it’s no way there is no way possible. There is no perfect playthrough to do this on a single playthrough. And I think that the fan that I think you get with Dark Pictures Anthology is that there is a perfect playthrough, but here and Until Dawn and The Quarry, I don’t think there is a perfect playthrough. You’re just going to get different stories and different versions.

    Michael Schofield  

    There’s a playthrough where you can get where everyone can. All counselors can survive. I believe there’s a playthrough for that for The Quarry.

    Replayability

    Tim Broadwater  

    Because they’re so subjective to like, what you get and what you experience are very different than when I experienced them.

    Michael Schofield  

    I was going to say it’s like, you know, they have the mechanics that tie you close to the game or suck your attention in like the kind of difficult walking in and kind of like wandering around looking for clues forces you to invest yourself. They have these cool things here. Just in the game itself, but the other like really strong quality here is kind of like a hallway chatter like after you play, during, or when you put when you play the game. The fact that you and I have extremely different experiences here is part of the design of The Quarry, right?

    It does like they put something together that spurns conversation, which I think is key to Supermassive’s success in this space. Like the reason that key they keep on coming back isn’t just because it’s all they can make, right? It’s because these are super successful. So you will, when you beat the game, you unlock an ability to kind of like rewind deaths, which I think is going to be kind of interesting. You can do like three per playthrough. Well, the other thing I want to I’m curious about, and I wish I would have fired up The Quarry before you and I talked because I wanted to see was that after you beat House of Ashes, you can play the other characters’ paths. So like, while you go on there, you go on path A as a character as a specific character in the play through the entire other path. Like what were the players doing who stayed back at camp, you know, what was their path or whatever you can play. And I wonder if The Quarry is designed like that, to I don’t think that was true. And like Man of Medan, Little Hope.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I’m also interested in the movie mode, which is like, yeah, well, movie mode lets you choose to let it run, it’ll be randomly configured and what happens happens. Or you can set up presets like settings, configure it, and let the movie run. And so and then. So all of your, if you think about the gameplay, like okay, take out all the walking, and all the reading, and I’ll be interacting, and you’re just watching the movie. It’s probably a two-hour movie. Like it probably doesn’t take long at all ends, but like the directors already said, like in about the game. It’s like, oh, the movies going to be different every time you play it like there’s no core story that is like, Hey, this is the core movie. We’ll randomly choose stuff every time you watch it, and it’ll be different. Or you can go into settings and say, I want this character to be an asshole or I want this character to be weak or coward and then play them. So I’m interested in like just the movie.

    Still, this is an interesting thing that we didn’t talk about before when we’ve talked about all these previous episodes. I’m super excited for The Devil Within are The Devil Inside or whatever the next I can’t even think of the name of the next Dark Pictures Anthologies which comes out this year, there’s a thing about video gaming.

    And there’s a completionist gamer who’s like, I want to get all the objects, or I want to unlock all the trophies, or I want to complete all the side quests. This game will never be that this game will never you can’t have a perfect playthrough, you will never have a perfect unlock, you’ll never, you know, there will always be tough decisions. And to get them, you have to make, like bad decisions or crazy decisions or so there’s nothing about this that could bug people potentially, or this type of game is that this is not a completionist game, this is not the perfect playthrough this is going to be truly subjective every single time. And there’s never going to be a similar playthrough. And that may not sit well with some gamers, or that’s maybe not the player experience that some people want.

    The Ziegarnik Effect

    Michael Schofield  

    There’s a sort of like a design pattern that you just made me think of that I remember being just kind of like a cornerstone of how I’ve been making apps and stuff in my short time here on this planet. And it’s called the Zeigarnik Effect. It describes the drive or almost like the gravitational pull you feel when you begin a process. But do not finish it. Like web design, the classic example here is one of those forms that that kind of like, it’s like maybe one or two fields long, and then as you engage them, the form expands reveal revealing that it’s ten questions a lot or something like this. But the kind of like pattern of having, say, like a subscription form where you need your name and an email. A user is much more likely to be able to choose to subscribe to a newsletter because it’s only two steps, right, but in two fields that are not.

    But what you can do if you want to capture more, and this is the Ziegarnik Effect in practice, is that you can do it so that once they type in their name, then they type in their email, the next questions to send, and it is unlikely that the user who has already decided to begin the process will abandon the process in the middle of it, they’ll finish it. So one of the things that like as Supermassive does here really well is, I think, was like with this term the Ziegarnik Effect in mind is because it’s deliberately not, you’re not able to there’s no perfect playthrough every and like the ending experience of every single playthrough is one that is going to feel incomplete relies on kind of that, that design pattern to make you want to go back to play it again. Because there is the, there is the promise of completionism over time.

    As you know, you can play Mass Effect like three or four times to get all the endings. You know, how many times does it take to play the chord to get all the endings. And then ultimately, you know, like, just to take this one step further, why other than for funsies would like Supermassive to want to create games that really like rely on this? Well, it’s because the more you replay a game, the more you talk about it, but the less likely you are to like trade it back and like dilute the market.

    Chapter by Chapter Completionism

    Tim Broadwater  

    So I’ve seen Supermassive Games, and maybe they do, and I haven’t done it before. I know that Detroit Being Human lets you do this. Because you could go by chapter by chapter and you could fix it, you could find everything yes and fix it, but I mean you could change your decisions you could find things and then your permanent record or how it’s permanently recorded changes I’m assuming I have you gone back and played any of the House of Ashes games.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, I went back, and I played Man of Medan and Little Hope, and I have not gone back and played, except for one scene where I’m playing as a different person.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Does it fill out the capacity to find all the evidence you get all the cards, you found all the things?

    Michael Schofield  

    You complete the game like when you get all the paths and have all the trophies,, right? But it requires three playthroughs to do, plus.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Or they are playing through each chapter or three chapters.

    Michael Schofield  

    Going through a Little Hope, I chose different things and got a different ending. And I got more things. At that time, the promise of the reward for playing again seemed much smaller. I did not get the sense that the game would be drastically different from the first two playthroughs, and I only had a few collector’s items I was missing, but I just didn’t care to go back through. Now, I think House of Ashes tried to one-up this because, as I said, you can go back and play the same characters with different paths, but then you can play the other characters too. That wasn’t even an option for you in the first playthrough. So again, more playthrough potential there. And I wonder if The Quarry just, you know, did that exponentially on its own too.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Speaking of that Ziegarnik effect you’re talking about, if it does postulate that people remember unfinished or interrupted tasks better than completed ones, I have no desire to get all the trophies and like this certain game or collect all the things in this game. However, I do in the Supermassive Games, I want to know the story, I want to get a better score, I want to find out more about the story, and I do agree with you that I think they do that very well. That the replay value is are they know what they’re doing.

    Michael Schofield  

    It’s like reading a book halfway and then just abandoning it.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Well, it’s like the pick a path book which is kind of like but very complex and different, but it’s to where like when you get a premature ending you want to complete, but you will remember that you did not go open the tree house cellar versus investigating the duffel bag because then you will know not what happened.

    Sign off

    You know, we will be back here in October, man. In October of this year, we will be back to have this discussion again with the Devil In Me.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, I was going to say roll back through our backlog. And listen to our episode about sequels. And while you’re at it, smash that like star heart and favorite this episode on your podcast on your podcatcher of choice that helps us tease the algorithm in the sky to sprinkle its sweet mana all over us. We offer super affordable advertising. You may have heard an excellent ad here earlier in the mid-roll. We compose them ourselves. We make you look good. And it’s super affordable, the costs of like a fancy coffee or a couple of them a week, and you get a custom-made Design Thinking Games advertisement for you. We have a Patreon where we post these things ad-free, and we post them early. You can go to patreon.com/designthinkinggames and run all the social media. Look for us there. You’ll find it; remember, what doesn’t kill you makes you stronger.

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the Design Thinking Games podcast. You only have so much time, and it means a lot you shared it with us. To connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim, visit Design Thinking Games on TikTok, Twitch, and Twitter. DM’s are open. You can also check out design thinkinggames.com where you can request topics, ask questions or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on.

  • 026: Everybody Loves a Hero

    026: Everybody Loves a Hero

    Games mentioned in this episode about heroic tropes:

    • 5:49 Final Fantasy
    • 9:24 Mass Effect
    • 11:18 Legend of Zelda
    • 16:51 Lord of the Rings
    • 17:05 Castlevania
    • 19:04 Metroid
    • 21:10 Halo
    • 22:47 Mega-Man
    • 28:04 Sonic

    Introductory Guy  

    Welcome to design thinking games, a gaming and User Experience podcast card-carrying UXers Tim Broadwater and Michael Scofield examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper role-playing games, live-action games and video games. Play through the backlog on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at designthinkinggames.com.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Very soon, it is going to be Independence Day, July 4, 2022.

    Michael Schofield  

    What a year to celebrate, eh? There’s something fun about it, the fireworks. The bravado is fun, and the mythology around it is fun. And I don’t know, I think it just sort of happened that, Oh, no, July 4 happens to be one of our release days. We saw that it was coming up. And you and I started throwing shit around and stumbled on what I think is a really common explorable trope in storytelling, especially video games. We started this chat going, hoorah.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Specifically, July 4, in the States, is Independence Day. The movie Independence Day came after the holiday. And it commemorates the Declaration of Independence. It has a lot of historical contexts, but it’s become the celebration of victory, right? Not just honoring and celebrating heroes, but the victory of heroes. And so, we’ve started talking about how people love victory and heroes. And, and so I think that’s where we started talking about, wow, there’s something here that this hero trope or the hero, or the underdog and what they have to face. And then this is not just in films and books but in games.

    Michael Schofield  

    We’ve just started to deconstruct some of our favorite Americana. And, we identified a pattern we see throughout games, across all genres, namely that there’s a recipe for this specific heroism where the world is on the brink of destruction. When I think of Independence Day, I think of that time when aliens attacked. Sometimes the world is literally on the brink of destruction. Everything is on the line. And, there’s a, a ragtag chosen few who will make the difference wresting this idea of freedom from some sort of oppressive force or circumstance. 

    And you can name any media out there, from fiction novels to video games, to movies, where there’s sort of an unambiguous choice. The heroes aren’t always great, but you always side with the heroes because they have to save the world. The alternative is no world. And, once we identified that trope, it became pretty fun to cherry-pick all of our favorite games that fit well in there, and we ended up with a hell of a list.

    Tim Broadwater  

    It’s too big for one episode. And so, we were looking at it from exactly what you said, which is what is this recipe well, he said everything’s on the line, the world is on the brink of destruction and, there is a chosen one or a chosen few who can get the job done. And save the world, save mankind, save existence, save sentient life, whatever, right? And it’s always at the stakes are at the highest: freedom, genocide, extinction of life, as we know it, whatever metaphor or trope you want to tie to it.

    Why do people like Lara Croft? Or why do people like Cloud from Final Fantasy? Or why do people like Link from Legend of Zelda? Or Megaman even? So we started looking at, for this to really work in games are not really work because it does work. But what the player experiences from the game side, and I guess we’re really focusing on this episode moreso of video games, not tabletop games, or other games, but from the video game perspective. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    I feel on the part of the player, you’ve put sunken tons of hours and effort into grinding for this epic struggle, and you’ve been attached to the story, which pulls you in, right. And there’s a right cause or a moral cause attached to it. And then with all that story, everything is on the line, and at stake, and you or the player or players you control, when you beat the game, it just is this phenomenal experience.

    Michael Schofield  

    This sort of trope could be applied in a really cheesy way. But of course, the list we started generating is full of examples of where it worked really well. The first component is that the game begins in the shadow of certain death, or there’s impending doom that can be avoided but is always present. Right? It’s always on the horizon. It’s always it’s always there. 

    Under the guise or the under this looming threat, all the other interactions in the game feel a lot sweeter.

    There’s this funny fantasy RPG trope where, oh, no, the world is literally going to end, but first, you need to help make all these deliveries. I think about all of the interactions that feel sweeter because they’re time-limited, or they’re literally gate-capped, but it’s the notion that everything happening here is under threat. And so it makes even these kinds of little potentially it could make these little quests feel better it makes the relationships you form along the way sweeter.

    Tim Broadwater  

    There is this humanizing piece that you’re talking about where, whatever the looming threat is, the evil presence will taint the land. Gannon from Legend of Zelda, yeah. But it is the human or humans, or if it’s an animal, or if it’s an alien species or whatever, but the humanizing effect of working together, collaboration, helping someone, so they will help you building alliances, that’s the building allies and building strengths and tools to, everyone has to pull together, right? To fight this oppression. And sometimes, the hero or the group of heroes facilitates that with small quests, as you call it. 

    Michael Schofield  

    The cadre you alluded to before where is an important component. This existential threat is that it’s big enough to force unlikely alliances. For the first time that the hobbits and dwarves and elves find themselves, on the same side, or, or, or something that, or, the states band together, or, the societies come together, the species come together, but But you’re right, there’s this, this coming together, this unifying aspect of, of maintaining, or, surviving a way of life or a way of being that is really, it’s the embryo in which all the story happens, everyone’s coming together, because, oh, no, this thing on the horizon is really that bad.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, in Zelda, it’s literally the humans and Zelda, or aliens, right. And they combine, and they work across the aisle, or collaboratively with the Zora, the watermark for people, the Gorons, the mountain people and the DEQ, who are the plant or health people, right. And so it takes them not only working together but helping each other or even assisting link with. This item will help you on your quest because we know that Ganon is this evil force that will eventually destroy the forests and the mountains in the seas. And so we will help you, ally with you, and back you because the risk is that great, right? Total Annihilation or total destruction of the world.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, yeah, it’s really interesting. Well, because there’s some aspect of existential threat. We acknowledged the existential threat that unifies forces. This is true, and in a zombie flick, however, I think there has to be, however remote, an element of hope that the existential threat can be overcome.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Exactly. That is completely abandoned, and zombie films, when you’re watching Walking Dead or zombie films, it’s survival. It’s not hope. It’s let’s just try to survive as long as possible. Exactly. That’s always the construct of zombie films or just this automated horror or this virus, it’s just, you’re just trying to we’re not banding together to save mankind. It’s we’re just trying to survive as long as possible. And to me, that is not a hero.

    Sal, Ron, from Lord of the Rings for your fantasy reference, power control, subjugation, slavery, all of these, it’s just core evil, I think of, Dracula, and Castlevania right to where it’s he is spreading evil across the land. He will turn everyone into his vampiric minions or their food. I mean, that is it. And only the bell lots the famous vampire hunting family you can and can enter him.

    Michael Schofield  

    I think you raise a great point, so it’s not only that the existential threat has to be winnable. You have to overcome it because the existential threat is deliberate. There’s nothing deliberate about the zombie horde. It’s a virus that spreads, and you’re screwed, right? But the but Dracula is a deliberate evil. What you said about the Belmonts, though, is that was something that I think works in interestingly, a way that this trope can be made a little bit unique in that it’s not really time-limited. So. So something the Belmonts, you can resist vampiric evil over generations, but I think it’s resisting an existential, a deliberate, intelligent, existential threat. That is a key component if it’s not intelligent. Or if it’s not deliberate if, for whatever reason, you’re fighting capitalism, it’s not the same thing. Right. It’s an existential threat, but there’s no, deliberate subjugation there.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so I think there’s definitely a part to defining what evil is. But then, from the hero side, I think there’s always this underdog aspect, right? You’re just one elf and boy, or you’re just one little hobbit, or you’re just in the case of Metroid to take this genre and apply it to sci-fi Santa Saran. You’re just one female bounty hunter. Yeah, how are you going to save the galaxy? From this alien race Sigourney Weaver-style by killing the metroids, which literally thrive? Their existence is sustained by draining the lifeforce out of every sentient living being so that they cannot be allowed to stand, but how can one person do it? And there always seems to be, how does the Master Chief get empowered? How does Megaman get empowered? How does Samus or link or Lara Croft, I know we even talked about even from a warfare construct, how do Solid Snake and Metal Gear get empowered to be able to save the world from nuclear threat, right? And you have to not only have this crazy backstory and be an underdog, but then you have to, along the way, work with people to get items level up and become the Savior that sentient life or humanity or the galaxy needs.

    Michael Schofield  

    The underdog role is spot on because how did the Colonials overcome the British Empire? To that end, you throw Master Chief, and I often think of Samus and Master Chief, Doom guy, all in the same thing because they are effectively faceless heroes, right? Master Chief one is interesting, though.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I don’t know much, to be honest, about Master Chief. My understanding is that they’ve used some alien tech, but he’s genetically engineered, or he’s a super-soldier like how Captain America is a super-soldier.

    Michael Schofield  

    Somehow, Master Chief is not the underdog. Master Chief is the best of everything. Right? And so there’s something there that’s missing.

    Tim Broadwater  

    He’s a specialist, like Solid Snake is that for Metal Gear. He is literally the best.

    Michael Schofield  

    I guess that’s true. Right? So, maybe it’s the idea of overwhelming force, overwhelming odds, or one of the big narrative elements of master chief that I always liked is the brief tangent on Spartans and then the Halo franchise, but they are engineered there. They’re basically stolen as children genetically engineered, rigorously trained fatally, only a certain percentage even survived the training, data data, augmented with extremely expensive top-of-the-line armor, and, then oftentimes, given, accompanied by artificial intelligence.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I wonder if that’s the Sci-Fi swear because what you just described, Samus Aran is the best bounty hunter in the universe, right? Yeah. And then, for Mass Effect, the Shephard is on a special track to become a secret agent of the galaxy or whatever.

    Michael Schofield  

    I can’t remember the name of it.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, Megaman. Also, from the Sci-Fi perspective, the world is being taken over by giant evil robots from this evil person. And so we’re making a robot savior who, when he destroys robots, can absorb their power and use it for himself. 

    Michael Schofield  

    The threat scales with the hero, right? So even if you have a master chief who survives many encounters that you probably shouldn’t have, it’s still against the overwhelming threat to the entire civilized galaxy. And it’s still a by virtue, it’s still, it’s still an underdog story.

    There’s something that’s more underdog about Shepherd than Master Chief, or even more and more underdog about Mega Man. Right, that I think, I think if we were to model the impact, there’s probably something in that formula about distance, power gulf between the threat and the hero, the further they are apart. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, I think there’s definitely, an underdog. There’s definitely the only hero, but the person who is also so skilled at what they do, they’re the only person who can pull it off. Right. And then I think there’s also this Captain Planet or Avatar The Last Airbender. We have to change people’s minds and hearts. We have to convince different tribes to work together. To understand that this is, we have to fight together against this epic evil. All of them are heroes, all different flavors and genres, maybe in different backstories or specialties or underdogs, or maybe they’re empowered because only the chosen one can pull the Master Sword right from, and that is the one that high rule, the goddess of high roll thinks will save solid defeat Ganon and only lake can do that. And so I think one of the other things we started talking about were different types of heroes, right? Which was the unsung hero versus the chosen one. Versus a bland, a band of plucky adventurers thrown together to try to pull it off.

    Michael Schofield  

    Or a band of Inglorious Bastards? Who aren’t lucky at all, right? So

    Tim Broadwater  

    yeah, we’re the failed hero or the antihero? Batman, dude, Batman is dark AF, right? He is Spawn or the Punisher. And sometimes, the only way you can get the job done is just to be as brutal as the evil force now. Those are not world-changing things, but there’s definitely something to be said about an antihero.

    Michael Schofield  

    How important is it in this trope that you can identify with the hero? Because there are spectrums of ability to identify with, maybe it’s easier to identify. Let’s take a Batman because he has no powers?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, someone who would be branded as evil was a vigilante or someone unsafe, a vampire-werewolf but or something, but we’re a demon or, but does well with our power. So I think people just the thing that we landed upon and the reason why we wanted to talk about this episode, really, it was people love heroes, and I don’t care what type of gamer you are, what type of fandom you support. The hero is something that any player can get behind, right? No matter what form, maybe it’s a brutal antihero, or maybe it’s the fantasy elf who’s the chosen one, or maybe it’s the Sci-Fi space hunter, but it’s people who love a hero. People love to love a hero and also from the player experience side when you’re playing the hero when you’re playing a cloud from Final Fantasy, or you’re playing even a comedy swerve, which would be a Super Mario Brothers or a Sonic or something or Ratchet and Clank something that’s just ridiculous. People love overcoming that evil force or brink of destruction where everything is on the line, and they love that reward, I think, from when they succeed.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yes, they do. If you want to be a hero in someone’s life, consider subscribing to our Patreon at patreon.com/designthinkinggames, where you can help needy card-carrying UXers continue to produce this show every day a card-carrying UXer goes hungry.

    Perhaps you also heard an excellent advertisement at the beginning mid or, or maybe after this at the end of the episode. If you have something to promote to a minded audience, consider advertising with us, and we produce everything ourselves. Are all hosts read? None of them are crappy. We do a lot of work to ensure that you sound great, and we’re super affordable. So you can check that out at design thinking games.com/advertise. And lastly, if you have no bones to throw and you can still star hard favorite, this episode on the air podcatcher of choice. Everything you do to help boost the algorithm brings Design Thinking Games in front of more people. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    And if you’re listening to this and the day it releases, it’s July 4, And you are a United States citizen. Try and enjoy it with friends and family. Have a happy and safe July 4 Independence Day.

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the Design Thinking Games podcast. You only have so much time, and it means a lot you shared it with us to connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim, visit Design Thinking games on TikTok, Twitch, and Twitter. DMs are open. You can also check out designthinkinggames.com, where you can request topics, ask questions or see what else is happening. Until next time, game on.

  • 025: Lonely Hero Games

    025: Lonely Hero Games

    Games mentioned in this episode with Lonely Hero Games:

    • 17:44 Codenames
    • 17:48 5 Minute Mystery
    • 18:21 Bank Heist
    • 18:45 Hungry for Humans

    Introductory Guy  

    Welcome to design thinking games, a gaming and User Experience podcast. Card-carrying UXers Tim Broadwater and Michael Scofield examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper role-playing games, live-action games and video games. Play through the backlog on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at design thinking games.com.

    Jared Kaplan  

    I’m Jared Kaplan. And so, I am one half of Lonely Hero Games. And my day job is in marketing. And I have a marketing business with a business partner where we do web design and social media marketing, those sorts of things. And I also work for a resort where I do all of the web and marketing stuff there.

    Chris Kincaid  

    Well, I’m Chris Kincaid. I’m the other half of Lonely Hero Games. I’m from Beckley, West Virginia, but currently live and work in Morgantown, West Virginia; my wife’s family’s from here. My day job, I’m a family medicine physician. I currently work for WVU and am an associate professor there. Let’s see. That’s pretty much straightforward. I mean, that’s my day job. And every other minute is babies and board games. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    I guess the first thing I would kind of want to know is how did you come up with like Lonely Hero Games. It’s a very unique name. 

    Chris Kincaid  

    Lonely Hero Games, kind of; we tossed around a few names, but we kind of landed on that one a little bit early. I’ll let Jared chime in with any additions here, but pretty much we’re kind of always the way it was presented with me was, whenever you’re playing a game, even if it’s a co-op game, or a team game, or even a video game, it doesn’t really matter. Who else is there? You’re always like, you’re the center of your own movie, you know, you’re always the lonely hero of your own story, regardless of whatever things are going on. And that just kinda kind of fit because also you think about, like, the gamer person is often or at least historically, kind of the nerd or sometimes the outcast. And, and yet, you know, we’d like to create situations where they get to be the hero they get to when they get to be the champion. That’s how it always ranked rang in my head anyway,

    Jared Kaplan  

    we just needed a name, you know, and then this name, I can’t remember like, how it was first set, or whatever, but it was just like, this kind of, is weirdly perfect. You know?

    Tim Broadwater  

    How did you like backstory-wise? How did you two ever meet each other?

    Jared Kaplan  

    Yeah, so we have mutual friends who a close friends of mine and a close friend of Chris’s. They became friends. And then for through them, then we all started getting together as a group to you know, whether it was to watch movies or play games, mostly play games. We all started getting together. And then Chris and I, there was just a couple of times, you know, we just sort of hung out later than the rest of the group, you know, and hit it off and just really formed a nice friendship. And one night, we were having a board game night, and no one showed up but us. And so yeah, we just started talking about a game that I had an idea for. And Chris, you know, was excited about it, and just like, wanted to dig in, and it was just like, okay, cool. And it was just sort of born that night. Not all came together.

    Michael Schofield  

    Did you guys work from any kind of like, playbook or any kind of like blog about how to even start making a game? Or did you just wing it?

    Jared Kaplan  

    Really, I would say no, at least from the beginning. So like, at the very start, it was more of like, Oh, here’s an idea for a game. And I think most people at some point have had an idea for something a lot of people games, a lot of people Wouldn’t this make a cool movie, or a cool book or whatever. And you know, a lot of times I know myself, I’ve had those thoughts. I’ve probably thought of 7000 movies in my head. But this time, you know, when you get together with a person, and you start talking about it, it’s like well, this is like real, we’re putting stuff on paper. And from there, it was just sort of like writing down ideas and how they could work. We didn’t really get into the like how-tos of anything until it came to more of things like production and running a Kickstarter and those sorts of things, but in terms of like designing the game itself, Um, this might be a bad way to do it. But for our first game, we just sort of did it. I mean, I don’t know if Chris remembers that any different. Maybe he can provide some more input on that?

    Chris Kincaid  

    No, I agree we didn’t really take it from, well, let’s research how to make a game point of view, we just said, Well, we play a lot of games, we’re both smart guys, we both have a certain skill set. Let’s, let’s just make one. And that we already had a pool of friends so we could try it out. So as soon as we put together a little rough cut, which was very rough, I’m talking like glued to the backup playing cards, caught two pieces of like eight by 11 printer paper tape together with a board drawn on it, which evolved into a dry erase board. And again, it’s fun because now I got this drawer that has all the evolutions of the game as it came about. But literally, we just played and luckily, like the first two playthroughs, people are like, well, it’s not perfect, but this is a lot of fun. And then you just tweak it till you get it right. And honestly, we were just kind of Blessed there in the beginning, because some of the stuff it’s very hard, you know, in hindsight, trying to make new games and trying to work out the bugs. It just sort of gently happened for that first game. It just worked. And we got it right early. And things just fit. And then all we had to do was show it to people. And that’s where he said, you know, we kind of researched. Okay, well, we should show it to friends, and they like it. Now let’s show it to strangers. And okay, they liked it too. And one of the great things about our first game was that everybody enjoyed playing it, even if it’s not your type of game.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I love the fact that you’re like, hey, we kept it to friends. And your metric was they enjoyed it. And so when you started showing it to strangers, what was how did you show it to strangers? What strangers?

    Chris Kincaid  

    Well, there’s a game store in Beckley that’s, we kind of knew the owner of, and we asked him if we could demo it there. And that was our first one with real strangers, like, we demoed it earlier than that with people who don’t necessarily play games, but we knew so they’re always nice to us, you know. But when we sat down and explained it with strangers, which was really more of a test of the rulebook, because we were confident in the game for a lot of it, but they liked it, they were having fun. And the best part of watching that is when the game when we’re no longer involved in the game takes over. Like, they’re laughing and joking. And in our game, it’s a social deception game. So they’re like calling each other out. And it’s getting a little heated in places, but people are laughing. We actually also got a few play tests, like books, a million and a few other just random places you wouldn’t necessarily expect.

    Tim Broadwater  

    What other places apart from Books a Million?

    Chris Kincaid  

    some random people invited us. I had a teacher friend who really liked that we were doing anything like that. And she invited us over and had a whole bunch of hurt while invited us over to show the game and had a whole bunch of her teacher people over. I knew none of them but her. And some of them were in the games, and some of them were just friends. And they kind of took it and ran with it. That was at my personal home. So just a bunch of stuff kind of like that occurred that there might be others that Jared can think of.

    Jared Kaplan  

    Yeah, I would say the only other one that comes to mind initially would be a convention that a convention is normally a good place to do this kind of thing. But it was what’s called casa con, and it’s in Beckley. And it’s not a board game convention by any means. They do have a small tabletop gaming room. But we were the only game, you know, aspiring game designers at the convention. But that was like our first like, setting it down in front of just like the masses, so to speak. When I say the masses, we’re talking like several 100 People, not like 1000s and 1000s, but anywho just random people who would approach us and ask about it. And then we did some demos in that gaming room. And that was like the first realization of I think of how to present ourselves to the general public if that’s if that makes sense how to market ourselves in our game and, and get feedback. And, you know, I mean, it’s not like every person that sat down with us had the time of their life. And those experiences are the first time where you learn the first part of okay, who is our audience? And then you sort of have to break it down. We’ll further and understand like, Okay, who do we think is actually, yes, they are our audience, but they’re not having a good time, because there’s going to be those people who are never going to have a good time, no matter how good your game is. And then there’s going to be those people that should be in there or not. And so those are the ones to focus on in terms of what can we be doing better. And that was like the first learning experience with that kind of thing.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So like, you listen to stuff that user says, or the player says, and you have to, can you speak to like, Well, I think you spoke to a, but it’s like, some stuff, you’re very focused on the people like, they want to like the game. But that’s your improvement metrics right there. And then there are other people who are, I’m assuming if you’re talking about hundreds of people like you’re showing it to and demoing at a con, there’s just people were like me, and kind of keep walking by or may say something. And you have to know how to say that. That’s not really; we’ll take that suggestion and put it in file 13 or whatever.

    Jared Kaplan  

     So like before, before getting into all of this, like, you know, by personally, you know, I liked games. And I like playing. I wasn’t super deep into the community, so to speak. And so I didn’t realize that it was kind of those, you know, different factions of the community that like different types of games would just like, oh, everyone loves all games, no, people are not gonna lose, you know, some, I might like, heavy, you know, this type of game worker placement area control, they’re not going to like social production. I was calling our game a party game for a long time when we were first getting into it. And I learned fast to just remove that word because so many people that did end up liking our game. They did not like the genre of party games. It’s sort of a turn-off. But to me, I just thought of it as a party game because people are laughing and having fun. But it really just, we needed to focus it down into this is a social deduction game. And so, a lot of times, we don’t want to waste someone’s time. And our time is valuable, too. So it’s better for us to be upfront about the type of game. Well, this is a social deduction game. Do you like those types of games? And if they’re just sort of like, I’m not really, or, you know, then we kind of let them go. Or if they mentioned one that they liked, and we can kind of build from there?

    Michael Schofield  

    Have you done any kind of like, like, the purity of just being able to say, like, this is the type of game it is, and go find those people? Is feel foreign? To me, in my line of work? And like, like, did you ever do any? Did you ever have to do with any of your games, any kind of like, product-market fit? So it’s this type of game, but we noticed that there just aren’t enough people in that niche. So we’re going to change it into a different type of game. Where have you been, unencumbered from that?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Figure these like an elevator pitch, right? Like, you have to be able to deliver it in a small time as well.

    Chris Kincaid  

    Yeah, boy, we’ve gotten good at that. At cons, because you have people walking by the table, and you just give them like the, there are definitely people you look at and who kind of walked by the table, they only need the 32nd pitch. But there are other people you’re like, Okay, this guy is definitely really on board. He gets a four-minute pitch, you know. But, so two things with what you asked there first, you can’t please everybody with every game. So if you sit down to it’s better to make a good social deduction game and sell it to people who want to play social deduction games than to try to make it broader. And hey, this is a sort of a social deduction game with this because a lot of times, you compromise what you set out to do if you try to please everybody. So kind of like you’d said, you just target your audience, which is why we demo this game in the deception room at origins. So that’s a rim, basically a floor essentially, a big ballroom where all they play in their social deduction games. So people go around from table to table every few hours playing a different one. And all those people love those. That’s the core audience. There’s no playing with them. It’s very different than playing with strangers because they’re there for that. Whereas when you’re at a different type of con or an open gaming area, and kind of got to sell it a little different, and a lot of people because the social deduction is not a huge genre. A lot of people like that. They’ve just never experienced it before. And some people do, I mean, there’s been people who’ve sat down, and obviously, you can tell, this isn’t going to be the game for their Thanksgiving. But there are others who we, you know, we’ve been going to these cons now for a few years, and they’ll come back and be like, Hey, I love you guys. We bought this game two years ago. It’s our Thanksgiving game. It’s our Christmas game. Our whole family loves it. You know, my my, my aunt chloroformed my grandfather last time we played it. We all thought it was hilarious. With that, so yeah, I think it’s better to make the game you’re trying to make and make it good as opposed to trying to fit everybody’s needs niche.

    Tim Broadwater  

    yeah, I can see how understanding the terminology and being able to say, because I mean, I feel like gamers are pretty sharp, especially if you can say this is a social deduction game. It’s also a card drafting game, or this is a social deduction. And if you’re calling it a party game, everyone’s like, spit on that. I love this negative connotation for party games. And like, I think games like code names, or like, even I’m not sure if you’ve played like, five-minute mystery, which is kind of the after five-minute dungeon. Very cool. But I think the negative connotation there is that it’s just like, oh, this is for clubs, like party games or for clubs. Okay, what games have you published? What do you got out there currently?

    Jared Kaplan  

    So we do have two games. So we’re relatively new. We just started doing this in 2019. Our first game, which we’ve been talking about for a while here, was Bank Heist, which is out in the world. It’s in some stores in some neighboring states to us. And it’s available for order online. We had a Kickstarter for it back in 2019. And that is a social deduction game. The second game we just funded last fall. It’s called Hungry for Humans. That’s a totally different genre of game. That one’s more of a push-your-luck, two to five-player game versus the five to eight-player in Bank Heist. But in this game, it’s more of a take that / push your luck kind of thing. That involves cryptids and food from West Virginia, and it kind of honors our home state that way; we had a really great artist named Liz Pavelavec, who did all the artwork for it. She does a lot of things around the state. So we were lucky to work with her on that. And that one is going to be actually it’s on a boat and just went through the Panama Canal. So we should have those games with us. We hope within the next three weeks or so. To get stuck in a port, but we feel pretty good about getting those sent. But yeah, so those are the two games Bank Heist, a social deduction game, and Hungry for Humans. Which is a push your luck, take that style card game.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I’m excited about it. I backed it on Kickstarter. It looks amazing. 

    Jared Kaplan  

    Thank you. Thank you so much.

    Tim Broadwater  

    And then you’re saying anyone can order Bank Heist, like from the web or is it on a throughput?

    Jared Kaplan  

    On our website, lonely hero games.com, you can actually order both games, Bank Heist would ship, you know, within a day, and then the Hungry for Humans will ship as soon as we get them in. And we think that’s like set here in the next three weeks or so. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    I’m kind of curious about that distribution. When you said okay, to the state versus like surrounding states, any rationale for that specifically?

    Chris Kincaid  

    it’s just the whole point of having this company. We could approach other companies and pitch our games to them and have them publish them. But, my partner’s always been really good to kind of keeping our focus in that we’re not just trying to create games, we’re trying to create something larger. And though it’s not going to be super fast and super huge. But if we keep putting out quality games, one right after another, eventually we’re gonna have a large catalog and a company to be proud of. Literally, we were door-to-door salesmen when it came to the brick-and-mortar stores. I take a bag of games and go into a store and say, Hey, I pitch it to them. A lot of them were bought, so we have them in Pennsylvania has three or four locations. Pittsburgh, Morgantown, Maryland, and Northern Virginia, there’s there was a store in New York that bought a few games. So it’s just kind of nice. And then what we do is we always try to be good business people as well. So we’ll advertise their store on our website and try to promote them on our social media. And Jared is a marketing wizard. Just like with Hungry for Humans, you know, getting local restaurants involved, and then their food item is on our card. And it’s like, you know, it’s West Virginia pictures on the box, West Virginia cryptids in the game, and then West Virginia restaurants with West Virginia Food. When you’re from West Virginia, it’s easy because, like, you know, we don’t have a major sports team. We don’t have a whole lot of national something to be the, you know, super proud of sometimes, so literally will say, oh, we hear all the time, “Oh, you guys make board games, and you’re from here? Well, that’s cool.” And then people are just excited to interview us or show our stuff off, and then We try to always return the favor for small businesses and such.

    Jared Kaplan  

    And I would say on the whole like distribution side of it. The other thing that is kind of key for us is just the size of our business and, and the number of games like Bank Heist, our initial run on that’s 1000 games. And so if we’re throwing that on Amazon, like, it’s possible that we’d sell them, but it’s like, what, at what margin and that kind of thing. And it’s, it’s almost better too, because we know we’ll get through these games at some point. But this is gonna sound kind of strange, maybe, but there’s also there’s like the quality of sale. And like, if you sell someone in person when you don’t have that many. And they remember you, they remember your company, they remember the experience, selling them in person and that sort of thing. It goes a long way towards building our brand long term. And, and like I said, you when you don’t have that many games, and you’re dealing with board games, you’re already dealing with like razor-thin margins. It’s just better if you’re able to, but if you go through a distributor, and then when it goes to wholesale, and all those things, like there, are percentages that just keep getting cut down further and further. And this is not something that’s making us money already. So we definitely didn’t want to put ourselves in a position where we’re losing money doing it.

    Tim Broadwater  

    A lot of people would love to get into hame and game designs, right. And then a lot of people have, like, I don’t even know where to start. Or I can understand how to get playtesters online, or I can connect with communities. And I can build a version of it in Tabletop Simulator. And I’m sure you’ve heard kind of all these things. But more so, I want to focus on. If you had to give one piece of advice, or, you know, to anyone who’s wanting to get in kind of game design, anyone who’s where you were X amount of years ago, what’s the advice that you would share with people who are wanting to design their own games?

    Jared Kaplan  

    the first thing is just sort of like an inner belief. Like, it’s, firstly, I think you just need to understand that it’s possible. And it’s not like, you know, it’s easy to get into that mindset that like making games or making anything for that matter, is like a world reserved for a special few. It’s not. It’s something that is possible if you’re willing to put the time in. And frankly, like, it’s not the kind of time where you have to like drop everything and like give up your job and like neglect your family and that sort of thing. It’s, it’s just, you know, those new hours a week even. So, it’s just first understanding, it’s possible being willing to put some time into it in keeping up with the time and not just like a few hours every six months, but like, you know, weekly, you know, you’re putting something into it. But then more of like an actual action outside of like the belief part of it is connecting. We’re blessed in this day and age to have these online communities in places where people are willing to share their knowledge for free. It’s, it was the most amazing thing to me to find these groups when we first got into this, especially for like the Kickstarter side of it, where I could go in and drop a question about how to approach something on Kickstarter. And within an hour, I had seven to eight people telling me seven to eight good things, you know, so I think it is finding your community. And then be willing to ask questions and not be afraid to look like you don’t know because you don’t, and people don’t care that you don’t know. That’s why they’re there to tell you, you know, give you the information you seek. So, yes, I would say join a community, an online community, a Facebook group, or, you know, Reddit, whatever it is that you use. There are people out there that are willing to help and use that help.

    Chris Kincaid  

    Obviously, anything that’s going to be good requires hard work. And like you said, we both have the chair that’s like three jobs. I have a job I have a busy family. But you know, just take that time, that extra hour here that three or four hours you can squeeze out on the weekend and work on it. And then the nice thing about a game Making a game as you can play with it. So you go have a get-together or family function. And if your family your worksite way I, we play my games, every time there’s a holiday, my family actually really likes them. This is nice because they can find it in for the first year and then be like, alright, we want to play what we want to play, but they actually request to. The other thing is, and it’s very easy to say but very hard to do, is to learn to take criticism that people will give criticism in less than soft ways sometimes, and you don’t have to necessarily digest every little nugget of criticism thrown your way. Because sometimes people just give an opinion, as opposed to constructive criticism. But I know even with Jared, he and I will work together on something, and he’ll say something that I gotta, you know, take a couple deep breaths and the oh, man, I just don’t know if that makes any sense. And then it will. And I know I’ve probably said some things to him when we’re kind of fine-tuning a game where he’s, he’s kind of got to chew on it for a little while before we agree, but But yeah, just taking criticism from people who you know, are there to help. And for people who you don’t know, and just not being in a hurry with that, you know, doesn’t mean you got to change something every time somebody says they don’t like this, or they think this is a little clunky. But that’s a skill that I think maybe it’s sometimes lost.

    Michael Schofield  

    I love what you said about like the hard work, though, because, you know, so I don’t make games, but I on the side I make audio dramas that have like, you know, soundscapes, and they take forever to edit. And I’m one of the cool things about like being part of like this kind of community or you know, and because of design thinking games, and us being DMs and stuff that TTRPG community is that what you actually get to see is like a ton of people putting out a ton of work constantly. And it’s all good. And you don’t have anything because you have a family and a 40-hour job, right? But it’s really, like, I have to remind myself that, you know, a half-hour a day, 30 minutes a day will become something, well, you know, the episode will be great in the end or something like that. And it’s just that constant reminder that it doesn’t matter if you’re a fast worker. It’s just that you work, right. It’s just that you do it and it’s deliberate, deliberately timed. It’s a consistent downward sustainable pressure. Because you can burn out, and then you’re not going to ever do it again. But I always think like, just the fact that like, Hey, this is work and, and managing that work and being okay with the fact that the pace is variable helps a lot. So you just need to hear it. Sometimes I need to hear it, you know?

    Chris Kincaid  

    Well, and sometimes it’s perspective, like, my day job is very real life and very, just very real life. And, but it’s also, you know, I have to be type A in that day job. So I get a phone call, I’m answering it within 20 minutes usually, or calling somebody back and um, you know, shuffling through so many people coming to see me every hour. And then sometimes, like, I’ll slip into that with the game making, and it’ll make me crazy, because like, oh, no, it’s not fun like that. That’s not my fun job. But then you got to think, okay, if this comes out in three days or three months, who cares? You know, like it’s not going to change anything major, there’s not a deadline except for what I put on myself. Let’s just keep trying to make quality stuff as opposed to cutting corners and rushing it or getting burned out with it, like you said, and again, this is like a passion project for me. This is I relaxed, and I enjoy it, and honestly, like selling a few copies of Bank Heist is having that little tiny balance and are Lonely Hero Games account means more sometimes on some days. It’s just I’m prouder of that than I am some of the whole the other stuff, you know,

    Tim Broadwater  

    how do you want to tell or communicate to people how to connect with you or support you?

    Jared Kaplan  

    We try to be fairly active on social media, especially I would say our Instagram is where you know I spend the most time sort of posting on our behalf, and Chris gets on there and occasion as well. And we’re Lonely Hero Games on everything. I think at this point, Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, we have a TikTok, but we’re not active on that, really. But yeah, lonely euro games.com, people can contact us through the website. There’s a contact form. That yeah, if people want to reach out in any way they want to, they can DM us on anything like we want to talk to people, we want to engage with people that like our games or just curious about our games or whatever it might be. We sort of doing this not to be like that’s the best part about doing this is getting together with people and seeing people and meeting people. And, like, I have people that I consider actual friends now that I’ve met in the past three years, going to conventions, they don’t live anywhere near me. But it’s like, I know him from online. And I know I get to see him twice a year at Gen Con and Origins and but yeah, so people want to reach out to us like lonelyherogames.com Lonely Hero Games on most social media platforms.

    Chris Kincaid  

    The only other thing I would plug is we do have events running at Gen Con, and in Origins this year, there are still tickets available. So if you guys want to come to play, we’re playing Bank Heist at Origins. I think there are like five-hour blocks on Friday and Saturday, four-hour blocks, maybe. And then Gen Con this year, we have Bank Heist, I believe, on Friday for Turin and two tables three or four hours apiece and then Hungry for Humans on Saturday. The same thing, you can look us up on their event calendar, and there are still tickets available for all that.

    Michael Schofield  

    Give us a like, heart, or follow on your podcatchers of choice. Subscribe if you are to design thinking games. We are on Twitter and Tiktok. Twitch as DesignThinkingGames. And if you heard potentially like a really excellent ad spot that Tim or I designed, you too could have one of these. We are very affordable and just excited to help people elevate their voices a little bit. So consider supporting us in any way you can. Or on patreon.com/designthinkinggames.

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the Design Thinking games podcast. You only have so much time, and it means a lot you shared it with us to connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim. Visit Design Thinking games on tick-tock twitch, and Twitter DMs are open. You can also check out design thinking games.com where you can request topics, ask questions or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on

  • 024: The Geocache Killer

    024: The Geocache Killer

    Games mentioned in this geocaching episode:

    • 02:18 Sea of Thieves
    • 02:49 Letterboxing
    • 11:36 Ready Player One
    • 13:30 Rabbids
    • 16:29 Pokemon Go
    • 18:09 Ingress Prime
    • 19:32 Harry Potter Wizards Unite
    • 20:48 World of Warcraft
    • 24:06 Pikmin Bloom
    • 27:29 Minecraft
    • 31:13 Horizon Forbidden West

    A short intro to Geocaching

    Michael Schofield

    This began as an episode about geocaching. And geocaching is like one of these things that in this era of like Dungeons and Dragons popularity, and nerdom taking over pop culture that geocaching feels like a poindexterous, dorky as hell thing that you embark on. But it’s really pretty fascinating. It’s the idea that you know, you take your love of puzzle-solving, of discovery, and you take it outside. There is a robust community there.

    Tim Broadwater

    Yeah, so I know nothing about geocaching. When I first heard the term, I literally for probably a half a year or more, though it was what I now know is to be frisbee golf. And I swear, and I thought it was like, Oh, you take an app out, and you are playing with your friends frisbee golf, and it tracks it or does something, and then people, you know, kind of my understanding was like, Oh, you go to these specific places and do these things. And I did not. So I know nothing about geocaching at all. But you’ve played it before, right?

    Michael Schofield

    It’s hard to say you’ve played it. It almost doesn’t feel like a game. What it is, is it’s a modern treasure hunt, you know, the whole idea that you have a map and X marks the spot, find your way to a desert island, dig a hole, or perform some task. These are things you know, like Sea of Thieves brings back into pop culture, wherever you want just sails around finding treasures. That treasure-finding thing.

    What geocaching does is like, take this. Well, let me rewind for a second. So there’s this idea. There’s a sort of like game, sort of global or national or large scale, scavenger hunt style activity. It’s hard to call it a game, but an activity that you partake in is called letterboxing. Right? And it’s really the idea that, in the end, is very simple. It’s like hey, man, you’ve got a shoe box, and you wrap it in some plastic or whatever, you make it waterproof. You go somewhere, put a couple of trinkets, bury them, and leave clues to their location. Hopefully, someone goes and finds it.

    Geocaching is a treasure hunt

    Tim Broadwater

    So it’s like a treasure hunter scavenger hunt.

    Michael Schofield

    It’s a scavenger hunt. But now like ever since like, like in 2000. It was actually the year 2000 when GPS became a readily available thing. And you can see the timeline of people partaking in geocaching increasing from those who had extremely expensive GPS devices up to 2007 when you had a GPS in your phone. And the idea is that, yeah, it’s a scavenger hunt with GPS coordinates.

    Tim Broadwater

    And, wait, like everyone can. Everyone contributes to it. Everyone hides, and everyone finds.

    Michael Schofield

    Yeah, exactly. So you can just find so, so here’s the basic premise; like you, there are specific apps or lists, and some are obscure. There are geocaching lists on the deep web. And you know, it’s your access to these lists of endpoints that really is part of the game, but you know, there’s a geocaching app, you can just like to look it up, you can pull it down and basically what it is like hey, around you there’s a geocache key, or at this coordinate, it’s using like a Google map or an Apple map overlay, and there’s a pin drop. But the idea is like hey, at this coordinate which might be in let’s uh let’s go easy, right, it’s in the park.

    Somewhere within 100 meters or so is buried treasure. It’s hidden there are some clues the listing might say: walk like from from from the beginning point of the coordinates like walk north 100 steps until you are under like that.

    The spider

    The eaves of a great oak that look right or something like and so what would happen is you go there and you like look up, and you see a, and you see like a spider on the tree, and you’re like oh shit what a big spider and you realize it’s fake. And you figure your way up to up the tree. Look under the spider.

    The spider is tied by a long piece of like thread or fishing line. It’s tied to like a little fist-size package that’s in the knot of the tree. And in that package is a little keychain, something for you to take and a logbook. You document yourself. “Tim was here at this time.” And you put it back, and maybe you leave like a little treasure for someone else. But that’s it. That’s the game.

    Tim Broadwater

    Oh, wait, wait, wait, I have like three questions. Literally orbiting around it. So who started it? And then I guess the second question is, is it possible to go to them and there’ll be nothing there?

    Michael Schofield

    Good question about the starting, so letterboxing as a game started in the 1800s. This is a thing that people did treasure hunting, you know, this, like you can imagine a couple of dorks like me and you walking around before the Civil War clearly far in the north. And we’re like, boy, did you read that Robinson Crusoe. It’s like how fun would it be to like to bury some treasure, and you’re like, “but I did bury some treasure Schofield onward!”

    Tim Broadwater

    “Tallyho!”

    Michael Schofield

    And that’s where it began.

    So the other thing is that this is governed by, like, by ethics, right? So there is a strong ethic that you don’t fuck up, or you don’t steal it, or you take a thing, and you leave the thing and stuff like that 100%. You can get there. It’s no longer there. Because it’s our nature, like maybe, you know, maybe like someone like literally chop down the tree oops.

    Tim Broadwater

    The game you’re playing has an agency or a federation basically that says like, hey, when you do this, you have to leave this or when you do it, like checking in on the site or whatever. So there’s like an agency and rules.

    Michael Schofield

    Yeah, so, the organization is like around you know, the provider of the list and the coordinates, but these providers can be decentralized like there for a while, there was like a whole like 4chan decentralized letterbox game there, you can find others that are coordinates based off l blockchain geocaching so that there is no central authority there.

    Yeah, and it’s one of those things that get increasingly more difficult. So my example of the park is fine. That’s fun. And in a way, you can imagine that if you had a real treasure map that literally everybody else had, the treasure would be picked over or whatever, but some maps are hard to get.

    And you might find them up, like midway up a mountain, or 100 feet under the sea, right? Where the adventure ultimately becomes the journey to get to this coordinate.

    Tim Broadwater

    Yeah, but once you get there, it’s like a 300-yard area, like cents a square foot.

    It gets you there physically. And then you have to kind of not just look, but then also take the clues or whatever you had, and you had legit have to search.

    Michael Schofield

    There are different kinds. So like, the coordinates might just get you to clue one, right? You can imagine this is some kind of like riddle verse, and it will tell you the next location is like in a forest, three miles to your east. And that location is not on the map, right?

    So it’s one of those things where it is really up to whoever goes in and places the cache, and kind of like the ethics of the list that you’re adhering to, how I don’t know how much hand-holding you give the person.

    The thinking is that there’s a Yeah, it’s a gamified thing with an actual leaderboard to get to a point. And that leaderboard might just be some notes inside a very rare cache or, you know, activity and like that’s, I’m like, that’s part of the app. But it forces you to go hiking for the most part.

    Tim Broadwater

    Yeah, this reminds me so much of Ready Player One to where it’s like, well, we can give you a clue. The clue just gets you there. But then you have to find the key. And then, once you have the key, you have to find the gate that the key unlocks.

    Yeah. So it’s very cool. So there is the scenario that you were describing with the spider? I mean, can you describe what something you said is? You’ve played this before? What was that something that you experienced? Yeah.

    Michael Schofield

    So that was one of my first ones. I had one that was in the median between an expressway, which was kind of like dangerous to get to. I’ve never actually found an ammo box; like often, there’s like an ammo box if you look it up. And it’s totally waterproof.

    And it’s full of shit. Everything that I find is like, you know, like a fist-sized, plastic-wrapped dice pouch full of, you know, stuff and like, they’re small. And they’re wedged into some weird spots.

    Tim Broadwater

    That’s cool, though. Still cool. Yeah. Now I’ve never done it. And I’ve always wondered what it was. And so

    Michael Schofield

    Ready Player One is very, you know, it’s the whole like, gumshoe three clue thing, right. It’s the is the idea that there’s a puzzle. And at a glance, the idea that like, Oh, here’s a GPS coordinate, and right there is a treasure.

    I mean, that doesn’t seem super fun. But you find those that lead to other caches that lead to other caches, and you end up going down kind of like a rabbit hole. Like some of this is like, coming up in pop culture. There’s a whole game there plus a story called Rabbids where Rabbids? Rabbits, not Rabbids.

    Some lists are dangerous to play. Oh, right. Some are occult-based lists, where what you’re doing is, the equivalent of like, learning how to open the puzzle box and Hellraiser or you’re going like, or you’re going to like haunted locations.

    The Geocache Killer

    Tim Broadwater

    or like a crazy serial killer put out an elaborate thing, and then you followed t.

    Michael Schofield

    Oh man, that That’s amazing.

    Tim Broadwater

    The Geocache Killer: Design Thinking games 2020

    Michael Schofield

    Watch out for our next game

    Niantic

    Tim Broadwater

    one of the other things we were talking about like as fitness you know, this is getting you outside, so this topic has turned into like like it was kind of like an augmented reality game, but it’s like a fitness game, or then there’s the whole topic of like the gamification of exercise and fitness and eating and then exploring the physical world outside of your house geocache.

    So I’m wondering, you know, there seems to be with some with geocaching, is there a point where you get to the location or that you’re using an app or that you’re using it more so in you know, kind of more than just getting to the 300-foot area?

    Michael Schofield

    That’s sort of where like Niantic comes in. Right? So if you think about like Pokemon Go, it’s not dissimilar. There’s more of a browsing quality where you’re looking around and hoping that you stumble upon a Pokemon, but there are specific locations and gyms.

    Gradually word gets around that you know a certain corner of like a University has a certain Pokemon. You know, these parts are different circles on a Venn diagram that definitely overlap. So the Geocaching apps I’ve only ever used just map right that like have little coordinates on it, but it’s kind of the same thing as the Pokemon Go.

    The Harry Potter-like all the Niantic things, I never played Ingress. But it was not dissimilar, except, you know, that leans more into the augmented reality thing, but you’re still scavenger hunting around. There’s more of a game or more of a video game aspect to it, more of a competent competitive aspect. Whereas like geocaching is the journey more than a result.

    Tim Broadwater

    Yeah. And I know that there’s also like geocaching trails, right, like places you specifically go to. And you know, there’s also like places that I’m assuming that also can happen at places that you want to visit outdoor people place of like, beauty or significance or waterfalls or Yeah, and so the thing that conversely, and I’ve played Ingress, PokemonGo, Harry Potter: Wizards Unite, and I’m currently cracked out on Pikmin Bloom is that, that it was exciting and new. I think when it was my Niantic, it was amazing.

    Don’t get me wrong. Their partnership with Nintendo is phenomenal. I’m here for it. I am not. I prefer Pokemon the actual role-playing game you know versus the card game or Pokemon Go? Yeah, so just not a Pokemon Go person. Because you just like obsessively catching and bat. Yeah, there’s nothing else to it. But when Ingress First, you know, when Ingress first launched, I love the fields that you could draw areas and you were on teams and you’re trying to protect areas and the longer you can protect areas, the more energy and resources you get.

    And then it soon became apparent that okay, this is every post office, every city building every statue, you know, or money or monument, right. And then people could submit their own. I submitted two or three, two Ingress when I played which was like, there’s a memorial statue at a town close to me locally. I submitted that and it got added.

    Wow. So it was kind of definitely the data that’s building out like okay, memorials and places that didn’t now I found that when you kind of go to PokemonGo Harry Potter wizards unite and even Pikmin bloom it’s just like, oh, this is now a gym or a wizard tower dual place. I can’t remember with Harry Potter.

    Yeah, but it Pikmin bloom it’s like a place where like a fungus infestation can happen, you know, so then you so it’s neat. But I think now like being when I hear you describe and talk about geocaching, right, getting you to an area and then actually having a look at interact, solve riddles and clues. Versus I know where the gym is, I know where the post offices there just seems to be. It’s more about grinding, right? And so Pokemon to me is just like, grinding, grinding, grinding. And then there’s all these rules. People that say once you get over level 20 Like it’s horrid. Like it’s just so bad.

    Pokemon Go is rough at higher levels

    Michael Schofield

    Oh, really? Why? What’s bad about it?

    Tim Broadwater

    Well, most people, because it takes forever. And you have to be very strategic about what things you do to get experience because it takes so much experience to go up to like level 30 or higher or whatever. And then it just becomes well, why are you playing now?

    Like, sure you don’t get anything you know, and it’s just like, they could always add another 10 levels to it or World of Warcraft it like add another 50 levels, you know, but I mean, I will. Having said that though. I liked Harry Potter. It was cool. I like Pokemon that kept me there. Ingress was the whole sci-fi secrecy thing.

    And the whole thing about Ingress and the success of it, kind of as it relates to geocaching, I think is the exclusivity of it. Like it was a year that they only gave limited invites out it was kind of like Facebook strategy, right? And then you wanted to get chosen you wanted to win a survey or do all this stuff.

    And so they had all these people who were like, chomping at the bit to be users and they were just like, oh do surveys for us do this for us build our spread our social media like it and it’s just like, oh my god, you just created an army of people because they want exclusivity to do marketing.

    Michael Schofield

    Yeah, you’re right. There’s, there’s kind of like an element of like the niche, right? Like, you can imagine that like, oh, you know, because it’s weird to get into or hard to find or hard to get access to.

    The high friction point of getting into the hobby itself that suddenly you know, everyone who all the players are bound a little bit closer together because they kind of you know, made it through that hurdle. Yeah, that’s really interesting because like I remember when like Pokemon GO came out.

    Tim Broadwater

    I still know people to this day that you’ll be out in public like visiting a museum or something and they’ll just be on their phone like catching Pokemon.

    Pokemon Go and small businesses

    Michael Schofield

    It was like one of the first the the first zeitgeist, I can remember where meat like media outlets were actually talking about like, oh, yeah, all these like pasty kids who’ve never seen the sun are finally wandering around the park, or wandering into traffic or wandering off cliffs.

    Tim Broadwater

    On the small business side, it was cool. Like on the small business side, it was just like, hey, come in, get this Pokemon-flavored drink or whatever, we have a pokey stop next to us feel free to kick out because you can only kick in like three times. But they were just like, oh, show us your highest level Pokemon. And if it beats our daily average, we’ll get you a Free Milkshake or you know or stuff like that everywhere.

    Yeah, and I will say this like, I l Pikmin. I love the game. Are you familiar with Pikmin? At all?

    Michael Schofield

    Yeah. Familiar with Pikmin? Yeah, I have not played Pikmin Bloom, though.

    Pikmin Bloom is awesome

    Tim Broadwater

    Okay. Yeah. So I loved Pikmin ever since I played it on GameCube. You’re this little alien guy who lands on a planet. Then you basically have all these little plant people who want to work for you and love you. Basically do this, like, you give them nectar and they will do fruit for you or battle, or get fruit for your battle stuff. I love the sequels.

    I’ve played all the games and when I actually like Pikmin bloom better than Ingress, PokemonGo, and Harry Potter: Wizards Unite. The reason why is because it is an AFK kind of game, like a casual while you’re walking, you can plant flowers, and collect fruit. And it’s nothing, it doesn’t even require me to look at the phone a lot while I’m walking.

    But it gives me credit for walking. And it’s like, oh, you’ve walked this far. This is how many flowers you’ve planted. And then you can kind of keep walking and add new flowers and colors and types of flowers. And you can make your actual neighborhood or your yard or whatever. Actually, the digital looks like a digital garden and exert control – that sounds like nefarious, exert power. No, but actually, like creative tickles that creator kind of thing. Are you like oh, cool, I can make my own garden.

    Michael Schofield

    It seems like whereas like Pokemon GO and Harry Potter, you play by going to a locale so you’re but you’re still like consuming. You’re on the receptive end of like, whatever content. Yeah, so in Pikmin us you can actually like create, you have creative powers.

    Pikmin at PAX East

    Tim Broadwater

    Oh yeah, when I was at PAX East, everyone was playing Pikmin. And the entire Boston Convention Center looked like this lush, verdant flower garden. That was beautiful. They had all these different types of flowers and giant flowers.

    It was like filled with fruit and like so when you walk through it all your Pikmin are like grabbing fruit, and you’re paying for planting flowers so I can see what you’re doing. You can see what I’m doing in regards to planting flowers. And I think and between Niantic and Nintendo, I think this is gold. So AFK games are games that you can get on usually on a mobile device: plays itself and auto levels up itself, you’re just kind of log in every so often make choices, design stuff, whatever. Then you can just let it play itself.

    Pikmin Bloom is like this nice, great, cool area where there’s a hybrid of an AFK game, and a walking game and the Nintendo worker placement game, right. And so, in that sounds very complex, like hey, you can create your own garden you control your workers, you do work your management, but it’s also you don’t kind of have to be there to play because it counts your steps.

    It’s a kind of an AFK game and things will grow themselves and you know, and so it’s I’m really liking it and so that’s why I’m geeking out about it and talking a lot and it gets me out I have noticed walking like I actually want to walk because of it.

    Michael Schofield

    That’s the hard part, man like I love the idea that you can plant a garden. The promise of the HoloLens like back in the day and how you could take you know your Minecraft server to the real world. There’s something that’s really attractive about the idea that either through, you know, the window of your phone or in the future maybe a pair of glasses you slide on that you decorate your space and You can see the decorations of others. And there’s something that’s Ultra attractive about that. It’s almost as if I feel like a game, right? It feels more like collaborative art, you know?

    Tim Broadwater

    And yeah, I’ve always loved the Sci-Fi grid. Like, I love sci-fi movies. And I love it when they render like the internet or computer user interfaces and sci-fi movies as being like an overlay on reality. But all the user interfaces kind of seem to be like augmented reality over real space out and you’re out in the real world. Like, you don’t have to be limited to electricity or cable internet.

    Geocaching takes us on a tangent about being technological optimists

    Michael Schofield

    Or tied to a monitor to a keyboard. This is like, the science fiction thing of like, technology, ultimately liberating you from like, a cubicle you find yourself in weather that’s literally in a business office, or, you know, kind of like the, like, you know, many of us are remote now, I, we’re, we’re confined to the house. That’s where that so this shit is.

    Tim Broadwater

    I travel and work all the time. If I actually have if, if I’m going on a trip, I will use my phone as like a wireless hotspot, you know what I mean? Or cars now have wireless, so you can actually work and get Wi-Fi in the car, but it just connects through a cellular connection, but can be used as a Wi-Fi hotspot? I definitely feel like we are now at a more time than ever, historically, where we could actually, be completely mobile work on the go, we could actually, you know, kind of do that. And so, I love it.

    Michael Schofield

    I love the idea of being a you know, these things like untethering you from your devices, you know, games that you can play without having to be next to a console or to your like, powerhouse machine or, or something like that I like really attractive, especially the ones that, you know, have some sort of like community aspect.

    There’s a kind of like weird gamification to co-working spaces, right, and like finding one near you and going in, again, working order. There’s a weird kind of gamification to the whole, like, digital nomad lifestyle, but how nomadic can you actually be?

    Tim Broadwater

    I’m for fast, like, I’m totally like, utopian, not dystopian. I’m trying to have a positive outlook. And, and the thing is the fact that people can work with wireless hotspots, they can move, it doesn’t really matter. Then you have an office offices being structured now to where they have hotel desks. So you can just kind of go in use a desk for the day, but you don’t have to be back at that office.

    Maybe you’re not back at that office, I don’t know. But then with apps and games, and I think there’s this kind of version, it’s like, oh, with computers and stuff, we’re all going to be like matrix plugged in to where we’re just like our bodies have atrophied or they’ve gotten really obese, like Wall-E the Pixar Disney film. And so and I love this, it’s like no, it’s more like for sure Horizon Forbidden Dawn, take the tech with you. I’m into nature, you know, and you can exactly the Wi-Fi and yeah, I love it.

    Michael Schofield

    I definitely waffle back and forth between between, you know, being a technological optimist and not and like, you know, generally I don’t think I don’t think a matrix is before us. But I think, you know, the first step to that is like re communing with, you know, the actual outside and nature and real people, and what the tech is is just kind of like an extension of like function so like, you know, you can meet with your buddies and continue the conversation at you know, at any kind of distance but it’s not at the expense of ever meeting with your buddies or ever going outside or, or anything.

    Yeah, so yeah, so like, like, the moment you find me as a technological optimist, I definitely waffle the other way. But I’m with you, I think I think this kind of thing is like really interesting as the devices in our pockets become increasingly more powerful and like interconnected interdependent with like, like our stuff, you know, the ability to like, you know, like pretty leaderboards Rob, just kind of like random shit. Just like really kind of like attract those of you who enjoyed this or any of the prior episodes, give us a star heart favor on designthinkinggames.com Or your podcatcher of choice.

    We’ve got robust to backlog go back and listen to it we also offer some ads. Perhaps you you heard a good one just like a few minutes prior they’re super affordable so if you got something you want to promote to like-minded audience look us up and we’re on all the social media largely Twitter and Tik Tok as Design Thinking Games. We’ve been talking a lot about like a newsletter, and I think we actually have like some content from like interviews we’ve been working on and you know, some stuff like that. To subscribe to our newsletter if you want to hear more from us.

    Outro: thanks for making it this far

    Introductory Guy

    Thank you for listening to the Design Thinking Games podcast. You only have so much time and it means a lot you shared it with us. To connect with your hosts Michael or Tim, visit Design Thinking games on TikTok twitch and Twitter DMs are open. You can also check out designthinkinggames.com where you can request topics, ask questions or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on.

    This geocaching episode is brought to you by SEO, and the need to say “geocaching” about 23 times. For good measure: geocaching, geocaching, geocaching.

  • 023: Indie Games at PAX East

    023: Indie Games at PAX East

    Games discussed in this episode about PAX East:

    • 05:09 Aron’s Gift
    • 09:50 Dead Cells
    • 16:31 Rescue Pets
    • 20:59 Aegis
    • 22:55 Pocket Paragons
    • 26:08 Dragoon
    • 26:25 Life Siphon
    • 29:02 Reap
    • 30:49 Drinking Quest Six Pack
    • 35:21 Stream Queens

    Intro: we went to PAX East

    Introductory Guy  

    Welcome to design thinking games, a gaming and User Experience podcast. Card-carrying UXers Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper roleplaying games, live-action games and video games. Play through the backlog on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at design thinking games.com.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yes, so as you know, Design Thinking Games went to PAX, PAX East, specifically, which was in Boston, it was the April it was kind of April 21, to the 24th. It was a lot of fun, a super fun time. And I know that some of our listeners probably have never been to like a Gen Con or an Origins or a PAX. So just what I wanted to say is that you know, if you don’t know what Pax is, it’s the Penny Arcade Expo. And it’s a con or convention for gaming and all types of gaming. It’s tabletop, arcade, video gaming, everything, right? It started in 2004. And then I think it only was, you know, kind of in Seattle or had limited locations. But then, due to the popularity, I think in 2010, 12 years ago, they actually got PAX East, which is in Boston, which is the second closest one to me. The nearest one to me is PAX Unplugged, which just started last year during COVID. And it is only tabletop board games. No video games.

    Michael Schofield  

    That one’s exciting. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    I think we’ve talked about possibly going to that this year. But I digress. It’s like 67 or 70,000. People like who go it is huge, right? And as all these cool things, like it has tournaments, it has land parties, there are panels and that you can talk to with game developers and cosplayers and famous, like streamers on Twitch, there’s music concerts when I went before I got to see the Doubleclick, and I, you know, in the mini-bosses, which was awesome.

    The Megathon at PAX East

    And then they have the Megathon, which is probably what they’re most known for, which is like the con-long competition that they do. And so the Omega Athan is like a festival long competition that, I think traditionally like they had like one person is randomly selected, but I think you can do teams now. And so you, they don’t tell you the games, it’s like you sign up with three teammates and you, they can have you playing Tetris, and then you’re playing Street Fighter, and then you’re playing Halo, and then you’re playing like Monopoly, or like, whatever. They will throw any type of game at you, and the people who do the best win the Megathon, and they get to choose, like, whatever PAX they want to go to next year. They get free tickets. PAX is also one of these — kind of like Gen Con or Origins — that sells out within 15 minutes like all the tickets are gone, so it’s kind of in demand.

    PAX Enforcers

    And then one of the other things that’s unique to PAX is the enforcers. It’s the volunteers who work for it. They get like free admission to go. And they so it’s kind of, but they volunteer to work. And they’re like super helpful, they guide you to where you need to go, you know, they help like corral people in waiting lines for panels and stuff. So. So it’s a whole thing.

    So when Design Thinking Games was there, we spent time talking to indie tabletop games and indie video games. So people who were there specifically to create you to make a booth to they could be doing alpha or beta testing for their board game or video game, or they are plugging something that is just about to go into Kickstarter, or it’s currently in Kickstarter, or, you know, they’re giving like a preview of a game that will be out soon. And that’s the stuff I’m interested in. I mean, there are like the big booths there.

    They have like, you know, Nintendo and Sony and Microsoft and Discord and Twitch. I mean, like, there are big booths, but I love going after and seeing the indie stuff, so that’s what I wanted to bring back and share with our listeners. Sound good? Are you game? 

    Michael Schofield  

    I’m game. This is super exciting.

    Aron’s Gift

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so we start with indie video games. One of the ones that I got to see was Aron’s Gift. It is a game that is by Inktale Studios. And it is a beautifully hand-painted game that I think just two people have created, and they had a booth there.

    Joe Shiraef  

    So this is Inktale Studios. This is our first game, Aron’s Gift, that we’re showing. And we put together about a 15 to 30-minute demo, where you can get a feel for the atmosphere and the style we’re going for. It is an original hand-painted and placed 2d action-adventure game. And it’s made by Kristen and me, Kristen does all of the art and the music, and I do the programming and animation.

    This is our first time at PAX East ever. We’ve done PAX West, which is formerly PAX Prime. It is still in pre-alpha, I would say. A lot more developing months in the future. And we’re shooting for maybe 10 to 12 months down the road for a release on PlayStation, Steam, and Switch.

    It’s a very story-driven game. So you got to get to know the environment, the characters, and the ambiance by exploring the world. And there are plenty of RPG elements. But that’s not the core of the game. You’re not going to upgrade through a bunch of skill trees. You’re gonna upgrade about three major items and collect three major spirit stones, which give me most of your abilities throughout the game. The Steam wish list really means a lie kind of gives us a metric about when we can release safely without totally blowing it. Discord is a great place to follow our development process, as is our website inktalestudios.com. It’s great. You can contact us there and join the email list.

    Michael Schofield  

    Wow. 

    Tim Broadwater

    Everything is hand-painted. 

    Michael Schofield  

    It is gorgeous. Man. Yeah, so pretty. Also, super interesting. We’ve seen a lot of these smaller creators experiment with the notion of the game, or, you know, the mechanics of the game where, like, what he was saying about how this isn’t, there are RPG elements, but it’s not the point. Right? The point of this is to tell a good story, to roleplay, and that’s super interesting. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, and there is they had a tutorial set up for you to play like, kind of 15 minutes just to check it out. But I would say, you know, this is something for, you know, we’ve talked about narrative in the past on the podcast, this is something that if you are looking for a story-driven game, get your eyes on Aron’s Gift, and I think one of the things I didn’t realize until I started interacting with going to game cons and the gaming community in the game culture, and kind of all of this is that not only are you trying to build your following and getting your backers, you know, by going to cons of demoing your games, but you can also a lot of people like for video games use the Discord space to connect players, to developers. And so you can actually kind of communicate, release answer questions, you know, have that interaction there, which I wasn’t even aware of, you know, maybe because I’m more aligned to like tabletop games how those are, you know, back to cons but not so much video games.

    Dead Cells

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so very cool. Another one that I saw there was interesting. It’s called Dead Cells. And Dead Cells is interesting because it was made years ago by the game study of Motion Twin, and it was successful. But Motion Twin kind of wanted to move on. But they partnered with another gaming studio called Evil Empire Studios. And so Evil Empire Studios is like, No, this game kicks ass. So we’re gonna keep releasing content and making DLC and adding to the game. And so the original people, some of them are involved. But then some of them wanted to continue working on other games. And yeah, this is what the person I talked to from Evil Empire Studios said.

    Matthew Houghton  

    So me personally, I’m Matt, and I’m the marketing manager for Dead Cells. So we’re actually Evil Empire, who took over Dead Cells from Motion Twin three years ago. Motion Twin are the guys who made Dead Cells originally, and they want to move on to a new project. So we’re taking care of it, they retain creative control, and we work symbiotically. I joined the company just before COVID hit, so I never got the chance to, so this is like an important PAX to me. I’m loving it so far as well. It’s great.

    And so the game is Dead Cells. They call it a Roguevania, which means it’s a roguelike with elements of Metroidvania exploration gatekeeping. So it’s basically, the elevator pitch is buttery, smooth combat super-fast pace, 150 weapons, you’re gonna die a lot, but you will improve and grow your skills. Yeah. So this is where we’re showcasing now the Queen in the Sea DLC, which came out a few months ago.

    We’ve also got our latest update, which introduces a new level called the bank, which appears randomly in your run. And we’ve also got a preview of our next update, which is all about accessibility. So there are options to outline the player outline the enemy’s reduced particle effects, change the colors, and have an assist mode, which lets you adjust enemy health damage and tap speed. You can even add a continue. So we’re basically trying to allow everyone to tune it to suit them, so they can enjoy themselves. The places we most regularly post are on Steam. But if you don’t have Steam, we’re always posting on Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, and all the usual. We’ve got a discord. If people are curious about the game, they can throw that we always do announcements whenever we’ve got an update or an alpha or beta test to take part in. So those are usually good ways.

    Michael Schofield  

    How cool that they are leaning hard on the accessibility aspect as a product seller or a differentiator. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    And I, you know, for me, you are kind of right, because it is I love Metroidvania style games, as you know,

    Michael Schofield  

    I look at this; it looks as if it has Tim all over it.

    Tim Broadwater  

    But what you don’t get with Metroidvania-style games, which I love, like the sidescrolling going back and figuring out and like, Oh, I just get this item. Now I can go back to before, and now I can do this thing is the roguelike element. You always know, like with Metroidvania style games, like. Oh, when I go back to the fountain, there will always be this monster here. But no, like with the roguelike game. Like it’s different. It’s randomly generated, which is very cool.

    Michael Schofield  

    I think it’s really cool. You know, and of course, you know, as as an engineer, I’m sort of thinking about how impressive that codebase might be, right? Because it’s one thing to have a roguelike that is, you know, randomly generated with the intention or the assumption that the player is always moving forward. But what Castlevania is, or I guess Metroidvania is, you’re right, like, the whole idea is that there are things to unlock back where you came from, there are things you can’t even access until you get a certain item or level up to a certain point. And I’m super interested to see how this is actually like designed in terms of that replayability with, you know, like knowing that it was totally procedurally generated. So how dope.

    Tim Broadwater  

    The original studio was involved and had creative control, but like allowing DLC to come out, it was popular. Man, like, people were waiting in line to play. Because if they played and did well, they would get a free copy of the game. 

    Rescue Pets

    Tim Broadwater  

    And then one of the last, like, I think I talked to a bunch of people there. And it’s just like, there’s so much right. But one of the last ones that I wanted to bring up is Rescue Pets. And I think I talked to you a little bit about this before, but essentially, it is mobile games for Android and iOS, but the proceeds from the games go to actually help dog shelters in the real world.

    Daniel Scalise  

    Oh, my name is Dan Scalise from Scalisco. And we make games that donate to animal shelters. I’ve been to PAX before. This is my fourth one, actually. Yeah, so our first game is Rescue Pets. And, you know, I basically used to work at Amazon as a software developer, and I didn’t. I just wasn’t feeling fulfilled. And as I said, mobile games make so much money. What if we could use that money to give back to the greater good? You know, so I made rescue pets, you got this Corgi you adopt him, you grow a home for him and grow an animal shelter with him. And you get cute costumes and stuff like that. And the money you spend in the game or any ads you watch go towards helping different animal shelters. So 20% of everything we make, our revenue from ads, in-app purchases, or merch like the Corgi butt pins we have. They go to Dog On Seattle, and we rotate different shelters every now and then. But doggone Seattle, we’ve donated over $6,000, so we just released Rockminer. And it’s a brand new game where it’s 3d or Corgi. You get on a truck. And you just start crushing rocks and find animals trapped in the mines, and you save them. And now you can start playing as them too well. You can find us on social media at RescuePetsGame on Twitter, Instagram or Facebook. And then scalisco.com is our website. 

    Michael Schofield 

    Were there a lot of games out there that you saw where the mission was a big selling point? Like Rescue Pets has as a way to donate and help actual animal shelters. Dead Cells with like, the accessibility on the front end was like, did you notice this? Like, and great. And like, I don’t know, was this noticeable at all at this PAX East? 

    Tim Broadwater  

    I think it’s noticeable with indie games, right? Sure. So if you’re not a big studio, I mean, you’re kind of in it for whatever reason you’re in it, you know, and so some are people who want to make a game that they love to play, where some are like, no, let’s take proceeds to help, you know, kind of a cause or some are just like, I love my, like, we have great art that we want to weave into a game right? And so I think it’s kind of all over the place. And that’s kind of what I love about the indie games. And then if you have not, like if, if you do not know this game, and your listeners, you know, definitely go check it out because I don’t know if you saw the Corgi butt. 

    Michael Schofield  

    I love that pillow. So that’s what I just took a screenshot of it like as I was scrolling through the website.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Looks like any part of their proceeds, like a part of a percentage of the proceeds goes so I mean, that’s to help, you know, kind of animal shelters and the game itself is like, animal sim shelter, like you rescue a pet and you make an animal shelter, and you find homes for them. And so it’s very cool.

    Michael Schofield  

     I love that. Yeah, I haven’t loved the game by default. Having not even played it in a minute. They definitely target you straight in the heart of this is a good one. 

    A.E.G.I.S: Combining Robots

    Tim Broadwater  

    So the Boston Convention Center is divided into two sections, right? So one whole section is literally what they call the Vendor Mart, and that’s like the video game side that is only open for a certain time of day, and then it closes down but until midnight is the Tabletop Space because people are playing footy you know, tabletop games all the way till the witching hour, and, and so on the on. So on the other side, I got to talk to a couple of different game developers and studios, and one of the coolest ones I got to talk to was this game called A.E.G.I.S, and I’d never heard of it before, and it’s on its second release or season two. And I didn’t even catch it the first time around. But it is literally like multiplayer Voltron.

    Breeze Grigas  

    Oh, yeah. So my name is Breeze Grigas. Yes, I’m the head of Zephyr Workshop based out of Seattle slash Boston. I was going to be doing that, and we make A.E.G.I.S Combining Robots. It just is a 20 Minute tactics game. You have a team of five robots. Your opponent has a team of five robots you fight. It goes to six players. There are five different kinds of robots: assault, evasive, guard, intel, support – spells “A.E.G.I.S.” These types of robots are color-coded. And you can put robots of different colors together, including all five of the robots on your team, to make Voltron. So it’s all about team building. And there are like 100 unique robots in the box.

    Bunch of different game modes. Yeah, 100 robots in the box. And with this new box that we’re making for the sequel, there are 100 more robots. A.E.G.I.S. launched in like 2018/2019, and we sold through all of it, and now we’re returning to Kickstarter to reprint that first box, and also we’re doing a whole new second box called A.E.G.I.S., Second Ignition or A.E.G.I.S. 2 or A.E.G.I.S. Season Two, we just call it all those things. But yeah, it’s a whole new box that’s cross-compatible with the first one. And it has like every all the content inside is new and streamlined and good. So your robots share energy points with each other like your action points. And if you reduce your opponent to like after, there’s a point where once your opponent can’t make enough energy, they’ll lose, or if you blow up all your opponent’s robots, they’ll lose. And we’ve also introduced some new game modes in the new box, where instead of just doing a straight-up deathmatch, you just blow, your robots infinitely respond, but you’re trying to like accrue points instead. So it becomes like more of a gamified game sort of thing.

    Yeah, check out Pocket Paragons. It’s a five-minute dueling game. We have a box we haven’t. There’s a standalone expansion box for that game with A.E.G.I.S. just characters on it. That’s the only thing I could sell you because the games are different. Look for the first ages game on eBay. Please back our Kickstarter when it comes out there. The signup page is up. Now just click the green button. Find it A.E.G.I.S. 2. Probably go to ZephyrWorkshop.com, where many links are to our Kickstarter page. You can search it up on Board Game Geek. You can find us on Twitter @ZephyrWorkshop.

    Michael Schofield  

    Damn. What a cool game, and also, I like how lackadaisical the guy was about the marketing. So yeah, look, we’re literally everywhere. Did you see a picture of the inside of that box? And how many pieces are in there? Oh my god. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    The game was there. You could play a demo of the game at PAX. And then I can’t believe it was out already. And it’s like I’d never even heard of it. And now they and it’s had cross-compatibility. It’s played with other, you know, it’s kind of been featured and plugged in other games, like he said, but then, like, you have five robots, and you can have many players, and you can control robots and build them together and fight I need to share an energy pool with that energy pool lets you do special attacks and moves and super cool. Super cool.

    Michael Schofield  

    It is super cool. Man. I don’t know who didn’t grow up on Voltron or later Power Rangers and all that

    Tim Broadwater  

    Or Transformers, and like they had all the different types of bots that would build bigger boats.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Lay Waste Games

    Yeah, so one of the other games, this is not specifically a game, but a game studio that I thought was cool, like Lay Waste games. I talked to one of the people, they have multiple games that are out there, but they actually had whereas like, you know, with A.E.G.I.S and Zephyr workshop, they’re like, Oh, we had a game that already came out. And here’s a Kickstarter: please back us now because we’re the Kickstarter is active. This was a game studio that took a hit like during not hit, but kind of set back a little bit because of COVID. And so I actually got to talk to, you know, one of the people from their booth. 

    Jake Given  

    My name is Jake Given, one of the cofounders of Lay Waste Games. We’re the creators of a few games, most like, most notably probably is, the Dragoon series of games, where you play as dragons destroying and dominating humans. So the first Kickstarter we did for Dragoon would have been back in 2015. So I guess we’re coming on in seven years that we’ve been a studio. So we’re excited to be able to promote Life Siphon, which is our most recent game that is currently available. That launched and was available right before the pandemic hit. So we lost the ability to show it off at conventions and promote it that way. So we’re really excited about that. But we also have a new game that we’re starting to demo show around before we do the full Kickstarter later this summer. This is our hometown. We started here in Boston. We love PAX East. It’s our favorite convention to go to, so we’re really excited to be back. Our website is laywastegames.com. You can also find us on Twitter at @LayWasteGames and hit us up. We’re always happy to talk to people.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yo, their Dragoon pieces for their Gold Edition are amazing. I love them.

    Tim Broadwater  

    The pieces for Life Siphon, I’m assuming it’s wood. It’s beautiful, beautiful games, and then they had like a bunch of different ones out there for a minute when I passed them. I was like, Oh, this is just a store that sells games, and it’s like no, at least it’s a Lay Waste Games is a studio with these are our games, so it was kind of neat. They’re just very creatively crafted. They have these cool things on the table that you want to interact with and click with and move around, you know, which is neat. So, I would, uh, it was interesting talking to them, because, you know, board games are something we don’t typically think of, you know, it’s like, you have to be there in person to play and as online gaming, kind of like I think it went through the roof probably, and the streaming went through the roof during COVID. It’s like, well, what about the board-game love? So it’s kind of neat.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, that’s interesting. It’d be fun to chat with them. Their art style pervades each of their games.

    Jason Anarchy Games

    Tim Broadwater  

    And they’re all stylistically different, like how Human Era looks versus Dragoon versus Life Syphon. Very cool. And there’s also like, a talk to tons of different people. And hopefully, maybe we can have some on in the future or like a feature in the newsletter. But I think the last one I talked to was a guy who made a game called Reap. And then you have to know, I mean, you probably know of it. And everyone who’s listening probably knows of Drinking Quest. 

    Jason Anarchy  

    I’m Jason Anarchy, and my studio is Jason Anarchy Games. I’ve been making games for the past 10 years. My first game was Drinking Quest, the original drinking RPG in 2011. I just saved up $6,000, And I was working a fine job, but it was no, I wasn’t passionate about it. Like, you know, look at I’m just gonna kind of print a run of games and see what happens. And then I ran a Facebook ad. It took off quickly, and I’ve been running on that momentum ever since. And I quit that day job. I’ve been at every PAX East since, I think, 2013. It’s consistently been my favorite con to do. There are a lot of good ones. PAX East is my favorite. It just checks off all the boxes. I can drive here from Toronto. You know, it’s a day road trip to get here, but I don’t need to fly. It’s laid out. Well. It’s exciting for me. I like many things here, and it’s run really well. I think the organizers do a great job. Yeah, two new games. One of them is Reap, a game where everyone’s a grim reaper, and they’re trying to reap souls. But it’s also really silly, and it’s got really stylish artwork from Kelly Bastow. They’re all like ridiculous-looking watercolor Reapers. And they all have a theme like there’s Taco Reaper, and you know, Contemplating Life Reaper and, you know, Wi-Fi, Reaper, things like that. But at its core, it’s actually a really strategic game where you’re moving these Reaper meeples around, and you’re secretly bidding on Reap, Sweep or Keep to try and get those souls. So yeah, that’s coming out next month, and we’ve got an early copy showing off here. And then also I mentioned Dragon Quest, the original drinking RPG earlier. That’s been out of print for a little while, but my new game Dragon Quest Six Pack, puts the first six tricky Quest games in one big box. Many of them are now out of print, and they will be available again. And it’s big and beautiful and colorful and loaded with content. JasonAnarchyGames.com Links to all my stuff if you want to check it out. I tweet a lot. I’m @drinkingquest on Twitter. Jason Anarchy Games on Facebook. I’m just @JasonAnarchy on Instagram. Twitter gets all my like just throw away comedy content movies tweeting about how great my biceps are. Different bicep coils in the US just steal all my shower thoughts. But all my quality material, all my really good stuff, goes into my games.

    Michael Schofield  

    Bicep boils. Also, I wanted to like pull out “Reap meeples.” Talk about a guy who has just a good idea after a good idea after a good idea.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, this Jason Anarchy Games, if you’re not familiar with it, dude, like Drinking Quest Six Pack like Heck: the Game, Your Friend is Sad, like Reap. Dude, there was one that people were playing there, which is Your Friend is Sad. And it’s like cards. You played to cheer up your friends. So it’s like all over the place. Yeah, there’s not like, you know what I mean? It’s a bunch of Jason Anarchy games has like a myriad of different types of games there, which was very cool. And it was nice to talk to. The guy’s hilarious too, and he’s very humble.

    Michael Schofield  

    And to think that he just, you know, like, I saved up six grand and decided to blow it all away, which could have turned up poorly.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Oh, yeah. Drinking Quest sells itself.

    Michael Schofield  

    So admirable. Well, that’s what I was talking about. All these ideas are fascinating. Reap is 100% on-brand for me. So like, I’m just in awe of this guy. I’m gonna follow him on Twitter immediately.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, and because it was a little bit ago, you can get Reap now. I think it by it. Yeah, yeah. So it’s only been like maybe less than a month or a little less than a month, but yeah, Reap is available, so you can definitely get it. It is definitely a cool, very cool-looking game. Very cool premise Grim Reaper is fighting against other Grim Reapers for souls.

    Michael Schofield  

    Looking back through like Dead Cells and even Rescued Pets, A.E.G.I.S., and you know, like the Inktale game Aron’s Gift. And it’s like the artist frameable this is so, so fascinating. How neat. I have never wanted to go to a convention so bad. And you know, I come out of like higher ed, right. So, my biggest convention was the American Library Association. Man, this looks like so much fun. Folks, at least the level you’re talking to could be you or me or any, you know, like, like anyone who has a little bit of a dream and a risk tolerance.

    Outro: PAX in summary

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, that’s the humbling thing about it like you can. This is what I like is like when you go and you see like, here’s Sony, here’s Nintendo they bought like six slots of like booths. And then you see the indie game section. It’s like we bought one table. That’s all we can afford. Because we’re just trying to get our game out there. Yeah, right. I can’t even imagine what a table costs. And so anyways, when I see it, I mean, these are like real people who kickstarted who are just play testing, and they are the nicest people. People are the Yeah, they’re the coolest people you want to talk to. They’re down to earth. They’ll tell you how they did it. If you got a game idea, they’d be like, share it with me. You know, the gaming community is very supportive and very, you know, very humble. 

    Michael Schofield  

    Awesome, man.What a journey.

    Tim Broadwater  

    That was the indie game kind of experience at PAX, as I would if anyone kind of follows us on Twitter or Tik Tok. There was a lot of content that I think went out there about PAX because I got to meet the stream queens, which is awesome. They’re like a collective of trans and drag queen kind of streamers. On Twitch, they had a cool panel. There’s, uh, I got to see a lot of really cool cosplay, and some of that’s up on our social media. So and then, you know, our plan is some people know from our social media that we backed Goose Con, which is a new con and Ohio gaming convention that actually now has to happen. And so I think, well, maybe have some presence there. I’m not sure how that’s gonna work out. But we’ve also talked about going to more conventions in the future, playing games and doing some coverage talking to indie game developers. And so maybe another PAX or GenCon or Origins. I don’t know. I would just say stay tuned.

    Michael Schofield  

    What a journeyman. If you dug this episode, let us know. Give us a light heart or follow on your podcatchers of choice. Subscribed if you aren’t to design thinking games, we are on Twitter and Tiktok. Twitch as Design Thinking Games. And if you heard potentially like a really excellent ad spot that Tim or I designed, you too could have one of these. We are fairly affordable and excited to help people elevate their voices a little bit. So consider supporting us in any way you can. Or on patreon.com/designthinkingGames. See you guys on the flip side.

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the Design Thinking Games podcast. You only have so much time, and it means a lot you shared it with us. To connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim. Visit Design Thinking games on tik to Twitch and Twitter. DMs are open. You can also check out design thinking games.com where you can request topics, ask questions or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on.

  • 022: Bloodhunt Battle Royale

    022: Bloodhunt Battle Royale

    Games discussed in this episode:

    • 00:43 Vampire the Masquerade Bloodhunt
    • 02:33 Fortnite
    • 05:18 Vampire the Masquerade
    • 07:20 PUBG
    • 10:43 Apex Legends
    • 11:52 Battlefield V
    • 14:03 Call of Duty
    • 14:12 Fall Guys
    • 19:32 Dead By Daylight
    • 20:56 Tetris 99
    • 25:34 Predator Hunting Grounds
    • 31:23 Hell Let Loose

    Transcript

    Introductory Guy  

    Welcome to design thinking games, a gaming and User Experience podcast card-carrying UXers Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper role-playing games, live-action games and video games. Play through the backlog on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at designthinkinggames.com.

    Vampire: the Masquerade Bloodhunt

    Tim Broadwater  

    Did you download it? Vampire: the Masquerade Bloodhunt?

    Michael Schofield  

    No, but I did preorder it on Steam.

    Tim Broadwater  

    You don’t have to pay for it. It’s free to play.

    Michael Schofield  

    I bought a pack or something. I entered my credit card number for something, so I must have gotten like the I got the special. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    I played three or four games today.

    Michael Schofield  

    Oh my god, tell me, what do you think?

    Tim Broadwater  

    It is like Fortnite but on crack without the building but with vampires, and each character class is a clan. So like a Vanguard is like, a row is like a Brujah and like a Vanguard is like a Nosferatu or something. I’m totally butchering it, but it loads super quick. It is heavy action. And then, in the course of the game, you can literally – if you get killed by another vampire, you get one life, you come back. However, if you come back and you drink the blood of a human, it lets you come back another time. But anytime you drink the blood of a human, and I don’t know if this is in vampire mythology, but there is an organized government entity that hunts the vampires, and so they’re( the Inquisition). Yeah, yeah, kind of the Masquerade. And if you drain a human like you can come back to life again, but then they know it’s like reported, and then they will come after you like tactical dudes will come out you in addition to all the vampires that are gonna hunt you.

    Michael Schofield  

    Is everyone a player other than the tactical dudes?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, everyone is. You are logged into Prague. Whoever this entity is, that is like the Inquisition or whatever. They are burning down the city and smoking you out. And so that’s how the ring, like Fortnite, kind of keeps getting smaller and smaller.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah.

    Tim Broadwater  

    It forces you into the middle of Prague. And because they’re coming and so you are, there’s a story that leads into it, but it’s basically like all the clans are at war with one another, and we’re just like fucking each other up like it’s crazy. And so in addition to that, that’s when this Inquisition or whatever is like, you know, also hunting you, and so it is super fast-paced. It is amazing. You have sniper rifles and shotguns and axes and bats and like dual-wielding pistols. In addition to like, Dude, you can just climb and scale buildings and jump from building to building and suck the blood out to people and use powers to track people and transform and like hide and turn invisible. It’s cool, very cool. My first impressions of it are like this will be hotness people are going to love it. And I think a lot of people are playing it on Twitch right now. I noticed a couple of people that I followed the day it came out. They started twitching it, you know,

    Michael Schofield  

    I’m gonna have to check it out. It seems like what you’re describing is that it’s surprisingly in canon. So there’s even a narrative of Prague under siege, which I think is like an event elsewhere.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I’m interested to see, like once you get you spin it up and play it, I want you to send me a comment or tell me what you think about the story to see how canon is, but it feels pretty canon.

    Michael Schofield  

    You describe it as Fortnite. Is that only because of the battle royale, or is it cartoony?

    Tim Broadwater  

    No, not cartoony at all. The graphics, I thought, were impressive, but just the economy of the action and speed at which you play, and then it forces you like it shrinking the map and forcing you into the middle, which is not always the same place. It always it may shrink you to the left side or may shrink you to the bottom or may shrink you to like this church, just the chair.

    Michael Schofield  

    Can I ask have you played many Battle Royales

    Tim Broadwater  

    Probably not because I’ve tried Fortnite, and I was just like, yeah, yeah, this is never a big, you know, fan. I get the appeal, you know? Yeah, I never liked the thing, but I liked this. I just played like Five games, one right after another. It was good.

    Michael Schofield  

    Oh, that’s interesting. Yeah, it’s. I’m curious for whatever reason, perhaps I had it in my mind because there’s yet another Vampire game coming out or recently released, and I’ve been awash in Vampire the Masquerade stuff. I ended up on vampire Tiktok, so I’m like neck-deep in this stuff again, and I’m enjoying it. I even ordered the vampire rule book because I just got as —

    Tim Broadwater  

    They had a couple of LARPs like Vampire LARPs at PAX East. I was curious for a minute by was piqued. I was like, Can I just go watch but I didn’t go so

    Michael Schofield  

    I suppose my first thought was that I’ve played many Battle Royales. I generally enjoy the genre to a point.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So for me, I don’t know what a battle royale is.\

    Battle Royales as a Genre

    Michael Schofield  

    So Battle Royale is this I think it’s I think I would call it a genre or a category of game style wherein multiplayer imagine you have you know team-based collaborative you have Team Deathmatch if you’ve ever played you know, like one of the shooters Battle Royale is a Hunger Games style of play where potentially you and a couple like a small party like you and maybe two others against everyone else, the resources are things that you have to pick up they may be randomly generated resources or there maybe you know, specific locations that you have to find your way to get there. You insert differently every single time, and after about, you know, a couple of minutes or so, the effect of the ring of play begins to shrink, so you know. So Fortnite is kind of like a fascinating it may not be the originator, but the how this battle royale gameplay emerged into like the mainstream was through this game by I think of the studio, this is off the top of my head, blue origins and their game PUBG and it’s a “public battlegrounds” or something like that. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Heard of it, but I’ve never played it.

    Michael Schofield  

    So the idea of PUBG is that you are it’s kind of a real-world a Fortnite is sort of like cartoony and of course, something like Fortnite has all these or has had all of these events with Marvel and stuff. The idea of PUBG was that you are parachuted in, I believe it was like an ARMA mod or a DayZ mod, but you are parachuted in there’s alike at the beginning of the match. You are all in this like this four engine plane, and it makes its way across the map, which is quite large multi-terrain, and you can parachute out anywhere you like your goal pick up some weapons pick up some armor kill each other be the last person standing all the while the area of play shrinks.

    Tim Broadwater  

    The shrinking area is not a thing that’s distinct or new with Fortnite then.

    Michael Schofield  

    Right, so what you’re describing to me is sort of like this, this battle royale now what is unique is maybe like how they play off so Fortnite – so anyway, PUBG did this got popular PUBG was notoriously had notorious bugs and UX problems to the point whereas you and I have discussed so many times before, as soon as someone comes in and does kind of like meets those basic expectations. It becomes a question. The differentiator becomes like the quality of the experience of the UX, so Fortnite wasn’t always this battle royale style game, but they created a battle royale, and they did it better. And then the Fortnite phenomenon happened, and before that, it pre-existed before it got popular because they had a regular like Team Deathmatch and different build modes. But this battle royale they ganked from PUBG just executed on it. Then you know, you see Battle Royale is kind of everywhere. Another popular one that’s currently popular still is Apex Legends.

    Tim Broadwater  

     And I’ve heard of that as well, but I’ve never played a lot of games in this genre. This is kind of new to me.

    Michael Schofield  

    This is interesting because it is new to you. But this idea the shrinking stuff, the resource constraints, the speed right because worst-case scenario if you tried your Best not to encounter anybody and you just can’t, you still have to escape the ring which is going to drive you closer to other people and eventually you know the ring is gonna get Yeah. And and and yeah and so the way Battle Royales are unique is, you know, how they express these very basic mechanics. So apex, I think this is true for Fortnite. I gotta admit I’m not a Fortnite player because it was too cartoony. But Apex legends, you can have your party of three or up to a party or three pubs, or you can be in a party of four or one against 30 or whatever. The one that let me down because I like my tactical realism. So Battlefield 1, or Battlefield V, or whatever, one of the battlefields recently, I’m sort of written off this, this series Battlefield, they’ve burned me too many times. But they had one called. They had a mode called Firestorm. And that was the idea that was supposed to be kind of like a hyper-realistic first-person shooter, Battle Royale, and basically, you’re in a forest, and the forest is burning down around you, and those are the ruins, so this is interesting that you haven’t experienced this before. Oh, this is your first Battle Royale. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    It is my first battle royale that I’m like, Man, I’m gonna play the kid out of this. I mean, because it looks that fun beginning and then leveling up. Like when I level up a class, I don’t know if this is a battle royale thing, but there’s like a player experience level and then a character experience level. So you as a player have a ranking. But then when I level up my Toreador or my Brujah or my Nosferatu like they their powers become more potent, and you get more things to do and then, so what if I’d leveled up to like level three or four? Like it’s or maybe twice that’s when I played and then it was giving me all this stuff is like you now have visibility and this is unlocked, and so yeah, I don’t know. Well, I’m curious, like when you said that you played a bunch of battle royales, and this is like a genre you like, Sure. Like which ones like what? I’m not going to ask you to favorite because that’s like crappy, but I mean, if you played and played the most. 

    Michael Schofield  

    Well, the one I played the most was PUBG. I think Apex Legends is the smoothest of the ones I’ve played again; caveat: I know Fortnite is the most popular; it’s just too cartoony; I can’t get over it. I don’t want to play it, but Apex Legends of that caliber is the smoothest in terms of no bug-like expression of bugs or anything like that. But I have played the most of PUBG. I’m trying to think of like the others I’ve played; there are several Call of Duty has one. I’m not a big Call of Duty fan etc.

    Tim Broadwater  

    technically speaking is like, you know, Fall Guys, it’s free for everyone. Yeah. Is that classified as a battle royale? I mean, because you’re eliminating people as you go, and I don’t know, Yeah, it’s like it’s online if a battle royale is an online multiplayer, that’s a Last Man Standing kind of thing, you know, or survival at the pit when I mean fuck it there’s only ever one winner.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, it’s even listed: Fall Guys Ultimate Knockout is a platform Battle Royale game, that’s it. That’s exactly what it is, man.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I love Fall Guys. I did not even know that it was a battle royale because it’s as fun as athletic competition.

    Michael Schofield  

    To compare so, it’s like you know to take the mountain top view, and you look down before you on your right you see fall guys on the left you see Vampire the Masquerade Bloodhunt compare them.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so I guess I always thought and I the reason why I never and maybe this is true for other people because but you know, I always thought as a third person army tactical shooter whatever. And then I never you know Call of Duty, and I’m sure if Call of Duty probably is in this genre or some of the games of Call of Duty or maybe in this genre I don’t know but like Apex legends and then you know PUBG like you said or Battlefield or like I just stayed away from this genre because of the military tactical realism which is great for some people but just not my jam. But yeah, if you’re talking about the genre, this multiplayer video game is a survival or last man standing kind of thing. Like, I do like Fall Guys. I think fall Guy is fun. And then they keep coming out with seasons. Yeah. And so with seasons, there’s new content and new boards. Never played Fortnite a couple of times. But then yeah, there I think there will be seasoned to Vampire the Masquerade blood hunt, hunting. And I remember this about like, you know, Fortnite is that despite the cartooniness like what people loved about it is like you had total costume creation in it. Like, you could be a ninja turtle, or you could be John Wick, or you could be Sailor Moon, or you could be like a goth cheerleader. You could just build any, you know, kind of costume you want. And that’s this is my very limited exposure to the genre of Battle Royale games,

    Michael Schofield  

    What you’re describing, so even the character creation, like aspect is part of it. What, um, so yeah, the because I know that’s Rewinding to season one, that’s a big thing that you care about is customization customizability of your avatar. And that’s a thing so you can unlock different like, generally, like, I’m so you kind of stalled me when you said that, like, your character becomes more potent, which is, which is in line like basically, as your vampire levels up, you become more of a like a boss ass bitch. But in the like, generally, in like, PUBG, Call of Duty Warzone or fighting or Battlefield Firestorm, which, you know, I think was a failure, Fortnite and stuff. The character potency remains the same. But you know, your skins become cooler, and stuff like that. But what it seems like to me, I’m going to have to check this out, is that maybe like, if your character in Bloodhunt does increase in strength, or at least I like, unlock certain abilities. That rings true to me for something like Dead by Daylight, which I thought was cool. Because I played other. I don’t know what you call that style of game that Dead by Daylight is, but 

    Tim Broadwater  

    I think that is a MOBA. Like that. There’s no like the last person survived or like asynchronous horror,

    Michael Schofield  

    But you’re, but you level up your class, right? 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, you do unlock things as you go. Yeah. And then I will say, you know, yeah, Fall Guys, it’s all cost. It’s costume customization. You’re all the same. You all literally can just jump, slide and run. That’s it. What it appeared to be for Vampire the Masquerade Bloodhunt is that if they are putting together matches, or Battle Royale matches, and it’s like, oh, rounding to the closest level, like day by day like this as a MOBA. If you’re on level 1 through 12, and then, you know, that’s 50 players, and then after that, it’s like, okay, 13 through 20. Sure. I’m assuming those abilities that unlock are scaled. Do you know what I mean? So everyone’s going to get, you know, there, everyone’s going to get them. And so it won’t be fair, it won’t be unfair, because everyone at a similar level will be grouped anyway. Yeah, that’s what I was wondering. Yeah. And there’s another one that I found out. I just googled it too. And there’s another one that I play a lot. And you didn’t know it was? No, like Tetris. 99. Yeah.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, no, I haven’t played it. But I see it on Twitch a lot.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, it’s free on Switch. It’s streamed all the time. Yeah. And it is literally like, you have 100 people that log in, and then you’re playing Tetris. And every single time you get a line score, multiple line score, it adds it like screws other players, and you’re just trying to screw the other players to kill them as fast as possible. And then, you know, there can only be one Tetris winner who’s, and it’s the person who survives the longest. Yeah, it’s

    Michael Schofield  

    like classic survival of the fittest, or I guess since you made the reference. It’s classic Highlander.

    Tim Broadwater  

    You’re right. That is totally it.

    Michael Schofield  

    I think there are two mechanics that I think are interesting about Battle Royales that impact their longevity. One is to your point like what is the again, I don’t have a phrase for this, but it’s not. It’s not how it levels; it’s like, What? What? What changes what brings you in like, it like when we’re talking about like, RPGs we’re talking about or like, or specifically something like World of Warcraft? For the division is like, what is like the end game content the point where after you level up, what changes about the event, what special circumstances are there that, like keep the keep you keep players returning in for so so PUBG. One of the reasons that PUBGI think failed and it’s still going on, maybe they fixed it. But one of the reasons that Fortnite was able to slip in under this is that PUBG was the same map was a single map, same gameplay for months and months and months, right, like nothing changed, no events. And what Fortnite did kind of expertly is they not only had like events, and it wasn’t just skin on the original map, like, Oh, now it’s nighttime, or whatever, but it’s like, it’s like, bam, here’s fucking Thanos like, he’s part of your game. And he’s going to snap his fingers, or he’s going to merc all of you bitches. And you know, and then, you know, I guess it’s kind of dovetailed with that. The thing that makes a battle royale stand out is its engineering. So because it’s interesting to watch like, as a product engineer or a product manager or UX person is that over time, you really can see the engineering of one of these games precisely based on how well and unique the events are. And of course, like, you know, whether or not there are any bugs or problems of balance throughout the game, PUBG failed on both and got eclipsed by all of these other games. But something like Fortnite does it pretty expertly. And like I said, you can appreciate the quality of that engineering of the game because their events are truly unique. Like, and, and bananas, they changed the entire tactics of the map. So the time and like what I’ll be curious to see about Bloodhunt is like, Well, right now, you know, Prague is on fire. That’s the theme. What’s the next one? Right? Yeah,

    Tim Broadwater  

    there could be, like, werewolves at it. That would be bad. 

    Michael Schofield  

    There are werewolves in World of Darkness. Right?

    Tim Broadwater  

    100%. So

    Michael Schofield  

    if a werewolf of flux on people up, though, like,

    Tim Broadwater  

    well, that’s the thing. So if it’s literally an agent of chaos, where there’s one, you know, that basically you can maybe stun it, but you can never kill it, you know? Then it’s like, Okay, we have to run away from it.

    Tim Broadwater  

    when you play Predator Hunting Grounds, that’s asynchronous horror like Dead by Daylight. You have four Marines and one predator or one killer in for survivors, right? Much like Friday the 13th with Jason versus the counselors, however, what I like about predator hunting grounds is that each of the type of marine you are, it’s like, this is a scout. No, this is a sniper. This is like the guy who’s the medic. They all had different kinds of abilities, right? Yeah. And so what I noticed about Vampire the Masquerade Bloodhunt is like the Nosferatu can hide, he can use stealth, he can blend in. However, we’re, you know, the Brujah is much more of a melee fighter. Okay, right. And like everyone can wield bats, and everyone can shoot guns, you know, but there’s also a type of vampire which I did not, I don’t remember the clan, but there was a tracking one. And so it’s kind of like your trek to were like, (was it Gangrel)? I don’t know. I wouldn’t know if you said this because I can’t remember. And I literally only played it a little bit. But that’s a vampire who literally senses vampires and then can track them. So what happens is, is essentially like, you can drain the blood of humans and just kind of get more life he’ll come back. Sure. But if you kill another vampire, you can diablerie them.

    Michael Schofield  

    They have diablerie in this game.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I think it gives you you do it. I got it done to me a couple of times. And so it’s cool. I want to get your thoughts on it, you know, but because it does have kind of it has classes that have different skills, but there are also levels, but it’s a level playing field. But I didn’t even get involved enough to see, like, costume customization, but I would assume that that’s like, you know, this is the first release, if it’s popular, and it seems to be because, as I know from PAX East, what makes a game dictates its popularity. And its success is how many people add it to their PlayStation or Steam wish list or whatever the other equivalent is for whatever platform interesting. So based on how many people have it on their wish list, then they’re like, oh, This is gonna be successful or not. And so I know many people have already been playing it and streaming it. So I assume there are costume pieces that you can make and customize. So not every Nosferatu or Gangrel has to look the same. I feel like there’s something player experience-wise, not just that tickles the one side of a coin, which is like, the fun enjoyment piece of like these quick 15 Second matches, you know what I mean? But then also the other side, which is the competition to see like, how can how long can you last? Like, how good are you? And like, none of the games are ever longer than like, what? 5 or 15 minutes, something like that. And so it’s really fun because you can just keep playing, you can get like four or five games in, you know, in a half-hour.

    Michael Schofield  

    Wow. I mean, yeah, because when you play like PUBG, you’re going to have a map that goes on for, you know, 30 minutes. And so, one of the things I think is true about a good battle royale is that you can, you know, the goal is to be the last person standing. And you do not have to do that through violence. Right. So, one of the Yeah, you can just hide, right? Well, you can, you can try to hide or gather resources, like, you know, and then sort of there’s, there’s an element of like, the luck of the draw, like one of my favorites, sessions. Like, like back before PUBG was getting shut on by everything before Fortnite, like showed what everyone would battle royale could be was basically I was playing to man servers, so duos, and, and we ended up being in my partner and I ended up being in the top 10. And at this point, the ring had narrowed down into the kind of like, like, the edge of like a village, right.

    Like, so there’s a little bit of like, like open grasslands, and incorporated a couple of houses. And, the winner, like somebody, basically spent a good chunk of at least the last 10 minutes of the map or whatever. Luckily, in the right enough spot, like where they just were in one of these buildings, they held it down. What happens is like the reality is like the better equipped in, the better position person one so so yeah, like we just got mowed down because somebody had like, like, acquired, they had taken over a house that someone else had been camping in. So it had a ton of resources in there. They had all the armor they had like level three helmets, level three backpacks, level three bottle body armor, and they were poking their like big ass like a machine gun out of the window, you know, just mowing down, people were coming up, and then you end up just, you know, dying because they’re in a much better position than you. And like so. But the idea is that they could have one, and maybe they did kill only one person the entire time. The circle does narrow down. This is, you know, we’re talking about genre. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    To force you into a death field, and what have you first? Yeah. Okay.

    Michael Schofield  

    But you’re not new to it. You’ve never seen you participate in several, but you’ve just never liked connecting the dots. And now I guarantee that when you go in and watch Bloodhunt, or you know, so you end up playing another one, you will see this genre for what it is, and you’ll be like, oh, I now have a word for this. That’s cool. Because like, you know, it’s not often that you see as a new type of gameplay like something is like some kind of Team Deathmatch, even you know, my current game of choice right out of the evening is remaining Hell Let Loose. This team deathmatch, right, is squad-based. You know, you can put like some feathers on the cap to like to make it unique, but it’s not super often when you have like a new type of multiplayer game, right? And that’s something that’s like pretty cool. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    So we very much appreciate your listening. We’re a budding podcast, so if you could rate us or subscribe, we would appreciate it. We are on Twitch, Tiktok and Twitter, and please feel free to connect with us there. We also have super affordable advertising spaces as well as Patreon tiers. Apart from that, you can connect with us on designthinkinggames.com.

    Michael Schofield  

    And maybe you’ll find us in Bloodhunt. Bleah.

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the Design Thinking games podcast. You only have so much time, and it means a lot you shared it with us. To connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim, visit Design Thinking Games on Tiktok, Twitch, and Twitter. DMs are open. You can also check out designthinkinggames.com, where you can request topics, ask questions or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on.

  • 021:  Roguelike and Roguelike Hybrid Games

    021:  Roguelike and Roguelike Hybrid Games

    Games Discussed in this episode:

    • 02:32 Rogue
    • 04:57 King’s Quest
    • 10:50 Hades
    • 12:07 Binding of Isaac
    • 14:04 Faster Than Light
    • 19:36 Crypt of the Necrodancer
    • 19:48 Tomb of Horrors
    • 20:19 BIT.TRIP RUNNER
    • 22:41 Cadence of Hyrule
    • 24:29 Cuphead
    • 27:53 Mass Effect
    • 29:29 Moonlighter

    Introductory Guy  

    Welcome to design thinking games, a gaming and User Experience podcast card-carrying UXers Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield examined the player experience of board games, pen and paper role-playing games, live-action games and video games. Play through the backlog on your podcatcher of choice. And on the web at designthinkinggames.com.

    Tim Broadwater  

    We are talking about the history behind a certain sub-genre of game, roguelike games. I know that I’ve played a handful of them before that we’ve talked about. Have you played any of these games, or are you familiar with the genre?

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, I’m familiar with the genre a little bit. So roguelikes are not my cup of tea. The Binding of Issac is famous, but I’ve never played it. So the ones that I’ve played are like, I think the biggest one the biggest, the most famous roguelike that I’ve played through, is this is an older game that came out I think the 2010s Potentially earlier, but I think that early 2010 is called Faster Than Light or FTL. But I play a lot of games that are, I don’t know, how we would phrase it roguelike-like, there are certain things like around like permadeath, and reorientation, and things like that, that are core parts of roguelike. And I’ve played a lot of games like that.

    Tim Broadwater  

    That’s one of the things that I think is interesting. The definitions for roguelike games are kind of all over the place. We are throwing back 42 years, like looking at the 1980s. Right. And, you know, the term “roguelike, to my understanding of it, was kind of a, a term that’s taken from a type of game. And some of the games at that time are like hack Moria, Angband, and Rogue. And so the term rogue, or roguelike, specifically comes from the 1980 games.  

    Michael Schofield  

    That’s pretty early.

    Tim Broadwater  

    And the game itself was called Rogue, and it came out by epics. I’m not sure. Are you familiar with a game?

    Michael Schofield  

    I’m not all of this stuff came out. Before me, Tim. Like before I even existed.

    Tim Broadwater  

     That’s right. How old are you?

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, I’m 36. I’m 1985. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    I’m 77, so.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, so I started playing in the early 90s when I think those good video game memories started taking root. So you know, many of these early games definitely influenced )television or Atari). So I well, I had I, I had an Atari but my first real you know, hundreds of hours gaming system was, you know, the original Nintendo. And then from that, I went to Genesis, I think. And so my history kind of like, kind of like falls under those pipelines. But I had an early PC. And there’s some category where games like Diablo are roguelike or roguelike-like, right. And so I feel that like my, my deepest experience in this style of the genre, although I’ve played several, is more in experiencing the games that are inspired from it, like the second generation or third generation of games that came out of this kind of like the original design in the early to mid-80s.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so there’s a whole it’s interesting. Yeah. So so, let me describe it for you a little bit. There are a lot of PC games. And I think we’ve been talking about this on Twitter a little bit. Because if you think of your kind of story-based text games, right, like King’s Quest or Space Quest or games that are kind of from Ken and Roberta Williams, which you know, are kind of text games, and you would, they worked on computers, and you could type in like open chest, hit enter and, and open stuff. And then you could type in, look around, and it’ll kind of give you some description. So that’s even like 19. That’s the mid-80s. Right? So like, kind of when you’re born. And if you kind of roll back a little bit before that, Rogue is one of the first computer games, like I said, for Commodore 64, or kind of Atari. And to describe what it looks like, it is literally a screen made up of ASCII characters. So like, you know, via Yeah, American Standard Code for Information Interchange. So it’s, it’s kind of like the ASCII art, or ASCII if I’m saying that correctly. And so the map that you are exploring, like, in the dungeon, literally is made up of hashtags, hyphens and ampersands, and symbols. And so you at the bottom, some text tells you your level, How much gold do you have your hit points, you know, experienced things like that. But you literally are just moving around, and as you’re moving around, the environment made from hyphens and different character symbols is being generated. So procedurally generated or, and that’s kind of Rogue. And it also came out on the Tandy, I believe, so, but it is a 1980 game. And the term roguelike comes from that game itself, rogue 1980 epics. But to your point, like when you say roguelike-like games, there are when people talk about, you know, roguelike, I think there are general characteristics, but it’s really vague, right. Permadeath, like you mentioned, is one of them, but randomly generated levels, or creatures or maps, right. And so, I think, I also think that kind of resource management is a piece of it, as well. So I really think my mind goes more so and I think this is probably what it is to most people is that you go to randomly generated maps and monsters, and the restart or permadeath is something as well. And you kind of have to proceed with caution because you have to start over, you know, if you die here or fail.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, cuz I guess like, for me, like I, you know, the biggest takeaway of like, the roguelike-like, aspect is the permadeath. This is something I feel like, the idea that you have a character who can accrue resources. There’s a deep resources management aspect to it, but when you die, it’s gone, and all of your stuff is gone. And there are certain, you know, certain cool ways where you might be able to go and get it back. However, that sense of mortality, like, and, and kind of, like, finite, is not right.

    Tim Broadwater  

    No, I know what you mean,

    Michael Schofield  

    you don’t, you know, saving, you’re saving your games and, you know, game over these kinds of like things that, you know, as games are getting increasingly more forgiving. Because as, as we kind of explore, you know, what, you know, the many different toggles and switches of the capital P capital E, the player experience, you know, some people don’t want the sense of, like Mortal anxiety to be a part of their game. But that’s the biggest takeaway from me. And I think if I think about it, the games that I have played are probably randomly generated. I know, there’s like a fine line of debates. You know, purists will say, like, the random generation is the roguelike part. Maybe more the, you know, like, but there’s a there’s kind of like, a scale.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I would agree. People say, Oh, it’s a regular game, or that’s a roguelike game or a roguelike. And then, when you have mashups of multiple genres, I’m not a fan of regular game roguelike games. I’ve played just a handful of them. However, it becomes really exciting when that genre is matched up with other genres.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I know that we’ve recently talked a lot about Hades. Hades was nominated for a lot of awards. It is a roguelike. Meaning that so basically, you are the son of Hades. And you kind of find out that your dad slept with Persephone. But Persephone is no longer in Hades anymore. And so you’re trying to escape Hades. Or hell, to find your mom and just find out what’s going on. And every time you die, it doesn’t matter if you are in Tartarus, or in Elysium, or like, whatever part you’re trying to get out, you know, of the underworld. You have to start over. However, I think one of the things that we see a lot in modern, like roguelike games, is that you can buy things or advance outside of the run, quote, unquote, the rotten meaning that the one attempt you get.

    Michael Schofield  

    And so that’s interesting that sorry, a quick interjection. So that’s, that’s a modern roguelike thing. Right, that’s like, or is that a convention that goes way back?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so. So with Binding of Isaac, which is actually actually a very sad story. You know, if you’ve played the game, you’re kind of thrown into, you have to kind of attack to get away from your abusive mother, and you’re thrown into the basement, and you’re trying to escape the basement, and you’re just to do that, you’d have to kind of go through different levels of the basement to escape every time you restart, you restart, right? However, you can unlock or purchase things outside of the run with games like Hades. So you’re at some point, let’s say, with Hades, you know, you can buy permanent things, or you can find things that are permanent, and then that will help you with the run. But essentially, every time you start to run, you’re like, got no cash, you’ve got a set amount of life, and you and that’s it. But you can, over time, kind of grinding or just doing runs, you can accrue things, or you’ll run into like stores and buy stuff. And you can also increase your health, unlock new weapons, and unlock abilities that you can kind of like you have like objects or artifacts that you can before you set out on a quote-unquote, run, you can equip that will help you in some way. And so there are ways to kind of, you know, I think maybe what you’re saying is like modern roguelike games, there are ways that it makes it a little bit easier. But it’s still the roguelike to where permadeath or reset. And every map, every level, every monster, everything’s kind of procedurally generated or randomly generated. So what is the game you’re talking about?

    Michael Schofield  

    The one that I’ve like, played through all the, like, all the way through that I spent quite a long time in. I just had to look it up because I thought it was like the 2010s, and I was right. It was 2012 2013. There’s basically this kind of like science fiction ship-based combat game called The FTL, faster than light. And the idea, I mean, the conceit is is is basically that you are, you are the ship, and you know, you have like a small crew, and your goal is to I think like reconnect with like the Federation, which has several jumps, but or waypoints like away from where you are. And that basically, like as you navigate through space, you burn fuel, burn things like beacons, and encounter hostile forces. And you have to navigate your way through successful completion of the objectives, of course, gives you more resources with its to do things how you assemble your crew, you know, it’s, it is whatever the number of the route you must take to really kind of join the Federation is random. And the opponents that you encounter along the way are random, and there’s no restart, right, so like if your ship is defeated or destroyed or you run out of resources, and you drift into the emptiness of space.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So every track is completely random and different. Yeah.

    Michael Schofield  

    And as I think about it, that resource management may be more than the permadeath for FTL because I didn’t really like account. Like, I don’t identify with an individual and like this particular game, like it is the ship, right? My goal is like I am, I contain multitudes, but like, what I really like about this kind of style of game, which I think does appeal to those who like resource management, and I do is, is that now what sucks is that you can have like, you can start with a couple of like, unfortunately, lucky or unlucky, like, jumps early in the game. And you’re, you’re pretty fucked, unless you’re incredibly clever, and can, like overcome kind of like the big constraints or the foes that you encounter. But yeah, so it’s just this kind of like, nice little like FTL game, and there is we’re sorry, space combat spacefaring game, and appeals to my science fiction, my enjoyment of science fiction, and it has like a concise narrative. So that you can you the story you tell as your own as you go, which might be another factor of like, well, roguelike means right, because I guess the with the idea of like, random map generation, there’s only so much controlled narrative that the game designer can infuse the game with. And so this kind of dovetails maybe a little bit with like our last episode in which we’re talking about journaling, RPGs, and things of that sort where the story emerges from the play as opposed to you experiencing a story.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So talking about like, how roguelike has different meanings to different people. But the style has things that are like reset or permadeath. And then procedurally are randomly generated, and then resource management. I think what we see a lot of is what excites me is like that genre when it’s attached or combined with another genre. And so, I don’t know if you’ve ever heard of the game Crypt of the NecroDancer Have you?

    Michael Schofield  

    That sounds like an old-school d&d module. Looking it up now.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, it does sound like what is the tomb of horrors, the very first guy. Yeah, dungeon dragons kind of thing. I mean, it definitely has that feel like, oh, yeah, Crypt of the NecroDancer. Wow. So essentially, do you like a lot of rhythm games?

    Michael Schofield  

    I do. Yeah. Yep.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so there’s like Bit Trip Runner and bit beat runner. And you know, and then there’s Guitar Hero and a lot of other things to where it’s a rhythm-based kind of game 100% But uh, they’re so they basically combined Crypt of the NecroDancer combines a roguelike, kind of procedurally generated dungeons and monsters with a rhythm game. And so essentially, I would highly recommend it like, it’s super cheap, and it’s an indie game. And, but you can only move or like, you not only move, but you want to move and on the beat. And so it becomes very strategic to where you are going like left, and then as your monster comes up, you have to dodge them, and you have to attack them on the beat. And even as you like, dig through the tunnels or uncovered chests, or unlock different things, you literally are doing it through rhythm. There are parts where the music speed and tempo increase to where you have to move faster. Or maybe you get hit by a monster, and it slows you down. But the longer you stay on beat, you know, the more of a damaging kind of buff you get. Oh, that’s cool. Kind of. Yeah, and it has a lot of really cool mechanics, and I think there’s even I think there are spin-off games of it. But what I like about it is like when you go down to the tomb, and you, let’s say you fail if you come back and you did have some gold, and you did have some diamonds or stuff. There is like a town that you can buy like a better shield in or a better weapon or more health or what Ever. And so then when you go on your next kind of run or dungeon crawl, it actually, like I’m saying with Hades like, you can kind of give yourself buffs and equipment and stuff outside of the roguelike procedurally generated dungeon, which increases your chance of being successful as well as you know, enjoying kind of your the gameplay a little bit more.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, that sounds like a blast.

    Tim Broadwater  

    And I believe that Crypt of NecroDancer has partnered with Nintendo at some point and Zelda. And they actually came out with Cadence of Hyrule. And so Cadence of Hyrule is literally like a Zelda game. But it is the same mechanics where you can only move and attack and fight bosses in rhythm and move around. Same kind of time tempo, increase, decrease, whatever and the character from Crypt of the NecroDancer teams up with Link and Zelda. And so, like, I actually think her name is Cadence. I apologize for that. Yeah, her name is Cadence. And I think she, which is kind of interesting for the rhythm fair, but she Cadence joins Link and Zelda in the Cadence of Hyrule. So it’s definitely worth checking out. It’s super fun, and it’s also kind of challenging.

    Michael Schofield  

    What makes it like so, so? So how does like the roguelike part? Like, really like complement the rhythm-based part? Um, generally like, like, as long as you enjoy the loop? That is, the aspect of the repeatable gameplay, right?

    Tim Broadwater  

    100% Yeah, 100% I think there’s this old. Then, the thing that I think with roguelike games that are the appeal is, you know, when I am playing a Mario game, or a Zelda game, or whatever game, I know that when I get to this point, in the 3d map, a guy is hiding behind his crate, or if I do three jumps, and that extended jump on the side-scrolling game, I know the monsters that are on the screen, so you can kind of to some degree, memorize it. And that’s kind of the appeal in the difficulty of Cuphead. Right? Because Cuphead is, is just like it’s you have to play it perfect. And its memorization Cupheads appeal is that you can memorize, and you just have to get it perfect. It’s a perfect run, right? That is completely off the table with a roguelike game because, in a game like Crypt of the NecroDancer, every level is different, every map is different, and every monster that populates is different. Now you can think like, oh, when I encounter this type of snake, I have to block the attack, or when I encountered this, you know, kind of skeleton night, I have to go around him and attack from the back. You can think about how to deal with specific enemies, right? And you can think about like, Okay, I encountered this type of wall I can dig through it, or this is like something that requires a bomb, but everything is random. And so the skill is not in the memorization of the board and the jumping so like when you see like the people who believe beat Super Mario Brothers three and like under two minutes because they can just remember epically run because they memorize it. Yeah, I think the appeal of roguelike games is that it is random. Yeah. And so it really comes down to like, well what is what are you testing? Are you testing memorization, or can you deal with problems on the fly that are generated for you and every run or loop or whatever you want to call it, you know, challenges you, and you may not you may suck really bad and not even get past the second level or maybe you may be one time you do so great you get to you can beat the game you know or get through all the levels or the boss fights so I think that’s the uphill but with crypto NecroDancer like the fact that it’s put to music it makes it just make you do it quicker and makes you do it on a beat and makes it a little bit more enjoyable.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, I feel like there’s something like really appealing to like the potential of like, like aggressive Guitar Hero and like fighting enemies and like I love the idea I might see if I can find this on Steam because I love the idea. I love the idea of attacking rhythm. There are games like Assassin’s Creed which are, you know, without music, rhythm-based combat or something like that, but something like this seems just incredibly fun and nostalgic.

    Tim Broadwater  

    As listeners who’ve, you know, tuned in to the last season of the podcast know you challenged me last year because Mass Effect Legendary Edition came out 3 Epic Games, very sci-fi narrative-based amazing games, and you kind of given me gave me the season to complete it all three, which I did. And then

    Michael Schofield  

    in hindsight, it almost doesn’t seem fair because, like, potentially, I gave you a 100-hour assignment. Oh, man, like, many games to punish even on the story mode. It’s like I was so like, when you’re like, oh, man, I did it. I was like, Oh, shit, really? Like, I also didn’t expect it.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, but I also put it in story mode for easy combat. And so like, every boss encounter was just like, Okay, this is like, and I do that with a lot of games. That’s not the game has to be rare for me not to do something like that. But like Horizon Zero Dawn or Forbidden West, I put those uneasy because it’s like, Man, I’m just here to have fun. I’m not really looking to have grueling combat. But having said that, there is a phenomenal, phenomenal roguelike hybrid game that I love I just got exposed to in the last couple of years. And I don’t know if you’ve heard of it. And that’s the one that I want to slap you with a gauntlet across the face for you to try. And the game is called Moonlighter. Have you ever heard of Moonlighter?

    Michael Schofield  

    Moonlighter’s, an action RPG? No, I’ve never heard of this.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Okay, so my plug, which will not spoil anything for you. But by the end of this season, and probably not, it won’t pick the whole season. But by the end of the season, that is the game that I want you to beat. I think the player experience is phenomenal on it. It’s a roguelike. But to give you a hint, that doesn’t like spoil anything. You are, by day, a person who runs a shop and like a run downtown. Yeah. And at night, you go into dungeons, like Legend of Zelda 1 style, and harvest parts have monsters and treasures and equipment and artifacts and whatever. And then you put that in your shop to sell. Oh, that’s crazy. And so it has this whole economics principle to it, combined with a roguelike. But then also, there’s a third piece that I would say to which is kind of a community or social development piece to it. So as you are in this abandoned town, and you’ve been kind of given this, you’ve inherited this rundown store. You are the crazy shopkeeper who goes into the dungeons to fight monsters and get treasure so you can sell things in town. How you sell things depends on the laws of economics like supply and demand, what people need and what people are looking for. And there are certain things that you can charge crazy prices for, but if you actually sell too much of the same project, the product you are going to run your own price down. But the other side of that twofold is the socioeconomics piece and social good piece, which is you’re slowly revitalizing this town with your shop and your business by reinvesting into the town. And what you find out through the dungeons and through the games to find out what is going on will blow your mind. 

    Michael Schofield  

    is there like a real there’s like a store like an encapsulating story to this?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Oh yeah, there is a whole thing like what you find out, so I don’t want to ruin anything. But there’s definitely a story about you and your shop, and you’ve inherited it, and you know you’re in a town that has like me near caves or mines that have like monsters and treasures and so people adventurers do try to go into this mind to like, find its treasures and survive. I, but you are doing that as a shopkeeper to sell to make a profit. But then you’re also using that money to reinvest into your town to grow your town. It is amazing, it is so fulfilling, and it is fun. And it is a not punishing roguelike game because two things one, there are things that you can do outside of the game that help you. So every time you kind of delve into the dungeons, so to speak, you can kind of put on a better weapon or a better armor, or you can better equip yourself, right? But then the fact that there’s a whole eCommerce like, or commerce, not eCommerce, but a commerce side of it in the game where you’re selling and pricing and supply and demand, but then you’re also revitalizing the town. That is what really made me enjoy it, like a very phenomenal game. I highly suggest it. If you’ve never played Moonlighter, please do so. And that is the challenge that I give you bike for this season two of Design Thinking Games beat Moonlighter, and we’ll talk about it.

    Michael Schofield  

    Like, let me let’s make a prediction here. So I just bought it. And I’m downloading it now. I already got the extended edition, which was only like, like, $4 more. And when I look at Moonlighter, I feel a sense of dread. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Oh, no, no. I know Dead by Daylight. I know. Cuphead. I know. Dark Souls. And I am not like brutal punishing for brutal punishing sake, if there’s no chance of progress. I will say that this game, Moonlighter is not difficult. You can definitely beat it. It’s super fun. And there are so many different parts of the game that are enjoyable. 

    Michael Schofield  

    This is definitely a genre that I don’t play a lot of. And so what I’m going to try to do is like in subsequent episodes, maybe we’ll have the Moonlighter moment. And I can get Moonlighter update. Yeah, like we’re like, where I am and how it’s and how it’s going. I’m really excited to like experience this a little bit more because, like I said, my experience with roguelike is really more like in the games that stress the permadeath, like, you know, that’s what they’re really like paying attention to.

    Tim Broadwater  

    If I can do all three Mass Effects, dude, you can do moonlight, you can do it. And I think I highly suspect that it will tickle the product designer in you. Yeah, it’ll harken back to some old-school gaming, and it’s really beautifully — like a fan of pixel art. It’s a beautifully rendered pixel art, so I will be surprised if you just rage quit it so so I am comfortable in what you know we’ve talked about in previous episodes and seasons about what totally you are against in gaming, and I think you will be fine with us.

    Michael Schofield  

    All right, well, I think that is our cue, so next episode, should you all choose to join us? Please do we talk about something and see how my adventure with Moonlighter is going? Will I be howling? Perhaps. Oh my God. Because I think he gave us your cup of tea, please consider supporting us on Patreon at patreon.com/designthinkinggames, where you can get episodes like this a whole week early without ads. Of course, if you like our ad reads, We put a lot of work into making good ad reads. Just be sure you subscribe on your podcatcher of choice, Spotify, Apple, Google Play, Overcast your cup of tea, but wherever it is, be sure you star heart or favorite as you can and if you could be so kind as to leave us a nice review that will help shine the algorithm favorably upon us. We release frequently. We are on social media sometimes. And recently, we’ve been like posting a little bit to tick-tock here I am just a delightful, delightful old shopkeeper, Daddy Daddy behind the desk with wooden floors a little patina of dust. I’ve just turned the closed sign. As the last customer walked out, it went ding ding ding as the store closed. What the fuck is happening here on Design Thinking Games? I’m not sure. And then I gaze out thankfully at the passers-by in town, grateful to be here but then the clouds part And what is it that I see a full moon.

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the Design Thinking Games podcast, you only have so much time, and it means a lot you shared it with us to connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim. Visit Design Thinking games on tick-tock twitch and Twitter. DMs are open. You can also check out design thinking games.com where you can request topics, ask questions or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on.