Archives: Episode

  • 020: Sexy Blood for Pin Daddy

    020: Sexy Blood for Pin Daddy

    Games discussed in this episode:

    • 05:22 One Thousand Year Old Vampire
    • 13:52 MAGfest
    • 14:46 Sailor Moon
    • 15:27 Betrayal at House on the Hill
    • 16:13 Unknown
    • 17:38 Pandemic
    • 19:55 Forbidden Desert
    • 23:02 Casting Shadows
    • 24:45 Elden Ring
    • 27:38 Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice
    • 28:36 Hades

    Introductory Guy  

    Welcome to design thinking games, a gaming and User Experience podcast. Card-carrying UXers, Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield examined the player experience of board games, pen and paper role-playing games, live-action games, and video games. Play through the backlog on your podcatcher of choice. And on the web, at design thinking games.com.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I know that we had a question going on during COVID times. And it’s not always easy to go out to your local game shop and play, you know, board games or tabletop games with other people. Additionally, people are less hesitant to come over to your house and do a board game night. I think that’s changing, of course, with the times. But it begs the question that I think we asked each other: what is the player experience like for single-player role-playing games? And have either one of us played them before? And like, what are some really great examples of such? 

    Michael Schofield  

    This is a huge umbrella. You can talk about like the Witcher 3, as a single-player RPG, there are huge ones, Mass Effect, etc.   I’m kind of excluding those. And I’m kind of an I’m personally sort of interested in like the single-player tabletop RPG, like the rolling of dice, or the flipping of cards or something like that, where there’s no programmatic response and is more it has less in common with a witcher or an Elden ring, then it does a choose your own adventure style book where it’s self-directed, and it’s self-motivated. You have to have the will to take the next step. And it’s solo. It is Solitaire, right? I’m sure people know this game. I don’t know if Gen Z knows because they didn’t have to grow up with computers in which Solitaire and Minesweeper were the only games that were baked in on it. But you know, it’s the idea of burning time. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    I think that most games that come out are video games, right? Yeah. Are single-player. There’s just, that’s a market. And, and I know, we talked in previous episodes about, like, winner  Game of the Year, last year, which was it takes two which literally requires two players to play. And this episode is almost kind of, I think, on the flip side of that, it’s like, okay, if 90% of video games are, you know, single-player, Horizon Zero, Dawn, Ghosts of Tsushima. You know, Cyberpunk, whatever, there’s so many. Yeah, I want to focus on tabletop games that are that way. So. And I think that’s how we got to this kind of category. So I’m just gonna say, dazzle me with your wares. Show me what your example is?

    Michael Schofield  

    I have a couple because I’ve been playing these on my own. And one of the things I want to say in their defense is that you know, something like The Witcher or, like you said, Ghosts of Tsushima. I have teams of up to 100 or hundreds, like people who, throughout the product, either engineer or design or make the strategic decisions or write it. And it is ultimately a single-player end-user experience, but it is a service companies provide. And so I’ve been playing this our last episode talks a little bit about how amused and interested we are in this burgeoning small TTRPG creator community that’s coming up. And so I’ve been playing like a couple of games that I discovered through here, meaning that they were designed by one person for one person’s consumption. I’m just kind of like practicing this as an I’m coming into this with like an added respect for the art of this kind of design.

    In the same way that a novel writer is an individual telling a story, and ultimately even if it is read by many people, it is experienced individually. So the game that like I’m having fun within, in a particular way, is this single-player … I don’t even know how to describe it. It’s like a single-player journaling RPG called One Thousand Year Old Vampire. The conceit is that you are telling the story as yourself of a vampire from just before you were brought into this dark world of immortality through history and into the modern age. What’s kind of compelling is that this is similar to choosing your own adventure in that it is really a game designed around a series of prompts. You roll some dice, and a random prompt emerges. You are pointed to a particular prompt. And that prompt gives you a situation that you then have to solve with the resources that your 1000-year-old vampire has on them, the various skills they have prepared at that moment, and the memories and situational awareness they have as part of that. And so what’s really cool is that as you progress, you know, you create your character, and you begin with several resources. It’s like five items that have real meaning to you, something like a locket that your loved one gave you to remember them by some other things.

    Tim Broadwater  

    What did you say was the name of this game? 

    Michael Schofield  

    It’s One Thousand Year Old Vampire.

    Tim Broadwater  

    it’s a tabletop board game, right?

    Michael Schofield  

    It’s a single-player RPG, right? There’s no board to it at all. It’s like a journal. I’m playing in a spreadsheet. Right. So this is a role-playing game that is like in my mind and using a spreadsheet. Specifically, I’m using an AirTable. It is effectively like a timeline. I don’t know if I’m selling this as well. Ultimately, what’s happening, like the actual artifact of play, is a timeline. You are crafting a history that tells the story of your vampire, from conception until death. And you can take this the journalistic approach, so like you respond to the prompt with like a novel, this is or not a novel, but like say, like 500 words, or something like that. And you ultimately use it like a writer’s prompt to craft. And that’s kind of how I’m playing it. But the idea is, ultimately, you’re telling a story, and the prompt comes up, that maybe you aren’t able to control your thirst, and you kill somebody you love: remove somebody from your contact list, and remove one skill, and remove one resource. And your resource and your skills and your contacts list. The people that you have are, again, they’re just like bullet points. You have five each, sometimes seven, sometimes three, or whatever. And you expand them as you go. And you gain new ones as you go as well. And the goal is that given the prompt you solve, you find your way through the prompt, or you respond and or you respond to that prompt or tell the story of that prompt using the resources you currently have on you. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    This game is like from 2019. It was on Kickstarter, it was successfully backed, and it’s been reviewed by a bunch of places like Shut Up and Sit Down, which is pretty awesome. And other places. 

    Michael Schofield  

    The story that emerges is unique. If you’re playing Vampire the Masquerade and you enjoy this kind of like Vampire tale, you can imagine that, Oh, like you’re a vampire of a certain stereotype or specifically a vampire, the masquerade, you are constrained by the rules of the game, and the clans that are provided, and your vampire has a certain life until it’s snuffed out by you know, the prince of the city or something like this. In this case, the only designation of like, what it is to be a vampire is that you have been transformed. And now you cannot die – yet, and you are consumed by this monstrous hunger. So whether or not you’re just like an immortal creature that must devour like others whole or you’re a vampire that drinks like sexy blood or something like that are really part of like the story you’re telling. Right?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Did you just say sexy blood?

    Michael Schofield  

    You know, when like, the stats, like bites down into the neck of the prostitute in 18th century New Orleans, and she goes, Oh, there’s like, like two lines of like blood. That’s sexy blood, sexy blood. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    The Clive Barker is very, you know, sexy blood, which is centuries of suffering. 

    Michael Schofield  

    Clive Barker doesn’t have sexy blood. He has the Midnight Meat Train. 

    Tim Broadwater  

     The words that come from the Cenobites are always just like so much pain to show you. Yeah.

    Michael Schofield  

    It’s like you will know the delights of endless suffering. It’s like, all right, tell me more, Pin Daddy.

    Tim Broadwater  

    It’s amazing.

    The game I’m thinking of is called Unknown. And it came out in 2016. Robert Cutter is the designer, and I think and I, I met him. And so let me give you some context there. That is before COVID. I went to attend mag fest and DC. Mag fest is a music and gaming festival. And so it is kind of famous that this is the CON for con-goers, not for big gaming industries. So. So it’s a music and gaming festival with musicians that compose music for video games come to it. It has tabletop board gaming, but it’s predominately video games. And they have like an entire area. For the length of the con, four or five days, there’s this arcade set up, and I mean arcade the size of a mall. And so you could there are so many games that you could just go at three in the morning and play like the Japanese arcade game Sailor Man, you know where you could go, they have a whole section where it says blank TVs. And so you can go just play Xbox games or Switch games or whatever because they have everything. So it’s a video game kind of conference with your music. Anyways, there was a section that was tabletop. There’s a whole tabletop section. And in the tabletop section, there was a guy just sitting there, and he was just giving demos of his games. And I sat down, and apparently, it was Robert cutter, the game designer. And he, you know, he kind of showed this game that the things that hit me immediately was that it looked like Betrayal at House on the Hill to where when you’re building out your map, you’re just adding tiles that are random.

    You don’t know what you’re getting. And, and that the thing that also boggled me is he’s like, Hey, this is a one to six-player game. And I was like, What do you mean what? And he’s like, oh, yeah, you can. He’s like there are scenarios and stories that are sequential. And you can be a single-player and play it. You don’t have to have six players or four players. You can play it by yourself. And so there, as you probably know, there are very few tabletop board games that you can just solo right and so on. I was like, Okay, well, let me check this outdid the demo, I thought it was great, and I bought the game, you know, the game is unknown came out in 2016, you are among a group of survivors that were smart enough to hide underground When the war came to your city. While there are many people here, only a few of you have volunteered to venture out past the relative safety of your makeshift camp in the tunnels. So no one knows what’s out there. Staying Alive isn’t easy. Your team must explore or yourself. But when you’re playing it single-player, you control a team. Your team must explore the nearby tunnels in order to keep the base camp supplied. And so it’s kind of like a single-player game to multiplayer game, to where you are exploring outside of your bunker. And then what you’re looking for is food equipment, technology, and weapons. And so you’re just kind of scavenging, right like you’re a scavenger, like in this post-war post-apocalyptic time. And so. So imagine, like, you start on a tile that is like, Hey, here’s the base, and we have like, 20 people living here. Yeah, you have a team that you control to where there are people who are like, different classes can do different things, which is kind of, to me, it’s kind of like Pandemic to where it’s like, hey, this person can move more spaces, or this person can heal because their doctor, this person can fire weapons more effectively, because they used to be a hunter or soldier or a police officer, right. And so there are these ever-increasing difficulty scenarios that kind of happen. The first one is really like, hey, go out there. And just secure the bunker to make sure no one can get in. Right. And because of this war, there are mutants and like, people have been turned into like monsters and whatever. And so you’re, it’s kind of also kind of like

    Where you, you need to get enough food to keep the people that you have at your home base alive. But then you also need weapons to defend yourself, and you need to set up barricades. And so it’s very much that kind of game. And it is really enjoyable. So if you wanted to imagine like if you played Betrayal at House on the Hill, like but it was just a single-player game, and you could tell everyone, and you’re controlling the monsters, the monsters have like a mutant that breaks into your, your tunnel and is trying to get to your bunker, like they have a set movement, they have a set attack, they do these things every round, right. And so you also are like, trying to get armor and food and equipment to survive. And there are also there’s like a mechanic system for it to where you can do each of them. Like, when you think of a video game, you’re like, Hey, I just want story mode. Or I just want normal, or I want hard or like epic hard are god mode or something like that. You have those in this game by just slightly tweaking the scenarios. You can alter the difficulty of the different scenarios you’re trying to complete. And so just doing the easy the first scenario on easy is challenging, because it’s kind of that the economy of moves and strategy that you know, kind of comes with like Forbidden Desert or Pandemic to where you’re like dude, I know these mutant dogs are about to break into you know, our bunker and they are going to kill the people there I need to set up a barricade, but I also need to get a weapon to defeat the mutant dogs and so it’s very along that line of Fallout post-apocalyptic, but then in the mechanics of Betrayal at House on the Hill with kind of action economy that comes in from like Pandemic. I know that sounds like a really weird hybrid, but um, it’s super cool. And then the board itself are like these tiles you lay down that are squares, but then the cards as well as it has a ton of like wooden tokens for Yeah, players and you know, that monsters and everything. So it’s actually really cool, and I wanted to buy it. But it’s actually rated really well like on Board Game Geek, and so I would highly suggest it to anyone who Hey, it’s if you want to dual purpose, like a game that you can play yourself that’s a role-playing game and see if you can get through the scenarios. But then you also want to be able to take that game and say, hey, I can. I also want to play this with three other people were five other people you can, so it has that level of adaptability.

    The people who did Here to Slay and Unstable Unicorns, they have now a Kickstarter that’s out for from thing for a new game that comes out next year. It’s called Casting Shadows. It’s a new TableTop board game, and I’m gonna plug them because I love them. They have a really good game studio, and all their games are super fun. So if you ever played Happy Dinosaur, Unstable Unicorns, or Here to Slay. They’re all really good games, right? But what you’re seeing is adaptability. So it’s like, Hey, back, so you get the first the one through the four-player game. But if you do the next tier, you get the expansion, which makes it like six players. Yeah, and if you do the next tier, you get the DLC or like the additional content which adds this mechanic or this kind of thing. And so it makes me think of like video games right to where you have DLC and the add ons and you’re doing these things to do it but like board games are I’m now seeing increasingly have like all of these mechanics to add additional players to open it up or to add monsters or to add a whole different type of agency or mechanics. And so

    Michael Schofield  

    it occurred to me that there’s something about like the difficulty level of like a single-player RPG that correlates with I don’t know to say we would correlate with that being good, but I think it correlates with it being rated critically well, and like I’m only saying that because like as I as you talk and as and as I talk I’m you know Thousand Year Old Vampire has a cognitive load to it that is that exists. And yours has a likelihood of failure. You know that the game of the moment now there’s like a Geist of the moment now is Elden Ring, which is a single-player RPG, which is defying, which is defying the, I think the critical expectations, but I wonder if there’s something performative about Elden Ring. I imagine a certain crowd is into Elden Ring, not because the game itself would appeal to them on their own. As for me, I’ve chosen not to play it. A couple episodes ago, I had talked about really looking forward to it.

    Tim Broadwater  

    You talked about getting it for and checking it out looks really beautiful, you know?

    Michael Schofield  

    And, but like, I’ve decided from reviews that it’s not a game that I probably will enjoy. But I think about like the performative aspect, like when you’re watching, like, like an athlete do something. There’s something about the popularity of Elden ring as a social media as like for streamers, like Elden ring tick-tock is like a thing, of course, on twitch or whatever. And it’s because they’re trying to overcome these really difficult situations with a high chance of failure. And so like, you know, I think about like the the the player experience for a game like Elden Ring, but like, but like whatever any souls born, maybe any medium, something that has high failure potential. And like I can see that maybe you go to that because the dopamine hit of success is greater than like the punch in the gut of failure.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Because we’re right back to pinhead again. The epic suffering, the ages of suffering,

    Michael Schofield  

    Leviathan, the God of the Cenobites, probably is some sort of like an aquatic creature straight out of the minds of like, folks who design Elden Ring and…

    Tim Broadwater  

    It’s literally an Elden Ring cenobite who’s just like, You’ll never beat this game. Oh, it hurts so much. So, oh, you’re suffering. You know, it’s just like, did I know I hear what you’re saying. And I think like I take those games back. Same. I know we’ve talked about this before. But if the appeal is, I get beautiful in single-player and RPG. Okay, I get it; you know, I think a Breath of the Wild Horizon Zero Dawn Tsushima, I rage quit Dark Souls after an hour. I’m like, fuck this game. I’m never playing it again. And I really liked the story that was being sold to me about Sekuro: Shadows Die Twice, you’re a ninja who has his arm cut off, and you have this prosthetic arm that is like robotic and transformative and like turns into all these like Ninja cool Ninja weapons at first stars. It is so difficult. After four hours in the game, I was like, Screw this, and I took it right back to get store credit for like Gamestop, and so yeah, talking about those difficulty levels, right? Like when I play Horizon Zero Dawn, I’m like put it in story mode. Or when I did Mass Effect story mode. I don’t, I don’t wanna, I don’t want to like hate combat to the point where I’m not able to pursue proceed, right. And I think, you know, the default is, and this is kind of like what unknown does it does kind of what your typical game does, which is like, Oh, easy light mode. Increase the difficulty, or here’s like the god mode or like, insane, right? I don’t know, I know, we’ve talked about Hades before. Hades actually has a really cool way that’s not punishing and lets you do it. Every time you die, you get a 2% shield buff. And so once you’ve died 40 times, you’ve got an 80% shield buff. And so then, at some point, it’s like, dude, you’ve died 50 times playing this game. So we’re going to give you like a, like a shield buff to a certain point of damage. So I don’t feel like I have to; it doesn’t make me as the player feel like I have to put it into easy mode because I can’t hack it or I’m not good.

    Michael Schofield  

    You also don’t have to get good, you know?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Exactly. The game dynamically recognizes you’re having problems, and I’m going to apply this kind of buff to you that reduces the percentage of damage. Now I can turn that off if I want. I’m just like, well, I trust the game to know that I’m dying over and over again. So if it’s gonna give it to me, then I’m just gonna keep playing, and it and I can enjoy it.

    Michael Schofield  

    What was cool is that there is like a wealth of these single-player experiences too, you know, scratch an itch in whatever way you need.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I think a single-player thing is like, I need to adjust the difficulty for me because this is just me playing this and me enjoying it. Right? I’m not logging online to play Smash Brothers or Mario Kart. You know, when you play online with other people, there’s kind of an agreed-upon difficulty level and settings. Right? And so you’re not jumping into like Super Smash Brothers or Mario Kart or Fallout, Fallout, but um, Fall Guys, or like any other Dead by Daylight or any other online game, and you’re saying like, Hey, guys, let’s put it in easy mode. No, that doesn’t exist even most of the time because it’s like, the agreed-upon thing is that there is a set of difficulty and rules that this is how it happens. But when you’re playing single-player, it’s kind of like, Well, dude, I don’t enjoy this. So I want to make it easy. I want to stream, or maybe I do really enjoy it. And I want to put it on god mode too, like, make it so difficult. Yeah. And I think that comes down to, you know, the player preference, but between the Unknown game and the Thousand Year Old Vampire. I mean, I think those are. I think there are probably a lot of other single-player games out there. Single Player role-playing games that are tabletop-based or not video games that I’d like to like look at some more.

    Michael Schofield  

    Thank you for listening to design thinking games. Season two is an experience as we settle into this, and I hope that you’re enjoying it. And if you do, and it’s your thing. If you can star heart or favorite this episode on your podcatcher of choice, tell a friend. This helps shine the algorithm in our favor. If you would like to support us and the more monetary ways, you, of course, can join us on patreon.com/designthinkinggames, where you could get this very episode a whole week early with no ads. But if you indeed love the ads that you have made, You heard during this episode, and you want to buy one, we are incredibly cheap and affordable, and we really enjoy the kind of like putting these ads together, especially to help small creators like us grow with us. So consider buying an ad like us on Twitter and on TikTok. We’ve been posting @designthinkinggames. And I think you can see on my screen right now that I have this strange puzzle box that says Do not open until the end of the episode. I’m going to rub my thumb around the circle, and it clicks open Oh, no. Oh no, the lights are shining through the walls. What is that creature?

    Tim Broadwater  

    We’ll tear your soul apart? We have such sites to show you.

    Michael Schofield  

    At designthinkinggames.com

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the design Thinking games podcast. You only have so much time, and it means a lot you shared it with us to connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim. Visit Design Thinking games on tick-tock twitch, and Twitter DMs are open. You can also check out design thinking games.com where you can request topics, ask questions, or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on

  • 019: Hydra Head, Supporters, Knees & Toes

    019: Hydra Head, Supporters, Knees & Toes

    Games talked about in this episode:

    • 1:35 Dungeons & Dragons
    • 11:09 Roll 20
    • 13:08 Owl Bear
    • 15:27 Tabletop Audio
    • 20:12 Jocks Machina
    • 20:48 Dungeons & Daddies
    • 20:53 Queens of Adventure
    • 21:46 Thingiverse
    • 23:04 We Croak

    Introductory Guy  

    Welcome to design thinking games, a gaming and User Experience podcast card-carrying UX. Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield examined the player experience of board games, pen and paper role-playing games, live-action games, and video games. Play through the backlog on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at design thinking games.com.

    Michael Schofield  

    So I don’t know if you’ve ever been to Disney World or Disneyland and gone on the Pirates of the Caribbean, but all of those skeletons whose like jaws are literally like hanging down on the hinge of like a bone. That’s probably what I look like when I’m like sleeping. Or, or if you’ve ever seen like the mummy when like Imotep’s chin just like distends from his face so he can like exhale Locusts. That’s what I do when I sleep, so I tape —

    Tim Broadwater  

    You exhale locusts like the mummy.

    Michael Schofield  

    Oh my god. Yes. So I taped my mouth shut. There’s a product that is designed for this. It’s like the breathe right strip for taping your mouth shut, but it’s just tape. Yeah, yeah, you should join me in this.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I’m good. But that does make me that the Pirates of the Caribbean, specifically the skeletons that are in it on the ride makes me think of my favorite Dungeons and Dragons spell, which is Skeleton Crew.

    Michael Schofield  

    Oh my god. Yes.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Are you familiar with the spell?

    Michael Schofield  

    I am but for our listeners for whom we just cold opened here.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I’m gonna just butcher it if you want to. Let’s do it. I think yeah, I think you summon like so many D6 of skeletons. They can’t fight but they have their seamanship or navigating sailing, whatever that skill check is, yeah. It is like your intel; if you’re a wizard and your casting is based on intelligence, it’s here like intelligence modifier is their plus that they get so if you’re a really intelligent wizard and you need in the use of the spell, it is like crap. I don’t know how to sail but i can summon an undead crew to sail for me. And that’s literally all they can do is sail.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, oh, yeah, you’re right. The skeleton cannot speak, attack or even defend themselves. But they are proficient in navigators’ tools. I love it. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    I literally was at a gaming convention once. I’m sorry, this is just too good of a story. Like, I was at a gaming convention once, and we were playing a high-level Pathfinder society first edition scenario, right? And the scenario was, we busted a dude at the jail because we needed to get them to lead us to where our treasure was at sea, and you find a Kraken or sea monster. But there was a chance there was a point to where everyone on this game happened to just be a sorcerer, or wizard or like, or like a witch or an Oracle, but no muscle, right? Yeah. And so we got to this point where they were all these dead people at this prison at sea, and we had to pilot a ship. And we had dead people on the boat. So we just started sailing, and then immediately a storm came, and we were fucked. And I was like, Oh, wait, this is exactly why you have to spell. I never get the chance to use it. And I literally had it memorized on my wizard to cast all those perfect skeletal crews. It’s someone a bunch of skeletons. I thought that was cool. Yeah, didn’t really have any more thought to it. Hey, I want to summon like 20 skeletons, you know. But yeah, I had it memorized. And the gamemaster was so pissed off because it broke the whole storm, like a whole part of battling and skill checks and who’s manning the boat while you’re battling, and it just made it we didn’t even have to do half the work.

    Michael Schofield  

    Oh my god, that’s amazing. My weekly table at the moment, which is going on like three years now, is because the Quarriors ended up sailing around – and I like Homebrews and rule extensions. So I had this naval, like 48 pages, like a supplement that I got, and the entire intention was that look, these guys are going to be like trapped out or not trapped. They’re going to be at sea for an extended period of time, and they have to deal with like a mutinous crew. And there’s like every so often like I might, there might be some like weird, like, like, I don’t know, maybe we’ll roll a dragon turtle, but I also had just picked up.

    Tim Broadwater  

    My God, it’s been so long since I’ve heard the word dragon turtle.

    Michael Schofield  

    I picked up this like d&d supplement from I’m not looking at my books right now. So the actual name escapes me, but it’s all of the Greek gods and Greek myths that have given d&d stats or whatever, and there’s an official work, but I just picked that up and it has some like cool ass Hydra and stuff like that. And so there’s

    Tim Broadwater  

    There’s a bone Hydra. It’s actually in the Hades game I’m playing right now.

    Michael Schofield  

    Oh, that’s crazy. Yeah, so like, anyway, they were fighting like a Hydra. And I was like, these guys are, these guys are screwed, right? Because they have like a wizard. And whatever. And my intention isn’t really to kill the party. But my intention is that every encounter is deadly. And exhausts resources. And it’s my secret pride to like, really, like harass my players with a delightfully weird encounter, that isn’t just like, you know, grind and chop, grind and chop, but you know, it’s whatever. So anyway, I had this, you know, like nine-headed Hydra, which I guess is the stock definition of a hydra emerging out from the depths of the ocean, they are on a sloop that is in eyesight of shore, but it’s just a smear at the horizon. There was a couple of rounds in which folks are, you know, trying to shoot at it or whatever, and they realize that this isn’t doing super well. And then —

    Tim Broadwater  

    Do hydras have nine heads, or is it eight heads?

    Michael Schofield  

    Um, it’s great, it’s a great question. It should be nine heads. And the idea is that every time you chop one-off, and I say this with the caveat that I’m literally not looking at anything, this is just from memory. When you chop it off, there is a percentage chance that two new Heads regrow. I think it’s a dice roll. It may be immediate. But I don’t like that. I like the idea that sometimes you hit it just right. And it’s, it’s not gonna happen. Unless you like cauterize that wound. Anyway, yeah, so this is a major monster. The campaign is, you know, it’s about the return of like, an eldritch Cthonic, you know, Deep Mind. And it’s weird, right? It’s like, it’s my, it’s my thing. And my intention is to like harass my players, and again, in this sort of, like, delightful encounter, then, they were like, hey, this sloop has like a really like long and narrow bow with I do not remember the proper term for basically like a really long, like a spear-like tip to it, right? Kind of like, like a narrow, like wind cutting a decorative thing to which like this the, like, one of the sales attaches. And they just were like, alright, we’ll figure out how to survive this next part, but we’re gonna ram the Hydra. (Nice). And, yeah, it was great (As one does). Yeah. So. So that’s, uh, you know, that’s our tale of fucking up or players fucking up in a dungeon master’s sailing. Like adventure.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, it’s funny, cuz I think we were talking about, you know, we’re both very versed, I think, in many different types of role-playing games, right? Like tabletop and probably video games and kind of your pen and paper, Dungeons and Dragons, White Wolf, that kind of stuff. And that’s cool that you are running it that way.

    Michael Schofield  

    So I run a few games. That’s my weekly table, my virtual table, I guess.

    Tim Broadwater  

    What do you use for a virtual table? Like what do you do? So as it were,

    Michael Schofield  

    I, I do just a zoom call. And we use a tool called Owlbear, a really neat web app for free. And, and increasingly it’s, you know, it’s a virtual tabletop and stuff like that. I’ve tried Roll20. And I think Foundry is the other one. Is that right?

    Tim Broadwater  

    I like Roll20. I’ve used it for years,

    Michael Schofield  

    I think the work required to set it up is, in a funny way, more like game design or development than I want my Dungeons and Dragons to be.

    Tim Broadwater  

    That’s interesting because I don’t see it that way at all.

    Michael Schofield  

    Don’t you have to, like, set things up? Like, I’m like, Oh, here’s like the wall …

    Tim Broadwater  

    So can I tell you my experience? So I do, like a lot online play society organized play with Starfinder and Pathfinder. And I use Roll20. And I actually eventually ended up paying for the pro version. And the reason why is because they actually have some really cool advanced tools where you can import and export games, mechanics, and stuff. So if you set up stuff like documents, maps, or creatures or whatever, you can just take them from one game to another, and you don’t have to keep re-entering them, which is nice. But then, I’ve always found it to be like, in this is great that we’re talking about it’s an instructional design problem is what Roll 20 faces. The thing is, is Roll20 has, if you just want to start drawing on a map with a pencil and have people chat and roll, that’s all you need. You can do that so easily. And it’s just the click of like, it’s a toolbar. But if you want to go to the point of, you know, starting making macros or creatures, and then saving them and graphics and special, you know, you can take it to that next level, which isn’t bad for character sheet tracking or whatever. But then you can go even further and do like light dynamics and physics and like crazy stuff.

    Michael Schofield  

    So you can go deep, but you don’t have to, right?

    Tim Broadwater  

    I think they do a bad job. And I don’t mean this in I pay for their product. So I like it. But I’m like what my perspective would be, from a user experience, like an onboarding person, like learning a new game or learning a new system or piece of software. I mean, if they just presented it that way, that is that’s a trainer friendly, kind of user-friendly way to where it’s like, hey, low tech, this is how you start using it today. Yeah, and you can just draw and do stuff. But when you want to start getting more advanced, you can import creatures, save stuff, and move it around. But then you can get to a whole level of like 3d modeling and light dynamics and physics, you know?

    I have to check out Owlbear, though, because I mean, I’ve not heard of it. 

    Michael Schofield  

    I’ll plug it. I think it’s pretty impressive. It’s Owlbear.rodeo. Like, that’s the TLD domain, like, so like, you know, like, as kind of like a, an engineer I, I appreciate this for what it is. And what it is, is that it looks like a couple of folks basically designed a web app that works totally in the browser with your browser, local storage, and WebSockets to produce what I think is like a relatively easy to use, like a virtual tabletop. The reason that I went to it originally…

    Tim Broadwater  

    Oh my gosh, do they have YouTube tutorials on how to use it.

    Michael Schofield  

    So so the other thing that’s kind of like, fascinating, yeah, is that it’s totally free. And it’s 100% funded through Patreon. And so like as a model of like, just a couple of people and their software product or their, you know, their web app. It’s pretty neat. And I was drawn to it because I like the soundscapes of a tabletop RPG, right because I have like, I like ambiance I like kind of like the background music as a way to really set the tone. And owlbear lets you basically stream audio from another tab in your browser. So I’ve used it for a couple things. So you know, I use it for d&d.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Do you have a Pandora playlist or a Spotify playlist?

    Michael Schofield  

    Yes, I did. I did before. What I consider like leveling up, and here’s what I mean. But there’s something called there’s a there’s an app, another web app, just like individual created called tabletop audio like tabletop audio.com. And there are very familiar with Yeah, and so like in there. So most people, I think, like find a scene and play it, and there will be some background music with a few like sound effects. For instance, there’s one that I really like called Waterkeep instead of Waterdeep, so Waterkeep Night, and you hear like a little bit of music. But you can also hear carriages like rolling a car across the cobble. But what’s really cool is he’s made an entire soundboard part of that app, where you can construct custom audio. And that’s what I do now. And I support you know, I support the tabletop audio person, I gotta tell you, I don’t really know who’s the name of the Creator or anything. It’s patreon.com/tabletop audio, but you know, I pay for that. I think it’s excellent. It’s just wonderful. So so that’s what I do, rather than Spotify? Yeah.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah. It’s kind of interesting. I know that one of the things that we’ve been interacting with, or experiencing with the podcast and social media, is there’s this whole big, like an online community of like gamers and gamer developers, viewers and pixel artists and cosplayers. And just like, people who support each other.

    Michael Schofield  

    Small creators, right? They’re not just game designers.

    Tim Broadwater  

    They put money into the community, and they help back each other’s stuff because they’re kind of interested in it. Still, they also want to help someone else because they’re in a situation. I love that, about kind of this, you know, the people that we’re interacting with, you know, through social media online.

    Michael Schofield  

    So, you know, one of the things that this, now this TTRPG community, helps people do is like, create some distance between themselves and say, their full-time job, maybe they can’t quit. But some of these people can and what they’re doing are making supplements for an official game, like, you know, Wizards of the Coast, Dungeons and Dragons. So there’s, like, an ecosystem or a marketplace from a product point of view. It’s pretty fascinating because, well, for instance, like the most famous of them all has to be Critical Role and the amount of income and IP and then, of course, eventually merging, not merging properly, but having some of their lore introduced officially into Wizards of the Coast. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Critical Role is definitely like, the first right, and it opened up a lot of different doors. I can’t remember the name of the guy from Magic Mike. Who did Jock Machina.

    Michael Schofield  

    You know how I know him? Yeah. Oh, what’s his name? I know him as the werewolf. Joe Magnela  He was the werewolf and True Blood and the love interest and

    Tim Broadwater  

    He has jocks that love to play, you know, games and it’s kind of a thing that came out of you know, tabletop and I think it’s a community now everyone’s just saying like, Oh my God, it’s possible and tabletop I just think like was just the opening of the door because I we’ve talked about it before, but I love like the Dungeons and Daddies Podcast. Which is a hilarious podcast, and Queens of Adventure, which was like Dungeons & Drag Queens, the live show, kind of, and I just feel like everyone is supporting everyone. Everyone’s kind of portraying patronizing everyone. Is it patronizing? That sounds?

    Michael Schofield  

    I mean, I think tactically patronizing in that they are patronizing, like being their patrons, right. Supporting.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, supporting. I love that a gamer will support Hey, I like this game. Maybe it’s Dungeons & Dragons or tabletop role-playing game, and it’s like, but here’s a product that normal people are just making themselves that helps us play online. Yeah. Or here’s like some dice, or here are some 3d models that you can buy. There’s a lot of 3d modeling in this community, too. You can go to Thingiverse or other places where people were like, Hey, you can totally have my models for free and download them. I’m just asking, like, share it with people, and there is a Patreon or donate kind of button, and it’s like 70 cents for a 3d model. You know, So and that, but I can print that and make my castles at home, or I can print things too like a game developer new pieces that I need to test out a game or where it’s a tee for a cosplayer, or whatever.

    Michael Schofield  

    I literally paid $2.50 for an iPhone app called WeCroak, which reminds me that I’m going to die once a day. And, and you know, like, it’s stupid.

    Tim Broadwater  

    It’s very morbid. Why do you do that?

    Michael Schofield  

    Well, well, because, you know, the world is incredibly neurotic. We who work in tech, especially in startups, are an incredibly anxious peer group, for whom, you know, every day is a struggle, you never know, if you’re going to be employed the next month or whatever. These are very, like, first world tip of the first world problems. But because there’s so much, I don’t know, there’s so much going on in this space. And it requires a sort of self-obsession and obsession with the space. It benefits me to benchmark My, my, my emotions I like so that I can navigate this incredibly kind of like neurotic. (Like, what do you mean by benchmark?) Oh, yeah. Like, like, like, I tried to ground myself and realize that you can wake up and say, like, Oh, my God, I have so many problems like this, this piece of code is so difficult to this client is super needy. Everybody is on fire all the time. And they’re running around with their fire hands, and you’re at risk of catching fire yourself. Yeah, but you know, like the idea of like, this little, this little app this WeCroak is the same idea of like, you know, like stoicism behind it. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    it’s to remind you to live in the present and that you only have so many days left. 

    Michael Schofield  

    It’s not so many days. This could be your last. So if you meditate or accept that, hey, this might be the last time Tim and I talk. Let’s make sure that whatever we chat about, like this kind of conversation, is one that we can like, look back on in the next three hours on our deathbeds. And be like, Man, that was a good use of my time. Could I have used it better? I don’t know. But it’s not a question of regret, regret, right. So if you’re going to walk outside and get hit by a bus, at least make sure that you prioritize the things that really mattered, and I gotta be real work in that context doesn’t matter. Like the problems with the client, they don’t matter. And that’s kind of, you know, so it’s kind of morbid, but it’s liberating, and it means that oh my God, there’s so much shit going on, But I am going to spend an hour talking about like, games and the community and, and whatever. And I don’t know how people like fucking survive, like in like, like, constantly contemplating the future I’ve, I’ve trained myself to like turn that part of me off. It’s an effort to keep sanity. I’m just like playing games like you’re like, you can play games to process emotions like That Dragon Cancer or play games to escape. That’s like, you know, that’s what I do with like Thegns and like this little single-player RPG is that I don’t have anyone to play with, but I’m just putting my brain, and to my, I’m stepping foot into like, the shoes of the 1000-year-old vampire. And, and you know, but it’s, it’s about you know, enjoying what she can especially you know, especially now it’s better just to like you know, live in the present right. So, you know WeCroak, if we can get in touch with the people who make WeCroak, I would love to like add like I will put together an amazing advertisement. I just wanted to remind you Tim and like as we sign off and all of our, all of our listeners to you know support Design Thinking games on patreon.com/designThinkinggames if you are a small creator, and you want to help us a small creator Grow, you want to grow together? We have super affordable like super affordable, we’re talking like 10s of dollars advertising that we would love to collaborate with you on. We’re kind of active on social media, you know. If that’s your thing, jam those hearts if you can like star heart and favorite in your podcatcher of choice like this episode or the show that teaches the algorithm to shine a beacon on to design thinking games. And you know if there’s anything you take away from this conversation, perhaps it was a little diverting, but don’t forget, you are going to die, and it might be right now.

    Introductory Guy  

    thank you for listening to the Design Thinking games podcast. You only have so much time, and it means a lot you shared it with us to connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim. Visit Design Thinking games on tick tock, Twitch, and Twitter DMs are open. You can also check out design thinking games.com where you can request topics, ask questions or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on

  • 018: Year of 3s

    018: Year of 3s

    Games talked about in this episode:

    • 1:32 It Takes Two
    • 10:50 Horizon: Zero Dawn
    • 12:37 Mass Effect: Legendary Edition
    • 13:29 Hell Let Loose
    • 17:21 Fury of Dracula
    • 19:29 Rock, Paper, Wizard
    • 19:46 Cuphead
    • 31:44 Splatoons 3
    • 32:10 Xenoblade Chronicles 3
    • 32:37 Bayonetta 3
    • 35:31 Starfield
    • 35:59 Elden Ring
    • 36:15 The Devil In Me
    • 36:59 Martha Is Dead
    • 39:30 Hades

    Introductory Guy
    Welcome to Design Thinking Games, a gaming and User Experience podcast card-carrying UXers Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield, examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper roleplaying games, live-action games, and video games. Play through the backlog on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at designthinkinggames.com.

    Michael Schofield
    What’s up, everybody? Welcome to a new episode of Design Thinking Games back from hiatus, season two, episode number eighteen. And this kicks off the first one back from our prolonged break, and it’s been a really meaty offseason.

    Tim Broadwater
    Yeah, last episode was we made it to the castle, we stormed the gates, and we blasted in this space on the holy day of Mass Effect. Maybe the best thing to ask you, Mike, is what’s been going on since our last episode.

    Michael Schofield
    I don’t really know where to start. You know, we could probably start with the Game of the Year Awards. You and I had a couple of predictions early on, but they happened, and the winners are, I think, pretty good. To be honest.

    Tim Broadwater
    Yeah, I actually played the Game of the Year winner last year. It Takes Two was only a release, I believe, for Xbox and PlayStation. It is really good. A little bit of a tear-jerker. But, like the game, like the studio produced before it, you literally have It Takes Two. You cannot play it with one player. You have to play with someone, either locally or online and have two people to play it. And I’ll have to say I don’t want to ruin anything. But I know why it wasn’t Game of the Year. It’s beautifully storied. It is not giving anything away. But it’s a couple that is no longer happy. They have a child, and they’re getting a divorce. And the child kind of puts a wish it’s not a curse or anything. But I think it’s a wish on them that they’ve learned to kind of love each other again. And she even goes to like the local library or school library checks out a book on, like how to fall in love. And she’s trying to help them. And it’s beautiful. And over the course of the game. I will say this, it uses the medium of collaborative, two-player games to teach, you know, the parents’ collaboration. And so there’s like shoutouts in it that are like Street Fighter. And their shoutouts and at that are a lot of two-player games like 3d tank games, like on old school and television. So there are a lot of references to 2d games. And it’s funny because it uses the medium of 2d games to teach, like, the collaboration between two people.

    Michael Schofield
    That’s fascinating. I didn’t realize what the story was behind it. I’d seen the gameplay a little bit and some of the mechanics, but it hasn’t appealed to me. But that sounds like it’s suddenly like up my alley. Do you find that? Like, if part of the under-theme teaches you how to love or fall in love? Or how to collaborate? Do you feel a sense of, I don’t know, attachment with your co-op buddy?

    Tim Broadwater
    Yeah, so I couldn’t. I got it in the mail. And it’s just like you have a second player who needs to log in, you can’t play, and I was angry because I was like, what I want to play the game. And so they have this cool thing that you only one player has to buy the game. And you can let the other player pay play remotely. So I’m on PlayStation. And so I played with my nephew. And there are instances in the game where you have to do everything together. Everything requires collaboration, every boss battle, getting through every board, you’re holding a switch while you’re waiting for someone else to run up somewhere to click on something so you can then proceed.

    There are points where someone’s piloting while another person is gunning. It is all collaborative. And there are points definitely where you know, you can get frustrated, and you’re like yelling at the other player or like, what are you doing Get over here. But then you realize it’s one of these things too, where I think it made me look at myself more to say like you need to chill out, and you need to, you know, you need to calm down. Because, you know, this requires two people to collaborate and work together and to do that you can’t be frustrated or angry at another person, you have to also, you know, kind of work together. And then you kind of get to this point where you look forward to working, it started well, it’s difficult, but then it becomes, oh, it’s a little, we’re getting the, we’re getting in the rhythm of it. And then it becomes enjoyable, like working together. And so you actually it does, my player experience was like, I haven’t, I don’t play a lot of two-player games. And I think that’s, you know, it’s usually one of those things where I think people play either online games, or they’re solo all the time. And so, in a lot of online games, you just randomly are paired, or you pick up people or you whatever, but it kind of threw me back to middle school when I was, you know, kind of on my friend’s couch, and we were playing games together, and we had to work together. And I kind of missed that in games. And this made me feel that again,

    Michael Schofield
    I don’t tend to play with people; I play with strangers. And, and yeah, by I do play a lot of multiplayer, man. And so like, some of the like, the best multiplayer experiences are, you know, really good cooperative ones. What’s funny is that you know, like, early on, in season one, we had an episode about, I think we had an episode or a good chunk of an episode about the role of collaborative games. I think we focus much of that on board games and whatever. But I, I believe that deep in that kind of, like, fertile soil that we planted, we’re speculating that, you know, this kind of collaborative enforced collaborative games, the software, hey, you know, to even play the game of the year, you must have a buddy. I think we speculated that the that was going to be increasingly present and like the coming years of gaming, right, you know, because we sort of, maybe we’ve maxed out on what we can do in terms of graphic fidelity or, or whatever Close. And now the ability through another network and, you know, creative game design to really tell collaborative stories more than just like two people on a squad shooting the same targets as exponentially better, like year after year over year. So I think it’s really cool that this is the game that won Game of the Year,

    Tim Broadwater
    When my nephew, who plays a lot of games, said, You know, I now know why this one game of the year like it’s a really good story. It’s the story that puts it above everything else. I think that’s Hazel light studios. Who made like, It Takes Two and then the game before that is a way out. I also played the only other exposure I had to the Game of the Year. You know, I thought like I was I you know, you have a lot of predictions you think is gonna win a lot of people thought Resident Evil village Rush was gonna take Yeah, and they took a lot of awards, but then I also played Metroid Dredd with one action game of the year. Yeah. And I know why it’s amazing. It’s a really good action game. So

    Michael Schofield
    I was more kinda like, interested in some of these categories that I’m sure have existed before. But you know, in the spirit of, you know, the UX Honeycomb, right where the player experience or the user experience is a cumulative of some tangibles and some other tangible intangibles, you know, so instead of like a genre-based game of the year, like action, or best roleplay, there’s one that I kind of like, in terms of like best community support and best ongoing games run backed, in that games for impact, innovation, and accessibility. It is coming to show, I think, how, you know, these kinds of, like, I guess, as games become more games of games as a service, as opposed to, you know, ship it and ditch it kind of banger that comes out with maybe a couple of patches, that you know, the qualities of what makes a game desirable are not too dissimilar from the qualities that make, you know, like web services, desirable that being that there’s a human on the other side to help you out. And then it’s designed for you to use in a variety of contexts. And all of those things are starting to get a lot of recognition and show up like nominees. I don’t know that people care about these categories more than Best Action Game.

    Tim Broadwater
    But the only one that people remember is, which is kind of a double-edged sword right because of the six games that I think were nominated for Game of the Year. I only played two of them. There are a lot of games out there. I have heard good things about Death Loop and Psychonauts and Ratchet and Clank and Resident Evil village. I played the demo of Resident Evil village. I never played the game, but at least it was freedom. You know, I played it. But the other thing is, is like I’m kind of which, you know, you don’t? If a game could win, like 20 awards, but not get nominated for the year. Does that make it a bad game? Right, not the best game. Right. I think an example of that is Horizon: Zero Dawn, you know, it never won Game of the Year, like in the proper GOTY category that we’re thinking but in one other words, and it won a lot of awards.

    What have you been playing game-wise since November 7, the last time that we had an episode

    Michael Schofield
    Isn’t that crazy? So I beat it just because we ended on November 7. I did be the Mass Effect: Legendary Edition on Insanity. Like I beat it.

    Tim Broadwater
    I can’t even believe that. That’s nuts.

    Michael Schofield
    It was insane. I can’t argue that it was worth it, to be honest. But it was a joy sort of to go through. Again. I mean, my whole catalyst or my whole rationale for running through this was purely because I played each game so many times. That I don’t know, I need to light a match under my skin to fill it feel alive. But since then, I had I bought a gaming PC. And so the games I’ve been playing my gosh, man, like so I’ve been playing, I’ll just tell you to like almost straight up. I’ve played a couple of others that I’m excited to talk about. But I’ve been neck-deep in Hell Let Loose, which is a relatively faithful, hyper tactical World War Two shooter with, I think, either 64 or 100 players, servers, but big teams. And you know, you’re replaying many of the battles of the European front. But what’s special about hell that loose, which maybe feels particularly sweet because of how burned I personally was with Battlefield 2042. And stuff like that is that there’s no handholding, there’s no HUD, there’s barely a tutorial, you cannot succeed as a lone wolf, maybe this is that spirit of collaborative games, you have to work together with your squad. Well, your squad has to work together with other squads. Well, your experience is not only one of loss, but it just sucks. You will get pummeled if you guys aren’t working as a team. And it’s fascinating to kind of like play with these hardcore mechanics. There are a lot of different rules that I really like the fact that it forces you to get along to even moderately enjoy yourself because the penalty of not collaborating is that you’re stuck in your spawn, and you’ll never get out, and the game is over. And man, it hasn’t been some of the most like cinematic epic experiences. Because the way you have to win the game is you know like your squad leader will be like, alright, fire teams, fire team, Charlie. It’s like we’re gonna go around these hedges. You know, you the machine gunner, you know, point up here and keep the doc at least 30 paces back, you know, stuff like that. And the effect is that you are roleplaying soldier, right? So so on top of like the high fidelity, the sound design, the gameplay mechanics, all of which are amazing, both of the different mini-games between being a leader, squad leader, or a commander versus the, I guess the core game of being an individual first-person shooter all coupled in together with having to pretend to be like the doc and you know, you have to yell medic to get someone’s attention. You know, so you have to have a mic. It makes for pretty sweet Pretend time, you know, really special events? I think so. So yeah, so the same thing you have to learn to work together. And the people who don’t work well together are immediately ostracized.

    Tim Broadwater
    Nice. That’s cool. There’s I know you tend to skew towards I don’t know what I would call it army Armed Forces soldier, like it, can be like a knight or like you just really like period-piece, like war combat games.

    Michael Schofield
    That’s an interesting umbrella. You’re right. I do because it doesn’t have to be World War Two or World War One. But, or knights, but it has to be in a period. Right? That’s relatively like faithful.

    Tim Broadwater
    I always have some ongoing games, but I mean, I guess since our episode, I tried a couple of board games. Barbearians, which is B-E-A-R, barBEARS. I finally got to play Fury of Dracula. And he did such a great game really good. It took me forever to finally get some people to play it. But it was a really great experience.

    Michael Schofield
    Yeah, yeah. Like what, um, as you know, I’m a fan. So I’m really kind of curious in the same way that I was curious to pick your brain about Mass Effects. Like what? Like, what about, I don’t know what design choices were really good about Fury of Dracula?

    Tim Broadwater
    Well, I say this, that there are some parts of the game that didn’t age very well. And the majority of which of those are in instruction manuals. And so when you play like a lot of games that have come out in the last three or four years, you know, the kind of onboarding upskilling, understanding the game tutorials, but then also the quick primer that you look to for like, hey, what does this mean? That’s kind of dated and Fury of Dracula. However, that is the most nitpicky thing I can say because the game is amazing. Like, truly the game is. You know, we had three people controlling the vampire hunters. We lost. Dracula won. All right. We found him twice and were on his trail. But there are so many vampire traps. And how we can put move mists over cities. So it’s kind of like a, you’re trying to coordinate to like tracking down someone and finding evidence of, you know, kind of is where across Europe, Dracula’s going. And so it was really interesting just trying to. I’m going to go take the sea routes. I’m going to cover Spain, you try to go to the car page. Like you go to Russia. Someone goes up to Norway, you know what I mean? You’re just trying to find any clue. Right? And then when you find it, you’re all in like, oh, like coordinating and triangulating position. So it’s a lot of fun. And I know that now that I’ve played it, I could play it, and it would not take as long as it did. But really good game. I’m glad it’s in my collection. I also got to play Rock, Paper, Wizards, which is very fun. Quick game. I had it for years but just haven’t played it. And I would say video game-wise, you know, apart from It Takes Two and Metroid Dredd. The biggest accomplishment that I can speak to is I beat Cuphead.

    Michael Schofield
    That was such an event, but it baffles me that that was after the last episode we shot because I was like, Oh my God, you’re like that because he took years, right?

    Tim Broadwater
    Yeah, it took a long, long time to be Cuphead, and it is one of those games that you just have to get right. Yeah, you know, I got it in 2017, and I beat it in 2021. You just slowly work on it, chisel at it, work on it chisel at it. And then finally I got to the end. And the last bosses. Before you fight the devil. You have to fight to the dice, man. He runs the casino. And I could never get past the casino. It’s just difficult. So you know, that’s was the biggest, you know, kind of challenge, and I kept coming back and coming back to it. And then finally I was like, I’m beating it this weekend. No matter what. I’m just gonna play it nonstop. And I did. I had to play it nonstop for two days, pretty much straight to be a bit.

    Michael Schofield
    crazy. But the high felt afterward must have been insane.

    Tim Broadwater
    Yeah, and it has DLC coming out soon. And so, like the Game of the Year awards, they announced you know Cuphead has the DLC delicious last course takes place on DLC Island. There’s a new character, Chalice, and then new powers. And if you haven’t played Cuphead, I mean, I think everyone knows about Cuphead. But I mean, it is so beautifully drawn that it’s like this classic 40s cartoon or 50s cartoon, right? Yeah, that is really good, you know, and to the point of even putting, like the dust or the hair that you would see on the film of a movie. I mean, they have that on everything. Everything’s dated. Everything’s well done. And then it also just launched a Netflix show. It has a Netflix animated series that came out too. So I think there’s probably gonna be more in the future for Cuphead. I think apart from the DLC in the show, I think they’re probably going to ramp up for, like, another game, you know?

    Michael Schofield
    Oh, 100% Yeah.

    Tim Broadwater
    It is right now. A couple of weeks before the first episode is coming out. The Winter Olympics just ended. And I think there are some big news items that have happened kind of in gaming, right? Stuff about Microsoft and Sony

    Michael Schofield
    a time that this is one of those things where I regret that we took a hiatus. I’m glad we did, you know, it’s the right decision for humans who need time off of stuff. I’m talking specifically about Microsoft acquiring Activision as one of the really meaty news items. Microsoft announced that they were buying Activision Blizzard for something like $70 billion. And what that does, (Tim: oh, my God, that’s a lot of money) and what that effectively does, with this quick caveat to remind you that not long ago, they bought Bethesda. They now own all of the Activision properties, including the highest-selling franchise in the world, Call of Duty, including World of Warcraft, etc., including,

    Tim Broadwater
    like, Heroes of the Storm, all of the stuff that Blizzard did, right. Yeah, exactly. So I mean,

    Michael Schofield
    it’s I’m being a little hyperbolic, but the argument is that they have eradicated all of the competition. And so you know, any kind of like, innovation that improves emerges from Creative friction is like out the door. The questions are twofold. Like, is this good for gamers? Question mark? Is this good for the industry? Question mark. And then there’s like some subdivided questions. Is this legal? You know, what does this mean for Microsoft, etc.? I think for consumers, this is pretty great, at least in the short term. And it’s a fascinating call. Because of what it does, it changes the emphasis on gaming. Microsoft is no longer, I mean, maybe this has always been true. But when you think of Microsoft, and you pretend that they don’t do other things other than Xbox, you think of the hardware, running third-party games, right? For the most part, Sony has the exclusives,

    Tim Broadwater
    I think of office 365. And then all the contracts with every hospital, bank, and school, you know, that literally has all of its all Microsoft, right? I don’t really even think of the gaming side of it. So,

    Michael Schofield
    exactly. I think Xbox is a loss leader. Definitely. But I think what I don’t know like the Xbox is a vehicle for like Game Pass and IP delivery. But what makes that interesting to me is again, I think you’re gonna see like, like Microsoft has an option to cut Call of Duty off of the Sony ecosystem entirely, for instance, or they can maintain it and move Microsoft software presence into the Sony ecosystem through Game Pass. You know, everyone’s talking about this as like a one-two punch to Sony. My hot take is that Sony isn’t divan on Microsoft’s radar, because when you consider especially that Microsoft has so much more than Xbox. And what I think what just happened is if you think about Microsoft as like a product engineering service, a service for engineers, a service for products and business and hospitals and like everything you just mentioned, they are producing a platform called Azure or I don’t know really how to pronounce the AZ u r. E. Azure. Yeah, Azure, which is cloud computing, a competitor to Amazon Web Services, and AWS is Amazon’s, you know, like dollar sign that’s how Amazon makes money. That’s how Amazon exerts control over the internet because so much of the internet relies on AWS. Think about what Microsoft just did. They just look, the biggest bandwidth hogs on the planet, like all of the games that are consistently online, have the biggest market share, have the biggest funding, probably take up the biggest server space, and they just took that business away from AWS. And they put it on, Azure. I think what this is, is their target is Amazon. Yeah, like it has anything to do with Sony.

    Tim Broadwater
    I didn’t even think about it. Yeah, I didn’t even think about it that way. You know, I know that I can be on my PlayStation or on my PC or whatever. And if a game requires me to log in with a blizzard Game Pass, or an Xbox Game Pass, or whatever, I don’t care. I mean, if I want to play the game, I’ll play the game. So I think like the end player, unless they’re really not wanting to get into an ecosystem, they don’t really care because I can. I’ve done it before on my PlayStation, where I can’t remember what it was; I needed something of a game pass or a certain type of game. And it is just like, let me create it super quick, like on my PlayStation through the click of a button, and then adding my email address. And I’m like, okay, great. Now I can proceed. So behind the, you know, behind the game, or behind the scenes, so to speak, like when you’re looking at what happens behind the scenes and like a service blueprint. I don’t think users really or players really care.

    Michael Schofield
    I agree. I mean, I think they benefit. They get way more games. They get in their favor. IP now has the bottomless budget of Microsoft.

    Tim Broadwater
    That’s interesting. Yeah, there’s some I just know. Steam has been around for so long on PC that its presence is something, and it’s very connected with discord and Twitch, you know, but I, Xbox, doesn’t even register to me for PCs. But I mean, that may change very soon, especially if there are exclusive titles that they now have control of it, right.

    Michael Schofield
    I mean, think about this, like so I have, I’m new to PC gaming. So I don’t really have a ton of biases built yet. So I have steam, and I like it. I bought the last couple of games on there. But I downloaded, but I had already because I was part of the Microsoft ecosystem and remain part of the Xbox AQ systems and Xbox One like I have an OG gamer tag, where I already owned Dead by Daylight there on that console, or on that account. So I read downloaded it through Game Pass on my PC. So that I could you know, and I plan to cross-play from there. But it’s just part of the ecosystem’s stickiness. The other thing you can think of like in terms of like a service blueprint, right? It’s like if you think about the journey of the gamer, where it begins from turning on a machine connected to an internet, plugging in some software getting online that Microsoft owns that entire horizontal like every touchpoint along the gamers journey is now owned by Microsoft, and I think that is huge to do with games right as to do with holding the path.

    Tim Broadwater
    What are your predictions for this year? What are your thoughts about coming up this year? For me? I have some very strong feelings about Nintendo this year because Nintendo will be the year of threes.

    Michael Schofield
    What is the year of threes?

    Tim Broadwater
    One of the most fun games to play online for Nintendo is split tans. It is like a MOBA that is super fun. It’s addictive. And it’s fast pace. So you know this here, Splatoon three is gonna drop. If you’ve never played Splatoon, it’s one of the most enjoyable fun games you’ll ever play. Yes. Yeah. And then also this year is they Nintendo has announced Xenoblade Chronicles 3. So Xenoblade is pretty big. It’s a pretty big, open-world RPG that has its own kind of mythos and its own kind of history to it. And there if you’ve ever played any of the Xeno games, you know, gears, you know blades in the blade Chronicles. I mean, so that sequel drops this year three. But then, in addition to that, Bayonetta 3 drops this year. And so, all three of those games are Nintendo exclusives. And so, Nintendo, how I like to describe it to people is like maybe you are not a Mario person. Maybe you’re not a Zelda person, maybe whatever. But Nintendo Switch with the price of its car So, and the pool or the draw of the exclusive platform games that they get is enough to make a player buy a game for a game, right? Like Animal Crossing will make people buy a switch, and then, you know, Zelda will make people buy a switch. I don’t know, I’m sorry, I’m not a Mario. But I mean, there are some people who love Mario. But this year, Splatoon three, Xenoblade 3, and Bayonetta Three are, are all dropping. And so this year, I don’t know much about what’s forthcoming for other, you know, kind of platforms because I tend to think of other games that are like, Oh, is this going to be on PC, Xbox, and PlayStation? Okay, you know, or is this title going to be on? Just, you know, I don’t really think of exclusives so much with consoles. Now, I know there’s some, like, Last of Us, it’s exclusive for PlayStation, right? And I know there are exclusives for everything, but I just it’s gonna be I’m, I’m just saying, keep your eyes on Nintendo this year, because when I say the year three, they have three, three, part three sequels dropping, that are going to all three be amazing. So I also think there are some really sweet MOBAs that are coming out that are cross-platform. So if you’ve not seen like, you know, Star Wars hunters more, or vampire, blood hunt. I mean, those are all forthcoming. Those are going to be really fun MOBA games. And so you know, if you’re a MOBA person and I will try every MOBA like I’ll try Friday the 13th, I’ll try predator hunting grounds. I’ll try Dead by Daylight. Yeah, I’ll try everything a little bit. Because they’re, they’re fun games. And I’m definitely going to check out both of those two games.

    Michael Schofield
    You know, there’s some IP that I’m anxious to check out, you know, I am nebulously excited for the Vampire games because there’s another one called Swansong that’s coming out as well. And you know, there are things like that I’ve already played, you know, some there’s some like really good kind of like psychological thriller games that are sort of in the spirit of you know, gone home or whatever like I just started playing Martha Is Dead. I think that’s going to be a big chunk of my year coming up, not that game specifically but that stuff, but I’m telling you I believe November Starfield, but as this new game is set to release, I don’t know that we know a whole lot about it, but I’m expecting Skyrim in space. And I think this is going to be huge, right? Because I don’t know why I suspect we’re gonna, I bet Game of the Year contenders at least in certain categories. I mean, you’re gonna have Elden Ring, which just came out, and you’re gonna have Starfield unless Starfield totally like shits the bed, and then everything else is kind of like up for grabs there.

    Tim Broadwater
    I will say one more thing about this year. That is on both of our radars is The Devil In Me with the fourth and final installment of season one, quote-unquote, of The Dark Pictures Anthology, whatever that means. There’s no date released, but it always seems to kind of drop around Halloween anyways. So that is when I’m very much looking forward to just because I know those games only have like a one playthrough appeal. But it’s still if you were a fan of the classic genre like a whodunit or what’s going on mystery peace. I mean, that’s definitely one to look towards this year as well.

    Michael Schofield
    I have a recommendation for you if you need a horror kick. So Martha Is Dead. Came out relatively recently, I think this month. It is a game. That is, it feels indie. It’s not the same as like, the dark pictures anthology, but it’s, you know, it’s a period psychological thriller, either. You know, like in the spirit of the dark pictures, you know, it’s like, either it’s ghosts or aliens are vampires. Or you’re insane. No, it’s one of those things that walk the boundaries. But Martha Is Dead is like the story of an I have twin girls sat in World War Two in Italy. I think it’s like 19. Oh gosh. 1944 Maybe 1945, And they’re twins and one of the sisters. Dies. And the other has to deal with the ramifications. She’s a young woman she’s like in our teenage she’s a teenager, you know, there’s pressure on the family. Her father is a German general. And there’s this like a fog of war of the actual literal war, like all around, plus does grief dealing with the death of a twin. And, you know, not to mention being in kind of like a spooky, like an old forest as a setting where this person’s imagination goes around. Or goes a little wonky? Maybe or maybe what she sees is real. But dang, dude, it is. It is a blast. I wouldn’t say it’s creepy.

    Tim Broadwater
    Because you know, when you’re, I will check it out. We got cool. Yeah, when

    Michael Schofield
    You’re dead inside like us. That’s not like really gonna like, shove you off here.

    Tim Broadwater
    Every UX professional’s dead inside.

    Michael Schofield
    is super good. And you get to take pictures with like these little old brownie cameras. And they do something cool with sound design that I think you’ll really like. But since Dark Pictures isn’t coming out until probably Halloween, right. I think this one kind of fills that void.

    Tim Broadwater
    One thing, my suggestion to you would be, which is something I’m playing now. Not sure if you’ve heard of it or know about it. I think you know about it, but it’s on every platform I believe is Hades. Yeah, I saw you raving about it. Yeah. So a couple people I work with suggested to me another UX professional actually did and said like, hey, it’s, you know, I don’t know if you like grindy games, but you should like, you should try Hades. And I’m like, Well, I like grindy games. He’s like, Well, the person I spoke to is like, well, I don’t. But if you if something’s so enjoyable, and it’s fun that it doesn’t feel like grinding, which kind of like moonlighters this way, as well is like Diablo-like the old Diablo games where you just you go into a dungeon, you try to get as much treasured, get as far as you can’t kill as much. And then you kind of can level up and be awesome. And so it makes it easier as you go. But it’s super fun, Hades as well. It’s won tons of awards, and it has voice acting and story awards. It’s really good. It’s actually. I’m surprised I picked it up based on a suggestion. And it was always kind of like somewhere buried in my game list. And then finally I got to it, and I’m like, wow, I should have picked this up much sooner because it kind of tickles that itch that is like the Diablo Moonlighter gauntlet kind of it looks.

    Michael Schofield
    it looks very Diablo-like; it looks like anime Diablo when I’m looking at the as a —

    Tim Broadwater
    Yeah, and you can think hours into it and not even think like you were grinding as much as you have. So, but definitely, a game to check out. And that, you know, I kind of keep going back. And I did this with Spider-Man I did it with Last of Us. And I did it with, you know, Ghosts of Tsushima and a bunch of different games It Takes Two I’m always kind of seeing like, Well, what do the people love and what gets really ranked, really well gets awards or gets Game of the Year each year. And there’s, you know, despite what people say, or the anger, if someone gets angry about their game didn’t win or not. The games that make it there to that final list are really good games, you know, they have a great player experience. And so Hades would be my recommendation to you. And you can play it on PC, Xbox, PlayStation switch all of it.

    Michael Schofield
    Maybe that’s the challenge for the rest of this season. Right? You know, like what, like if, you know if we kind of remove our biases from, and we look at, look at the qual data out there. What games might we not play normally but just get rave reviews? I wonder if that can direct how we spend some of our time because I got to tell you I’m really stuck in my like, you know, my genre hole, but I think.

    Tim Broadwater
    your your, your history warfare combat genre hole

    Michael Schofield
    Yeah. Like, I’ve got a specific taste for things right. But I don’t often stray too far from it, but probably to my detriment. You know, like so I think I’m gonna I’ll check out Hades because this I gotta tell you, it’s not a game that I would get normally.

    Tim Broadwater
    Well, it’s just a general game. That’s decent to fund, and your enjoyability will be it’s an enjoyable game, right? It is not like what we did last season where you challenged me to play a Mass Effect and play, and I’m glad I did because I never would have picked up the game, and it’s really good. I’m still brewing or percolating on what the game is that I’m going to challenge you with this year. Awesome. But when I do, I will hit you with the gauntlet, D’Artagnan. And he will have to; you have to try it out. There’s, there are so many good games, and I’m trying to really narrow the list to something that I think you would really enjoy. I have it down to about three or four, though. I will say that, so maybe here soon, in a future episode, I will issue the challenge.

    Michael Schofield
    Amazing. I can’t wait. I’m a little scared. I feel like you’re gonna hit me with like, some sort of like Metroid Vania that I’m just gonna want to like die playing, but there’s nothing you know, excellent. For reasons right by, I just feel like you’re gonna pull something like out of like, like the early like the late 90s or something.

    Tim Broadwater
    Like, it will be I know that you have an aversion to Metroidvania games. And so I’m considering that because I do factor in like, like, this January. So horrible. I just don’t want to play this. So some people are beyond sidescrolling. You know, and I get it, you know, because they’re just like, hey, I’m 3d games. We’re in a 3d world. Why are we going backward? You know, so, and there are legitimately people who feel that way, you know, so, and I get it. But I also, you know, kind of feel the same thing about 3d games, you know, you put go Tsushima right next to Horizon: Zero Dawn, would you put next to Mad Max, we keep the spider man. It’s like, okay, so how many times do we have a 3d open world where you go to waypoints on the map to get story development to and then you can do time trials or find, you know, kind of unlock and find all these hidden items to do the thing. I mean, that’s a mechanic just as a side scroller as a mechanic, and then having to return. You know, the thing about Metroidvania style games is that it’s a map, and you have to kind of constantly be looking at your Mac, in return back to places because as you advance and get new powers, or new abilities, or objects, you can do things that you couldn’t do before there. Yeah. And so, so that that kind of mechanic doesn’t appeal to people like to all types of gamers, but some people love that mechanic. And so games that are modern in that genre, which you think of like hollow Knight, or you think of Metroid dread, or you think of chasm or any other games that are kind of like that. You know, it’s so, but I will promise you, it will not be a side scroller, so I will, I will guarantee that.

    Michael Schofield
    Well, I don’t know if you’re feeling particularly brutal. I think the rules of the game are that I got to play. So. So I don’t know like I was gonna give you a little bit. Yeah, give me.

    Tim Broadwater
    Give you a hint. It’s gonna probably be an indie game. That’s what I’ve got it narrowed down to so it would be available on any platform.

    Michael Schofield
    That’s, I mean, that’s barely like,

    Tim Broadwater
    as much as you’ll get right now.

    Michael Schofield
    Alright, cool. That’s it. For this episode of Design Thinking Games, we need your help to grow in all sorts of directions that can happen by liking Harding and favoriting. This particular episode and your podcatcher of choice if you can leave a five-star review if they offer a review platform and something nice that goes a long way to helping train the algorithm and our favor. If you want to support us and help us pay for some of the overhead of coming to you consistently with such high quality. Join us over at patreon.com/Design Thinking Games, in which we have the most hilarious tears. For all price points. Look for Design Thinking Games on Twitter on tick-tock on Twitch and also on the internet that Design Thinking Games.com. We offer incredibly affordable advertising to small TTRPG creators or folks in the user experience design space who want to grow as we grow. Check out everything that we offer at Design Thinking Games.com/advertise. We’ll see you at the next stop. Game on do

    Introductory Guy
    thank you for listening to the Design Thinking Games podcast. You only have so much time, and it means a lot you shared it with us to connect with your hosts Michael or Tim visit Design Thinking Games on TikTok, twitch, and Twitter DMS are open. You can also check out Design Thinking Games.com, where you can request topics, ask questions or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on

  • 000 v.2.1: Season 2 Trailer

    000 v.2.1: Season 2 Trailer

    Introductory Guy  

    Welcome to Design Thinking Games, a Gaming and User Experience podcast. Card carrying UXers Tim Broadwater and Michael Scofield examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper role playing games, live action games, and video games. Play through the backlog on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at designthinkinggames.com.

    Michael Schofield  

    Hey, what’s up, everybody? We are coming in briefly, not with a real episode. But to sort of talk to you about what’s coming up for season two. We’ve put a bunch of things in place. We’re now grooming our episode ideas, and we just wanted to talk to you about it for a brief second, before our first real episode of the season comes out.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, I think that’s good. One of the things I think people are going to notice is that our logo has changed. I think the logo, if season one was kind of a more Gothic horror… 

    Michael Schofield  

    I love it though.

    Tim Broadwater  

    …kind of, and that’s if you listen to anything at season one, we were really hopped up on the horror and Gothic elements of like, a lot of games. But for season two, you’re gonna see that we change to kind of a space theme. Not that that means we’re gonna be talking about sci fi or space all season, but it may occur and pop up, reoccurringly.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, one of the things I I, I wonder or doubt whether or not any of our listeners like long term so far, like picked up on it. But we told a little bit of a narrative in the, in the descriptions of each of our podcasts. A kind of Middle Earth journey, so to speak. This season, we’re going to space.

    Tim Broadwater  

    We are, in the very last season, the episode of last season, which was the Mass Effect, you know, Episode 17, we entered a castle and launched into space. And so that’s where our adventure will continue for episode one of Season Two.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, I feel like we’ve done a lot of stuff in the first season that were just that was just entertaining for us, and a lot of that is going to continue for season two, but we we really kind of pride ourselves on you know, the quality of the podcast, or and try to improve it. You know, we’re UXers by trade. And so for season two, after we proved to ourselves that we can maintain a cadence and we have a really good workflow for producing these podcasts, we’ve added a little bit of complexity to kind of help us keep this ship afloat.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, I think people are gonna see that, you know, we have a new website. So if you visited our website, you know, designthinkinggames.com during Season One, it was it was really just kind of the episodes and a little bit about us. However, we’ve kind of really expanded between season one and season two, the scope of the website and the design, and so there’s a lot of information there that I think listeners will find useful. I think the biggest new announcement that they’re gonna, people are gonna see in season two, the episodes will have advertising pre roll, mid roll and post roll advertising. And so that will be a little bit of a change. If you’ve listened to us in the past. 

    Michael Schofield  

    Our goal is not to do ads that suck, though, because nobody everyone skips past them. And so we’re going to try to do host read ads exclusively, and partner with things that we like that actually matter to the kind of audience we’re targeting that matter to us.

    Tim Broadwater  

    If you’re interested, we actually have affordable, really cheap kind of slots. So other podcasts or game makers, you know, we can get your word out there as well. We have a decent listenership so far, and we’re only looking to grow. So if that’s something you’re interested in, you can head over to designthinkinggames.com and there’s an advertise link, and you can kind of find more information about that there support us, we support other people, it’s a community where we support each other.

    Michael Schofield  

    That’s right, we’re in it for the betterment of the community.

    Tim Broadwater  

    You know, we’re gonna have ads that are from the tabletop role playing game community, the gaming and game development community, and then ads that are from followers and listeners, and so you UXers as well. But we have a Patreon, which is was there just a hey, help us out, you know, during season one, but for season two, it actually has all of these really cool tiers that have okay, if you subscribe and support us at different tiers, you can get ad free versions of our episodes or even early releases of the episodes that that are ad free as well, so you can get them kind of up to a week early. If you’re on some putting us on Patreon.

    Michael Schofield  

    And to. And to our credit, the tears of our Patreon are hilarious. They are the best in the biz.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, you should definitely check them out even if it’s just a see them. Because it’s super cool

    Michael Schofield  

    patreon.com/designthinkinggames, you’ll see everything there.

    Tim Broadwater  

    We’ve kind of also want to give you something for supporting us because we appreciate that we appreciate the gaming community and the UX community. So I think you’ll find there’s some neat things that you can get if you support us and back us there.

    Michael Schofield  

    Speaking of we also have a newsletter that we made on designthinkinggames.com, you can subscribe to our newsletter for different kinds of announcements, we’ll probably give stuff away. And there’ll be possibly different kinds of content that are out there, it’s not going to hit your inbox every week 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Design Thinking Games is going to kind of be similar to season one. And that, you know, we’re kind of gonna go March to November. So it’s nine months. And the newsletter, which is just kind of signups for now is forthcoming. And then we’re talking about doing that maybe every two or three months. 

    Michael Schofield  

    So lots of stuff coming. We’re going to be respectful of your time and get out of your ears. You should follo w us on Twitter @DTGamesPodcast, 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Our listeners can you know, engage with us and kind of follow us on… you know, we’re on the three T’s we’re on Twitch, TikTok, and Twitter… 

    Michael Schofield  

    Twitch is a big one that I forgot. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah. Yeah. And so I think if you pay attention to those this coming season, you’re going to see a little, you know, kind of a crescendo or uptick in the interactions and activity there. If you follow us there should be should be a lot of fun. And you’ll get to see kind of maybe, behind the curtain some of the stuff that we’re doing.

    Michael Schofield  

    Lots of good stuff coming. Yeah, in fact, our first episode is going to be available to patrons on March 7th, and open to the general public with our dope-ass host-read ads on March 14. I think that’s it!

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the Design Thinking Games podcast. You only have so much time and it means a lot you shared it with us. To connect with your hosts Michael or Tim, visit Design Thinking Games on TikTok, Twitch, or Twitter. DMs are open. You can also check out designthinkinggames.com where you can request topics, ask questions or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on!

  • 000 v.2: Season 2 Intro

    000 v.2: Season 2 Intro

    Enjoy our fantastic and new season 2 intro for the Design Thinking Games, a Gaming and User Experience podcast.

    Welcome to Design Thinking Games, a gaming and user experience podcast. Card-carrying UXers Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper role-playing games, live-action games, and video games. Play through the backlog on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at designthinkinggames.com.

  • 017: N7 – The Holy Day of Mass Effect

    017: N7 – The Holy Day of Mass Effect

    Games talked about in this episode:

    • 0:50 Mass Effect
    • 7:54 Until Dawn
    • 10:27 Call of Cthulhu
    • 13:20 Final Fantasy
    • 16:50 Starfinder
    • 20:42 The Witcher
    • 31:40 Mass Effect 4
    • 33:27 Pokemon
    • 34:19 Mass Effect 5e
    • 36:23 Legend of Zelda

    Introductory Guy  

    Welcome to Design Thinking Games, a fantasy and user experience podcast. Each episode, your podcast hosts, Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield, will examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper role-playing games, live-action games, mobile games, and video games. You can find every episode, including this one on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at designthinkinggames.com.

    Tim Broadwater  

    This episode is brought to you by listeners like you at patreon.com/designthinkinggames.

    Michael Schofield  

    If we do this right, we’re releasing this before November 7. That is N7, the holy day of Mass Effect. And all throughout this series or throughout this season, I have frequently brought up Mass Effect this, Mass Effect that. I am a Mass Effects fanboy. We talked about Mass Effect, the Legendary Edition, and at some point, if folks ever have the inclination to go and listen back, you can hear as I gradually talk you, Tim, into sitting down and trying to play through what I think is one of the greatest series of all time. At this time, you have made it through, shoot, like 100 hours of gameplay between Mass Effect 1 and Mass Effect 3.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so it was released – just some context. We couldn’t get it until the Legendary Edition, which is the reboot, it didn’t come out until May 14, so I’m sure I bought it that day. And I’ve been playing it for what, five months? Six months? It’s big, it’s a lot.

    Michael Schofield  

    Well, I think the idea here is that with the rest of the last season, like in the back of our mind, we have introduced some concepts that I think the other gaming podcasts haven’t. These are things about games in terms of their usability, their design choice, user experience stuff; we talked about character, class, and customization, and the impact of those design choices on the player experience. So with all that in mind, this will be my opportunity to pick your brain about the Mass Effect universe. And we’re gonna weave in some of these concepts as we go. So Tim, tell us about Tim Shepard, captain of the Normandy.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Did I tell you I named him Tim Shepard?

    Michael Schofield  

    I think you did. You may not have, and I may have just assumed. Maybe before you were like, “I name all my people, Tim.”

    Tim Broadwater  

    I think yeah, it’s Tim Shepard. And it’s that through 1, 2, and 3. Okay, so Tim Shepard is a soldier who is halfway between good and evil. I guess they call it Paragon – and what’s the evil label?

    Michael Schofield  

    It’s Renegade. But Is Tim Shepard a spacer, a colonist, or earth-born? Tell us your story now. So you’re a soldier, Tim Shepard entered into the Alliance at an early age. And you picked Soldier and …

    Tim Broadwater  

    I was a sole survivor of a massacre.

    I went dark. It just seemed the most interesting like, you know, and then the first Mass Effect starts out you’re kind of ushered into like, your place, your potential as an important person in the human race as a Spectre.

    Michael Schofield  

    Right. Like early on in our season, we really talked about the importance of your ability to customize a character to your liking, where I think you and I actually took sort of, or like, slightly different stances where I prefer to be more on rails than not. You prefer freedom. I think Mass Effect does an interesting thing here where you have some amount of choice. There are some RPG elements, but as you set up your Tim Shepard for the first time, start fleshing him out as you accrued XP, you have classes. Then you have the whole morality train. How do you feel about your ability to customize Shepard to your liking?

    Tim Broadwater  

    So I’ve never played the originals, so I can only speak to, of course, what’s in the Legendary Edition. I mean, all you’re really doing is you choose sex and then essentially then kind of make up the face and voice, right? If I remember correctly, because it’s been a while since I set that up in the beginning, I remember thinking there are not many choices and there are not enough big beards. So I got the biggest beard that’s possible on a bald head because that’s my go-to in any game. So it’s like, I guess it’s just myself.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah. What about your ability to choose a class? In Mass Effect, you are given a choice of, I think, six classes. Off the top of my head, they are Soldier, Adept, Vanguard, Infiltrator, Engineer. That’s five. I’m missing one. But yeah.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So let me go ahead and put it at the beginning. It’s like Soldier was an easy class for just wanting to experience a story. And I’m like, check. The gameplay difficulty was just like, oh, just passive story, check. You know, because I, you know, I am not like a first-person or third-person shooter, typically. And I find that I toggle back and forth between Long Distance aiming and sniper aiming as well as like, I come from, like, MMO RPG. So when I navigate the world, I’m one of those people who always invert the y axis because I’m thinking, like, a plane or a cockpit to where I want to look down if I’m pressing forward.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, you are piloting your Shepard and not becoming your Shepard. Correct?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, and then the Soldier was the easiest. And I didn’t really know at the beginning, what biotics were, and all of that. So I kind of just went very simple. And that’s kind of, yeah, that was kind of the setup.

    Michael Schofield  

    So generally, what happens is you kind of pick your prequel, like you’re a lone survivor, earth born. And it suddenly puts you over the shoulder of Commander Shepard walking briskly through the Normandy where you are set to drop down on, I think the colony Eden Prime. And throughout this, like, you know, it’s teaching you some of the controls, this is how you jump, this is how you duck, this is how you aim – dah dah dah – and also, I think, gives you your first introduction to a conversation and how they handle choice. And I’m curious what you think.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so the conversation piece reminds me a lot of like, Until Dawn, or maybe Man of Medan, to where it’s like, there are certain things, you can just be like, okay, screw this and just in the conversation, or you can delve deeper and ask questions. And then at a certain point, you could ask things that have an emotional probe to him to where it’s like, are you kind of an ass, are you being like, nice, and then certain options are kind of like disabled. And I guess you can only do those if you either a have information or behave access that through the conversations kind of query or tree, you know, kind of progression, or you have to be like a paragon or renegade to ask worth a certain amount to be able to say something good, or as something to be evil, if so, very much. So I don’t know if it was anything new. But I mean, I never think about that. I never played this the first time around. So I don’t know if that influenced other games. 

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, I think at the time, this was super interesting, right? If you imagine traditional PC RPGs, where you have, say, three sentences at the bottom of the screen, and then you pick one, you don’t actually hear your character say them. You only have the response of the person you’re talking to. In this case, not only does your character veer a little off-script, so you might say, like, Sure, why not. And then your Shepard is going to put that in their own words. But it’s also one where you actually like, you know, you have a voice that you choose. How much control do you feel over that, or did you feel like this was railroaded? Was this, like, did you feel like you could take the conversation in a particular way or make choices in a particular way, or Were you pulled along magnetically without much? Was the choice only like an illusion?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, I mean, that’s a good question. So if I’m thinking of this right, Mass Effect came out in 2007, right? So the first one, like, I’m not sure.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, yep.

    Tim Broadwater  

    And so in games that I’m thinking of, like Call of Cthulhu, or Until Dawn or other games that have this narrative kind of concept. I mean, that definitely came afterward. So it is totally possible and probably is that it’s kind of gathered from Mass Effect. And I think you suggested that to me, originally, because like, Mass Effect won Game of the Year, I think, or maybe not the first one, but the second one did, definitely, right. So I didn’t feel constrained or anything. I never experienced it for the first time. It’s kind of like when you think of interaction models. And in user experience, it’s like, this is kind of what people come to expect after a while, you know, you can sort columns, you know, that’s just kind of something that people expect to do. And so like, dialogue, in games, I think, at some point, you know, I don’t know if it’s Elder Scrolls, or if it’s, you know if it’s a New World, or you know, or whatever the game is, per se, but at some point, you know, you feel like, you need to have options in conversation. And things you can say, and so, you know, I felt that mechanic is just has been adopted by games in general now, so, so not really felt restricted or anything, but just didn’t know that that’s exactly kind of, or most probably where that came from. 

    Michael Schofield  

    Something you said yesterday made it seem like you didn’t realize how many different directions everything could go.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So like, yeah, you know, the first game, the major thing that I’m hit with is like, and spoilers from, you know, 13 years ago.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, we’re gonna, we’re gonna spoil everything. Yeah, absolutely everything.

    Tim Broadwater  

    13-year-old spoiler here, but for a game that came out before the sequel, that won Game of the Year. In general, like there are choices, like in the first game, that it’s not until the end of the first game, where you start realizing like, oh, Wrex, Ashley versus Kaiden, do I save the Council at the Citadel, you know, these things? And then it doesn’t really hit me until the second game, which is the one the won Game of the Year that, oh, these actions have major consequences. And then the game is so epic. And it is, I think what I told you is like, it makes me feel like, Mass Effect 1, 2, and 3 remind me very much of like, the Lord of the Rings like it is this huge fantasy epic about the point in time where everything is at the risk of being toppled or destroyed by evil, and then all of everyone has to come together to save it. So it’s like the Final Fantasy moment, for lack of a better term. Because Final Fantasy, the game is always at the end of a world at the end of the brink of its destruction, you know what I mean? It’s always at that precipice. And so, the three trilogies like this trilogy here, I did not realize like, comparatively, like, Oh, if you let Aragorn die, he can’t save Minas Tirith. If you don’t like the surly space dwarf, you know, I mean, like, you’re not gonna see it’s not going to help you out in the next battle. And it’s like, Oh, crap. And so, having said that, now having played it and knowing that there is a 4th coming at some point, I would have to. I think I would be happy with what I did in 1, but I would definitely need to replay 2. Because of those choices that I’ve made in 2.

    Let’s talk about the narrative of 1, there are many things you can do in Mass Effect 1, but you have the main thread. And then you have a variety of side quests like I don’t know if you drove around in your Mako and found the space monkeys, but there’s a lot that.

    And that’s why I was telling you like when I was started just looking on YouTube, and it was like, Oh, you could get this, or you can see Tali’s face or, or you there’s an ending that does this, or you can have like, relationships between these people and, and I didn’t even romance anyone. I didn’t even try because I didn’t even think he could. And then I turned it down. So it’s like no, everyone could be romanced, everyone’s like you could have interspecies relationships, and I had no idea.

    Michael Schofield  

    Well, Mass Effect did something that made Fox News angry back in the day. because you could, you can have like, same-sex relationships. (Oh, yeah. Yeah. I remember) and, and the Mass Effect got like, I can’t say that Mass Effect got dragged by Fox News because I don’t think it had a significant impact. But there was a whole thing where, like, oh my god, there’s porn in Mass Effect.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Porn you don’t actually see, really. It’s just kind of like nudity, but nudity in porn.

    Michael Schofield  

    Do you know what I mean? We’re super desensitized and 2021, but perhaps 2007 was a genteel time.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I always think of it like nudity, and like Schindler’s List, I’m like, It’s not porn. It’s nudity.

    Michael Schofield  

    Exactly, exactly, no. Okay, so in Mass Effect, one, I kind of want to talk about the structure of how a basically like a three clue rule like structure or something similar about how, once you hit the title screen, you are given a variety of different paths that you can choose in any order that ultimately guide you to these observations. Oh, shit, Reapers. Oh, shit. Saren. And I’m curious how you think, the flow of the game, the kind of like, you know what I mean? Like your ability to like, navigate that narrow narrative, and whatever path, and I was curious kind of like what you think and like, I’m really interested in what you think of like the story, but also how you think the story was designed? 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so I think the universe is wonderful. The character species, and the down to the idiosyncrasies of them interacting with each other, you know, on the Citadel, and all that. So it’s amazing. It reminds me, honestly, of Starfinder, the role-playing game, right? Yeah. It reminds me of the depth of the universe like that Tolkien created with Lord of the Rings, and I maybe didn’t get that until two going into three. It was like, wow, this is really just its own universe, its own thing. And I understand. And I didn’t understand that going into it. Do you know what I mean? Probably, like Bilbo Baggins didn’t understand. Or like Frodo, like, just like, what is this ring? Okay, I’ll take it. And then you kind of realize how it affects everything, and destiny and all that. The game is 14 years old now. And so I don’t know if the story is. I don’t know if the story actually keeps pace over time regarding the three clue rule, right. Everyone’s seen Star Wars. Everyone’s seen many episodes of Star Trek. And so there’s a lot of this you can see coming in, I believe, and I know nothing about it. I’m just playing the Legendary Edition of the first one. And I think and most like the three clue rule, kind of like giving you like fleshing out the story.

    I just kind of could guess at the story. Super soon now, by the time I get, but that ended abruptly at two to completely like, but I think a lot of that is like the onboarding of you have to spend so much time with character development and universe development. Right? And the first one that it’s not, you can kind of go and drop on planets and explore like in your Land Rover and like find cool monsters and, and interact with aliens. And then you kind of find happenstance, like, Oh, crap, here are people who are slaving or here’s someone in the Citadel who’s doing something illegal, which I can bring up to him. And then you just kind of get this mountain of fluff that you’re like, Yeah, well, this is like the day in day out. Space police kind of deal with this.

    I’m not. I feel like I’m a Spectre. I have been empowered by all of the races of the Council, and I can or are the species, and I can literally just go and act with impunity. And so that’s kind of how I took it in one in two to where I was like, I don’t have time for this. I’m saving the universe. This is beneath me. You need to keep going. But I came to find out later that by not helping anyone or like doing that stuff and skipping that kind of stuff. So you eliminate contacts and opportunities, and stories change, and what happens changes. But conversely, if you wait too long, and you do too many side stories, and you do too many side quests, another consequence happens over time, which you can kind of see in the second one when you actually go through the red Mass Effect portal?

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, the one that takes you to the Collector ship (Correct).

    Tim Broadwater  

    I can’t think about what. But if you wait too long on that, right, more of your crew can get killed. So it’s kind of like, Here’s reality, suck it up, any choices you make or don’t make, anything you do or don’t do will affect the world in the story. And I will say that I’ve never experienced anything quite like that magnitude in any other game Except Mass Effect.

    Michael Schofield  

    It’s, it’s fascinating to hear, because the other thing that not to put like words in your mouth, but at one point, there’s like a player choice that you could just totally divorce from the narrative that says, like, I kind of just want to do the main quest, and I’m just going to do it, but as and that’s always fair, that’s how I feel about the Witcher way too many side quests can’t do, I’m just gonna follow the story, or whatever. But I always kind of distinguish that as you know, that’s a choice that I’m Michael in playing and not me, The Witcher. the way you described it, it is very in character, both to like I think the general Shepard umbrella, but also to like Tim Shepard, that like, Yo, the galaxy is about to end, being nice, and like, you know, helping this gentleman retrieve his wife’s ashes, or whatever is totally in conflict.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I’m saving all sentient life. I’m sorry that you need to deliver something. Yeah.

    Michael Schofield  

    Let’s talk about how that’s like that serious take affected your narrative story. So What was your choice with Wrex?

    Tim Broadwater  

    So I will say this. I found a YouTube video that said Mass Effect trilogy: All squadmates and crew die in the worst playthrough ever. And I was like, I feel attacked. Because I lost the majority of my crew in Mass Effect 2 when I went through the mass relay. I think that was it. It was the Omega 4 relay. I think it’s what it was called. I lost my entire crew except for Zaiid.

    Michael Schofield  

    Wow, and Zaiid is like a side character. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah. I lost every single crew member. People from one who made it over to two people who are new in two. Because it was, I mean, in. So for me, when I say to answer your question, I specifically focus on Listen, we’re here trying to save all organic and non-organic life. And that’s one of the things I actually like about the game as well. But to do that, we have to defeat this kind of foe. And there’s no time for, you know, what you’ve signed on for, you know what I mean? So one of the things that maybe I didn’t understand so much about the second one is you are kind of putting together this crew on behalf of Cerberus, and so so essentially, I was kind of like, you’re just gonna lose, people die. That’s what the life of being a Spectre is and saving the universe. It’s a suicide mission. Yeah, so I went on the suicide mission, and everyone got killed. And then I was like, holy shit. And then I started to realize, like, oh, no, you could have saved them. You just had to do this, or you had to do this. But if you did that, the doctor on the ship or the pilot, or like other people, like NPCs, you’re gonna sacrifice NPCs for PCs. And it’s just like, oh, (fascinating). Yeah, so then when I went into three, it was really dark. And you don’t have anyone. I was all on board for the quest to save the universe. Find out who’s controlling the Spectres and the Geth, and find out the Reapers and what they’re doing and what’s their plan and what’s the rationale? And then doing that. And then saving, you know, all of sentient life, essentially. Well, there were a lot of losses. So mine was tragic, like the ending of two for me was very tragic. It was very sad. And then the ending of three also was that as well because of 2.

    Michael Schofield  

    No, it’s thematically interesting, though, because you had chosen a lone survivor type of character for whom this wasn’t their only tragic event. And in a way, you opted for, like what I think is really kind of interesting about like, the story is that you made choices for the greater good at personal cost, right at the cost of people, you know, at the cost of the Council. Right. Because I think your choice to save the Council or not?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Oh, they just keep throwing it up into your face, through 2 and 3. Well, you didn’t save the Council. And it’s like, come on, because for people, I mean, I know the representatives of these races. (Yeah. But choose just four more people.) Exactly. That’s how I was looking at it, but no, like, they did not like that.

    Michael Schofield  

    Like as you experienced and kind of like waffling between Paragon and Renegade. Like, what do you think of those systems?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Um, I think they will be subjective based on what you as a player are tired of dealing with or want to do. So there are times where you want to be nice. And you’re like, I don’t care. But there are other times where you want to choose that option. Like the alien, like not the alien, but then, the little angel and the devil on your left and right shoulder. And it’s just like, they just pop up for a second. They’re like, Well, you could be nicer here. Or you could be more chivalrous or do something more honorable or responsible. Or you could be like, I’m tired of this shit. Let it be over, or like, I’m gonna throw out a threat. I’m a Spectre; you don’t know who I am. You know. And so it’s kind of, they give you that and then I think it’s up to you like how you want to deal with it or not. I think in most instances, I never have. It was always like a 50/50 with me. Depending on how mouthy some of the characters got, and I was like, you’re getting Yeah, you’re getting some Renegade, you know,

    Michael Schofield  

    Did you punch the reporter?

    Tim Broadwater  

    I did not punch the reporter. But I probably ended many relationships that could have been better just by being dumb to question my authority. I’m the captain of this ship, that kind of stuff. So when it came to my crew, I was just like my way the highway, you’re my crew, I can drop you off the next planet, you know. So I was definitely in Star Trek terms. I was more of a Janeway and less of a Picard if that makes sense. There are all these different types of artificial intelligence, synthetic life, or whatever you want to call it. And they all have different philosophies, and what I really like about the Geth, and probably Legion, is one of my favorite characters in the game. And if I actually went back and redid, the changes I would make would be to still let the majority of my crew die. But, to be honest, I wouldn’t be like, Oh, but I saved them all. But I would save Legion. And I would definitely save – not Rex, but I think Grunt, you know.

    Michael Schofield  

    That’s interesting because they’re both kinds of like, almost like infant-like characters, right? Grunt is literally like a test tube Krogan. And Legion is an unshackled AI who kind of discovers, I think, Shepard’s armor if I remember right. And starts modeling itself after the standard that Shepard set. And both seem like, ultimately, incredibly innocent, in a way. So that’s why I love the Geth. At first, you’re like, Oh, my God, they’re all bad guy robots. But the reality is, it’s fascinating because they are synthetic life that achieved a kind of consciousness and discovered very Matrix-like that they were enslaved. Right.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah. And they are still unique, and individuals and their experiences are that, but they also connect and share one another. Yeah. I like that a lot. And then it sucks that Joker is such an NPC, but I understand why he can’t go into battle and why.

    Michael Schofield  

    Joker played by Seth Green. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    he did a great job with that voice. And I would say that apart from I would say the only other person I really had the feels for would be interested enough in saving, I think, is Jack.

    Michael Schofield  

    I love Jack Yeah. Jack’s amazing. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so I feel like those are the characters that I would want with me in the end. But, um, you know, if, unfortunately, like if Frodo had to choose like, Okay, this is the Fellowship of the Ring, but you can only keep three at the end who you got to keep, like, I know that’s kind of a stupid way or maybe a morbid way to think of it But that’s how I would think it was like I want Legion. I want Grunt, and I want Jack. 

    Michael Schofield  

    I feel like it’s totally realistic. There’s so much in general that I want to ask you around, like sequelization and how you think the Mass Effect 2 played against Mass Effect 1 played against Mass Effect 3 played against Mass Effect 2. Because the sequels were a deliberate choice, they’re supposed to model space operas where the second one is always the darkest timeline. And then the third one is redemption or saving and stuff like that. But there’s also like, just like narrative questions that I’m really interested in talking to you about, like, you know, gosh, what’s like, what’s like the saddest moment.

    Tim Broadwater  

    The saddest moment, really?

    To answer your specific question, that note at the beginning of three, just like the hopelessness of sentient life and innocence, just knowing that it can do nothing except being destroyed or harvested. I mean, that is, that’s pretty sad, you know, and that’s pretty potent. Now. Of course, I will say, the second to that before, to answer your question is that when Tali and Garus bite the bullet at the end of 2 for me, yeah, that was like, oh, I kind of knew you are more. I’m sorry. That really hurt a little bit more. And then when Legion died, that was the worst. So having watched the trailer for Mass Effect 4, it gives me chills, but then it makes you wonder like wild crab, depending on anything you chose, in three houses 4 even going to work. But if Cerberus does have this technology as we know the Reapers do, that allows someone to be brought back from death? Because it’s already happened? Sure, then is all not lost? I mean, can we save the entire crew? Are the Reapers even a problem anymore? You know, so I have a lot of questions. Of course, that will not be answered until it’s out. But, you know, I believe that trailer came out this year, right? But there’s a lot of things online too where people are like, hey, the reason why the Legendary Edition is dropping is that they want people to play through the three again for that save game file to be important.

    Michael Schofield  

     I think that’s what it is. I’m sure they’ll pick up a canonical ending, right? Because one of the things that like Casey Hudson I was, I was doing a little bit of like reading Casey Hudson was like the head of Bioware at the time. And one of the things that he said is that Mass Effect 3 was a lot easier to write than one or two because you didn’t have to think about continuing or continuity after Mass Effect 3. So I wonder if they’re going to do something where they’re gonna pick like a canonical choice. Or they’re going to like, not reference it at all. Right?

    Tim Broadwater  

    You play a Dungeons and Dragons Fifth Edition game that’s modded for Mass Effect, right? (Yes.) Yeah. So I’ve played one for Pokemon to where you can be a trainer, and as you level up, you can control more Pokemon or own more and have them there, they get powers, and then you can eventually like more higher-level stuff and, and so I know that dungeon dragon mods are fun now having experienced Mass Effect, one, two, and three, I see how this is like a huge, like, a world or galaxy of fiction. Just like, you know, like I said, Lord of the Rings, Star Trek, Star Trek, Star Wars, whatever. And so I guess I’m just wondering, like, how long have you been playing it? And is it an official one, or is it fanmade? One?

    Michael Schofield  

    It’s fanmade. One, it’s at n7.world. The world is the domain. And it’s a fanmade Mass Effect homebrew (Oh, wow). And I think I’ve been playing it for like a year now. (And it’s 5e, so that’s pretty recent.) And it’s 5e. My friend Sopher is the Dungeon Master. So I’m usually the Dungeon Master. So I’m actually a player. I play a Geth named Myriad. Myriad contains multitudes, and I think Myriad’s a cool ass character. Myriad is a philosopher unshackled from – he’s an unshackled AI interested in identifying self from the cornucopia of his personalities. So how, like, his entire journey is like, how does he turn we into I? And, honestly, we’re a bunch of like murder hobos.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I mean, that’s pretty much all.

    Michael Schofield  

    And we’ve sort of become like pirates, right? Like, like in a weird like way. And I believe we are adjacent to the or just a little bit before the beginnings of Mass Effect because we haven’t encountered Reaper or anything like that. We are legit just going through a pretty cool narrative. That is, I mean, kind of mundane if you think about like, it’s like all the Reapers are when the gods arrive, or whatever is like this is like, you know, pre that or pre Sauron. Right? Yeah, this is like Second Age middle earth. There are still bad guys and stuff.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I wanted to play or experience more about the Elcor. I actually thought that that race was super cool.

    Michael Schofield  

    So in the homebrew, you can play as an Elcor.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Like, this is gonna sound weird, and I’m not saying it’s gonna happen. But I feel like there are some times with Legend of Zelda, right? And I’m going somewhere, so follow me. But Legend of Zelda was like a universe. It’s a myth, right? It has people and races and stuff because it’s become that way over time. So now we know that there are Gorons, the rock people, and these fish people on the planet. And there are these bird people. And then there’s the ancient Hyrulean and the bloodline and Ganon and evil and everything. Okay, so if you just step back and look at the universe, when they made it into Breath of the Wild, and it was a 3d game that you can play that’s open world expansive. It got people’s brains thinking. So what I’m wondering is, does Shepard matter so much in Mass Effect? If Mass Effect was an MMO RPG?

    Yes, to where you could make any race of characters you have a class, and then I’m not saying that there aren’t Spectres or Shepards. And those are important. Do you know what I mean? Or Spectres per se, and Shepard being like the Luke Skywalker of this one story or what have you. Like, the myth needs that like, and I know that Lord of the Rings has done something like this, where it’s like, Hey, you can just make a dwarf for halfling or, or Hobbit, I mean, or elf, and then you can kind of explore the world. It doesn’t have to be the main story, right? It doesn’t have to be you don’t have to be with Frodo or Gandalf. But I mean, you can still experience the world as any of the species that are there. And I was just wondering, like, that sounds cool. And from what you’ve been describing, as this fifth edition mod, I mean, that sounds like something that would be a lot of fun, but I don’t know if that’ll ever make it to do a video game per se. You know,

    Michael Schofield  

    it’s really neat. In my experience, the world is fine without Shepard, and I’m a Mass Effect fanboy. But that world is less interesting than, say, Middle Earth is without Aragorn, right. Like, like, it’s, it’s cool. But I think it really depends on the quality of the story, so I think if it were just like a half-assed MMO, it probably feels pretty bad. I feel like Star Wars online might have done that better. Anyway, like, it’s, it’s interesting. And so like, I know, there’s an entire world where Shepard did some Shepard stuff. But the galaxy is large. Liara ends up as the Shadow Broker. And has her own life and her own wishes. And, and the other thing you forget about is like Liara, and the other Asari live many human lifetimes. And like, I think it’s interesting, like when I think of like, playing like elves, or whatever, or shit like Superman, when I think of characters that are above and beyond, I care less about their powers and where they’re like, oh, like, oh, the dwarf can like swing a hammer or whatever. But what I really like, in terms of like, the narrative opportunity is like, Okay, what is it like being 2000 years old? How much do you care about anybody? And like, my suspicion is that like, the older you get, the less you care? The less interest there is, like with Geth, what is it like being multiples and freely going between individual and multiples or freely choosing a personality? That’s right for the situation. Like that’s kind of interesting. The other thing about Geth that’s really interesting is like you’re immortal, right? Like, you can clone your processes, your subroutines, and come back as long as you sync up to somewhere else. Right? So what is that like? And I find that really interesting. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    I guess I didn’t realize how much of the universe existed when you told me to check out Mass Effect Legendary Edition. I thought, Oh, this is a game, I’ll play it. It’s like 123. You’re packing together, whatever. But I guess I didn’t really realize going into it like, oh my gosh, this is a mythos this has all the way down. This is an epic space saga, but it’s also how did I not know about this? Do you know what I mean? Yeah, so I know about the Marvel Cinematic Universe. I know what everyone knows about Star Wars and what Disney is doing with Star Wars, and I like trying to expand the universe and put in more stories and tell more, and fill in the gaps and then just grow it right. And Marvel’s been doing that forever. But I’m just wondering, like, do you see it this way? Because you also talked about fiction? Are there canon books that are written, not fanfiction? 

    Michael Schofield  

    It all starts with the Codex, too, right? I mean, you can dump hours into reading the Codex. They have a really interesting prequel, like, what was like early Earth civilization, like, around the time they discovered the Prothean ruins on Mars? And then we were introduced to galactic society, there’s like, shit like that. It’s really interesting to

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so I never considered it as a media franchise.

    I didn’t realize it. I don’t know how a fandom and I say fandom instead of like, yeah, you know, kind of immediate franchise. Like, I just didn’t realize that there was art and novels and games and like, just all of this stuff. And then there are films, apparently. It has toy lines. It’s just like, it’s a lot, and I’m just like, how did I get to this point in my life? Like and I didn’t even realize that this cool and I love Starfinder and I and the reason why I love Starfinders, because there was no game or system out there that spoke to my sci-fi and I had giant hopes, like we talked, you know, before dystopian stuff like cyberpunk or whatever. But I mean, like, this has been here for a long time, and I just have never, for 13 or 14 years, I just didn’t even know about its existence. I’m very grateful that I now know, and I have a glimpse into this world that I’ve never done before. You know,

    Michael Schofield  

    just think about all of the other things that are out there in this wide galaxy of ours.

    Tim Broadwater  

    We put a lot of work into Design Thinking games. So if you like what we do and want to help us cover some costs, consider supporting us at patreon.com/designthinkinggames. We also are Design Thinking Games on TikTok, Twitch, and Twitter.

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the Design Thinking games podcast. To connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim, please go to designthinkinggames.com, where you can request topics, ask questions or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on.

  • 016: Interactive Fiction and Storytelling

    016: Interactive Fiction and Storytelling

    Games talked about in this episode:

    • 1:09 House of Ashes
    • 2:00 Until Dawn
    • 5:26 Man of Medan
    • 8:31 Silent Hill: Shattered Memories
    • 15:49 Resident Evil
    • 20:47 Little Hope

    Introductory Guy  

    Welcome to design thinking games, a fantasy and User Experience podcast. In each episode, your podcast hosts Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield, will examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper role-playing games, live-action games, mobile games, and video games. You can find every episode, including this one, on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at designthinkinggames.com.

    Tim Broadwater  

    This episode is brought to you by listeners like you at patreon.com/designthinkinggames.

    It is Halloween 2021. Our podcast Design Thinking Games does skew to players and gamers who like horror and mystery and phantasmagoria. That’s definitely apparent from season one. And one of the things we talked about doing for Halloween, playing and checking out the new game House of Ashes, the Dark Picture Anthologies third out of four games for season one. And so I guess the first question is, how many of your five main characters survive?

    Michael Schofield  

    I got through with three. I had three survivors. We should preface this just for folks who don’t know that, okay, so like, there is a series made by a variety of people but namely supermassive – Supermassive Games? Supermassive is the studio – called the Dark Pictures Anthologies. They now have three of them, and they have promised four for what they’re calling their first season. Supermassive got famous or got lauded for their Until dawn game, which was a PlayStation exclusive.

    Tim Broadwater  

    And did they make Until Dawn?

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah!

    Tim Broadwater  

    I love Until Dawn. That’s why I love this, you know, kind of genre, like watching a horror movie.

    Michael Schofield  

    That’s what it is. Right? It’s a choose your own adventure with quick-time actions. Right. And so, you know, Telltale got pretty popular doing this for a little bit. But Supermassive Games did it right. Whereas Telltale is pretty buggy in certain cases. For the most part, these are really well-put-together narratives that have really interesting branches. So they have three games out. They just released House of Ashes.

    Tim Broadwater  

    And I think the trailer has been out for a year because of what they’ve been doing. And what I kind of like, is that when you beat one game, the reward for beating the game is it unlocks the trailer for the next book. And so you don’t really know until you beat the game. I mean, you could kind of check online after the game comes out. But it’s kind of that nice piece where like, where’s it going next? And so a year ago, when you beat Little Hope, which is the small kind of Salem’s Lot witch village one when you beat that you got a trailer at the end for House of ashes, which is, I believe, set in Desert Storm, right?

    Michael Schofield  

    No. It’s 2003. This is post 9/11. This is the invasion of Iraq. So House of ashes is set there. You play a number of participants, mostly Marines. There’s a CIA operator. You also get to play one of the Iraqi Republican Guard, which takes place after the fateful announcement where George Bush announced, “Mission accomplished,” there’s even a newspaper lying around where you can see it on the front page. So Saddam has fallen. And it’s almost the immediate aftermath of that when go figure they’re still looking for chemical weapons and weapons of mass destruction. And the entire premise is that, hey, satellite imagery has shown that there is an underground facility out here and the middle of nowhere in the middle of next to what they call the Zagros Mountains, and you are part of or the people you play are going to investigate it.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, and I think the other thing is it’s so fresh that the war being fresh or Saddam, all of that so fresh that even members of the Iraqi military, right? They’re not –

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah, no surrender has been declared.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Correct. Yeah. So that’s the environment you’re going into. And, and if you’re familiar with the other games, it’s layers of an onion, right? So you just kind of constantly peeling back, and it gets deeper and deeper and deeper. And if you’ve played Man of Medan or Little Hope, it starts out as like, this is one thing that you think you know what’s going on. And then it kind of goes into like, oh, and expands like what you think is happening at the beginning, where you’re just exploring, like your, what you say Marines, and that you’re exploring a potential weapon site, turns into like, Oh, this is not a weapon site. And then when you think that’s going on that you’ve encountered, let’s say, in an ancient temple, or something of that nature that’s been buried, then it turns out that that’s not what’s going on. And then when you kind of go down that rabbit hole, it again is like, No, you have no idea what’s going on. And I think what I like is I did horrible, you’ve played all three games. And I think I played all three as well. I did so horribly in the first one that, you know, this is now three years old, that you were in Man of Medan. So you can end the game prematurely and lose a lot of your characters and not really uncover the full story. And that’s common. That’s a very common experience. And so, you may not get to the full truth. And then the other thing is the Curator, right? 

    Michael Schofield  

    The Curator is this kind of Call of Cthulhu-like keeper character, who there’s not really any kind of narrative sandwich here, where for whatever reason, you are helping the Curator flesh out these tales.

    Tim Broadwater  

    He’s kind of judging you. But then also prying you at some points, giving you a hint.

    Michael Schofield  

    there’s something sort of supernatural about it. Right? Because you are not really the characters in the stories you’re telling, you are choosing their fates, you are that meta, you are that player. And the Curator, some sort of, I don’t know –

    Tim Broadwater  

    He definitely treats you like a reader or as a game. Yeah. Like, if there’s that acknowledgment of the fourth wall, that it’s like, oh, he will say comments. If someone dies accidentally or makes a wrong choice, you will call out your choice and why you let that person kill them. So the tense is not of the character. It’s actually you outside of it. And he acknowledges that omniscient kind of the fourth wall.

    Michael Schofield  

    I think that’s a really, I think that’s a great way to put it, this kind of like fourth wall framing is, provides like a really interesting dynamic, because you’re right, the Curator judges you like you made a bad choice. And so, and one of the characters dies, and he kind of tsks you could have gone another way he begs that question, and you know, it could have you could have made a different choice.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so there’s another mechanic that’s similar to this. I don’t know if you’ve ever played some of the Silent Hill games, right? (Yeah.) So there’s one Silent Hill: Shattered Memories. I don’t know if you’ve played that one. But the whole thing keeps going. Yeah, so every so often, you cut back to like, you are obviously sitting, and it could even be like an L.A. Noir thing. Like you’re telling you’re in the with police or a homicide detective and you’re recounting what happens, and then it keeps coming back to that. But in Shattered Memories, you’re with a therapist, and you’re kind of telling them what you experienced in Silent Hill. And they’re like, Well, why did you do that? Or why did you go there or why? And so there was this kind of outside character that frames this horrible experience that you’re going through and this phantasmagoria-like, mystery kind of intense, horrific experience. So it’s nothing new, but what I will say about the Curator is that I think they are pretty hard on the nose, hinting that he is Death.

    Michael Schofield  

    Maybe! Oh, I don’t know. I didn’t get any of that.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Every time the lightning flashes, he’s got the skull overlay, or you see the skull behind the face right, really you every time the lightning flashes (wow, I never noticed) the scar behind him. And then the intro music for all three games is the old mountain music, “I am Death,” but they’ve turned it into a rock kind of thing. And then when the credits roll at the end, it’s “I am Death,” but it’s like a punk thing, right? So it changes the flavor, but the song is still “I am Death.” And so he always takes this kind of posturing to where, you know, he’s kind of intrigued and judging it what you’re doing, but then also, maybe will help you, but that he is outside the story, he cannot interfere. And he is just the Curator or the Chronicler. (Wow.) You never got that impression?

    Michael Schofield  

    In three games now, that never dawned on me. So like, I thought of him more as like a, like a Sandman comic book-like character, where, where I guess Death is literally a character in the Sandman as well. But I think of him as sort of like the librarian or the keeper, like, like a proper chronicler I like that there’s some sort of like, thing, where he expresses that you the player are The Choice-maker, there are rules that he must adhere to, and he is not allowed to interfere. But occasionally, he will bend those rules to offer a little bit of help, a little bit of guidance, but in general, (like he’s a deity or something). Well, I mean, like, you know, and if he’s not the rule maker, he is bound by some other rules. So what I think it really does is kind of interesting, because there’s a layer like, there, there are different layers of agency. Whereas you know, these characters are so well defined that they are, they have their own choices, they have their own personality, makeup, they have a sense of their own direction, their own agency, but the reality is, as a player, you are making these choices for them. Or you are making the choices for some other unspoken unnamed character who is also making choices for them. And you are part of some larger framework with a curator of which there are rules. And you know, the choices that you actually get are quite limited. They’re only like, go left, go right, do this, don’t do that. And there’s this whole, I don’t know, you could probably deconstruct this entire Dark Anthology series as some sort of like a message about how little control you actually have in any given situation, someone’s already making a choice for you, or the path is largely laid out before you.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, I guess I’ve always interpreted that way. Because, you know, anytime that you visit him, or cut to him, or begin with him or end with him in his library, where he has all of the books about what’s happened and in and is interacting with you, it is always storming outside, and every time it cracks, the lightning, you see the skull behind his face, every single time and all three games, right? And then the logo for the Dark Picture Anthologies is a skull that has, you know, it changes the overlaid image each time for, you know, Man of Medan, or Little hope or House of ashes, and then also for the one they show at the end, which is the Devil Inside, I believe. And so I’m,

    Michael Schofield  

    I mean, now that you say it out loud, this totally makes sense, right?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Well, no, I also think I know what you’re talking about with Sandman. So he does seem like, okay, he’s the deity as well as a curator, and you get appearances behind that he is his Death, you know, and that’s how I’ve taken it. And you can find pictures online where it actually has the skull, flash lightning kind of overlay. And it’s, it’s happened in all the games. So

    Michael Schofield  

    yeah, I’m gonna go back and like I’m gonna do I’m gonna, I’m sure there’s like a YouTube cut of like, all the who was the curator kind of conspiracy theory because now it’s super interesting, but I love the framing. And I love the idea that it’s ultimately like, you know, these characters are hopeless because no choice they make is their own.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, and all of the tales, it doesn’t matter. You know, there’s only three out now, but they’re all tragic. All of them have Death, like in the first and the second game. There’s so much Death in the beginning. So that I mean, it just sets the pace of like, there’s no way that you can save the people in the beginning, you know. It’s the same thing here, like your whole team who goes in and everyone you know, maybe there’s 10 or 12 people. Still, five are really all you potentially can save, and to your point, like you save three, I only save two, and mine came down to where I thought it was doing really well. They were surviving longer, but then it was one of those Gosh, darn freaky horror? What did you call it? It’s like a skills check (a quick time action). Yeah, like a quick time action jumpscare or a skill check kind of thing where you’re running, and you’re trying to, you have to hit something at a certain time. And you’re literally like, oh, no, I was scratching my face or I went, I was reaching for my drink, or I was eating a chip at the end here, and they’re dying. And so it’s like, oh, so it does keep you. So at the edge of your seat. And we’ve talked about this before in the horror mechanics method like you cannot run in the game. You have to walk through everything. So it forces you to experience it. It forces you to pay attention. And, and all it takes is one second. And you could, and everything could change.

    Michael Schofield  

    The biggest thing I clocked here was that this felt like Resident Evil controls because you’re over the shoulder, or a little bit behind, you’re piloting the character. You’re slow. It’s dark,

    Tim Broadwater  

    you’re enclosed, tight, enclosed,

    Michael Schofield  

    And so sometimes the camera is actually really quite difficult to control. And, you know, we’ve talked in the past about like, well, you know, in another circumstance, these could be pretty annoying controls. But in this case, they force you to pay very careful attention. Pan the camera very deliberately, right? Check your corners, right? Because oftentimes, you’re walking around in a cave with a flashlight, so you know, you’re going bit by bit, and it just forces you to take it at a certain pace so that ultimately the game can control the narrative and scare you or worry you with a quick time action that you weren’t prepared for.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, I think that totally contributes to the creep factor on it. But then you can’t shoot. You’re not like, like, you can just unload. Yeah, you could never really unload

    Michael Schofield  

    until it let’s see if it gives you an option. Yeah. You had to give this a rating. You recommend people like, how did you like this?

    Tim Broadwater  

    I liked the game series because I like it and I didn’t know. Or at least maybe I forgot that. The same studio made Until Dawn. Now until Dawn takes about nine hours, eight to nine hours to play through it. And so it is doable in a day. But what I like – a movie is too short, right? A movie is like your hour and a half or two hour kind of movie. But I feel like they have this just right. Like they have this to where you are watching a mystery, drama, horror, whatever action or whatever. But that’s the genre, right? And they keep it to like roughly five to six hours, the game will be over no matter what, at the max Yeah, five to six hours, like it could be definitely premature. I mean, you can kill all the characters and be done much sooner. But like, whatever the ending is, whatever you’ve chosen, whoever you’ve protected, or you know, or like, whatever choices you’ve made, or whatever paths or secrets you’ve uncovered, it’s set to that time. So it’s kind of like you are watching this scary horror drama movie. And you are making choices and doing skill checks through it. And so it is passive, but you are on the edge of your seat. And so I say in general if you like scary movies, or you like survival horror, or you just like mystery books, I think this type of game, this game series is for you. And what I also like about it, and we’ve talked about this before, social media is very popular in telenovelas and soap operas. And we’re also seeing like an American Horror Story is that you have characters coming back, real actors coming back every season, right? Who played just different characters, doing different things with different names. And I strongly believe now I can’t say this for certain, but I strongly believe that is what the Dark Picture anthologies are doing with their characters.

    Michael Schofield  

    Until you mentioned it in a tweet to me, like I think you’re right. I think the Marine Lieutenant you play with is Jason. His face looks like the main character whose name I forget in Little Hope, who is ultimately responsible for the events of that series. And who grows up to be that bus driver at the end. Their faces look identical. And I think Rachel is –

    Tim Broadwater  

    That’s also Joe from Man of Medan. Joe from Man of Medan is the same person you’re described. Yes. And so I love it. There are these. So I think that it’s kind of a nod. Either they’re trying to get away with it. But I don’t think that’s the case because gamers are smart, and they know that. So I honestly think that they are kind of aligning themselves with this telenovela, soap opera, American Horror Story kind of thing to where we have, hey, we can use, we can use the same actors, it’s the models, right, but we can change the voices and change their personalities. Because a lot of people I think, are making these connections between, you know, the main character in House of Ashes and Joe for Man of Medan, or the girlfriend or the scientist, you know, the girlfriend from, you know, Little Hope, or the scientist from House of ashes. I mean, they’re the same kind of thing. So, I find that that’s kind of, that’s cool. That’s interesting. And that is what keeps people in the series, and when you beat each one like we said, it shows you the trailer for the next one. So that’s kind of the cliffhanger. Within a year, it’s gonna come out. I don’t know when the next one’s gonna come out, which is The Devil Inside. But I feel like that’s the appeal. Like it’s like, I’ll come back to it’s like Jessica Lange, like for American Horror Story, like people will keep coming back if they keep using Jessica Lange or, or Lady Gaga, or, you know, Angela Bassett, or whoever.

    Michael Schofield  

    It’s a really interesting mechanic, right? I guess they did do that with telenovelas, the, you know, I think of it as an American Horror Story trope. And it’s really neat to see that applied to a game. I can’t think of anyone who has done that. And I also would hazard a guess, although I’m happy to be wrong, that it has no bearing on the narrative. So I have this like, like, high-level theory, that’s only like that I only 10% by myself, but I think there’s a potential here or like, oh my gosh, like, all of these characters are all the same, like reincarnations, like something like this.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Well, the Curators are the same. You’re the same. And then when you’re in the curators’ library, and he has four books there that all have these golden symbols on them, and one is of a boat, and one is a little doll, and one is, have you know that it keeps you wondering, like how are these four related and why they encapsulated in a series? And then you know, and then this is not an I don’t think this is a stretch by anyway because if you look at the characters of House of Ashes – who was Rachel, not her husband, but the one that he was in a relationship with? (Nick. Sargent, Nick.) Nick, literally, is the same face as Alex from, you know, the first game Man of Medan. So like what it is, it’s the same thing.

    Michael Schofield  

    Alex is the kind of nerdy character who went along with his brother on the boat, right?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, but in this one, he’s a Marine. He’s been through some trauma, and then is exactly, and so Dude, it has to be there. They have to be building up to something. The fanboy in me is like geeking out because it’s like what is and then when they also the big drama bomb that they also dropped at the end was not just you know, the trailer for the next game, but then also the announcement that this is part of “season one” that’s like what right so so that actually season one does put parentheses around the first floor right exactly promises that there will be something different coming.

    Michael Schofield  

    How strange, right, especially because these are about like a year apart. Right? They’ve taken a while to come out, and I’ve never considered them as part of a singular whole, I guess. I guess when you think about it makes sense. Because these are part, this is an anthology series, but I never thought of them as part of a singular tale. Until they’re like, bam, the next episode being or the next game is like the Devil Within, I think (The Devil Inside or something like that.) Yeah, like you know, the season one finale and I’m like, Whoa, okay, so now you have to kind of like think back on the three games that you have just finished as some part of a whole. One thing I wanted to point out that really struck me is that House of Ashes to me was the least scary of the two and there, but there’s a framing that is true about Man of Medan – (let me ask of the three which one was the scariest for you?) I think maybe Little Hope was the scariest.

    Tim Broadwater  

    It was for me. Yeah, I agree with you. It was creepy. Those ghosts were super creepy.

    Michael Schofield  

    For real, man. Well, and even a Man of Medan like the ghosts are creepy as well. Right?

    Tim Broadwater  

    You Can only if you prematurely end the game, you’re left with like, Oh, this is what I think’s going on. And this is what I meant by the onion peeling back, like the layer. Yeah. But if you make it through the game, you will see what’s going on. And you can never really replay it. I mean, it’s really, not to get the story will not have the same impact, right? Like the onion story, like a metaphor. It’s like the first one, you’re like, Oh, we’re gonna go explore this abandoned ship, we can get it for treasure. And then you’re like, oh, it’s haunted. And then you find out something else is going on behind it that explains it. But at some point, you may not even make it to the haunted ship. You could die before you even get there. Right? And then you could also die when? And you’re like, Oh, my God, I got killed by ghosts because the ship is haunted. And then you don’t realize, oh, what’s real? You know, the story behind it? That happened to me, right? Now the second game, same thing, you’re like, I’m going to this witchy cursed town. It’s like Salem’s Lot. And then you kind of find out after a while. It’s like, oh, wait, I’m kind of getting the feeling that why are these ghosts specifically like, the vices of these people? And then you kind of figure out like, Oh, this is not happening at all, what’s happening is actually this same thing for, you know, kind of House of Ashes.

    Michael Schofield  

    Have you gone and looked at the other endings? Because I haven’t. But I didn’t get the sense that there was one of those things in House of Ashes. I get the sense that what you think is happening is really happening.

    Tim Broadwater  

    No, it’s just like how far you get Gotcha. Because what I’m saying about the onion metaphor now, and it’s horrible. And I keep saying again, but what it is if they constructed the story, in such a way that it functions layer by layer to a core, so if you don’t make it like in House of ashes, I will say, Man of Medan has been out for 2019 since 2019. So no real spoilers there, but the thing is, it is like you can die before you even get to the ship. So it’s just like, Oh, it’s a bunch of kids partying, and they have a diving accident, and it’s over.

    Michael Schofield  

    Wait, what? There’s an ending that’s that early?

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, no, no, it’s not like an ending. What I was saying about the UX here (amazing) is of a pick-a-path story, like a Choose Your Own Adventure book. And if the listeners at home probably know what those are. But they have pick-a-path as a name brand or choose your own adventure as a name brand. But essentially, it’s this book that you start reading on page one for those who don’t know it. And then it says, like, Hey, make this choice. And if you make this choice, go to page 42. If you made this one, go to page 387. And then you kind of keep jumping, so you’re just kind of, you start out, all the same, you start out at the base of the tree, right? When we say this kind of tree, kind of pick-a-path kind of narrative system. So they’ve been constructed, so it’s better probably as a tree than an onion because I think of it more like layers, right? But at any point in that story of Man of Medan, if all of your characters die, or you come to a halting stop, for whatever reason, and maybe some characters survive, you know, you didn’t go to the full extent of the branches of the tree. And you don’t really know what all’s possible that’s given with pick a path stories, because you can’t figure out like, Oh, I didn’t even interact with the dragon, or I didn’t even see the knight or didn’t go into the base, you know, but with these, it is you didn’t, you have to make it through. And part of the mechanics of these Dark Anthology games is finding they have these little pictures that are, you know, spread out through the game or tablets, or artifacts or objects or whatever, but they actually show you a potential future you have a premonition. And then when you do that, it creates like a branch, which lets you mitigate and stop. Now, if you didn’t find that picture, that branch end would be your end. Or you wouldn’t know who’s coming and that could have been your head. But you kind of have to, and I don’t know if you agree with this or not, but I feel like those games are structured in such a way where you are trying to find all those pictures to try to mitigate all of the potential premature endings or short endings, so you can make it through the longest tree out to the tiniest branch. And that is what you find out. Like at the very end, that’s the only way that you will find your survival. And mitigating those and navigating these branches or tree systems is the only way you’ll find out what’s really, really, really going on. Because if you do not, you think you’re just a bunch of kids who died like partying on a boat or you encountered a ship and were killed by pirates, or you’ve encountered ships you got away from the pirates, but you did not use the ship was haunted, or you know and so on. 

    Michael Schofield  

    It really is a masterclass of game design. You can tell that they playtested the shit out of this. The timing, the feel, the unraveling stories, the way House of Ashes literally is about descending through layers, and the story gets weirder and weirder. And first, that’s got very big exorcist vibes with like Pazuzu the demon right which is a spoiler because I think that’s literally like the like one of the symbols on the in the like the trailers or whatever, and it continues to go back and here’s digging through history and history the weirdness unravels in such an impressive way.

    Tim Broadwater  

    I feel like there’s also this there is these weird kind of nods and connections that are actually in like American Horror Story right that is like, oh wait, Freak Show’s connected to Asylum, and we now know that because we saw a Freak Show which happened two seasons after Asylum and the character from Freak Show was in Asylum right. And then we found out later that oh Hotel is connected to Coven because they actually go to it. 

    Michael Schofield  

    And even that, like post-apocalyptic one, is connected to Coven as well.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, and so it’s these little pieces that are put together, but the thing about these games is like if you didn’t see that stuff, pay attention or choose the right path. You probably didn’t get the connections.

    Michael Schofield  

    What a design choice, man, that just makes its replayability. Again, this is narrative layering that is impressive, like it is just impressive.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Very impressive.

    We put a lot of work into Design Thinking games. So if you like what we do and want to help us cover some costs, then consider supporting us at patreon.com/designthinkinggames. We also are Design Thinking Games on Tiktok, Twitch, and Twitter.

  • 015: Usable Games with Michael Fienen and Aaron Hill

    015: Usable Games with Michael Fienen and Aaron Hill

    Games talked about in this episode:

    • 6:12 Monopoly
    • 10:40 Chinatown
    • 17:12 Diablo 2
    • 20:28 Sonic the Hedgehog
    • 22:18 For Honor
    • 26:14 Betrayal at House on the Hill
    • 30:38 Dominant Species
    • 31:29 Roll for the Galaxy
    • 32:46 Zombicide
    • 34:29 Call of Cthulu
    • 37:07 Gloomhaven
    • 39:22 Psychokiller
    • 41:49 AD&D 2nd Edition
    • 44:08 Camel Up
    • 46:25 Condottiere
    • 48:34 Kill Doctor Lucky
    • 50:41 Lords of Waterdeep
    • 52:06 Firefly
    • 55:29 Fury of Dracula
    • 57:01 Valiant Hearts
    • 1:02:50 Munchkin
    • 1:03:25 King of Tokyo
    • 1:06:42 Smash Up

    Introductory Guy

    Hello. Welcome to Design Thinking Games, a fantasy and user experience podcast. Each episode, your podcast hosts, Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield, will examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper role-playing games, live-action games, mobile games, and video games. You can find every episode, including this one on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at designthinkinggames.com.

    Tim Broadwater

    This episode is brought to you by listeners like you patreon.com/designthinkinggames.

    So I’ve actually wanted you all to meet for a while now because Mike Schofield had me on his podcast when I was doing UX in higher education. His podcast is the Metric UX podcast. And then last year. Oh my god was, I think it was last year,

    Michael Fienan

    I think was the end of season three.

    Tim Broadwater

    Yeah, so I was on the Drunken UX podcast, so and then that is something to where being a guest on those two.

    Michael Schofield

    Oh, nice. He’s holding up your book. That’s UXFMK at your local Amazon.

    Tim Broadwater

    Yeah, so really, all the three people here actually inspired me to want to do a UX podcast, so Michael Schofield, Michael Fienen, Aaron Hill.

    Michael Schofield

    Yeah, I like that this is some sort of like, meet and greet, even though we asked you to come on.

    Michael Fienan

    Gotta start somewhere.

    Michael Schofield

    Yeah, you guys are our first interview. We haven’t done one before. And we thought it was cool that we could get some folks on who likely have like a ton of overlap, right? Where we all do UX work to some degree professionally. We write or publish or talk a lot about UX and guarantee that we’re all gamers.

    Michael Fienan

    So it doesn’t hurt that I’ve got like 100 board games over in my closet. So…

    Aaron Hill

    Mine ae on the other side of that wall right there.

    Michael Fienan

    All the books back here on the bookshelf in the video that’s all role-playing games.

    Tim Broadwater

    Oh, nice. Yeah, right here. My top shelf is all the board games from my A list. I actually went through a thing this spring to where if it wasn’t a definite keeper game, I gave it to the game to Goodwill.

    Michael Schofield

    Those are best the games Goodwill has had in a long time.

    Aaron Hill

    Probably every once in a while, you get some choice titles there. I picked up a couple of good ones from my childhood at Goodwill.

    Tim Broadwater

    Yes, so the design thinking games podcast, kind of to what Michael said, is really kind of still finding its footing. But it’s kind of under this experiment or idea that people who are UXers actually really like games, and we thought there’s potentially something here. And then I would say over the course of season one, we kind of had that confirmed on social media to where a lot of UXers love, like gaming and, so there’s this also intersect between player experience and user experience.

    Michael Fienan

    UX folks like journeys, right? Like crafting journeys, and customer journeys, user journeys are a big part of the work. And the journey of a player through a game is kind of like a, you know, not to go ahead and jump the shark early, but it’s a gamified version of that, you know, and that process, starting out somewhere, going through transactional things, trying to complete certain goals and come out the other end with your thing done, so to speak.

    Aaron Hill

    I’ve done some amateur game design. And what I find is that the parts of my brain that I use when thinking about UX in web or in app design are very similar to the parts of my brain I’m using when I’m trying to determine how to model a concept in game interaction. So it just feels like a very similar experience from a creative perspective.

    Michael Schofield

    Earlier this year, we were taught, or Tim introduced me to this idea. I don’t know if he named it. I feel like we stumbled on a name for it, but this idea of like operator agnosticism where when you’re designing, let’s say like a dashboard in a web app, the tendency is to say like oh, let’s take WordPress or whatever. These are bloggers who are going to do X, and they’re going to need this variety of toggles, and they want to see this information on their list of blogs in their dashboard. Whereas the reality is the job to be done doesn’t really care about your role whether you’re a blogger or you’re an SEO marketer, or you have some other title that you’re all still using the same writing experience in WordPress, and so the idea of operator agnosticism is to build a table that gives the, in this case, the user choice about what they see in it like if they don’t want this column let them hide it. And you see that a lot in games as well that really allows players to choose and set the parameters of how they experienced that game.

    Michael Fienan

    Can I throw a really bad example of that at you?

    Michael Schofield

    Do it.

    Michael Fienan

    I hope that when I say this, your instinct is to cringe, but bear with me – Monopoly.

    Tim Broadwater

    I literally was just at a mall, or whether there’s an entire shelving section of, like, Monopoly knock-offs.

    Michael Fienan

    But here’s why I bring that up because while most people who are gamers will say no, Monopoly is actually a terrible game (and it is), one of the reasons I think it has really held on and lasted is because of the amount of customization that is possible within that rule-set, and that Home Rule instinct. Do you pay all your tax money to free parking? Or does it go to the bank? You know, do you collect $200? Or do you get to go to an unclaimed property? People home-rule, all kinds of things around that, to make it not just more fun to them, but more palatable, more accessible, and it makes it feel like their own. None of that feels like it breaks the game at any point.

    Aaron Hill

    There’s a whole, like, cultural expression around that, right? You meet a family, play Monopoly, and they’re like, Well, how do you play it? What are your rules?

    Michael Schofield

    No, exactly. You can tell a lot about a person about, like, how much of a jerk they are. Especially if you get into …, I don’t know if Monopoly actually specifies rules about how you haggle. Right? And how do you like to trade?

    Aaron Hill

    I’ve had to look at the rules not long ago.

    Michael Fienan

    I’m gonna say something, and then not expand on it: but let’s just say, depending on how many clothes are lost during the course of a Monopoly game, that can also tell you a great deal about –

    Tim Broadwater

    I will say I have played that version of Monopoly more than once.

    Aaron Hill

    You literally lose your shirt, playing.

    Michael Fienan

    Yes, that’s what that means. Yes.

    Aaron Hill

    In Monopoly, the rules that I find people frequently don’t know, and some of these, you probably know all these, but maybe not for the listeners. Like Michael mentioned, do you put your money on free parking when you pay taxes or whatever? And like free parking is just free parking. But another one that I think many people don’t know is that when you land on a property, if you choose not to buy it, it’s supposed to immediately go to auction. And that’s one way that the game gets sped up a lot because you can land on a property and then choose not to purchase it at list price, hoping that you can get it for a cheaper price. And that someone else won’t steal it from you. And then the other one is just that, like, there’s no bonus money. The only money that gets added into the game’s economy is passing go. So there’s a regular addition of $200 per player each time you go around the board, adding into the game’s economy, but that’s it. And so the game should actually be very fast. You can do a game monopoly if you play by the book in 30 minutes or less. (Yeah, it never has happened.) And playing it by the book, it’s not a bad game. It’s cutthroat, and like what it says about how we live in a society, you know, like that is obviously terrible, but I mean, Game Design-wise, t’s not bad, it’s very tight. It’s very controlled. It has all the hallmarks of a general, interactive type game, but people don’t play by the rules. They like to make up their own because nobody likes to lose, and the game is built to be like the crushing loss of capitalism.

    Michael Schofield

    That’s interesting. Yeah, cuz I was just gonna say something like semi profound, “What an interesting case study that that game transcended its own rules.”

    Tim Broadwater

    I don’t think I’ve ever actually played it the right way. You start with double money to go around the board wives. And, you know, if you can’t buy it, then oh, someone never can buy it unless another person lands on it. Or just like all of these home rolls that I don’t even know where they came from.

    Michael Fienan

    You want to go down a rabbit hole here with, like the UX thing: let’s talk Monopoly. Let’s talk good Monopoly. There is a game, I believe Z Man produced it that, in my opinion, is every bit as good as Monopoly. It’s all the good stuff about Monopoly with none of the bad, and it’s Chinatown. Chinatown brings in the aspect of property ownership, the concept of a monopoly without it being exactly that. But this idea of, you’re trying to collect sets of things, because they’re worth more money. And it has all of the haggling. Now, you know how in Monopoly, one of the hardest things is trying to get the properties you need from the people who have them because it’s such an inequitable choice, you know when you’re trying to trade with people in Monopoly because usually, it means you want both people to get something useful. But one guy is obviously trying to bend somebody backward a little bit, or you’re, you’re literally on their hotel and have no money. And so you’re like handing over properties. Chinatown takes that and makes it fun and equitable. Because you can haggle over something that you’re like, this is gonna make you a lot of money. But because of the way the game plays out, it’s not necessarily gonna make you a lot of money now, and it may not make you a lot of money later. It could. And so there’s this exchange of businesses that can happen and where they’re located in all of this. To me, it’s like they sat down and talked about what would make monopoly fun. People love haggling. They love that action. They just don’t like the way it works in Monopoly. They like ownership. They like trying to complete things. And so they got rid of pieces moving around the board, and all of that you get money every turn, still, you make money from your businesses, I really have found a lot of fun in that. And it also doesn’t feel like it draws it out a lot of games where it’s user interaction, and like trying to like argue with people or things, those games feel like they can really draw out on overtime. Chinatown resists that.

    Tim Broadwater

    Yeah, I have to check it out. It’s rated really well on board game geek. Which, of course, is my KPI for purchasing a game in the value of the real power value of BoardGameGeek. But that’s actually one of the things that I think like when you play Here To Slay, or Munchkin or things like that, to where it’s like, let’s haggle to see if we can take someone down or if we can buff the monster. The haggling in Monopoly to me always felt just kind of like, are you gonna let me slide this month? Or are you gonna rake me and take me to the bank and I have to, I have to, like, you know, exchange all of my property and that to pay you off, and then it’s just…

    Michael Fienan

    There’s no depth to it like, and there’s no way to add depth to it. It’s a very superficial kind of haggling that happens in Monopoly. And that’s why I guess it works better in Chinatown because it plays out over I think six rounds – six or nine, I can’t remember now – and it’s like, the way you haggle in the next to last round is vastly different from how you haggle in the first round. Because you only have so much time to make any money. The other way this works, I think, is, you know, in Monopoly, the game is pre-determined well before it finishes. You know who’s gonna win before they win. Chinatown does a really good job of obfuscating the horse race a little bit, so you don’t necessarily feel like, “oh, god, they’re so far ahead. I can’t catch them.” You have stacks of money, but that money changes every turn, it consolidates, and you don’t have to show it to anybody. And so that makes the game a lot more fun. You do feel like even up to that end, you have a chance, whereas, in Monopoly, it’s like, I’m gonna go one more round, and if I land on one of your properties, I’m done for – I need you to land on 14 of my properties. This is over.

    Aaron Hill

    Here’s some monopoly trivia for you. Well, first, another obscure rule is that, if you know, in Monopoly, rent is doubled even without houses. A lot of people don’t know that. It’s written on the title deeds, but not everybody reads those.

    Tim Broadwater

    So you said you’ve played Monopoly recently, then? (yeah, well, I have kids) Is it good for kids? I don’t even know what the age rating is.

    Aaron Hill

    Oh, with house rules. Sure.

    Michael Fienan

    I played pretty young, actually. I remember playing it in our first house. And I think we were out of there by the time I was eight.

    Tim Broadwater

    I remember I’m also playing it very young like that. My grandparents it’s Yeah, the only board game my grandparents had.

    Aaron Hill

    We would play that with you with like the seashore and stuff. I go to the Jersey Shore or something and pay Monopoly. See, here’s the trivia. One of the properties the colored properties on the board is not a street. Do you know which one it is?

    Tim Broadwater

    One of the properties on the board, but it’s not a street?

    Aaron Hill

    Not the railroads, not the free parking or whatever. One of the colors? The color properties that you can buy one of them is not a street.

    Michael Fienan

    The one that jumps with me is like Marvin gardens. (Yes, that’s it!)

    Tim Broadwater

    I can’t believe you remember that? That was a

    Aaron Hill

    It’s a housing development. I think it’s gone it, but it was in the early 1900s. It existed in Atlantic City. Um, every other one of the places were actual streets in Atlantic City.

    Michael Fienan

    Huh. Marvin gardens.

    Aaron Hill

    So there’s a book by – I think I read this when I was a kid. I’m pretty sure it’s this one – by Philip Urbaines. It’s called Monopoly, the world’s most famous game and how it got that way. And it’s fascinating. There are all kinds of great trivia there. Marvin gardens thing though I found from John McPhee, he wrote it was called in search of Marvin gardens in his book Pieces of the Frame, and it was about the history of Monopoly but also like him literally looking for Marvin gardens Atlantic City.

    Tim Broadwater

    Oh, nice. I kind of want to know what’s on everyone’s hot plate right now, like what game are you obsessed with or what have you giving some time to?

    Michael Fienan

    Easy. Diablo 2.

    Aaron Hill

    Really. That just came out, the remaster?

    Tim Broadwater

    It’s a remaster of the computer game. Or was Diablo 2 on the computer?

    Michael Fienan

    In 2000 so it is 21 years old, and if you want to feel like you’ve lost track of time, Diablo 3 is nine years old. (Oh geez. Oh my god.) That hurts, doesn’t it? (So, is it good?) It’s Diablo 2. That means yes, it’s good.

    Aaron Hill

    Did they change anything about it? Did they fix anything?

    Michael Fienan

    So I mean, this, I think, is actually a kind of a great topic for you guys as much as anything because of what they changed. They came out and said we’re not making the next iteration of Diablo; that’s what Diablo 3 was. Diablo 3 was good. My only complaint about it really was that it was a very short feeling by comparison to the other games. I don’t know if that was just objective or subjective rather, but it felt very short. Diablo 2 always felt long, it felt big, it had a lot to it, you could do a lot. So they’re like this is the original game: a.) if you haven’t played it, or I mean if you are playing it but haven’t switched it back and forth between legacy mode and new mode – man. Command and Conquer did that too – also a game from my childhood, so of course I bought it – but the difference between those is very worth just looking at. One big thing they did, though as we have a lot more power with regard to accessibility in games now. And so they did a lot more with transcription of all of the voice audio that is in the game. They’ve given you a lot of options for color palette, color blindness stuff. You do things like auto pickup gold now. You’re not trying to click every single little piece of gold to try to get it, so they’ve tried to help with motor control. They have an article on their website, like how they sat down and said, “how would we do this now knowing what we know about game design for people with disabilities?”

    Tim Broadwater

    That’s cool Yeah, I love the grind in that game. It was fun to go into dungeons and grind and get experience and gold. What about Aaron?

    Aaron Hill

    I’m just currently being wowed by the Diablo 2 preview you just shared. It’s awesome. I’m gonna have to check this out. Um, let’s see, board-game-wise? I’ve been rotating through a few different ones. I’ve been going to a weekly board game night and had It’s been fun, so I get to try out a lot of games I haven’t tried ever before. I think the one that’s probably been in hot rotation just because it’s fun and easy to play with new people is Splendor, the gem trading game. I got the expansion for that. So we’ve been playing some of the expansions. Video Game-wise. Most recently, I replayed – I was showing someone Sonic the Hedgehog 1. And I was replaying it, and I was like, Oh yeah, like, if you get all the chaos emeralds, then you could turn it to supersonic. But I mistakenly got Sonic 1 and Sonic 2 mixed up, and so in Sonic 1, it’s just a different ending. But I did do it, though.

    Michael Schofield

    I never saw the ending to any of those Genesis-era Sega games (they’re pretty brutal). I never got past like the third level of either of the Sonics – Sonic 1 and Sonic 2, the only canonical Sonics – but yeah, I mean, I never saw any ending at all on the Sega.

    Tim Broadwater

    Mike Schofield. What are you playing currently?

    Michael Schofield

    Yeah, it’s almost not worth mentioning, but my almost two-years strong weekly d&d night continues. So I play a lot of Dungeons and Dragons. Board games… I don’t think I’ve done a ton other than board games with my kids. We played Dungeons and Dragons. And I introduced them to like Pandemic over the summer, which was a ton of fun, especially because they were devastated by the Pandemic winning.

    Aaron Hill

    We named the red disease COVID-19.

    Michael Schofield

    Yeah, I think we did too. And yeah, the black disease was like the zombie virus. It was an awful pandemic. But then, like video games-wise. Well, first, I should be playing the latest Life is Strange. I downloaded it. I’m waiting to play. I love that series. But I keep going back to For Honor because it feels good to swing a sword in that game. Have you guys ever played for honor? For Honor is a fighting game that has “realistic” weapons fighting. But you have to have your guard in the right spot to block, and it’s about timing, and it feels like you have to practice to get good. And I like those games. And this is a great fighting game. And so I’ve been playing t.

    Tim Broadwater

    It sounds kind of like Bushido blade or like Vagrant Story. (Yeah, that’s what I was thinking). Really focus, block, and parry.

    Michael Schofield

    It’s really similar, or even something like Chivalry 2 where you have to raise your shield, or you’re going to get an arrow in the face. But it’s one of those things that I like the material. I like knights fighting samurai. I think it’s cool. (Oh, right!) I like that you have to practice to be good. And it feels like something that’s merit-based, right, you know, like you kind of earn your wings, and it feels excellent, frankly, in a multiplayer.

    Aaron Hill

    Oh, there is a board game. I haven’t played it in a while. But it’s I think one of my favorites is I forget the publisher. It’s like a red bird on it. But The game is Above and Below. And then they also did Near and Far, Islebound, and there’s another one, it’s a smaller game. But Above and Below and Near and Far are both like worker placement games, but they have a whole thing of like there’s a storybook that goes along with it. And when you like, in Above and Below, when you venture into the underground, you draw a random card, and you roll a die, and then it tells you which encounter you get, and then someone reads it. And then there’s usually like some narrative, and you have to make a choice, you have to roll a test using the workers that you brought with you. And then stuff happens, but also you’re purchasing buildings and doing other things. It’s a neat mixture of storytelling but also worker placement. And then Near and Far is similar to that, but on a larger scale: there’s a countryside you’re exploring that’s got more of an RPG kind of thing. There’s even a legacy mode where you have the character, and they level up and get abilities and stuff. The art is cool. I love the art of these games.

    Michael Fienan

    You mentioned Pandemic, and it just made me think we’ve got a Pandemic Legacy on the shelf like waiting. I want to touch it. I want to play with it, but we have forgotten. (What are you waiting for, man? Like we really just lived through the lockdown.)

    Tim Broadwater

    I actually played Pandemic one week before lockdown. We had friends over, a couple, and we had dinner. I made crock-pot lasagna. And we’re like, what are we gonna play? And we played Pandemic. And it was just when they started to say, like, “Oh, I think there’s COVID-19.” And then literally, two days later, is when the lockdown and everything happened, and so we now have this memory between two of our friends and me and my partner. And remember, when the Pandemic kicked off with us playing Pandemic. (They’re gonna blame you, Tim.)

    Michael Fienan

    We’ve gotten on a big legacy game kick in our group because we went through around Christmas time and destroyed Betrayal Legacy over the course of literally two straight days.

    Aaron Hill

    Is that Betrayal on the House on Haunted Hill?.

    Michael Fienan

    Yeah.

    Michael Schofield

    That’s such a good one.

    Michael Fienan

    Oh, it’s so good.

    Aaron Hill

    It’s the legacy mode.

    Tim Broadwater

    So is that the expansion or –?

    Michael Fienan

    The full legacy version of the game. If you like the Betrayal on the House on the Hill, get it. If you like legacy games, get it. If you like both of those things, definitely get it. The start of that game, and the middle of that game, have two of my favorite points in gaming I’ve ever run into. The people they had to do the game design on that and think about like = a story game, like Betrayal, literally has a story. And it feels very much like an American Horror Story kind of theme that kind of runs through each round of the game because it’s the same people but in different kinds of situations and stuff like that. And they really thought about how that would go. The setup is so good. I was caught off guard. I was surprised. Do you know how hard it is to get into a game like that and genuinely be like delighted?

    Tim Broadwater

    So for someone who knows – I was about to say Betrayal at Baldur’s Lake. But Betrayal at House on the Hill, when you’re saying “the legacy,” what is that exactly?

    Michael Fienan

    It is basically a game where it’s meant to be played over time. And as you play it over time, the game changes. You put stickers on the board, you scratch off stuff on certain cards, or put things on certain cards, you’ll throw stuff away.

    Michael Schofield

    The legacy aspect is that it’s mutable, and it changes, right? You actually changed the game as you played.

    Michael Fienan

    Unlike some legacy games, once you’re done with it, it’s still a playable game. You can then continue to replay it over and over. It’s just now your version of Betrayal, and it just plays like a normal Betrayal on House on the Hill type of game. It was so good. Like it got everything right. I’m trying to think of a moment where we were playing in a mechanic that just didn’t work right or something, and it just didn’t hit those notes wrong anywhere. (That’s good.) My legacy game experience right now is limited to Betrayal and Gloomhaven. Pandemic’s waiting. It’s there. I’m gonna get to it.

    Aaron Hill

    When are you gonna play it? When’s that gonna happen?

    Michael Fienan

    Soon-ish. I don’t know.

    Aaron Hill

    I haven’t played it, but I have friends who have, and they really enjoyed it.

    Tim Broadwater

    Is Twilight Imperium considered legacy then? Cuz I know it takes a long, long time to play it, but I don’t know if it’s technically legacy.

    Aaron Hill

    I think Legacy is when we change the game itself, right? (Yeah).

    Tim Broadwater

    Oh, then no, I think it just takes a really crazy long time to play Twilight Imperium.

    Michael Fienan

    Android, or Axis and Allies.

    Aaron Hill

    I remember when I was growing up, my dad told me about this game it was I think it was made by Avalon Hill, but it was like a Pacific Theatre Air Combat battle simulation game, and the mat for it was like 15 feet by 15 feet. They would start at the beginning of the summer, and it would take all summer literally long, and they wouldn’t finish because there was so much intricacy with the turn.

    Tim Broadwater

    It’s on my bucket list to play Twilight Imperium. And I’ve seen one, two, and the third version now. And it is notorious in the world as being one of the most complicated. It makes me think of like Parks and Recreation is just like there are so many rules and so many pieces and so much going on that it just takes you three months to play the game.

    Michael Fienan

    Complex doesn’t have to mean the long though, right, or hard. I think of a game like Dominant Species, which ranked real high there on Board Game Geeks for a while, and it’s a game that when you spread it out, and you look at it, and you read that rulebook, it feels like there is so much going on here. And when I played it, that’s a game that I think, and I don’t know what their playtesting regimen was like, but I feel like whatever they did in that cycle, they got right. Because the mechanics flow well, it’s easy to understand, transitioning between different scales and things and growing your species or changing something about the environment. That game is very dense, very complex, but plays like a nice instrument. And then you get into something like Race for the Galaxy, which people love, and I get it, I love Roll for the Galaxy myself. But Race for the Galaxy is good, too. But that iconography can be such a dense, hard hurdle to get over as a new player and trying to explain to people. If you’ve got three people who know Race for the Galaxy, and one person who’s new, the amount of time you have to spend explaining all the iconography to them and everything and what does what and how you play it. That’s a stumbling block that is not new user-friendly at all. It’s a hard thing.

    Aaron Hill

    I remember when my friend taught me Race for the Galaxy, it was so confusing to me. You would take a card from the deck and put it facedown on one of your planets, and that was like the resource that you get from it. Because I’m like, “Well, wait, does the underside of the card matter at all?” Like, it’s just the idea that they were using the cards for two different purposes was really hard for me to grasp at the time.

    Tim Broadwater

    Yeah, I actually was at Origins. It was canceled last year, and I picked up Zombicide.

    Aaron Hill

    I don’t think I remember that one.

    Tim Broadwater

    It looks great. The artwork, the miniatures are phenomenal, it’s great, and that’s what I wanted about the game. And like everyone looked like they were having fun playing it. And then, when I got home and opened up the rulebook, it was so intense. And I’m just like, “Okay, well, I will just put this at the bottom of the pile. And I’ll eventually get to this because this is going to take some time.” It’s not one of those games that you can find a YouTube video that teaches you how to play it in five to 10 minutes. It is not that casual or easy of a game, and so there’s some nuance layer with like, well, what is the thing that we can put in front of a player, maybe a card that we know exactly what they can do in their turn, or like okay, here’s a sheet that goes in front of the player that explains what all the icons are, versus how do we simplify through video, or through, you know, kind of the game manual, onboarding someone to the game so they can get in and playing and enjoy it, like sooner rather than later.

    Michael Fienan

    I like Zombicide, I know Zombicide.

    Aaron Hill

    More games need to include those kinds of handouts. I know they all have like the little quick poker card reference things. But like there needs to be just a general quick one-sheet summary of, like, what happens on a turn, and I don’t think enough games do that. Thankfully, the player community usually makes them for at least popular games. Those always are really handy to have.

    Michael Schofield

    There’s a cool concept that I encountered, I think, in some Call of Cthulhu forum for the first time that in web design, we talked about usability in part in terms of its learnability – how easy is an interface to learn? Well, the flip side is like your teachability index. And there is this concept which is how roughly easy is it for an experienced player to explain the rules and get you started? But if you could have one person who has it all in their head, how quickly can they teach it? It’s a different measure than learning it from scratch. And there are some games that are really good at like that.

    Michael Fienan

    Teach it in a way where somebody doesn’t 10 minutes say, “Well, you didn’t tell me that. If I had known that, I would have done this entirely differently.”

    Michael Schofield

    I like how d&d gets around that it’s like, the DM’s rules or the highway.

    Tim Broadwater

    Yeah, I’m not a homebrew person. And we can have a whole different episode about that. I am an organized play person. But I feel like we run into the same problem in software development, that we always punt the documentation, training, and instructional designer to the very end, and then we bring them in, and they’re like, okay, it launches in two weeks, and they’re like, “I don’t even know what the app does, I, someone’s gonna have to walk me through it. So I can translate it.” One of the things I’m trying to be more cognizant about at the very beginning is we need to get people on board who are documentation and training people that can literally understand it, as we understand it, as it changes, and then they can help with contextual help or tooltips, or things of that nature, as opposed to just like, constantly kicking that can down the road.

    Michael Fienan

    I think it’s a constant problem that we see a lot in game design in documentation, you know, the same way where it comes back to this notion of who’s writing the documentation for who? And how much time are they spending, like, going over that with people? I mentioned Gloomhaven earlier, and it’s a fine game, you know, I know, it’s really popular with certain folks. And I understand why. The rulebook is also garbage. That rulebook is not good. And they made a lot of decisions about the gameplay that is designed for thematic reasons, which again, I understand, but then they do a poor job articulating in the rulebook, they’ll name things like you’re strengthened, or you’re muddled. And they’ll have effects like this, that really what they mean is you are advantaged or disadvantaged, they all have the same effect. You either draw two cards and keep the best one or draw two cards and keep the worst one. But they called it a bunch of different things because, well, it makes sense that you’re going to have this effect or that effect, and I get that, but when I have to spend time in the rulebook as we’re playing, it hurts you know, it really slows down the fun to have when you have to go through these rules and figure out what does this word mean? You’re using this as a keyword. So I’m looking for that keyword in the rule book, and you’re not using that word anywhere in the rulebook. That stuff is really gnarly.

    Tim Broadwater

    One of my metrics for tabletop board games that I like is that onboarding is easy. There are other ones I like, but it’s just like how quick can we start to play and how you know understandable it is. Circling back to like one of the games that I’m obsessed with right now is Starfinder and Pathfinder and Pathfinder second edition, and I just went to a con and played five games for five hours each, so like 25 hours of gaming over the weekend. And Mike Schofield got me to play through Mass Effect Legendary Edition.

    Michael Schofield

    One of the greatest games of all time.

    Tim Broadwater

    I’m on three right now. And so we’re just about to start three, but a tabletop board game, I don’t know if you know it. It’s ranked really well. I bought it. I’ve played it, and I’m obsessed with it, is Psycho Killer. (Qu’est-ce que c’est?).

    I’m doing it injustice by calling it Uno, but it’s essentially that Exploding Kittens kind of game. You’re just controlling the flow of the cards. Is it reversing or skipping or backing up? It’s got a really a lot of cool mechanics, and the theme that’s wrapped around it is like 80’s slasher horror. You are collecting wounds and weapons, and then you’re trying to survive and be the person who’s not killed or wounded the most, and I cannot recommend this game enough. Its video that they created for onboarding to teach you how to play it, and its instruction guide, is the best example of instructional design for a game I’ve seen recently.

    Aaron Hill

    Michael’s talking about the keyword thing, “is this a keyword I’m gonna look for in other places?” And that’s something when I’m writing, either a procedural or like, if I’m writing rules, text or something, I try to be very careful about what words I use to describe things because if a mechanic is the same, you should call it the same thing each time. So that you can reduce the cognitive load of the person trying to learn the game. In-game that have explicit names for different concepts, and those concepts are unique to those things. I’m trying to think of one that does this poorly, and I’m having trouble thinking of one, but I definitely noticed that a lot like in rules text though, when they just get too verbose, and it’s clear they didn’t have an editor or at least not an editor who was familiar with the game.

    Michael Fienan

    Tannhauser. The rulebook is a crime.

    Aaron Hill

    Actually, did any of you play second edition d&d?

    Tim Broadwater

    Oh yes.

    Aaron Hill

    Okay. Remember THAC0 armor class?

    Tim Broadwater

    Yeah, armor class zero.

    Aaron Hill

    Yeah, and like you know, carrying weight and like encumbrance and on like all of that the saving throws were weird. Like everything about that felt so overly specific and like the third edition fixed a lot of that by making everything positive bonuses. I think that was a big improvement.

    Tim Broadwater

    I feel so triggered right now. (Oh, sorry.) I’m so triggered. I spent the majority of my youth probably in the second edition. And I know the final like, screw this game moment where everyone flipped the table is like when they literally added Psionics.

    Aaron Hill

    I have the brown handbook for that upstairs for the second edition.

    Tim Broadwater

    Players Guide to Psionics or Player’s Handbook to Psionics. Another question I wanted to ask everyone here is, is generally, it sounds like we all have a lot of experience with UX and a lot of experience with games. But I think the question that I kind of want to know is, it doesn’t matter if it’s a board game, video game, tabletop game, live-action, whatever. I just want to know kind of what is the first thing that pops into your frontal cortex or your brain about what is a really usable game one that you were just impressed with? Like everything like artwork instructions, gameplay enjoyment is just like at that top of the list for you.

    Aaron Hill

    In terms of like quality of UX?

    Tim Broadwater

    Enjoyable, usable. What is the honeycomb? All of the metrics, checkboxes.

    Michael Schofield

    High desirability, low accessibility.

    Aaron Hill

    There are two games that come to mind. When I think about if I’m meeting up with a group of people who maybe have varying levels of experience with games, right? So maybe they played a bunch. Maybe they haven’t. You’re not really sure it’s gonna be a mixed bag. The two games that I think I always have with me are Splendor, which I mentioned before, and Camel Up. Also, Camel Cup, either one. Even in German, either one is okay. The board game designer that made it says Camel Up / Camel Cup. The reason why is because, in both games, the actions that you can take on each turn are limited to four, maybe five, different possibilities. It’s really easy to grasp just those four or five things. And you can basically take any of those actions at any turn with minimal risk. You’re not going to screw yourself later in the game, majorly. You can just do stuff to advance the game forward so that you can interact with the game without having to make a whole lot of mental calculations or anything. Also, the artwork on both of them is great. Splendor’s artwork is beautiful, and Camel Ups’ artwork is very thematic and kind of fun. It does a really great job of reinforcing the theme of betting on camel races. The thing I really love about Camel Up is that the game is so absurdly swingy. Have you played it before?

    Tim Broadwater

    I have not. I’ve not played either of those two.

    Aaron Hill

    Okay, so I’ll give you the 20-second synopsis. It’s a race with five different colored camels that go one lap around a track, and while they’re going, and they’re moving, everyone’s making bets on the progress of the race until it finally ends, and then that ends the game. So there are mechanics in the game that affect like catch up and like how the camels like progress on the track. And I’ve seen games where the Camel that was in dead last ended up winning because the dice just came out in a certain order. And man, like I’m not exaggerating when I say that when I played this with my family, and that happened, there were literally hoots and hollers and screams, it was really exciting, and it was like holy shit, this happened! It’s a really great game. It won [award] in 2015 or thereabouts. I think one other honorable mention. [Condultiary?] is a beautiful game with beautiful artwork, the original release of it had real tall columnar cards. It’s like a bidding game for territory control of Reconstruction Era Italy. Unfortunately, it’s not an easy one to explain, and that makes it harder to introduce the people, but when you play with people who know the game though it’s so much fun, there’s a whole layer of, “oh well, they played that card which means they probably do or don’t have this,” and you have to like get behind the hand and read their minds, and it’s a lot of fun, it’s just not easy to teach someone in five.

    Tim Broadwater

    So then it goes to you, Michael F.

    Michael Fienan

    This is the kind of thing I should have prepared for a little better.

    Tim Broadwater

    What pops into the front of your mind?

    Michael Fienan

    So here’s the thing right, there are a lot of games I really enjoy, and there are games I play a lot of that I also would not consider necessarily good games. It’s like movies I’ve watched their movies that I watched that are total trash that I would never recommend to somebody, but they give me some kind of visceral enjoyment. How about this: so I’ve already given you a love letter to Chinatown. I do think Chinatown is a game that anybody who likes Monopoly and wants more. There’s a lot of love for Catan as sort of the gateway game. If you’ve if you feel like you’ve outgrown Monopoly and you want to go a different direction but not get something hard that people can still kind of get into, Catan served as that for a long time. I would go ahead and throw Chinatown as a gateway game. Another gateway game that I think pretty much gets almost everything about itself right. It knows what it is, it’s easy to get new people in, it’s fun with people who really know how to play it, is Kill Doctor Lucky. So you know Clue? Kill Doctor Lucky is the first half of Clue. Clue is all about figuring out who killed the guy, where, and with what? Kill Doctor Lucky is all about getting in the room with the guy and kill him with something and not be seen. It’s not complex. It has a very simple mechanic. The old guy is walking around his house. However many people are in there trying to get in rooms you’ve got a line of sight to consider, and you get cards, and everybody else has spoiler cards, so you’re like I’m gonna kill them with the hammer, and somebody throws a card like a dog goes running through the house and so your attempt to spoiled. You build up points for every spoiled attempt. So over time, you will eventually have enough points that somebody is going to outweigh the number of spoiler cards that everybody plays on you.

    Tim Broadwater

    I’ve seen this before. I said that I misspoke when I said I had not played it. I haven’t played it, but I’ve seen it been played before.

    Aaron Hill

    Is the one that is print and play. They have a pretty play version.

    Michael Fienan

    I don’t know if they do or not. I’ve got the full version of it. But it’s a relatively cheap game, and I want to say Walmart carries it now. It’s that mainstream as far as things go, but it’s a well-thought-out game, and I like that they did this idea of the first half of Clue because that makes it feel very grounded in something that people do know. A lot of people know Clue. Even if they haven’t played Clue, they’re familiar with it. It reduces the amount of anxiety they may have about getting into this game and. “oh, I’m gonna suck at it because I don’t know the rules. It’s my first time.” A hard game that I’m trying to think of if I really consider this to be a game that gets things mostly right and given the amount that we play it and the amount of fun we have with it. I’m gonna say yes, that’s Lords of Waterdeep.

    Tim Broadwater

    (Oh, I love that game.) That is literally the one I was going to say.

    Michael Fienan

    Okay, well then, I’m right. I get another gold star. Thank you.

    Tim Broadwater

    I love totaling games. I don’t even know what they’re called that. But it’s that mechanic like Ticket to Ride and other games to where you don’t know until the end until everyone reveals all their cards, and so it’s always kind of exciting. At that last five minutes, because you’re kind of seeing what everyone did, and you weren’t even aware of the whole game that they were working on.

    Michael Fienan

    You have that opportunity at the end like even if you’re in last, it’s like it’s not out of reach, because I still have this stuff in the bank, and I know I’m gonna jump 20 points, but there’s also a lot to it, there’s a lot of gameplay to it thematically, it’s very rich because it’s got a lot of the D&D stuff to draw on. So there’s a lot of grit to it for people who enjoy that kind of world. I had another easy game, and now I just simply don’t remember what I was gonna throw out there. But those two, I think, are definitely high. They’re easy to pull out. They always get good marks from folks whenever they get into them. I like other games like Firefly. Firefly is great. It takes 18 hours to play.

    Aaron Hill

    I was just gonna say I love the Firefly game, and my son and I play it sometimes. It drips with flavor. If you’ve seen the show and you love the show, you’ll love the game, but holy shit, there’s nothing in the game that drives itself to completion, so you can literally just fly around the verse and run missions and stuff and have fun and then just decide when you’re done playing, and that’s actually a totally legit way to play that game.

    Michael Fienan

    I have every expansion you need a dining room table and two leaves and extra table space if you have all the expansions. To me, that’s what makes it not really that great as a result. I like Mansions of Madness. I think the second version is better. The second edition is definitely an improvement on the first edition because it’s another game that these games there’s a lot of these games that they’re really fun thematically, but Arkham Horror kind of falls into this a little bit like, man, it’s fun, but I’m 39 years old now I don’t want to stay up till 4am playing it. So that kind of hurts in ways. So I’ll leave it with those two then: we got Lords of Waterdeep, and we’ve got Kill Doctor Lucky.

    Tim Broadwater

    I have to choose another one because you took Lords of Waterdeep away from me.

    Aaron Hill

    I love how you explain Kill Doctor Lucky as the first half of Clue, like Clue before Clue happens. And I feel like that explains so much of the mechanics behind the game that you have an instant understanding of what the game is before you even.

    Michael Schofield

    It’s a great elevator pitch.

    Michael Fienan

    I don’t know if this is even possible, but I want to see one group play Kill Doctor Lucky. And then, the second group plays Clue based on the outcome of Kill Doctor Lucky.

    Michael Schofield

    That’d be awesome.

    Aaron Hill

    But my friends that I once played a game of Risk where every time you attempt to attack or take a territory, instead of rolling dice, it turns into a game of Stratego. We did not make it through a whole game of Risk this way, but —

    Michael Schofield

    I love it! I love it so much. That’s appeals to my Wargaming instinct. I love it. Oh my god.

    Aaron Hill

    Well, the Stratego pieces you get are based on how many armies you’re attacking with. Or proportionally, so you have to kind of like you draft them, etc.

    Michael Schofield

    Oh no, I don’t have a Marshall. Yeah. I gotta play this.

    Tim Broadwater

    What about you, Michael Schofield. I may know this already, so I’m not gonna say

    Michael Schofield

    There are a few. The games that I love that I think have, like, what I’d call a net positive UX, necessarily imply that there are things about it that really suck and are hard to get into. I’ve actually got three: and I just have to name-drop these in terms of like board games. The one that I love, I think maybe out of nostalgia, because it’s a super goth game. It’s one of those that are highly themed and is the first game I really played that had, like in the second edition that had like miniatures with it was like a high production value board game. And I love it. And it’s the Fury of Dracula. Where you, for the most part, are probably a vampire hunter chasing Dracula himself across the old world. And one of the players is Dracula, and there’s like a day and night cycle. So during the day, you and three other compatriots work collaboratively to locate Dracula kill his undead minions, basically drive a stake through his heart. But then night happens, and Dracula can flee to the next city, create a whole bunch of like vampire spawn and just otherwise escape but also spread the dark seed across Victorian Europe. And it’s wonderful, and it’s timed, and there’s only like, eight, eight nights, you got like a week to do it. And then it’s over. And then Dracula wins. It’s the same thing with Pandemic: I like the idea that the bad guy wins. It’s really cool. It’s just a cool theme. I was really racking my brain because like what’s like the most usable game, which suggests something to me other than like, most fun? And I was just going through my like my library. And this one’s a video game, but I want to give a shout out – I don’t know if this ranks anywhere, really if I really had to make a hardcore list, but this one stood out to me, and I said, this is a great UX – have you guys have played Valiant Hearts? It’s a side-scrolling World War One Love Story game.

    Aaron Hill

    Those are three different things that I never would imagine being mushed together.

    Michael Schofield

    So the idea at the heart of it is like a story that’s a love story between an elderly French farmer, his daughter, and his daughter is in love with an Austrian farmhand. And then the Great War starts, and the Austrian farmhand gets drafted. And the French elderly father also gets drafted. And you play a cartoonish campaign on both sides through the Great War until they either reunite or they don’t – no spoilers – but that’s the kind of story can you survive the war long enough to get reunited with your love or to get back to your daughter or whatever, and sometimes you play as a dog, there’s a lot in there. But in terms of usability, great, super cartoony, like a friendly comic book thing that you might find in the children’s part of the library, right? It has great hints and has great mechanics like that. And there’s just a side scroller. The controls are really easy, but it’s treacherous because you have to, like, evade bombs. Watch out for mines. Watch out for mustard gas. It’s really pretty gruesome, and sprinkled throughout this kind of comic booky World War One Game are little postcards of real history. That show like, Hey, man, this was a bad time, and stuff like that. I totally recommend it for the folks who like to play games on their screen. It’s one of those things where my son played it at age seven. (Oh, wow.) He was really interested in it. And he walked away knowing something about the Great War, and he cried at the end, it was a good experience, that a kid can just pick up and play, but the really heavy concept and this is one of those things that like, I can’t really think of a whole lot else that does that. Anyway, like I said, I just found this like scrolling through my library, and I was like, “Oh my god, I totally forgot about this game.” You think about like the UX honeycomb or any of those models like fleshes out the entire circle. It’s really good. Put it on your radar.

    Tim Broadwater

    Nice. I’ve actually had a fury of Dracula on my Amazon wishlist. I know you’ve talked about it a lot, and it’s rated pretty decently on Board Game Geek. As you know, I love asynchronous horror, and it’s like asynchronous horror in the form of a board game. So it’s kind of like, hey, we’re all friends, and then oh, I touched a voodoo artifact, and now I’m a witch or zombie or mummy or whatever.

    Michael Fienan

    I do think I had Fury of Dracula on my wish list at one point. And it went out of print, and I took it off, but I’m looking at the map now. Yeah, I think I know this game. I think it was. I think it was on an episode of Tabletop.

    Michael Schofield

    Yes. That’s where I learned about it, too. Yeah.

    Aaron Hill

    Can I give a quick shout-out to a game that is a board game version was terrible UX, but the app game version was awesome. Have any of you played Elder Signs? (Yes.)

    Michael Fienan

    Oh, yes. Yeah, also known as –

    Aaron Hill

    Cthulhu Yahtzee.

    Michael Schofield

    That’s exactly what it is.

    Aaron Hill

    In the tabletop version, I have it, and I’ve played it a bunch. I even have like a little Field Notes book that has like, every time I play it, we write down like, which was the elder God, and did we win or lose, who was playing, etc. But man, so much table maintenance. And the app version, which actually played before I played the tabletop version, the app version fixes so much of the game, making it so much more fun. And you could focus a lot more on like the, you know, the dice rolling aspect, which is a lot more interesting than maintaining the table state. So, kudos to the development team.

    Michael Fienan

    Did you advance the clock? Did you remember to move the clock up three hours? Right, forget that. I don’t remember. Yeah. That’s happened a lot.

    Tim Broadwater

    I’m pretty sure that was one of the games, like Sheriff of Nottingham, this is too — I don’t care.

    Michael Fienan

    If you like Cthulhu games, you have to be a little bit of a masochist. Many of them are very good, but they all hurt. All of them take a toll on you in one way or another.

    Tim Broadwater

    They do. They do. I have strong feelings about Cthulhu games.

    Michael Schofield

    I like the idea that they’re intentionally obtuse games.

    Tim Broadwater

    I will have to say, for mine, from that from the tabletop perspective. Even though I think if I got a group of people together, I would want to play in a collaborative board game, so everyone’s always thinking like Forbidden Desert or, or something to where we’re all working together, and it’s fun. But I’m competitive, and if it is the right group of people, I love me some Munchkin, and I love me some King of Tokyo or King of New York. Munchkin is great because it’s like a simplified Dungeons and Dragons to where your base character and you add your sex, your class, your race, your armor and everything to it, and you kind of bump it up, and there are so many flavors of Munchkin now that it’s just like Monopoly to where it’s just like made every single version of it. But I’m sure you’ve played Munchkin. But if you’ve not played, I’m not sure if you’ve played King of New York or King of Tokyo. It is one of those games where it’s like I just want a bunch of big dice, and I want to slam them down and attack everyone else at the table. And I want to give the monster I have a third head and eye lasers and wings and mutate them to dominate and destroy all the other players, and it’s just so gratifying that you roll these dice that have claws on them for attacks, and it’s just physical. And that’s I guess what I really like about that game, and I don’t know anyone who’s played the game and not had a blast. It’s so user experience or player experience-wise. I think a lot of people just want to be a giant monster that destroys cities and fights other giant monsters to the death.

    Michael Fienan

    You name two games there between the King of New York and Forbidden Desert that also interestingly, the sort of bigger version quote-unquote, is definitely the better version like that one like if you buy the base version, then buy the advanced version you discover you never played the base version. King of Tokyo, though, did a good job of saying, but you have all these monsters, and you can use all these monsters and everything in the bigger version. So they brought it along. And Forbidden Desert did not do that with Forbidden Island. So it’s like if you want to play Forbidden Desert or something like that. You almost never go back to Forbidden Island once you have it.

    Aaron Hill

    Yeah. The thing I like about the King of Tokyo is that the mechanic around who gets pulled into the city, like you know, you go into the city, okay, now everyone’s hitting you, and you’re hitting everyone. Until you choose to leave but then when you choose to leave, whoever hit you is the person that has to go in. So the game is always pushing, always pushing forwards.

    Tim Broadwater

    Has to be someone in the ring. Can’t leave the ring unoccupied. What I guess I think I liked about Munchkin and the thing that I like that’s similar between Munchkin and King of Tokyo is I love the add ons you can add like you can buy, you can play Cthulhu, you can play King Kong, you can add like all this stuff, but then with Munchkin, apart from the different games, which I have played a bunch of the different flavors of Munchkin, but Munchkin zombie is by far the best. So instead of the normal Munchkin where you’re kicking in the door, fighting the monster, and getting the treasure, you’re kicking in the door eating the person, and it’s so gratifying to eat accountants and teenagers and cops and kids. You know, and you have instead of the classes or races that you have in traditional like, Dungeons and Dragons, or high fantasy that’s in the core Munchkin. In Zombies Munchkin, are you a toxic-energy zombie? Are you a voodoo zombie? Are you a radiation zombie, and so it kind of goes. But I love the fact that you can, if you do like the game, you can add supplemental, you know, kind of monsters and cards and stuff to it. And I feel like those games don’t have a huge learning curve. And they are always quick. They’re always done within an hour.

    Michael Fienan

    Smashup’s like that too. It’s got that like, hey, which you know which expansion sets you to want to add to your set and everything and change the way things feel. And it’s kind of got a fun little —

    Tim Broadwater

    Unicorns and Transformers. Are those the two you want to put together because? That’s like the ultimate speed attack of unicorns and transformers.

    You all are coming up on your 100th episode. And I just listened to your WordPress episode on the Drunken UX podcast. The WordPress episode was great, actually. Because as someone who’s been kind of working with it for years, and like, this is what I always do versus like, what you can do or what other people’s setups are was kind of neat, and I guess I want to plug, you know, kind of, as we’re wrapping up, I know how I would describe the Drunken UX podcast. If there are people out there who haven’t heard of you, I mean, how would you describe your podcast?

    Michael Fienan

    Everybody has not heard of us. That’s kind of the way that goes. What I tell folks to Drunken UX is the show is not about UX. The Drunken UX is about the listeners’ experience with us. We’re sitting there because we’re two middle-aged men from the elder millennial generation. So obviously, we have to have a podcast where we sit and drink. But we do talk UX, we talk accessibility, we talk design development, from the technical to the non-technical. And it’s all about you know, if you are somebody who is interested in web development, interested in web design, how people get into those positions, you know what, what those journeys look like, and what you need to be thinking about to get further that’s, that’s what we like leaning into a lot. We try to keep things light. If you’re high tech, if you’re deep in the field, and you love syntax, and you love web developer tea and those shows, fantastic. They’re all great. We aren’t them. They are different. They are fantastic. And they have you know their niche, they know their stuff. We take a lower brow approach a little bit, I guess.

    Aaron Hill

    I wouldn’t say lower brow. We’re not prurient!

    Michael Fienan

    Definitely casual. But we have fun with it. And that’s, you know, we do bring in guests as frequently as possible to talk about, you know, what they’re building, what they’re excited about. We just had Kellen Mason from WP engine to talk with about the headless WordPress stuff. That was a fantastic talk. Yeah, really, you know, it just helps expand the understanding of what you can do with all of these tools that are out there. Is it WordPress? Is it, you know, the way you go about user research? Is it how you think about, you know, making your site available to people that you know have different abilities. That stuff’s important to us, and so we enjoy sharing it. If anybody wants to check it, we have new episodes every other Monday. We’re at DrunkenUX.com. Search for Drunken UX in your podcast thing. We’re on all the things, and yeah, we have this sort of convergence. Episode 100 is going to come out, and we’ve got some stuff we’re going to be announcing there. And then in like two more months, three more months, the season four finale has to come out, so I’ve got to like, I need to figure out what’s what we’re announcing for the 100 and what we’re doing for the finale, so I don’t know to stay tuned it’s gonna be a surprise to me too.

    Aaron Hill

    The finale will just be like the amazing stuff that’s happened since the 100th episode announcements, right?

    Michael Fienan

    Obviously, what we got picked up by Spotify, you know, we signed a major label.

    Michael Schofield

    Joe Rogan of UX.

    Aaron Hill

    Actually, you know, like, other than I guess if you replace all of the cannabis with alcohol, that’s probably not far off.

    Michael Schofield

    To tell me about the UX of aliens.

    Aaron Hill

    Yeah, basically. Yeah. Yeah. The one thing I really like about our show is like, is the casual tone. But I think that a lot of the newer podcasts with like, the younger, the young people, people showing up in it, yeah, like younger people, they have fantastic ideas, and they are so innovative and moving forwards. And I think that Michael and I have a lot of experience. And I think that from that experience it, it helps inform us to talk about like, more nuanced things like accessibility and usability because those are sort of like you really have to have a keen understanding of like HTML and of like, how websites function and things to kind of really grok that. And that’s something that I think is a perspective that we both bring to it.

    Michael Fienan

    Nice way of saying we’ve earned the gray in our beards.

    Aaron Hill

    I don’t have much of a beard, but I do have gray hairs in it.

    Tim Broadwater

    We definitely appreciate you both gracing us on this episode. I totally love talking about the intersection of user experience and games. And thank you both for being on. You have an open invitation going for it. If you ever want to sit and talk about games and user experience. You’re always welcome.

    We put a lot of work into design thinking games, so if you like what we do and want to help us cover some costs, consider supporting us patreon.com/designthinkinggames. We also design thinking games on TikTok, twitch, and Twitter.

    Introductory Guy

    Thank you for listening to the design thinking games podcast. To connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim, please go to design thinking games.com where you can request topics, ask questions, or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on.

  • 014: Baffling Sequels

    014: Baffling Sequels

    In this episode we talk about

    • 1:12 – Vampire: the Masquerade
    • 4:41 – Legend of Zelda
    • 8:38 – Grand Theft Auto
    • 16:30 – Monster Hunter
    • 19:46 – Resident Evil
    • 22:55 – Evil Within
    • 23:47 – Final Fantasy
    • 25:24 – Shovel Knight
    • 34:51 – Last of Us

    Introductory Guy

    Hello. Welcome to Design Thinking Games, a fantasy and user experience podcast. Each episode, your podcast hosts, Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield, will examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper role-playing games, live-action games, mobile games, and video games. You can find every episode, including this one, on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at designthinkinggames.com.

    Tim Broadwater

    This episode is brought to you by listeners like you patreon.com/designthinkinggames.

    So if we are talking about the same that I think we’re talking about, are we talking about the thing I think we’re talking about?

    Michael Schofield

    This is how sequels always start, right? You think you know what you’re going to get, and every so often, you are stopped like right up front? Do you get a cold surprise welcome or not? So let’s transition weirdly into Vampire the Masquerade: Blood Hunt.

    Tim Broadwater

    Because definitely a sequel. Yeah,

    Michael Schofield

    Let’s talk about that. Okay, so 17 years ago, when games were – I guess games are good now – when games were still good, but good in a different way. Vampire the Masquerade: Bloodline. Was that right? Gosh, now? No, I’m second-guessing myself.

    Tim Broadwater

    Yeah.

    Michael Schofield

    Vampire: the Masquerade Bloodlines came out, and it was – we talked about this a little bit in our VTM episode, so I’m not going to go deep, but it was a transformative game. It was a great RPG, standalone, with multiple threads and the style that the folks may think of, like Bioware games. They had good, goodish voice acting, little stilted because the main character you play is from Renaissance Europe and it sounds a little silly, but in general, the voice acting was on point. And the powers were cool. The mood was right. Cool RPG.

    Tim Broadwater

    And it has a sequel right this year. 2021. Vampire the Masquerade Bloodlines 2 – indeterminant release date how they keep saying is quarter three quarter four.

    Michael Schofield

    That’s one of those games that have been delayed a little bit. But yeah, so what we’re ending up is roughly in the same time period, and if we zoom out until like a 20-year timespan, give or take a month or a quarter, Vampire the Masquerade Bloodlines 2 and Vampire the Masquerade Bloodhunt are going to come out roughly around the same period.

    Tim Broadwater

    It’s interesting two vampire games this year.

    Michael Schofield

    It’s caused a little bit of confusion. White Wolf, the owners of Vampire the Masquerade, are trying to put vampire as an IP out in front of more people beyond, just like the tabletop. I think they’re trying to chase that DND glory that Wizards of the Coast are really enjoying right now. But yeah, because of that, we have two game IPs releasing roughly around the same time. A lot of concern about the sequel proper, Bloodlines 2, and a lot of confusion about the question-mark sequel Bloodhunt whether or not it’s even a sequel or anything, but just basically tagging on to that IP has created a lot of consternation because what Bloodhunt is is not an RPG.

    Tim Broadwater

    See, I always get confused about this with Call of Duty. I’m not a Duty person. I know that some people are Duty people, and that’s fine.

    Michael Schofield

    Pretty sure the Call of Duty people don’t call themselves “Duty people.”

    Tim Broadwater

    I call them “Duty people,” that’s a lot of shade, I’m sorry, but it’s like I get lost I have no idea – and it’s like Assassin’s Creed as well – but is there a timeline? I don’t understand the timeline. Or is it a sequel, or are we just using that word for flavor? And it’s like Resident Evil for the longest time adhered to a number system, And then it started going “Veronica,” and like, well wait, where does this fit in. Legend of Zelda’s another example where there are no numbers except 2 – the Adventures of Link – the rest have no numbers. And so there are many internet pages dedicated to how the timeline works and which ones first. We know that Skyward Sword is the very first one in the actual timeline, and then the timeline splits into three different timelines if the hero fails versus if the hero wins, and then it’s just crazy.

    Michael Schofield

    Do they continue to like the story after the hero fails? Do they actually continue that narrative?

    Tim Broadwater

    It does. And so the timeline that’s put together by fans factors in if Ganon is stopped or not stopped, and the Legend of Zelda wins. And so I believe if my understanding of it is correct, that there is what is known as the “dark timeline,” or the hero is defeated, the hero is successful. Then the hero-is-successful splits in the two timelines because there is time travel in Legend of Zelda. So there’s the child era versus the adult era, while the child era if the hero succeeds is like Majora’s Mask and Twilight Princess and Four Swords where if it is the adult era where he succeeds, it’s the Wind Waker, or Spirit Tracks or Phantom Hourglass, but if the hero’s defeated: A Link to the Past, Oracle of Seasons Link’s Awakening, and then eventually, the first Legend of Zenda, and Adventure of Link. It’s just, it’s just crazy. It’s baffling.

    Michael Schofield

    Was that intentional? Or are these fan theories?

    Tim Broadwater

    I think that’s a good thing to talk about, because I think, for the player or user, right? And the reason why we’re kind of talking about this, in general, is sequels. Why the numbering …, or just spiritual sequels, or the theming, right? But we also live in a time where, apart from the craziness or shenanigans that can happen when you introduce numbers and break away from numbers, or if you mis-number things, or you don’t use numbers, you’re just using words (and then what where does it fit in the timeline)? You also have prequelization, where the prequels come out after the original one, like Outlast, Outlast 2, then there’s Outlast: Whistleblower, which is the third one, but it actually takes place before 1. So then, apart from that and spiritual sequels, we have ultimate timelines kind of stuff, right. And then you also have things that are like Mass Effect game carryover, like what you do in your first game gets saved in person to the second game and affects things. But now, technology-wise, we all know that software is: when you buy the CD, it literally just goes into your gaming console to download the file, right? Because you don’t have software proper anymore. Nintendo is literally the only one still doing the cartridge, right? But even if you put in the cartridge, you’re still downloading gigs of files on a switch, right? But then with DLC, it’s like do we even need to make a 2 or 3 or 4? Why make a whole new game if all we’re just gonna do is give you more quests, more stories, more items, you know, so then you just have an ever-expanding game as opposed to the traditional sequel that we’re all used to.

    Michael Schofield

    That’s the Rockstar formula, right? So Grand Theft Auto 5 came out, what, 10 years ago? Does that sound right? And they’ve constantly expanded the universe, introduced tons of different games, new physics. One of the functional reasons for sequels in games – let’s forget like sequelization of novels and cinema for a minute, but just in games. One of the things with sequels is that it provides literally a demarcation where teams can build brands, new technology tailored to new platforms that didn’t exist prior. They can load in a whole bunch of stuff and kind of see how it plays. So the demarcation between, you know, Title One and Title Two, and Title Three not only represents narratives sequelization but new technology. Rockstar doesn’t have to do this anymore. In fact, nobody really has to do this. And that kind of introduces kind of an interesting point, which is, you know, why? Why would they release like a Grand Theft Auto 6?

    Tim Broadwater

    Everyone’s having the same freakout when on the Nintendo front with Breath of the Wild because, yeah, Breath of the Wild 2. I mean, is it? Is it its own game? Or is it just DLC? They don’t think any of the rendering engines, they don’t think any of the graphics, it is literally new content, but “Breath of the Wild 2” is how it’s being presented, but it’s just gonna be DLC for one.

    Michael Schofield

    Do they know whether there is a new voice actor cast or a new deep narrative coming?

    Tim Broadwater

    Yeah, so Nintendo is like one of the last people who actually participate in E3 because everyone’s just abandoned E3, but in their 2021 E3 demo, they actually had a two-minute-long preview of the sequel to Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild. And they leave it untitled. But everyone refers to it as Breath of the Wild 2, and it is the same on Google search, it’s Breath of the Wild 2. And so it’s kind of this thing to where, you know, when you’re trying to break the mold and change the model, it’s like, hey, we have this world that works. We have a system that works. Everything we have is golden. So why can’t we just keep adding more to it, like adding more maps, adding more stories, adding more quests, and let that, you know, kind of shape it out? And so I feel like you have the traditional people who are thinking, “no, it has to be a new game that has a new title,” and people are opposed to the DLC sequel. So I think what’s interesting here is what is user preference, or player preference, versus what people think it is.

    Michael Schofield

    The way my gear is starting to spin toward identifying what the jobs to be done here are. On the developer side, I think the job to be done of sequelization is pretty clear. A sequel is a convenient production container, right? It’s something that can have a finite budget; you can see a finite or constrained return on investment. You hire or contract VO and engineering work and whatever design work for that specific unit product. And I get it that as a business sequelization makes sense because you need to modularize things for your own sanity, I can appreciate that long-running long running franchises that are largely DLC, maybe something like World of Warcraft, I can appreciate like that the management of such a thing as probably more difficult.

    Tim Broadwater

    DNDs like that as well. Or Guild Wars when you add new content,

    Michael Schofield

    The job to be done for users for when a sequel comes out, I would guess, probably relates to the job for the developers. There’s something about a sequel versus DLC that you pointed out where I think a sequel represents whether or not anyone would use this language, but you know, feel like you know, let’s feel this out. I think I’m onto something here, but a sequel represents a focused allocation of money from the developer. And so when you see a sequel, you expect, you know, production value, right? Whereas DLC literally sounds cheaper.

    Tim Broadwater

    What you were saying before, which is, a sequel traditionally was like, hey, we have new tech, we have a new console, so let’s release something on this new hardware capability. And so, the software is matched to the hardware. But I think what we’re seeing increasingly is software being agnostic of hardware. We’re in a time where recently, this year, Netflix has announced they’re going into gaming, and those games can be delivered on whatever you get the Netflix app, so that could be your PlayStation, your phone, your Roku TV, or wherever. So it’s it doesn’t really matter what the hardware is. To me, as opposed to thinking of it like hardware, and I know we’ve talked previously about the great interaction models hardware that Nintendo uses because Nintendo, in that regard, is always ahead of the curve. You know, they had the first 3d rendering on the 64. That’s why the controllers looked like Starfox ships, in my opinion.

    Michael Schofield

    Whoa, wow, what an observation.

    Tim Broadwater

    I think the GameCube is the first one that lets you plug in four controllers by default, and the games were like, let’s do Super Smash Brothers, or Teen Titans or Godzilla Destroy All Monsters, which allows four players on screen at the same time, then they went into motion control with the Wii, and then they had the first tablet, and the tablet was literally a step to the Switch. And then, the first pen interaction was with the DS and 3ds. And, and so I like the hardware chasing, you know what I mean, but there are certain gamers who don’t care about the hardware at all. But what they love about Mario is the fun sidescrolling mechanics of it. And how, from one edition to another, are those mechanics improved? In Monster Hunter, which has tons of sequels, how do they look at the preview? I think there’s a piece here that is also how do we improve? How do we improve? How do we improve? Apart from the hardware piece, there is how do we keep the essence of it, add to the world the narrative but then also improve gameplay. So it’s a tough order to fill. And so what people love about the new Monster Hunter Rise, which just came out for the Switch, is everything that was laborious and took tons of time and was a huge time suck they automated. And just by doing that, like gathering, materials mining, fishing, like doing all these things that were just like, Dude, this just take so much time, they just made it “oh, no, it’s one click,” you just have to go do it. And people loved it, because then the focus became hunting the monsters and killing the monsters, not like all of the tedious things. So that type of improvement, improving the gameplay, but adding to the story, and embracing the hardware advances, is kind of what sequels are about. But some of them never change, right? I mean, some games, like every single one that comes out, are literally the same. And I think that’s maybe where the perception of this is why certain people maybe don’t get into certain franchises.

    Michael Schofield

    We’re kind of in a time both technologically and spiritually, maybe where sequelization is a big umbrella category for a lot of different things. You’re talking about Monster Hunter Rise. And I was going to ask whether you consider that a proper sequel? Or is it an expansion? Do you consider an expansion a sequel?

    Tim Broadwater

    Yeah, so that is also where they just kind of jump and change in the middle of the processes. So Monster Hunter has been on a lot of different platforms. You have Monster Hunter, then Monster Hunter 2, and then for we they did “Tri” but three. And then there was 4 that came out on 3DS, and then they abandoned the numbering system, then it became World and then it became Rise, and as it went to PlayStation or Xbox or Switch. I feel like the numbering is something maybe from the 80s that we all have to do.

    Michael Schofield

    That could be.

    Tim Broadwater

    Maybe, because Street Fighter seems to be that way. I would also say Resident Evil, right? I can’t even tell you like all the things: but there’s Resident Evil. Resident Evil 2, 3is Nemesis. Then there’s Veronica, then Zero, which comes out, I guess before the first one, then there are remakes of them, Outbreak, Resident Evil 5, 6, 7, so they’re keeping largely to the same number series just like Final Fantasy does. Final Fantasy is very specific to the numbers. And when they say Final Fantasy 16, people know what that is, you know, because they’ve played 6789 or you know 123 and 4.

    Michael Schofield

    As the user, as a player, as a consumer, I find this equalization obnoxious. I am often confused. When I think of a sequel, I am thinking of the narrative next step. The fact Mortal Kombat one and Mortal Kombat 2 largely bleed from one to the other, I think, is an accident because I do not consider Mortal Kombat 2 a sequel when we’re talking about it. I would consider Mass Effects 2 a sequel to Mass Effect 1. Red Dead Redemption 2 is actually a prequel to Red Dead Redemption 1. When you’re getting into Assassin’s Creed, I think they kind of stopped numbering things after 3. They are loosely aligned but so loosely rooted in the same narrative that, eventually, they do what I think sequels do, and that like trends towards the entropy of just dropping the numbers entirely. And considering themselves expansion, but as a user, it’s hard because, like, I’m an XBot. But one day, I’m going to pick up a PS4 or a PS5, and I am going to go play some of those Naughty Dog games. I tend to expect that I can’t play Last of Us 2 before I play Last of Us 1. That’s probably true.

    Tim Broadwater

    I will make myself do a horrible prequel that’s 10 years old.

    Michael Schofield

    Well, you’re doing that now. Right? You’re playing, or you have played Mass Effect 1.

    Tim Broadwater

    I started out with this is one of my favorite games is, as you know, The Evil Within. I saw the trailer for Evil Within 2 at E3 years ago, and it gave me shivers like, it was like, Dude, this is something I need to play. But then, when I found out like, oh, the first one came out for PS2, it’s really old, you know, and, and so I or PS3, maybe I can’t remember. I went and played it. It was painful. So I get why people say that they’re like, just start with 2, don’t worry about it. But I will say, there’s so much context and story, and you will not feel, and it will not hit you in the feels, too, if you did not play 1.

    Michael Schofield

    That seems like a proper sequel. And that’s really interesting. Because that’s kind of like what you expect where it becomes spooky is like the Final Fantasy game. Were things that have like tons of sequels, Bro, I haven’t played Final Fantasy since seven.

    Tim Broadwater

    Well, the numbering there is like crazy, like you know, basically like Final Fantasy one comes out many years ago and it’s released in Japan and us, and it’s like Final Fantasy, but then two and three come out in Japan, but they don’t get released in the US and then Final Fantasy 4 comes out in Japan, they released in the US, and they changed to the number 2. That’s a whole nother issue.

    Michael Schofield

    My general argument here, and maybe I’m not making the argument, my general feeling is that sequelization is bad for player usability.

    Tim Broadwater

    And I think where it’s properly used is when it’s when it fuels the story, right? Definitely, playing Last of Us 2 without playing Last of Us, you’re missing out so much. I don’t know if you know the Legend of Zelda: Oracle of Seasons and the Oracle of Ages. It’s like a light/dark version. Yang/Yang. The two games exist simultaneously, and the actions you do in one game affect the other game. But you need the left part of the story for the right part of the story. I like that model because it tells a story. Similar to that is Shovel Knight.

    Shovel Knight is amazing. If you’d like those grindy hard old-school sidescrolling games, it is there. And if you’re a Mega Man person or Metroid or you are into Metroidvania games, which is an actual genre, but it’s like the map and sidescrolling. Yacht Club games came out with Shovel Knight, and it’s like, hey, this is a tech, this is what it looks like, it looks old school, pixelated. However, we’re not changing our engine here. We’re going to release four games. They’re all going to tell you four different sides of stories of the same story. So you play the first one, Shovel Knight, which is Shovel of Hope that tells you Shovel Knight’s story where he’s like the main hero, and he’s saving is another knight that he works with. But then you get to play Shovel Knight Plague of Shadows, where it’s like you’re an evil guy who’s one of the evil knights you go up against him, and it’s for the evil queen. But you see, his story is different; the reason why he’s doing what he’s doing is a totally different motivation, right? But then you when you play the third one Specter of Torment, or the fourth one, which is King of Cards. It’s they’re all like different stories of the same game, but different perspectives and motivations, much like Octopath Traveler.

    Michael Schofield

    That’s really interesting.

    Tim Broadwater

    I love sequelization for the story, and I’m not a story person, you know that. But I love sequelization for the story. I don’t like equalization when it’s Street Fighter 2, Street Fighter 2 Turbos.

    Michael Schofield

    I think when we’re talking about Street Fighter, we’re talking about product containerization. We’re talking about different technologies. I mean, one of the ideas about sequels, which the popularity may come from the 80s, is that your sequel, your Destiny 2, will make a lot more money than revamped Destiny expansion. You know that when Grand Theft Auto 6 eventually comes out, Rockstar is gonna make a billion dollars. So it’s one of those things where it could technically be built on the same thing, but there’s a product moment around these kinds of sequels that are lucrative to the company. To your point earlier in the episode, I wonder if we are in the death throes of that type of sequel now that technology doesn’t require it. Because now the barrier to entry to create games in a particular IP is lower than it has ever been. And the technology doesn’t require product containerization because you can ship entirely new engines over the wire. I mean, it’s interesting.

    I have some vocabulary and what we’re kind of discussing when we’re talking about Bloodhunt, and some of the others, like Octopath Traveler, we’re talking about something that is classified by the Library of Congress as a “standalone sequel” that works that in the same universe that has very little of any narrative connection to its predecessor and can stand on its own. We kind of talked about this sort of product containerization thing, and the Library of Congress isn’t going to classify a sequel like that, although I think the point stands.

    Another one that’s coming straight out of our background of engineering and tech world is “sequel as semantic versioning.” Some of our listeners may not know the numbers on versions like 1.1, 1.2, 2.0, 2.1, 2.2 have meaning. And a lot of the time, it’s a three number based system where it’s like 1.1.1, where the rightmost number is a patch or a bug fix, the middlemost number is an additive feature that doesn’t break anything, and the first number, the 1 to 2, the 2 to 3 represents a breaking change. And so when it comes to software —

    Tim Broadwater

    Oh, wait for a second. What do you mean by breaking?

    Michael Schofield

    Breaking changes: semantic versioning tries to standardize how these version numbers are made. And the idea of going from 1.0 to 2.0 is that you are signaling to consumers of your software that whatever you’ve done, or used or built around 1.0, should not be expected to work. You are signaling that there is a breaking difference between 1.0 and 2.0. And so I don’t know that players know this internally. But when it occurred to me, I guess, when we were talking is like one of the great reasons for maybe doing a version change like that a 2.0 to 3.0 isn’t just for the ability to market the shit out of it and like and then squeeze all the dollars out of it. But it’s a signal, not so much that something’s new, although people interpret it as that they expect new software, new goods, new changes, or whatever, bug fixes or whatever, but also that it is not going to work in the same way. It’s saying like this is significantly different.

    Tim Broadwater

    Substantial enough change to reset your expectations. We’ve changed from the core, built it from the ground up differently, or if made it more efficient.

    Michael Schofield

    Exactly. So like, if an API is 1.0 to 2.0, whatever you built around that 1.0 API will probably break if you upgrade. When I’m looking at these, like Library of Congress, classifications of sequels, we just added to the right, from engineering numbers. And I think one of the things with games is that you’re smashing the right brain of the game industry, which is like narrative and story and experience with a left brain, which is engineering. It kind of mushes together, and I wonder if that might be a reason why numbering systems are stupid bananas and, at this point, baffling.

    Tim Broadwater

    So with semantic versioning, and we think about things of software, that’s one piece of it, that’s gonna play into how it works, but then also, the story piece as well. So this story piece may or may not relate to the semantic versioning is kind of what we’re saying. And so does it matter having Final Fantasy 12345 all the way through 16? Or, can we just have DLC, which would be okay, 1.2 1.3 1.4, you know, version of the software? And then, of course, there’s a purchasing model; we want to sell DLC, we want to make money from it. Will we get five bucks or one player if we add DLC, or is it better to get $60 for a brand new game per person? Will they pay more if it’s an expansion of the story?

    Michael Schofield

    That’s fascinating. I can see the motive as the motivation coming in either direction, sometimes it sounds counterintuitive, but sometimes it’s cheaper to rebuild the whole thing from the ground up, you know, once you build enough what they call technical debt, or whatever. And so I can totally see a world where it’s like, Hey, Unity 5 is out, and we need to rebuild on on this new engine, and we’re just gonna scrap everything, because now the developers who work in this framework don’t exist anymore, because that’s 20 years old, and you know, we’re going to get something new. We’re gonna start from scratch, breaking change, new number, then creative has to be like, oh, shit, well, do they just slap a new story on that? I think what we might be pinpointing is, if anything is like, why numbering systems for games are strange because really, it is a question like, Is this just a book? Is this a narrative? Is this like a movie? Is this art? Or is this technology? And the answer is yes.

    Tim Broadwater

    There is an answer already. I mean, or let me give you an example of what you just described. We have the Last of Us. We have The Last of Us 2. Huge award-winning games on both accounts, phenomenal story. Makes the player hurt at what difficult decisions they need to make, right? Last of Us: Left Behind, which is the DLC, that is for the first one, The Last of Us, which expanded the story and showed Ellie’s girlfriend and that kind of relationship with they built out between 1 and 2. That seems to be a win-win, right? It’s like this is DLC that also furthers the story. And people want that story piece, but it is DLC, you had to pay for it, you know? So I think that is probably, you know,

    Michael Schofield

    One of the problems as a player with DLC is that – I don’t know – if I had to look at DLC, I think my bias is that it’s at least skippable. So something like that, which I seem to remember, the news around that revelation was huge. But is that considered an extension of one as, like, 1 isn’t complete without this additive story before you can get to 2? Or could you skip it?

    Tim Broadwater

    So my understanding of this from playing the games and not have to play the DLC, but kind of knowing 1 and 2, and kind of what the DLC is, is that that’s character is in 1 proper, but you never know what happens. There seemed to be something there some meaning in the relationship, either really good friends or whatever, you know, if you wanted that story being developed, that’s it. That’s what you get it for. That is related to the story, and it kind of adds and fleshes out its character development. That’s what you’re paying for. It’s very different than Bioshock, where they were literally just DLC the crap out of you for a whole new story, or just a little mini-game or like a new kind of thing in the same place. And like “this also happened in Rapture, pay for it.” That doesn’t really contribute to the main story, but it does show another story that happened on the same maps, and to me, that feels I’m less inclined to experience this also happened versus like, Oh, this is a deeper dive into character development or the story or what was going on? Just for me.

    Michael Schofield

    So the Library of Congress classifies what you just described as a “midquel.” Stories that take place between two proceeding stories or between events that serve as a sequel to nothing. It’s lore-building, right? It’s like, Hey, tell me more about this red dragon from beyond the hills. Clearly, it’s eaten a whole bunch of villages and stuff. Tell us a story about those villages, right? It’s in the same world, it’s lore, that doesn’t change the value – that doesn’t change what happens to Bilbo and his companions. But it’s more.

    Tim Broadwater

    We put a lot of work into Design Thinking Games. So if you like what we do and want to help us cover some costs, then consider supporting us at patreon.com/designthinkinggames. We also are Design Thinking Games on TickTock, Twitch, and Twitter.

    Introductory Guy

    Thank you for listening to the design thinking games podcast. To connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim, please go to designthinkinggames.com, where you can request topics, ask questions, or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on

  • 013: Roll for Sanity

    013: Roll for Sanity

    Games talked about in this episode:

    • 5:11 The Thing
    • 6:31 Call of Cthulhu
    • 7:19 Silent Hill
    • 8:58 Lit
    • 10:00 Outlast
    • 16:00 Resident Evil
    • 17:39 Thief
    • 20:32 Zombies Ate My Neighbors
    • 21:17 Dead Rising
    • 24:42 Fury of Dracula
    • 25:50 Outlast 2
    • 27:15 Dead by Daylight

    Introductory Guy  

    Welcome to Design Thinking Games, a fantasy and user experience podcast. Each episode, your podcast hosts, Tim Broadwater and Michael Schofield, will examine the player experience of board games, pen and paper roleplaying games, live-action games, mobile games, and video games. You can find every episode, including this one on your podcatcher of choice and on the web at designthinkinggames.com.

    Tim Broadwater  

    So, this is the only time that happens this year.

    Michael Schofield  

    We’re talking about Friday, the 13th.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Correct. My favorite holiday, and also a floating holiday? Sometimes you don’t even get it a year. And then sometimes you get it only once. Or sometimes you get it two or three times. So being topical. One of the things for Friday the 13th that I like is like scary movies and being scared, and you know, kind of, I’m that type of person. I find that there are very few people that like horror out there or like being scared. What about you?

    Michael Schofield  

    Oh, yeah, I mean, it may be that I surround myself with people who think the way I think it’s probably true. I mean, it’s factually true comedy performs way better at the box office than horror. But I gotta tell you, the people I talked to, are horror people, even my daughter who is 10. She and I are watching the new IT movies, chapter one, and we’re partway through chapter two as well. We just watched earlier this year the Haunting of Bly Manor on Netflix. She’sseen Pet Sematary, the original one, etc., and at age 10. These are questionable parenting choices. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    No judgment. One of my best memories as a kid is my dad had to work a Thanksgiving one time. And so we didn’t have like a Thanksgiving dinner, which sucked. But he got paid like two and a half times or, you know, whatever. Yeah, exactly. Not the end of the world. My mom took us out to the theater to see this Child’s Play or the second Child’s Play. Chucky films. So no, I, I’ve watched horror since I was a kid. I think it’s, I think it’s weird. And we can have a whole other conversation about, like, why in our country we want to hide people from horror, or Gore, or whatever, people are jumpscaring or whatever. But we want to protect people from like, like, sex or sex is okay. But horror is not okay. You know, it just seems like a weird landscape out there. So no judgment on my part. But I guess so you’re a horror person. I’m a horror person.

    Michael Schofield

    In our last 13 episodes, half of the games we talked about were somewhere in this category.

    Tim Broadwater

    Like disturbing, or horror.

    Michael Schofield  

    Ultra tense, ghosts. Phantasmagoria, Call of Cthulhu. The Man of Medan. This is definitely a trend. This is what we do. Not only that is interesting, though. But I think one of the cool things about capital H horror as a genre, which, of course, can be subdivided into gajillions of different facets. What’s really neat about horror, in games, is that to give you a sense of helplessness and a sense of real danger, they have to get pretty creative with the mechanics. On the other hand, most of the games out there are really about empowering, right, putting you into the shoes of someone badass, or, you know, giving you the high, like highly dexterous controls to really take advantage of your badass twitch reflexes, even in games that don’t have a narrative, but horror is about putting you on your back foot. 

    Tim Broadwater  

    Oh, it’s the helplessness, right? It’s like the exact opposite, not empowering you but making you to some degree, it’s making you feel restricted or limited or that you know. They’re definitely mechanics that lend to that that are like jumpscares or lighting or music in games or you know, there are different metrics. That can be used like, I remember. I know this is popular and like the Call of Cthulhu games, but it also like one of my favorite movie franchises is John Carpenter’s The Ting I love the movie with where it’s the alien that kind of can assimilate people and

    Michael Schofield  

    Lovecraftian alien creature.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Then it has a prequel to it, which is a movie that came out like X amount of years ago, but it’s more recent. But most people don’t know that there’s actually a sequel to the original one, which was in a video game, which was written by john carpenter and had the same actors and voices and stuff. Yeah, and it’s a Canon. It’s called The Thing, and it came out for PlayStation 2, I believe, or 3. You had a sanity meter in that game. I mean, like, literally, when you were exposed to much of crazy or too many crazy things happened. Like, you know, that happened. But then, like every other game, you had a health meter. So if that goes down, if sanity goes down, you go crazy. If health goes down, you die. There was also a cold temperature meter because you were in the Antarctic. Yeah, wherever that Arctic was in the movie. And so, dude, that game was difficult because, like you had, I can’t get too cold, I can’t be exposed to too much crazy. So it limits. It makes me hesitant to walk around and explore. But, you know, so

    What happened when you got a little crazy? Because there are certain games where you know, if your sanity meter gets to zero, you die, or in Call of Cthulhu, the tabletop games when your sanity drops to a certain point, which may be zero, your character you forfeit. So, like your, your character becomes an NPC.

    Yeah, correct. Call of Cthulhu, which I hate the roleplaying game, but I love the video, but I love the video games is because maybe it was just a bad experience with it. But you’re correct, like sanity is a giant issue. And it has that whole Phantasmagoria kind of, I think, is the punishment, right? So like when your sanity goes, it’s like, Am I crazy? Am do I know what reality is? Do I know? What can I tell the difference between what’s real and fantasy? And I like that. That’s to me, is very Silent Hill. Yeah, it is exactly what Silent Hill is to which it’s like Phantasmagoria; you don’t know if this is a dream or reality? Or you’re crazy. And then I think in those games when you lose your sanity, it’s just like, you lose control of your character or like you do something crazy or you killed some your friend because you thought they were a monster, or whatever.

    Michael Schofield  

    Oh, that’s an excellent mechanic there. Where? Where? Yeah, you. Like in game design, you could literally skin a colleague or friend as some evil creature trying to get to you. They do this in movies, too. Where oh my gosh, somebody is trying to, you know, shake you awake or something like that. And you look you open your eyes, they’re a vampire or something. And only when they’re dead bleeding on the floor, you realize that they were really, you know, your long-lost sister. Or, Oh my God, love it. Yeah. And

    Tim Broadwater  

    it gets even worse if you saw Annabel, but I’m not going to even tell you what that is. If you haven’t seen it, it’s clear to crazy. But yeah, I think that’s like that sanity metric. But then some things are like, I think music, and this is horrible. You know, I understand that there are deaf people in the world. And I understand there are people with visual acuity, kind of, you know, accessibility issues. And so you can lighting and music are also two big things that are used sometimes, but I almost feel like those could be chucked to the left or right for the accessibility reason so, but I’ve played some great games that toy with lighting back on the Wii, there was a game called Lit to where you had to negotiate your way through a high school, but you can never step in the shadow and that thing to where you found like oh no my bad my flashlight turning my battery or like I need to turn on this switch to turn on the lamp on a desk, but I can’t get across the room. I’m gonna have to knock a hole in the wall to make a light to walk through, you know? Yeah, it was that’s, you know, that was scary. Creepy in the music to like with it made it really creepy.

    Michael Schofield  

    Alright, so you hit on like three different things. I want to rotate back and talk just about like sanity as a mechanic. And then the next thing I want to follow up with is this idea, this kind of like mechanic of ultra-limited resources. Resident Evil, for instance, has, you know, you have like five bullets the entire game or something like that, you know, so it’s really hard to come by but specifically, things like Lit where your battery runs out or Outlast where you are using a camcorder, and your battery runs out, so I want to kind of like rotate back to and on top of that resources.,

    Tim Broadwater  

    In Outlast, You can not also fight back.

    Michael Schofield  

    Oh, that’s a big one as well. Correct. So back to sanity real quick. So the interesting about like sanity as a mechanic is that sometimes it’s done poorly. And I, at some point, I’d love to hear like, what about your experience with Call of Cthulhu the roleplaying game soured for you, but maybe that’s

    Tim Broadwater  

    that’s a bad GM? Okay. I think it kind of conversation, you know, well, maybe not like, that’s not a game mechanic. That’s

    Michael Schofield  

     But I think the sanity mechanic of Call of Cthulhu isn’t great for it being as central as it is. For those who don’t know, the idea is that your character. Based on, it’s actually like a cumulative value from different attributes, your character has ranked charisma; I think I’m actually rattling off dungeons of dragons that attributes because it has very similar plans, right? But you have a sanity metric between zero and 100. And, and Call of Cthulhu. When you roll a die, you’re not trying to beat a score; you’re trying to come under a score. So if you have a difficulty of 60, on a scale of 100, you roll the die, and it comes up 59 or less, you have succeeded. So insanity is the same thing. Your GM is going to make you roll for sanity. Whenever you encounter a Lovecraftian Horror, you turn the corner, and the shadow of the coat rack there actually moves to come to get you BAM rolls in. Yeah, the penalty for failing is, I think, kind of stupid. But it’s also interesting in that,

    Tim Broadwater  

    What’s the penalty? Just remind me. 

    Michael Schofield  

    So very simple, like low level, I don’t know if that’s the right word, but like minor sanity rules where you miss by two or three, sometimes the penalty is just reducing your sanity, sanity score. Remember, once you get to zero, you, you effectively lose, you are an insane part of the so you’re 60

    Tim Broadwater

    Goes down to like 40 or 50.,

    Michael Schofield  

    It’s even like, you know, by points 60 goes on to 59. So you don’t really even feel at that certain point. But if you have what I think is called an extreme failure, you accrue some kind of madness. And there’s like madness tables. And maybe every time you walk, you have to stand and stare every time you cross a mirror. And maybe that runs the risk of seeing something else in there. There are some really good roleplay mechanics, but it relies on the DM to like and be good at it.

    Tim Broadwater  

    What I like about that is that the thing is, is like you have some onus to some degree, like do you want to look at the worms, or do you want to look in the mirror, you know, so that’s the selling point, right? I guess, like when you were saying like the bad, like, to me, and this is just my thought the inverse of that is when like, I’m just gonna encounter x things in the environment that I’m currently in, and those things are just going to drop my score, you know.  

    Michael Schofield  

    Call of Cthulhu scenarios are like that, like, Oh, you open the door role sanity. And, you know, you have to have like, you know, just being able to pick up the book. And play means that you’re going to like have your first experience now playing with a GM maybe who hasn’t done it if you’d like to often and which is I think, a common experience with like Call of Cthulhu I don’t know that a lot of people do like huge long term campaigns in this world.

    You’re supposed to die. But like everything, like open the door sanity, and it just becomes a chore, right? Like it is so, but there’s

    Tim Broadwater  

    so for me, let me just speak to that really quick like most people I find as a game master or GM or a dungeon master dm or whatever. storyteller or as it was in dungeons and dragons, original referee. (Wait, really?) Yeah, the very original version of Dungeons and Dragons. I think it’s got a referee. So the referee

    Michael Schofield  

    Boy, that doesn’t roll off the tongue.

    Tim Broadwater  

    No, no, but essentially, to what you’re saying, there is that? I guess, you know, I completely lost what we were talking about. I’m sorry.

    Michael Schofield  

    You’ve just rolled you failed your sanity,

    Tim Broadwater  

    I feel that I wrote a one. Oh, yeah, what I was gonna say is like generally, and I’m sorry, I just thought of it. But like generally people I find and tabletop roleplaying games want to keep their characters and grow them and grow their experience so, so playing games like Mork Borg or I mean Call of Cthulhu definitely, but to a lesser extent, some of the White Wolf games are like your character can’t really survive. I mean, your characters are kind of cursed or limited. And it’s just so difficult and sanity being a metric or whatever. But

    Michael Schofield  

    it’s supposed to chip away at the longevity of your character, ultimately, where it’s not like, like sanity has like a roleplaying mechanic. Super interesting. But in these games, you’re right. They use sanity as a way to get you closer to game over.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah. And no, the other thing you were talking about is like, the resources, right? So this is a reason why I think people love it. Like, I think old school and like new school. And like the people who want to scare or people who want the scare, but also some of that tear comes from resource management, which is how many bullets so how do I find the guy and am I conserving my shotgun sales? Can I run around the zombies, you have a flashlight? Exactly. And so you know, that’s kind of scary, you know, when now when you earn Outlast, and you’re out of batteries for your camera and, or your flashlight or whatever, I think it’s a camera that has a light on it. ,

    Michael Schofield  

    it’s kind of, like, a mid-2000s handheld camcorder, right? And you can open the screen and look through it and night vision, which makes it even scarier, right, because it’s got that green hue.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, and if you’re out of batteries, you’re in the dark. Now you can get really close to something like you would when you’re in the friggin dark, you have to feel. Oh, that’s a stove. Oh, that’s a bed; this is a wall. So you can run around without the resources, but you are doing it so encumbered, or like at such reduced visibility that you have to crawl the wall, because that’s the only way you have to kind of feel yourself around. The other

    Michael Schofield  

    the thing that’s really interesting about a mechanic like that, right? Which forces you to go slow because going fast would run you into an opponent or something is that it lets the frankly, lets the level not be too big, right? And passing a level still might take, you know, one or two, two hours. Did you ever play the Thief games, the late 90s, early 2000s PC games? (no, I haven’t).  So we have the term first-person shooter. So thief was a first-person sneaker. And I like to think, although I believe there are many different people in this lineage or lineage. But things like Splinter Cell, etc. Really inherited a lot of the shadow mechanics from Theif – actually think Metal Gear Solid predated it. But it’s one of those things where you’re a thief and kind of like a medieval city called The City. And you are not a fighter; you can fight one or two people. But if you come up against like a cluster of guards, you’re toast; you got to run away. You’re built for speed and lightness, and you’re just, you know, kind of like a roguelike cloak, and you stick to the shadows, and it had a light mechanic, and you walk around to the dark. This isn’t a thief talk. But one of the things about this kind of mechanic like staying in the darkness because the darkness is safe or playing with light and some games like you know, stay in the light because the light is safe. Like Lit. It forces you to take the level slowly, and it can take forever. And what that actually does, I think you know Dishonor does this, right. I don’t know if you’ve played any of the Dishonored games. They’re made by many of the folks who came from Thief’s Looking Glass Studios. And it’s sort of like the spiritual successor. So in the dishonored games earn thief, you have to take your time navigating the level, and in so doing, it forces you to really invest yourself in the level when you’re waiting for – like in Outlast when you’re waiting for someone in the asylum to finish their pre-programmed patrol You have to kind of like, you know, wait on the edges of a hallway and just watch the flickering light in the distance to see someone pass so you can time your movement.  ultimately, this level isn’t super big, but Because of the pacing, it feels huge, and because you’re taking it slow, you see every single chip in the paint or flicker of the light, and it really works on your mind.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah, so I think you made a good point there because there are two things. And it’s kind of like, visibility, you know, I would say to some degree and the resource management of it, like if it’s, but also pacing, like it slows you down and puts you into that creep, there’s also the exact opposite, which is, you are like Zombies Ate My Neighbors, where it’s like, dude, it is constant pressure, it is on the exact opposite. So the pacing is forced upon you from time and monsters, and you’re running around, and it’s also like resource management, you’re, you’re literally trying to run around and get as many missiles and guns and weed eaters and like anything you can use to fight off anything that’s going to come at you and everything that’s going to come at you. And it is you’re not going to the game is notoriously difficult is to beat it’s really there are timers on each level as well. And then you know, at some point you’re never gonna make it, it’s like how long can you last? Because they’re pressure pressuring you?

    Michael Schofield  

    Dead Rising? Yeah. So you know, there are games that are similar Dead Rising has a total timer. It’s not per level, but you have, I think, something like 72 hours, then, and then you’re toast, right? (Oh, Wow.) And so, but in this game, like Dead Rising, it is semi-comical. And so the idea is that you’re you are resource-limited, but you also have plenty of opportunities to like, replenish. And the real danger of something like a Dead Rising is the Horde. Like one zombie, two zombies. Heck, 10 zombies, not a whole lot. But 20 zombies 30 zombies getting from one side of the mall to the other? You’re toast. And that’s kind of an interesting thing, too. It’s funny because when I think of Dead Rising, I don’t really think of it as a horror game. But the reality is that you have the time you have, you have all of the all the mechanics there to make it spooky, A.) you have a monster, B.) you have a pacing element. And you know, the stakes are big, you’re going to die, or unlike Dead Rising 2, your daughter is going to die. Because spoiler for a game that came out, you know, 11 years ago? But like Dead Rising to your daughter is infected. And you can hold off the zombie virus, provided that you have one of these vaccinations, but those were off. You know, they have this zombie build-a-bear, or something like that, you know, was a pandemic joke. But, uh, but that’s one of the things that are at stake to you. And there are very few of those vaccines. But as but with Resident Evil, like and specifically the earlier ones PS 2 era, you move like a snail. Like the monsters are faster than you have almost zero ammunition. It’s super dark. And, and the cameras suck. So even the constraints of like the game and again, trolls make you feel like you’re on death’s door at every corner.

    Tim Broadwater  

    And kind of circling back to one of the things that I think we both kind of mentioned at some point sound I think there’s a two-piece or two sound right one part of it is the jumpscare right where it’s just like you’re going along and it’s like oh my god yeah, doing something for you. And the music escalates that right it’s the same in horror games as it is in horror movies. To where it’s just like keep you very silent walking around all you hear is dripping water in your footsteps and then essentially, then something pops out makes it loud and that scares you. But then there’s also the sound piece which is like you can’t put off sound, or you know, you can’t make too much sound or, or there’s a synchronous horror game to where if you make too much sound like the killer, the monster will find you right.

    Michael Schofield  

    Yeah.

    Tim Broadwater  

    And then, like the whole horde thing you were talking about like this unstoppable force, you know, I feel like it’s their games that have this unstoppable force how like this is going to happen eventually. Or it’s forthcoming, or it’s a timer. Yeah, it’s either something is going to happen. Yeah. And

    Michael Schofield  

    it’s either like many many, many monsters, or you know, you come face to face with Dracula, and the old Sherlock Holmes Dracula games like Dracula is gonna whoop ya. Yeah. Like, there’s a, or that’s, that’s like Fury of Dracula to Dracula is way more powerful. When you encounter a Lovecraftian horror in  Call of Cthulhu, say goodbye, dude. Right, you know, so you’re part of it. Oh, that’s a great mechanic. Like part of that is not drawing attention to yourself. Like you don’t run around. Yeah, you don’t run around and Outlast. Because those little guys will hear ya.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Yeah. It’s Yeah. The tome, Outlast, is very and I’m talking about. I’m a fan of Outlast and the prequel whistleblower. Although I liked to I’m not it’s, it’s I in my opinion, it wasn’t as good as the first one. What

    Michael Schofield  

    do you what do you think the differentiators were? Why was the first one so good? And what well, what about this next one? Like

    Tim Broadwater  

    you’re trying to survive and run away and creep around like this mental hospital where you find out like things have been going on like experiments, and then you find out that it’s even more you’re

    Michael Schofield  

    A journalist, right.

    Tim Broadwater  

    Who gets called in an investigation, and you’re in your dress trying to get out? Do you know what I mean? So the second one is like it goes a little like, okay, crazy. Appalachian country called town, you know, version and you’re trying to survive, and you don’t you’re trying to find out what’s going on. And it has loose relationships to some of the things you find out in the first one, but it’s kind of just like, it’s like, I don’t need to play. You know? What is that? The movie about the inbred heck wants to deliver? Well, no, no, no.

    Michael Schofield  

    The Hills Have Eyes.

    Tim Broadwater  

    It’s kind of along that Disturbance may be or the one like oh, Wrong Turn with Eliza Dushku cue or anything? Like puffy. But yeah, so it’s kind of like that. I’m like, what I found more creepy is trying to get out of the mental hospital and not draw attention to myself, you know, and that was like, I’m lost, like, the other one just felt contrived, you know, and I tried to make it scarier. Yeah, yeah. And the creepiness of Outlast was like, you’re trapped in the dark, you can’t see you need to find batteries, and you’re trying to get out, and you know, you and then there’s you just take, it’s crazy. But all you can never fight back. You can only hide, you know. You’re just trying to survive. And that’s, to me, those guys have great jumpscare. But they also like you can’t put off too much sound like you’re saying so they really that game really, to me, is an effective use of sound Dead by Daylight is too, and we talked about that all the time. Because when the killers close, you can hear his heartbeat. And as it goes away, you that’s how you can tell if he’s going away. And that’s the same in Outlast when somebody you’re someone searching for you, you know, or you’re trying to hide. So they’re really cool, I guess disturbing horror or sanity bass game kind of mechanics. Yeah. And then we talked about music and sound and jumpscares. And then this unstoppable force, you know, and there’s also Resource Conservation or resource management, right?

    Michael Schofield

    Just the different facets of what makes you like the mechanics that horror writers or horror game designers use to make you tense. And one of those is one where you are you are not empowered, you are weak, you die. So like, again, the journalist and Outlast where you all you can do is run. In Call of Cthulhu, you get shot once you’re toast man is pretty like real life, right? You’re not going to rise up heroically? Yeah, it’s really sort of like, sort of like the antithesis of a lot of the games that we play, where oftentimes we step into the shoes of somebody who is a hero, who can bite off the Horde, you know, Aragorn can murder, like, you know, like 100 orcs, or, or whatever, but it’s when you step into a character, which is that you are entering the shoes of a character who has who is not? Who is not weaker than who is probably as weak as you. It reminds you about your own helplessness, which I think is compelling and spooky. Yeah, if you’re in the if you’re an asylum, or, you know, you and I last Yeah, like, Tim, you’re gonna you’re a fighter, like you. You were a martial artist. Do you could probably take a couple of the inmates out? Well, you couldn’t take them all right, you know, and plus would be really scary, and they have nothing to lose and, you know, stuff like that. Me? I’m toast, man. I’m hiding under the bed.

    Introductory Guy  

    Thank you for listening to the design thinking games podcast. To connect with your hosts, Michael or Tim, please go to designthinkinggames.com, where you can request topics, ask questions, or see what else is going on. Until next time, game on.